It occures to me with Charlie's arrest that this might be the start of people being arrested for things they did in the early days of bitcoin when it was all still considered "play money". With the blockchain being immutable as it is, the crimes of a few years ago (Stealing 10,000BTC) for example, might now be prosecutable, even though at the time maybe people thought it was worth no more then a 1000 USD. I bet a large number of theives or just lazy/entreprenurial bitcoin early adopters might have done things that sounded like fun at the time but now might be considered serious financial crimes. I wonder for example when Fontas might get found/arrested/prosecuted for securities fraud....
One of the very first bitcoin transactions I did was over PayPal. The Vietnamese kid (?) got all screwed up with PayPal. After I had the BTC, sent him some extra $US so he could un-fuck himself and break free of PayPal. He kindly sent me the money back when this was accomplished. (This probably gave us both a somewhat false sense of the community...oh well. It was a calculated risk, and $20 to me was probably a lot more to most people in Vietnam.)
Anyway, it would never give me pleasure to steal anyone's Bitcoin, identity, $US, bucky-balls, or anything else. I think the last thing 'stole' was a balsa-wood airplane to which I affixed the wrong price tag when I was about 10. It still bothers me 35 years later. Someone who did find these things fun is someone who well might be inclined to do it again. Frankly I'm happy to have them identified at least (so I can avoid them), and I'm sure not going to shed to many tears for them if they need to pay for their indiscretions. At least if the punishment fits the crime.
Shrem engaged in known criminal activity with the intent of enriching himself, but he was providing a service which was in demand and not engaging in straight theft of fraud against individuals from what I read. Someone who flat out steal from people is much worse in my book. Even if it is for 'less than $1000 worth of play money' and even if it was several years ago.