It should be pronounced for blind users.
What about the deaf-blind? two metal handles that would shock you in Morse code? 
Topic: Hardware Bitcoin Wallet - page 3. (Read 4810 times)
Quote
OK, say you want to make a transaction. You fill out four things in the PC client: the wallet to transfer from, the amount of BTC, the destination address and the password for the wallet.
You press OK, and the transaction is sent to the device via USB for signing.
The Send-To address is changed by malware to another address before being sent to hardware wallet for signing. Hardware signs the transaction.You press OK, and the transaction is sent to the device via USB for signing.
You cannot get any security on compromised computer! It is only a question how sophisticated is the malware.
It should be pronounced for blind users.
And how many people will be comparing them? We are talking about people with IQ consisting of only two digits who infect their own computers with malware and still operate them.
Generate addresses that have matching few first digits like 1dice for every starting digits and have the malware to select address with matching start digits to display on LCD.
I can do many things, but I can't fix stupid. Generate addresses that have matching few first digits like 1dice for every starting digits and have the malware to select address with matching start digits to display on LCD.
Quote
OK, say you want to make a transaction. You fill out four things in the PC client: the wallet to transfer from, the amount of BTC, the destination address and the password for the wallet.
You press OK, and the transaction is sent to the device via USB for signing.
The Send-To address is changed by malware to another address before being sent to hardware wallet for signing. Hardware signs the transaction.You press OK, and the transaction is sent to the device via USB for signing.
You cannot get any security on compromised computer! It is only a question how sophisticated is the malware.
Generate addresses that have matching few first digits like 1dice for every starting digits and have the malware to select address with matching start digits to display on LCD.
Quote
OK, say you want to make a transaction. You fill out four things in the PC client: the wallet to transfer from, the amount of BTC, the destination address and the password for the wallet.
You press OK, and the transaction is sent to the device via USB for signing.
The Send-To address is changed by malware to another address before being sent to hardware wallet for signing. Hardware signs the transaction.You press OK, and the transaction is sent to the device via USB for signing.
You cannot get any security on compromised computer! It is only a question how sophisticated is the malware.
http://www.safenet-inc.com/software-monetization/sentinel-hasp/ could be used as a secure wallet. Without a screen and buttons though.
I don't see how. That product is when the computer software doesn't trust the user (to have the right license).This product is for when the user can't trust the software on the computer (to do as he says).
Quote
OK, say you want to make a transaction. You fill out four things in the PC client: the wallet to transfer from, the amount of BTC, the destination address and the password for the wallet.
You press OK, and the transaction is sent to the device via USB for signing.
The Send-To address is changed by malware to another address before being sent to hardware wallet for signing. Hardware signs the transaction.You press OK, and the transaction is sent to the device via USB for signing.
You cannot get any security on compromised computer! It is only a question how sophisticated is the malware.
I absolutely love this idea, but what if it needs an upgrade for some reason? Is it a flashable eprom? If this is the case then why not just have an external usb drive with your bitcoin data that you just unplug? If it isn't flashable then would upgrades cost money?
If you use a normal USB drive to hold your bitcoin wallet, a well-written virus could simply steal that file when you connect it.With this thing, once you put your wallet on it, you can't get it off again (so keep a paper backup).
There is a chance that the bitcoin network changes some day, and that could make this product obsolete. I chose this approach because:
- It's the most secure. There is no chance that you load a malicious firmware that could expose the wallet.
- It's simpler. The simpler, the lower the price. The simpler, the faster to market.
- It's a pretty low cost thing anyway, at USD 12-15. A bit cynical maybe, but if you can afford one, you can afford two.
- if the bitcoin network changes, it's quite possible that the hardware in this thing need to be replaced anyway.
http://www.safenet-inc.com/software-monetization/sentinel-hasp/ could be used as a secure wallet. Without a screen and buttons though.
You know, someone could probably build the app to do this in C, targeting Linux as the OS, using serial as the interface, and it would probably run on gobs of hardware that's already out there for nearly free. People could root their old 2nd generation iPod or whatever, and use it as a transaction verifier and be able to get into it for zero hardware cost (or pick one up on eBay).
Absolutely possible. The device software will certainly be written in C, and I fully expect to open-source it. The PC part of the software will also be open-sourced, and in the long run will be able to support a lot of different transaction-signers.Getting it to run on all kinds of strange hardware will be a different project.
If your transaction signer simply assumed the existence of one standard serial port at /dev/something and was designed to call some other binary to ask user a question and get a response, then someone else could worry about the hardware by creating that other binary.
I absolutely love this idea, but what if it needs an upgrade for some reason? Is it a flashable eprom? If this is the case then why not just have an external usb drive with your bitcoin data that you just unplug? If it isn't flashable then would upgrades cost money?
You know, someone could probably build the app to do this in C, targeting Linux as the OS, using serial as the interface, and it would probably run on gobs of hardware that's already out there for nearly free. People could root their old 2nd generation iPod or whatever, and use it as a transaction verifier and be able to get into it for zero hardware cost (or pick one up on eBay).
Absolutely possible. The device software will certainly be written in C, and I fully expect to open-source it. The PC part of the software will also be open-sourced, and in the long run will be able to support a lot of different transaction-signers.Getting it to run on all kinds of strange hardware will be a different project.
You know, someone could probably build the app to do this in C, targeting Linux as the OS, using serial as the interface, and it would probably run on gobs of hardware that's already out there for nearly free. People could root their old 2nd generation iPod or whatever, and use it as a transaction verifier and be able to get into it for zero hardware cost (or pick one up on eBay).
Sure, but that's a nerd thing.
We are targeting grandma's here.
Not exactly. The goal isn't to make it a hobby project for nerds, the goal is to get the hardware cheap. There is SO MUCH obsolete hardware that could run an application like this that people are throwing in the garbage. It would be a sustainable business model to pick some old gadget, refurbish and recycle it into a low-cost bitcoin transaction verifier, and sell it on the open market to grandma. An iPod modified to be a transaction verifier would be very grandma-friendly (if someone else does the modification, of course).
looks like nice, i like stuff like this.. if it will cost up to 2.5BTC i will buy it ..
You know, someone could probably build the app to do this in C, targeting Linux as the OS, using serial as the interface, and it would probably run on gobs of hardware that's already out there for nearly free. People could root their old 2nd generation iPod or whatever, and use it as a transaction verifier and be able to get into it for zero hardware cost (or pick one up on eBay).
That's an interesting idea. I have a portable digital storage oscilloscope that appears to have been built into an mp3player hardware. Maybe work from the rockbox project.
You know, someone could probably build the app to do this in C, targeting Linux as the OS, using serial as the interface, and it would probably run on gobs of hardware that's already out there for nearly free. People could root their old 2nd generation iPod or whatever, and use it as a transaction verifier and be able to get into it for zero hardware cost (or pick one up on eBay).
Sure, but that's a nerd thing.
We are targeting grandma's here.
@op, if you have nothing to offer but a cupple of ideas you better be good at organizing everything and being happy even with a little share. Good luck!
You know, someone could probably build the app to do this in C, targeting Linux as the OS, using serial as the interface, and it would probably run on gobs of hardware that's already out there for nearly free. People could root their old 2nd generation iPod or whatever, and use it as a transaction verifier and be able to get into it for zero hardware cost (or pick one up on eBay).
Why do they need you?
Hehe, they don't. However, I have a few undisclosed ideas left.
How about a smartcard with bitcoin wallet?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Java_Card
edit: with usb smart card reader it's quite close what you suggested
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Java_Card
edit: with usb smart card reader it's quite close what you suggested
hmm.. that is kinda cool.
Jump to: