Wow, that's such a profound advice OP, I am pretty sure that even if people follow what you're professing, it's not going to make anyone successful to a certain degree. The advices are generalized and pretty shallow imo because anyone can do all that and at the same time this aren't even a part of the formula to be successful in finances except the reading books about personal finances part and even that is flimsy at best because what could've worked for that person, it might not work for you.
Only one that can be annulled is included in the category, but that's not necessarily the same as reading byuku can improve finances completely in a nutshell, reading takes a long time to understand the essence of what is conveyed and its application also requires time and capital, so it can't be assess that after reading one book you become a person who can manage finances, then we turn it around again we can understand money management but our finances are limited or it is difficult to get more income than we need then we will live by standards in general in class, but I am enough believe that income will go hand in hand with knowledge and ability, so increase it to increase the source of financial flow.
Fulfilling your needs and exercising financial discipline is indeed a good thing and must be done, but what happens if the financial problem is not due to spending or spending arrangements, but rather because of a lack of income, what you mentioned is not useful because of course among people who have financial problems are not in what they want to buy but in the amount of their income, which on average is less so which arrangements are appropriate to implement, if in a situation you need money for outpatient treatment but you also need to eat and drink, what discipline? which must be taken into account in this case.
That's right, we must realize that there are other things that can make someone experience personal finance problems like the one being discussed here, they cannot manage finances because their income is very low, even far from enough, you are right maybe it is only enough for outpatient treatment when they are sick but on the other hand they also need to then and drink. So how can that person manage their finances if what they get is not enough for their life at all. Yes, it's because it's difficult to find additional income, especially in this difficult time, I think you also know that many people now feel difficulties in anything, especially money. So with that alone I think it's normal that they don't have a good income.
Honestly I will not corner them to do this, because obviously they will not be able to because their money is limited and far from enough for their lives. I will only suggest this for people who have good luck in terms of their finances, but as the title above they can't use it well at all, and obviously that's only for them.
So we have to know that everyone has different needs, it could be that those who are not financially well-off have a heavier burden than others in the midst of their income which is far from enough. and honestly I don't really have the right formula for this problem. But I will say that they should remain grateful and enthusiastic to improve their finances.
To be honest, only the person himself understands what the financial situation is like. If you look at what the OP said, there are many factors that influence finances, but the focus is more on spending which makes the discussion seem only for those who have income that can be calculated more. from having enough for their needs but not being able to manage it well, but this becomes unable to see that each person has different conditions in their case which makes the conversation unable to look fair on financial matters, which makes it complicated to draw one side from the other.
You must have read/heard or have experience in talking about finance both in earning income or managing expenses, you don't have to have a complex formula to solve problems, but maybe your knowledge and suggestions can be useful for readers here, sharing a little knowledge is much better .