better something human that contributes to something. Not sure what exactly, but maybe answering questions put up by users or something.
Or maybe adding ratings to something. So the mining would be adding value somewhere and generating the reward.
Identifying dead links or old results from a list.
Hmmm what else.....
Globb0
Topic: I was wondering " A real Human Mineable crypto" (Read 1810 times)
what about some human quorum process where the humans in the system function so as to exclude machines/bots?
What might work is that when you create an avatar, there is a little interview or quiz that establishes you as human.
Basically a Turing test.
The test would give you "human rating points" that are an input to the avatar/name creating transaction. The game system
would encourage players to co-operate and talk to each other and pass "human rating points" to each other. Only transactions
that have human rating as input would be valid.
Huntercoin pretty close to this.
PlanetDollar will be based on free distribution, it's just another way of getting the coin outside of mining: www.planetdollar.org
I think it's important road to go down though.. find ways to distribute outside of just mining.
PlanetDollar will be based on free distribution, it's just another way of getting the coin outside of mining: www.planetdollar.org
I think it's important road to go down though.. find ways to distribute outside of just mining.
Bingocoin, sit everyone down in a physical bingo hall, and whoever gets bingo first gets the coin!
just as the btc blockchain must agree with its majority of versions,
what about some human quorum process where the humans in the system function so as to exclude machines/bots?
what about some human quorum process where the humans in the system function so as to exclude machines/bots?
"A simple maze problem won't do, as these problems are easily cracked by a computer. As for the captcha, where would it be created and checked? Can't do that in client, so you'd probably have to resort to a central server, which is bad."
This is true only if one is armed with a map of the maze.
Quite right. But staying with the maze idea, if the puzzle is to find out the exit from the maze... even then computer (=bot) would always beat human, and the human-mineability is broken.
One naturally thinks that the moves in the maze could be encoded to transactions (just as in Huntercoin). Then solving a block = finding out all the correct moves(transactions) in the correct order = solving path out of the maze.
Only there would have to be some element where humans can better do than machines. Some sort of co-operation and shared communication might do the trick.
Hi folks !!
I was wondering whether it is really possible to create a coin where blocks will be mined by humans .. Like a puzzle will be generated for solving a block and if a person is able to solve it , he gets the reward . And as difficulty increases the puzzles gets harder and harder ..
Is it really possible ?
I was wondering whether it is really possible to create a coin where blocks will be mined by humans .. Like a puzzle will be generated for solving a block and if a person is able to solve it , he gets the reward . And as difficulty increases the puzzles gets harder and harder ..
Is it really possible ?
you mean, like, your girlfriend?
LoL..Unfortunately i have got none...
Hi folks !!
I was wondering whether it is really possible to create a coin where blocks will be mined by humans .. Like a puzzle will be generated for solving a block and if a person is able to solve it , he gets the reward . And as difficulty increases the puzzles gets harder and harder ..
Is it really possible ?
I was wondering whether it is really possible to create a coin where blocks will be mined by humans .. Like a puzzle will be generated for solving a block and if a person is able to solve it , he gets the reward . And as difficulty increases the puzzles gets harder and harder ..
Is it really possible ?
you mean, like, your girlfriend?
Check out HunterCoin.
Yeah ..I checked but is not purely Human Mineable crypto...
it was at the start, now is full of bot, not exactly what you call human minable...
"A simple maze problem won't do, as these problems are easily cracked by a computer. As for the captcha, where would it be created and checked? Can't do that in client, so you'd probably have to resort to a central server, which is bad."
This is true only if one is armed with a map of the maze.
think of this maze more as a 'tunnel network' which has never been explored before.
assuming a map of the maze is as much as assuming that one is provided with the solution to the problem along with the problem.
In the Maze of the Minotaur, victims were not provided with a map to the exit.
im still working on this 'human cryptocurrency' idea. it's a question that has occured to many people. i believ it has a solution.
it is up to us to find it.
plz keep inputting, and thanx to the originator of the thread.
something along that line came to mind also
block is hypercube or sphere of integers.....
proceding inwards... as portions of it are mined...
i thought of connexive pathways.. like the maze...
doors are found.. the 'work'..
access to a path is a transaction..
the volume of the hyperspace you 'own' or have found is the content of your account, or wallet,
thus,... 'worth' is equated to volume... 2,4, or n dimensional.
the prime block is immutable by mathematical lemma.
the prime block is the genotype, the digital state of the 'economy' is the phenotype.
the inner configuration of the cyberspace is clear enough to me, although it is difficult to stuff it through a keyboard.
in any case, the concept of 'maze' or pathway is a good one to work with.
time to think...lol
block is hypercube or sphere of integers.....
proceding inwards... as portions of it are mined...
i thought of connexive pathways.. like the maze...
doors are found.. the 'work'..
access to a path is a transaction..
the volume of the hyperspace you 'own' or have found is the content of your account, or wallet,
thus,... 'worth' is equated to volume... 2,4, or n dimensional.
the prime block is immutable by mathematical lemma.
the prime block is the genotype, the digital state of the 'economy' is the phenotype.
the inner configuration of the cyberspace is clear enough to me, although it is difficult to stuff it through a keyboard.
in any case, the concept of 'maze' or pathway is a good one to work with.
time to think...lol
U r definitely a genius .
A simple maze problem won't do, as these problems are easily cracked by a computer. As for the captcha, where would it be created and checked? Can't do that in client, so you'd probably have to resort to a central server, which is bad.
Here's another idea. Have a client draw up a maze and connect to a random online node. The players at the nodes then play a little game that requires co-operation. For instance: the other player has to capture flag, while the other has to keep monsters away. When the game finishes, both players get X coins. This could obviously be played by bots as well, but perhaps that would not be such a bad thing, if the game was designed to always last a certain amount of time (like by spawning more monsters and flags).
Also, the nodes/players could have a chat window for exchanging messages. Players could be given "humanness rating"
by other players, so those players who have been verified as humans would be rewarded in some way by the system, for example by giving them more chances to play.
Here's another idea. Have a client draw up a maze and connect to a random online node. The players at the nodes then play a little game that requires co-operation. For instance: the other player has to capture flag, while the other has to keep monsters away. When the game finishes, both players get X coins. This could obviously be played by bots as well, but perhaps that would not be such a bad thing, if the game was designed to always last a certain amount of time (like by spawning more monsters and flags).
Also, the nodes/players could have a chat window for exchanging messages. Players could be given "humanness rating"
by other players, so those players who have been verified as humans would be rewarded in some way by the system, for example by giving them more chances to play.Thanks for coming up with that . But I think this will make it more complicated .
How about updating the post with the ideas possible and what are is still a barrier . So people don't have to read the whole post before replying with a suggestions..
The problem is that with this method you'd need quite a centralised system or something to read the input of the people solving these puzzles but I'm sure people who are better at programming could elaborate on that and know for sure if it's possible or not. Bitcoin's major advantage is precisely that everything is automated and can easily be done by desktop PCs, not requiring a huge network of servers or anything like that as traditional banking systems have always had to use.
While I think it would be a fantastic idea and certainly a next step when it comes to using Bitcoin's protocol I have trouble seeing how it would be done realistically without somebody having a central server and hovering over everything, there would need to be some kind of automated system going in the background to calculate whether people are actually legitimately solving these puzzles and as people have already said, things like captcha's and so on are easily solved by bots.
There's also the question of how you would deal with hackers and cheaters etc.
While I think it would be a fantastic idea and certainly a next step when it comes to using Bitcoin's protocol I have trouble seeing how it would be done realistically without somebody having a central server and hovering over everything, there would need to be some kind of automated system going in the background to calculate whether people are actually legitimately solving these puzzles and as people have already said, things like captcha's and so on are easily solved by bots.
There's also the question of how you would deal with hackers and cheaters etc.
A simple maze problem won't do, as these problems are easily cracked by a computer. As for the captcha, where would it be created and checked? Can't do that in client, so you'd probably have to resort to a central server, which is bad.
Here's another idea. Have a client draw up a maze and connect to a random online node. The players at the nodes then play a little game that requires co-operation. For instance: the other player has to capture flag, while the other has to keep monsters away. When the game finishes, both players get X coins. This could obviously be played by bots as well, but perhaps that would not be such a bad thing, if the game was designed to always last a certain amount of time (like by spawning more monsters and flags).
Also, the nodes/players could have a chat window for exchanging messages. Players could be given "humanness rating" by other players, so those players who have been verified as humans would be rewarded in some way by the system, for example by giving them more chances to play.
Here's another idea. Have a client draw up a maze and connect to a random online node. The players at the nodes then play a little game that requires co-operation. For instance: the other player has to capture flag, while the other has to keep monsters away. When the game finishes, both players get X coins. This could obviously be played by bots as well, but perhaps that would not be such a bad thing, if the game was designed to always last a certain amount of time (like by spawning more monsters and flags).
Also, the nodes/players could have a chat window for exchanging messages. Players could be given "humanness rating"
by other players, so those players who have been verified as humans would be rewarded in some way by the system, for example by giving them more chances to play.
something along that line came to mind also
block is hypercube or sphere of integers.....
proceding inwards... as portions of it are mined...
i thought of connexive pathways.. like the maze...
doors are found.. the 'work'..
access to a path is a transaction..
the volume of the hyperspace you 'own' or have found is the content of your account, or wallet,
thus,... 'worth' is equated to volume... 2,4, or n dimensional.
the prime block is immutable by mathematical lemma.
the prime block is the genotype, the digital state of the 'economy' is the phenotype.
the inner configuration of the cyberspace is clear enough to me, although it is difficult to stuff it through a keyboard.
in any case, the concept of 'maze' or pathway is a good one to work with.
time to think...lol
block is hypercube or sphere of integers.....
proceding inwards... as portions of it are mined...
i thought of connexive pathways.. like the maze...
doors are found.. the 'work'..
access to a path is a transaction..
the volume of the hyperspace you 'own' or have found is the content of your account, or wallet,
thus,... 'worth' is equated to volume... 2,4, or n dimensional.
the prime block is immutable by mathematical lemma.
the prime block is the genotype, the digital state of the 'economy' is the phenotype.
the inner configuration of the cyberspace is clear enough to me, although it is difficult to stuff it through a keyboard.
in any case, the concept of 'maze' or pathway is a good one to work with.
time to think...lol
I meant to use a captcha beofore submitting a block that will be a puzzle or something that can be solved by a human brain or a botnet and using captcha on top of it just to be secure and sure that the block was mined by a person.
I like the idea. A block could be solved by working out a maze puzzle, and as difficulty increases the maze becomes more complex.
Quote
System should be decentralized: only shared state should be in the blockchain. How would one generate puzzles/captchas without central server?
The hash of the previous block could possibly serve as a parameter for maze generation?
Quote
I think we need some more expertised devs to work this out. but still atleast you got a start . And we can also wait for some others for their views .
more to come
all right, here's a start.
each network standard node contains a copy of "the prime block"
the prime block contains some # of crypto units. people like big #s so lets say one quadrillion [10^15] Kryptonite. [give it a catchy name, right?]
nodes are available for download from any other node.
nodes, and the prime block are immutable, they must demonstrate conformance with all other nodes, and copies of the prime block cannot ever change.
........................at this point i'm having a little trouble making the mining human only, after all, ive only had a few minutes to work on it............................
my thoughts are getting interesting though.
presuming we design the working foundation of this coin,
do we have access to the progremming expertise needed to manifest it?
each network standard node contains a copy of "the prime block"
the prime block contains some # of crypto units. people like big #s so lets say one quadrillion [10^15] Kryptonite. [give it a catchy name, right?]
nodes are available for download from any other node.
nodes, and the prime block are immutable, they must demonstrate conformance with all other nodes, and copies of the prime block cannot ever change.
........................at this point i'm having a little trouble making the mining human only, after all, ive only had a few minutes to work on it............................
my thoughts are getting interesting though.
presuming we design the working foundation of this coin,
do we have access to the progremming expertise needed to manifest it?
I think we need some more expertised devs to work this out. but still atleast you got a start . And we can also wait for some others for their views .
all right, here's a start.
each network standard node contains a copy of "the prime block"
the prime block contains some # of crypto units. people like big #s so lets say one quadrillion [10^15] Kryptonite. [give it a catchy name, right?]
nodes are available for download from any other node.
nodes, and the prime block are immutable, they must demonstrate conformance with all other nodes, and copies of the prime block cannot ever change.
........................at this point i'm having a little trouble making the mining human only, after all, ive only had a few minutes to work on it............................
my thoughts are getting interesting though.
presuming we design the working foundation of this coin,
do we have access to the progremming expertise needed to manifest it?
each network standard node contains a copy of "the prime block"
the prime block contains some # of crypto units. people like big #s so lets say one quadrillion [10^15] Kryptonite. [give it a catchy name, right?]
nodes are available for download from any other node.
nodes, and the prime block are immutable, they must demonstrate conformance with all other nodes, and copies of the prime block cannot ever change.
........................at this point i'm having a little trouble making the mining human only, after all, ive only had a few minutes to work on it............................
my thoughts are getting interesting though.
presuming we design the working foundation of this coin,
do we have access to the progremming expertise needed to manifest it?
I don't think captchas would work out, since sites like http://megatypers.com/ exist.
Also, websites that already use captchas could just give out the captchas that they're mining instead, giving them a huge advantage.
Also, websites that already use captchas could just give out the captchas that they're mining instead, giving them a huge advantage.
for that it can use some different kind of captchas or anything that is not solveable by a botnet.
Well . I think my words got you mislead.
I meant to use a captcha beofore submitting a block that will be a puzzle or something that can be solved by a human brain or a botnet and using captcha on top of it just to be secure and sure that the block was mined by a person.
sure, it can be done.
just figured it out...
what is the objective of the coin?
i can see clearly the objective of the method..
but the coin, .. why create it?
before i put more thought into it id like to know in what way it would better our lives.
just figured it out...
what is the objective of the coin?
i can see clearly the objective of the method..
but the coin, .. why create it?
before i put more thought into it id like to know in what way it would better our lives.
Well the objective will be to make a coin not mineable by a botnet thus making it safe from pump n dump.
And the main problem i feel for crypto currency is hardware . Since a normal person will not be able to afford a costly GPU or CPU or ASIC for mining but definetly he can use his brain for mining . and as mining is done with brain there will be no to negligible electrical expense.
sure, it can be done.
just figured it out...
what is the objective of the coin?
i can see clearly the objective of the method..
but the coin, .. why create it?
before i put more thought into it id like to know in what way it would better our lives.
just figured it out...
what is the objective of the coin?
i can see clearly the objective of the method..
but the coin, .. why create it?
before i put more thought into it id like to know in what way it would better our lives.
Jump to: