It seems like it would be easy to answer the simple questions asked by Marcus above.
If it so easy then I suggest you start putting together the report with all the transactions reported here. I'll fill in the blanks.
You can be a volunteer too like the people who ran instawalllet as a free service.
...unless there is reason those 'haters' are correct. Lots of MtGox people used similar arguments when people challenged their solvency.
Mtgox customers are victims, not haters.
The haters are not victims because they got their money back yet continue to spread FUD.
Did Phinn ever get his 1000 BTC returned?
Ask him. I do not know about any valid claim of such amount. It sounds insane to store so much on an instawallet.
If there was ever a valid claim from this person, it would have been paid back.