Pages:
Author

Topic: Is bitcoin vulnerable? (Read 2266 times)

sr. member
Activity: 303
Merit: 250
June 18, 2015, 11:51:30 AM
#48
I think bitcoin is very robust as it is decentralize.
It's can't be killed by anyone.

YES ! It's can't be killed by anyone. it's the beauty of bitcoin
sr. member
Activity: 462
Merit: 250
June 18, 2015, 05:55:25 AM
#47
I think bitcoin is very robust as it is decentralize.
It's can't be killed by anyone.
sr. member
Activity: 303
Merit: 250
June 18, 2015, 02:34:08 AM
#46
No, bitcoin is not vulnerable ,but, some associates are vulnerable & they have to fix immediately !
legendary
Activity: 3038
Merit: 4418
Crypto Swap Exchange
June 14, 2015, 11:18:26 AM
#45
Maybe if bitcoin becomes very popular perhaps the elites in power now will stage some type of blackout and send themselves 50% of bitcoin?
You're obviously mistaken about what a 50% attack can do.
Sending 50% of bitcoin to themselves is not what the evildoers could achieve by staging a global blackout.
Double-spending attacks, well, possible, but there would be no targets to launch them at. There'd simply be no one to accept those double-spends.
Receiving 100% of the block rewards for the time of the blackout? Absolutely.
That's somewhat less than 4000 BTC per day of the global blackout.

4000 BTC/day in comparison to the huge negative impact on economy during the global blackout?
Well, no one said powerful elites were smart. But stupid like that? Roll Eyes

edit: typos
Can't the government just spend a bunch of money and overtake the Bitcoin mining world with a 51% attack?

it was already said numerous times, the cost of doing this far exceed the cost of doing the exact same thing, but helping the network instead, thus retrieving profit with the usual mining reward system...
If government want to take over bitcoin; or seriously regulate it, then the best and simplest course of action is to regulate bitcoin mining. The most crucial way is for governments to regulate ASIC manufacturing, for example by forcing manufacturers to add kill switches to the hardware or require end users to have licenses. It would be pretty easy operation, and it can be done without high cost.
I fail to see how regulation of ASICs can be done effectively and affect Bitcoin. It isn't easy at all. Reducing the hashrate doesn't affect much. There are still many other companies all around the world. It will never be possible for every miner to own a license. The fact that you can mine while connected to tor makes it even harder. A simple firmware mod can easily bypass the "kill switch" you said. Furthermore, to regulate mining, you are going to have to regulate the computer industry as a whole too. Don't forget CPU and GPU can also mine.
legendary
Activity: 1596
Merit: 1005
★Nitrogensports.eu★
June 14, 2015, 10:18:28 AM
#44
Maybe if bitcoin becomes very popular perhaps the elites in power now will stage some type of blackout and send themselves 50% of bitcoin?
You're obviously mistaken about what a 50% attack can do.
Sending 50% of bitcoin to themselves is not what the evildoers could achieve by staging a global blackout.
Double-spending attacks, well, possible, but there would be no targets to launch them at. There'd simply be no one to accept those double-spends.
Receiving 100% of the block rewards for the time of the blackout? Absolutely.
That's somewhat less than 4000 BTC per day of the global blackout.

4000 BTC/day in comparison to the huge negative impact on economy during the global blackout?
Well, no one said powerful elites were smart. But stupid like that? Roll Eyes

edit: typos
Can't the government just spend a bunch of money and overtake the Bitcoin mining world with a 51% attack?

it was already said numerous times, the cost of doing this far exceed the cost of doing the exact same thing, but helping the network instead, thus retrieving profit with the usual mining reward system...
If government want to take over bitcoin; or seriously regulate it, then the best and simplest course of action is to regulate bitcoin mining. The most crucial way is for governments to regulate ASIC manufacturing, for example by forcing manufacturers to add kill switches to the hardware or require end users to have licenses. It would be pretty easy operation, and it can be done without high cost.
legendary
Activity: 3248
Merit: 1070
June 14, 2015, 10:00:57 AM
#43
Maybe if bitcoin becomes very popular perhaps the elites in power now will stage some type of blackout and send themselves 50% of bitcoin?
You're obviously mistaken about what a 50% attack can do.
Sending 50% of bitcoin to themselves is not what the evildoers could achieve by staging a global blackout.
Double-spending attacks, well, possible, but there would be no targets to launch them at. There'd simply be no one to accept those double-spends.
Receiving 100% of the block rewards for the time of the blackout? Absolutely.
That's somewhat less than 4000 BTC per day of the global blackout.

4000 BTC/day in comparison to the huge negative impact on economy during the global blackout?
Well, no one said powerful elites were smart. But stupid like that? Roll Eyes

edit: typos
Can't the government just spend a bunch of money and overtake the Bitcoin mining world with a 51% attack?

it was already said numerous times, the cost of doing this far exceed the cost of doing the exact same thing, but helping the network instead, thus retrieving profit with the usual mining reward system...
legendary
Activity: 1554
Merit: 1026
★Nitrogensports.eu★
June 14, 2015, 09:34:56 AM
#42
Maybe if bitcoin becomes very popular perhaps the elites in power now will stage some type of blackout and send themselves 50% of bitcoin?
You're obviously mistaken about what a 50% attack can do.
Sending 50% of bitcoin to themselves is not what the evildoers could achieve by staging a global blackout.
Double-spending attacks, well, possible, but there would be no targets to launch them at. There'd simply be no one to accept those double-spends.
Receiving 100% of the block rewards for the time of the blackout? Absolutely.
That's somewhat less than 4000 BTC per day of the global blackout.

4000 BTC/day in comparison to the huge negative impact on economy during the global blackout?
Well, no one said powerful elites were smart. But stupid like that? Roll Eyes

edit: typos
Can't the government just spend a bunch of money and overtake the Bitcoin mining world with a 51% attack?

Is it really worth the cost/effort?
Bitcoin is not such a big threat.... yet.
legendary
Activity: 3374
Merit: 1824
June 14, 2015, 07:57:29 AM
#41
No.

But here is some food for thought.

What if there was a global black out, some how... wouldn't bitcoin be vulnerable to someone with solar powered computer and internet access?- (an engineered global black out just in case you were going to say that there wouldn't be internet access"


It will not work and blackout on a global scale is near impossible. Bitcoin is very safe from any sort of vulnerabilities, there are several ways which bitcoins are vulnerable, if 51% of miners get together and decide to hard fork; or cracking the sha 256 algorithm on whose back bitcoin is build, on which case both are near impossible to do and likely won't happen in the next 100 years.

This really seems like a scenario from a catastrophic movie and personally I do not believe it.
What would be the possible motivation of miners to do something like this?
What would they get by killing their ''golden goose'' which brings income to them?
I really don't see any realistic reason for it.
hero member
Activity: 994
Merit: 500
June 13, 2015, 08:12:06 PM
#40
Maybe if bitcoin becomes very popular perhaps the elites in power now will stage some type of blackout and send themselves 50% of bitcoin?
You're obviously mistaken about what a 50% attack can do.
Sending 50% of bitcoin to themselves is not what the evildoers could achieve by staging a global blackout.
Double-spending attacks, well, possible, but there would be no targets to launch them at. There'd simply be no one to accept those double-spends.
Receiving 100% of the block rewards for the time of the blackout? Absolutely.
That's somewhat less than 4000 BTC per day of the global blackout.

4000 BTC/day in comparison to the huge negative impact on economy during the global blackout?
Well, no one said powerful elites were smart. But stupid like that? Roll Eyes

edit: typos
Can't the government just spend a bunch of money and overtake the Bitcoin mining world with a 51% attack?
legendary
Activity: 3248
Merit: 1070
June 12, 2015, 10:08:36 AM
#39
If there is no internet, Bitcoin is the least of your problems.

this is debatable, if you have a big stash of bitcoin, losing the access to it, indefinitely, it will be one of your biggest problem, especially if those are the only money you have

Little known fact humans need water and food to survive.  I know most people don't know this but it's true!

only true if after the black out, we return to a point where money aren't really needed, and we can just fight our way through the jungle , to get food by hunting and water

do you really think that this scenario is realistic, if a blackout really happens? to me it seems a bit fanciful

legendary
Activity: 1512
Merit: 1011
June 12, 2015, 10:01:06 AM
#38
No.

But here is some food for thought.

What if there was a global black out, some how... wouldn't bitcoin be vulnerable to someone with solar powered computer and internet access?- (an engineered global black out just in case you were going to say that there wouldn't be internet access"


It will not work and blackout on a global scale is near impossible. Bitcoin is very safe from any sort of vulnerabilities, there are several ways which bitcoins are vulnerable, if 51% of miners get together and decide to hard fork; or cracking the sha 256 algorithm on whose back bitcoin is build, on which case both are near impossible to do and likely won't happen in the next 100 years.
legendary
Activity: 1638
Merit: 1163
Where is my ring of blades...
June 12, 2015, 09:52:58 AM
#37
No.

But here is some food for thought.

What if there was a global black out, some how... wouldn't bitcoin be vulnerable to someone with solar powered computer and internet access?- (an engineered global black out just in case you were going to say that there wouldn't be internet access"


I think if there would be a global black out , people who have solar power even if they were mining bitcoin before, they would stop doing it because they are going to need that precious power then.
in the world without power the one with the power has the money, they don't need bitcoin anymore!
hero member
Activity: 658
Merit: 500
June 12, 2015, 09:52:20 AM
#36
If there is no internet, Bitcoin is the least of your problems.

this is debatable, if you have a big stash of bitcoin, losing the access to it, indefinitely, it will be one of your biggest problem, especially if those are the only money you have

Little known fact humans need water and food to survive.  I know most people don't know this but it's true!

To survive, yes. but humans do way more than surviving.
copper member
Activity: 2968
Merit: 575
www.Crypto.Games: Multiple coins, multiple games
June 12, 2015, 09:46:58 AM
#35
If there is no internet, Bitcoin is the least of your problems.

this is debatable, if you have a big stash of bitcoin, losing the access to it, indefinitely, it will be one of your biggest problem, especially if those are the only money you have

Little known fact humans need water and food to survive.  I know most people don't know this but it's true!
And in order to get food and water people nowadays needs money. In other words without money it's hard to survive.

Like Amph said if you have a huge amount of bitcoin as an asset this is going to be a huge problem because due to a global black out  you won't be able to access your "DIGITAL"  currency!  There are some thirdworld countries that have no access to generators and solar powered computers.
legendary
Activity: 1722
Merit: 1000
June 12, 2015, 09:30:25 AM
#34
If there is no internet, Bitcoin is the least of your problems.

this is debatable, if you have a big stash of bitcoin, losing the access to it, indefinitely, it will be one of your biggest problem, especially if those are the only money you have

Little known fact humans need water and food to survive.  I know most people don't know this but it's true!
legendary
Activity: 1722
Merit: 1000
June 12, 2015, 09:28:48 AM
#33
No.

But here is some food for thought.

What if there was a global black out, some how... wouldn't bitcoin be vulnerable to someone with solar powered computer and internet access?- (an engineered global black out just in case you were going to say that there wouldn't be internet access"



Do you actually understand what a global black out would do..?

I REALLY don't think you do. 
legendary
Activity: 1946
Merit: 1137
June 12, 2015, 08:27:54 AM
#32
if global blackout happens, bitcoin and what happens to blockchain is going to be your least worries since it is going to be chaos everywhere and you have to worry about survival instead of bitcoin.
Q7
sr. member
Activity: 448
Merit: 250
June 12, 2015, 07:14:37 AM
#31
I don't understand why suddenly this becomes an issue. Each country in the world have their own power generation capability and capacity. For a global blackout to take place all at the same time, you are talking about probability that is so small that is almost negligible. Unless you are referring to a solar storm which probably is somehow possible but very rare but then, what are the chances for it to hit every country in the world.
hero member
Activity: 774
Merit: 500
Lazy Lurker Reads Alot
June 12, 2015, 06:59:09 AM
#30
LOL if internet goes down we all are screwed .... hence my quote "|I can promise you can not do shet anymore without internet|"
My banks, access to governement, insurance, tv everything else i did not mention at this short answer is internet based
So if it goes down bitcoin is not your only concern, your lost i can even promise that alot of jobs can't be done for instance because they work online in the cloud.
For example office360 and much more programs.
Think about how used we are to use the internet, nobody ever goes to loopup info at books anymore ..... WE GOOGLE IT ALL.
You gonna cry if the net is down !!!
legendary
Activity: 1386
Merit: 1000
English <-> Portuguese translations
June 12, 2015, 06:47:12 AM
#29
Receiving 100% of the block rewards for the time of the blackout? Absolutely.
That's somewhat less than 4000 BTC per day of the global blackout.
Not exactly. The difficulty changes only about every 2 weeks, so it will remain at the same level for days after the blackout.
During those days, the people with the "solar computer" will get 100% of the block rewards, but because they are the total hash power working at the same difficulty, it will be much more than 10 minutes between blocks, meaning much less than 4000 BTC per day.
Also good to remeber that the difficulty would not be adjusted at only one difficulty change.
There's a "min and max" possible change when the new difficulty is calculated.
Pages:
Jump to: