Topic: Let us define constructive posts (wrt DaDice signature campaign) - page 3. (Read 2898 times)
March 15, 2015, 05:37:45 AM
Can you have a look at my posting as well? I would like to know if my posts are constructive or appearing spammy
I think most signature campaign managers obviously rule out posts like a smiley, +1, and one word posts. Apart from those they probably have a minimum word count and require the post to have some bearing on the thread's topic. I saw one post that was cut and pasted words from a song. That's the kind of thing that would get disqualified.
Well, I got to get more opinions so that we can improve our counting. lol, I couldn't find this and didn't know it was moved from Services section to Meta. Had to gt herre form recent posts. Will put a link in our campaign thread to get more opinions 
Edit: Would also like any suggestions on including and excluding boards.
Edit: Would also like any suggestions on including and excluding boards.
Maybe you should change the title to Let us define constructive posts (wrt DaDice signature campaign)
If this is specific to the signature campaign, Marketplace --> Service Discussion would be the right place for this thread.
Yeah, I guess. Initially it was not intended to be relating to dadice campaign. Now I think, it is.
I will move it to Service Discussion and change the title.
Thanks
I think this should be directed to all signature campaigners, due to the recent events of alot of campaigners banned because of insubstantial post + sig adds, campaign manager on the other hands should be strict to this issue, there are quite some signature campaigns that dont check the post quality of their campaigner
Well, I got to get more opinions so that we can improve our counting. lol, I couldn't find this and didn't know it was moved from Services section to Meta. Had to gt herre form recent posts. Will put a link in our campaign thread to get more opinions
Edit: Would also like any suggestions on including and excluding boards.
Edit: Would also like any suggestions on including and excluding boards.
Maybe you should change the title to Let us define constructive posts (wrt DaDice signature campaign)
If this is specific to the signature campaign, Marketplace --> Service Discussion would be the right place for this thread.
Yeah, I guess. Initially it was not intended to be relating to dadice campaign. Now I think, it is.
I will move it to Service Discussion and change the title.
Thanks
Well, I got to get more opinions so that we can improve our counting. lol, I couldn't find this and didn't know it was moved from Services section to Meta. Had to gt herre form recent posts. Will put a link in our campaign thread to get more opinions
Edit: Would also like any suggestions on including and excluding boards.
Edit: Would also like any suggestions on including and excluding boards.
Maybe you should change the title to Let us define constructive posts (wrt DaDice signature campaign)
If this is specific to the signature campaign, Marketplace --> Service Discussion would be the right place for this thread.
--snip--
for me, constructive would be either your post give a contribution to the topic or not
in other words, we can just imagine, did our post actually give up worthy opinion for the discussion topic on the thread or answer up question related to the discussion topic
Thanks
Out of the last 20 posts here: https://bitcointalksearch.org/user/mishax1-125554 , for instance, (if you take all boards as included except the ones in the dadice campaign thread), how many posts will you consider as constructive?
Im not in a position to judge, since i mself consider that not all of my post can be considered constructive too and also the words "constructive post" in this forum cannot be define acutally , because it is due to the preference and judgement of some people are slighty different one another
I will personally exclude #20, 19, 17, 16, 15, 12, 4 and 3 as being not constructive enough, since im not in a position to judge as mine was not better than any top poster in this meta board
Thanks for your opinion
He had posted that he considers at least 90%+ of his posts to be constructive. That is why I just asked
Well, I got to get more opinions so that we can improve our counting. lol, I couldn't find this and didn't know it was moved from Services section to Meta. Had to gt herre form recent posts. Will put a link in our campaign thread to get more opinions
Edit: Would also like any suggestions on including and excluding boards.
--snip--
for me, constructive would be either your post give a contribution to the topic or not
in other words, we can just imagine, did our post actually give up worthy opinion for the discussion topic on the thread or answer up question related to the discussion topic
Thanks
Out of the last 20 posts here: https://bitcointalksearch.org/user/mishax1-125554 , for instance, (if you take all boards as included except the ones in the dadice campaign thread), how many posts will you consider as constructive?
Im not in a position to judge, since i mself consider that not all of my post can be considered constructive too and also the words "constructive post" in this forum cannot be define acutally , because it is due to the preference and judgement of some people are slighty different one another
I will personally exclude #20, 19, 17, 16, 15, 12, 4 and 3 as being not constructive enough, since im not in a position to judge as mine was not better than any top poster in this meta board
--snip--
for me, constructive would be either your post give a contribution to the topic or not
in other words, we can just imagine, did our post actually give up worthy opinion for the discussion topic on the thread or answer up question related to the discussion topic
Thanks
Out of the last 20 posts here: https://bitcointalksearch.org/user/mishax1-125554 , for instance, (if you take all boards as included except the ones in the dadice campaign thread), how many posts will you consider as constructive?
Constructive is a relative term and it differs from person to person. I am making this thread to get an idea (for me and for the readers) what posts are generally accepted as constructive and which are not.
While making the spreadsheet for the dadice campaign, I found a way to check the board of posting and also the number of characters in a post. But how can it know which is constructive, which is not?
I always wondered how bit-x bot uses differentiates between both. I think they merely check the number of characters and at the end of the period they check the recent posts of relevant pariticpants and take a percentage of their post count as not-constructive, deduct it and payout for the rest.
Any way to do this?
(We won't make the ultimate count automated, but it will be better if we show approximately how many posts will be counted in real time)
Let me know your thoughts
To post what you think as constructive and what as not, quote a post and say whether it is constructive, why/ why not you consider it so. Try not to quote your own posts.
(Please don't be offended if someone quotes your post as not constructive. It is just a chance to know what people think and how you can improve)
Thank you
While making the spreadsheet for the dadice campaign, I found a way to check the board of posting and also the number of characters in a post. But how can it know which is constructive, which is not?
I always wondered how bit-x bot uses differentiates between both. I think they merely check the number of characters and at the end of the period they check the recent posts of relevant pariticpants and take a percentage of their post count as not-constructive, deduct it and payout for the rest.
Any way to do this?
(We won't make the ultimate count automated, but it will be better if we show approximately how many posts will be counted in real time)
Let me know your thoughts
To post what you think as constructive and what as not, quote a post and say whether it is constructive, why/ why not you consider it so. Try not to quote your own posts.
(Please don't be offended if someone quotes your post as not constructive. It is just a chance to know what people think and how you can improve)
Thank you
for me, constructive would be either your post give a contribution to the topic or not
in other words, we can just imagine, did our post actually give up worthy opinion for the discussion topic on the thread or answer up question related to the discussion topic
Constructive is a relative term and it differs from person to person. I am making this thread to get an idea (for me and for the readers) what posts are generally accepted as constructive and which are not.
While making the spreadsheet for the dadice campaign, I found a way to check the board of posting and also the number of characters in a post. But how can it know which is constructive, which is not?
I always wondered how bit-x bot uses differentiates between both. I think they merely check the number of characters and at the end of the period they check the recent posts of relevant pariticpants and take a percentage of their post count as not-constructive, deduct it and payout for the rest.
Any way to do this?
(We won't make the ultimate count automated, but it will be better if we show approximately how many posts will be counted in real time)
Let me know your thoughts
To post what you think as constructive and what as not, quote a post and say whether it is constructive, why/ why not you consider it so. Try not to quote your own posts.
(Please don't be offended if someone quotes your post as not constructive. It is just a chance to know what people think and how you can improve)
Thank you
While making the spreadsheet for the dadice campaign, I found a way to check the board of posting and also the number of characters in a post. But how can it know which is constructive, which is not?
I always wondered how bit-x bot uses differentiates between both. I think they merely check the number of characters and at the end of the period they check the recent posts of relevant pariticpants and take a percentage of their post count as not-constructive, deduct it and payout for the rest.
Any way to do this?
(We won't make the ultimate count automated, but it will be better if we show approximately how many posts will be counted in real time)
Let me know your thoughts
To post what you think as constructive and what as not, quote a post and say whether it is constructive, why/ why not you consider it so. Try not to quote your own posts.
(Please don't be offended if someone quotes your post as not constructive. It is just a chance to know what people think and how you can improve)
Thank you
Jump to: