Manipulation / ETF's | Bitcointalksearch.org

criptoevangelista

sr. member

Activity: 448

Merit: 691

In ₿ we trust

Quote from: franky1 on January 05, 2024, 01:45:42 PM

....

This is very interesting, these days I have been researching exactly where the big market players buy their bitcoins, especially because it is not through the traditional retail system.

A giant purchase of bitcoin would cause substantial damage to an exchange's offerings, bringing unusual volatility.

Thank you for sharing this knowledge.

Kemarit

legendary

Activity: 3080

Merit: 1353

Quote from: bluebit25 on January 06, 2024, 04:16:31 PM

I can only feel it will cause volatility in the short term before the news and after the news, but in the long term we still have many other things to see about the possibility of all acceptance of bitcoin. The SEC may exert their power, but they are not the sole controllers and given the nature of bitcoin it is here to stay. I remember the "Tulip Syndrome" that was gradually forgotten when we had to be realistic that with bitcoin it was in a completely different state, and the comparison no longer applies much to that.

To be honest, I don't think that Bitcoin can even be compare to the Tulip Mania before. It was really a bubble and so just matter of time before it will blew up and bubble being burst.

Quote from: bluebit25 on January 06, 2024, 04:16:31 PM

This market's scale is still too small, those who come early always keep their opportunities and also take risks, but anyway, as someone who has absolute faith in bitcoin, I expect there will be more and more large organizations pay more attention to bitcoin.

I think it's big enough to accommodate institutional money and retail investors. And I don't think that someone can manipulate the price before or even the approval of Spot Bitcoin ETF. Investors are too much for that right now, we will call it when we see that there are entities from behind trying to control the market. And I do think that the market is going to mature once we see the first Bitcoin ETF approval regardless of who is is going to be.

bluebit25

sr. member

Activity: 1708

Merit: 295

https://bitlist.co

I can only feel it will cause volatility in the short term before the news and after the news, but in the long term we still have many other things to see about the possibility of all acceptance of bitcoin. The SEC may exert their power, but they are not the sole controllers and given the nature of bitcoin it is here to stay. I remember the "Tulip Syndrome" that was gradually forgotten when we had to be realistic that with bitcoin it was in a completely different state, and the comparison no longer applies much to that.

This market's scale is still too small, those who come early always keep their opportunities and also take risks, but anyway, as someone who has absolute faith in bitcoin, I expect there will be more and more large organizations pay more attention to bitcoin.

ChiBitCTy

legendary

Activity: 2282

Merit: 3014

I would say this is really no different than many other areas of the financial world that are overseen by the SEC. As a licensed FA who's under SEC "rule", so to speak ( or more so FINRA rule), I have seen the SEC allow ALL SORTS of shit that's not remotely legitimate. Take a look at how "dark pools" operate. Or take a look at "bonus annuities". There some real shady shady stuff going on that the SEC truly doesn't give a fck about.

That said sure, I'm not sure it will manipulate bitcoin like ETFs do to many stocks. Think about say a healthcare ETF (I like VHT quite a bit). There's some dog performers in that fund that are artificially being propped up like no other because of the fact that so much money gets pumped in to it, mainly for the other stocks inside of it that are attractive. At least bitcoin is just bitcoin and it's not pumping up itself in the way that money to an ETF with many assets inside can/does.

PrivacyG

hero member

Activity: 882

Merit: 1873

Crypto Swap Exchange

For Shit Coins it is easy to manipulate with a small bag of Coins. You can purchase a few thousand Dollars worth of a Shit Coin and change its Market Cap and value by 50 percent.

For Bitcoin and such other huge Cryptocurrencies, it is easier and smarter to manipulate using power of influence. You release negative news, produce negativity and negative events and talk big names into helping you out with it. This includes institutions and Governments themselves publishing such information that always has an impact on the Market.

To manipulate the Bitcoin Market you likely need as much money as you would to change other Markets that are just as large.

highalch

jr. member

Activity: 87

Merit: 3

Quote from: moneystery on January 06, 2024, 11:25:22 AM

Quote from: highalch on January 06, 2024, 02:50:26 AM

Since Blackrock is a 10 trillion dollar company, they technically are able to manipulate every market in the world.

....

you are wrong, blackrock is not that valuable, they are only ranked 118th most valuable company by market cap. the $9.42 trillion you mean is probably assets under their management

Yes I mistyped, but obviously meant AUM. That's what matters, that's the "stuff" to manipulate markets with. That 10T is not a minor footnote to ignore.

bettercrypto

sr. member

Activity: 1498

Merit: 271

DGbet.fun - Crypto Sportsbook

Quote from: Harpaggie2001 on January 05, 2024, 01:19:41 PM

Is there a general consensus on how much volume it takes to move the BTC market price?
Is the SEC not worried about market manipulation?
Is there a legal framework in place to deter / reprimand BTC manipulation? - I realize this could only apply to US patrons.

My theory was that BTC was too susceptible to manipulation to issue an ETF yet. Apparently I'm wrong, which is understandable, because I make beer for a living...

Any friendly opinions welcome!

The bitcoin market is hard to control; why do you think each bitcoin is cheap? And for you to manipulate the market, do you think that 100 bitcoins is all you need to be part of the so-called whale investors?

What do you want to emphasize on the topic of this op?

Quote from: moneystery on January 06, 2024, 11:25:22 AM

Quote from: highalch on January 06, 2024, 02:50:26 AM

Since Blackrock is a 10 trillion dollar company, they technically are able to manipulate every market in the world.

you are wrong, blackrock is not that valuable, they are only ranked 118th most valuable company by market cap. the $9.42 trillion you mean is probably assets under their management, in management it means they manage these assets but do not have full rights to them.

while bitcoin's market capitalization is around 864.23b and is predicted to increase, and that is many times compared to blackrock's valuation. so for them to be able to manipulate the bitcoin market would be very difficult because they would need to mobilize a lot of resources just to move the market which could actually harm their company.

How did you say that Blackrock is not that valuable? And for you, it's only ranked as the 118th most valuable company in the world? Do you think it's easy to be included in that ranking achieved by Blackrock? I'm not defending Blackrock; I don't really care about that.

If Blackrock is not that valuable, why is it included in the most valuable company in the world? Do you think it's that easy to get Blackrock ranked as one of the most valuable company? You don't seem to understand what you are saying. Sorry, but I'm just correcting what you're saying. Do you think that Blackrock can't be considered one of the potential whale investors? Let's say out of the 9.4 trillion dollars in Blackrock's total assets, 1 trillion of that will be allocated to Bitcoin. Do you think that's a small amount?

moneystery

full member

Activity: 868

Merit: 202

Quote from: highalch on January 06, 2024, 02:50:26 AM

Since Blackrock is a 10 trillion dollar company, they technically are able to manipulate every market in the world.

....

you are wrong, blackrock is not that valuable, they are only ranked 118th most valuable company by market cap. the $9.42 trillion you mean is probably assets under their management, in management it means they manage these assets but do not have full rights to them.

while bitcoin's market capitalization is around 864.23b and is predicted to increase, and that is many times compared to blackrock's valuation. so for them to be able to manipulate the bitcoin market would be very difficult because they would need to mobilize a lot of resources just to move the market which could actually harm their company.

RioBlemz

jr. member

Activity: 77

Merit: 9

Quote from: Harpaggie2001 on January 05, 2024, 01:19:41 PM

Is there a general consensus on how much volume it takes to move the BTC market price?
Is the SEC not worried about market manipulation?
Is there a legal framework in place to deter / reprimand BTC manipulation? - I realize this could only apply to US patrons.

My theory was that BTC was too susceptible to manipulation to issue an ETF yet. Apparently I'm wrong, which is understandable, because I make beer for a living...

Any friendly opinions welcome!

Manipulation is what makes the market interesting. The SEC itself has their interest they are not innocent. They want control as it favors their government.
What you should be sure of Bitcoin has come to stay and the value will increase with time.

BIT-BENDER

hero member

Activity: 1666

Merit: 709

Playbet.io - Crypto Casino and Sportsbook

Quote from: seoincorporation on January 05, 2024, 03:02:21 PM

Quote from: Harpaggie2001 on January 05, 2024, 01:19:41 PM

Is the SEC not worried about market manipulation?

Manipulate bitcoin market is not cheap at all because you are trying to manipulate a market with $854,777,215,245 capitalization, so, even if you join with $1million, $10millions or $100millions, it will be not enough money to make a big difference in the prize.

A good example that we have of market manipulation is what Elon did with Dogecoins, and looks like SEC gives zero fucks about it. So, people don't have to worry about this.

I thought the same too, it's not easy to manipulate the Bitcoin market, Bitcoin has gone far above that right now, you can only manipulate a less saturated market like altcoins, infact to be honest the Acronym FUD fear uncertainty and despair and FOMO fear of missing out are mostly attributed to altcoins especially those new altcoins.
You would need to play around with very huge amount of Bitcoin across a high number of whales before any discussion about Bitcoin manipulation can be carried out.

Solosanz

hero member

Activity: 952

Merit: 662

What you're talking about?

We already face so many manipulations: China ban and unban Bitcoin, no bull season on 2021 due to recession, Bitcoin is bubble, Bitcoin harm the environment, Bitcoin is for money laundering, Elon Musk accept and reject Bitcoin in Tesla etc.

ETF is just the next, since it was caused by centralization (BlackRock), so no surprise if they will accept this year and then reject it at the same year or in the future.

amishmanish

legendary

Activity: 1904

Merit: 1159

Quote from: EarnOnVictor on January 06, 2024, 06:39:12 AM

Quote from: Harpaggie2001 on January 05, 2024, 01:19:41 PM

Is there a general consensus on how much volume it takes to move the BTC market price?

I am happy that it is not me alone who knows that the cryptocurrency market is being manipulated. But the market capital of Bitcoin is discouraging it, yet it is happening as we can see during the ETF saga and some other few times that people may not even notice much. But there can't be a general consensus for this, once the money is big enough, it could possibly move the market as they want depending on the condition the big amount met the market with.

Why are you so sure that the market is being manipulated. Especially Bitcoin. Bitcoin is not promising smart contracts or a world computer. It is just the penultimate settlement layer and reserve currency of the evolving Web3/ DLT world.

Also, when it comes to market manipulation, it is generally stuff like insider trading that corporations can engage in, specifically the people within those organizations who are privy to privileged information. In case of Bitcoin, there is hardly anything that can be hidden. The network is transparent for everyone to see and anybody who tries to buy/ sell the news is going to do it in full public view.

Unless the SEC itself is compromised about the ETF news.

Lucius

legendary

Activity: 3234

Merit: 5637

Blackjack.fun-Free Raffle-Join&Win $50🎲

Quote from: seoincorporation on January 05, 2024, 03:02:21 PM

~snip~
A good example that we have of market manipulation is what Elon did with Dogecoins, and looks like SEC gives zero fucks about it. So, people don't have to worry about this.

I wouldn't say that they (SEC) didn't really care that Mr. Mars was manipulating that altcoin, which managed to pump up to, if I'm not mistaken, $0.70 - and I see proof of that in the fact that he very abruptly stopped what he was doing because he probably received a warning that he could be punished much worse than it was in 2018.

Quote from: bitmover on January 05, 2024, 05:13:50 PM

~snip~
Sec regulatory requirements may be pain in the ass and terrible for price, but they do work to make market manipulation more difficult.

I think they just wanted to ensure as much control as possible over such a way of trading when it comes to Bitcoin, and if they now have the largest company that is practically very close to political structures (BlackRock) and the company that will do the custodial part of the work (Coinbase), we can to conclude that there are conditions for approving such an ETF.

EarnOnVictor

hero member

Activity: 826

Merit: 641

Leading Crypto Sports Betting & Casino Platform

Quote from: Harpaggie2001 on January 05, 2024, 01:19:41 PM

Is there a general consensus on how much volume it takes to move the BTC market price?

I am happy that it is not me alone who knows that the cryptocurrency market is being manipulated. But the market capital of Bitcoin is discouraging it, yet it is happening as we can see during the ETF saga and some other few times that people may not even notice much. But there can't be a general consensus for this, once the money is big enough, it could possibly move the market as they want depending on the condition the big amount met the market with.

Quote

Is the SEC not worried about market manipulation?

Of course, the SEC, as a responsible agency will be worried about this, but they can still do little in the crypto space.

Quote

Is there a legal framework in place to deter / reprimand BTC manipulation? - I realize this could only apply to US patrons.

Well, there will be a time for that, but I certainly do not know when. The privacy and decentralization of cryptocurrency have given room to this unethical practice which is of one the worries of the government. Over time, I think there will be some kind of solution to this, I am certain that the crypto space can't remain the same in the next 10 years in terms of regulation. This, I will 100% support for sanity sake.

Quote

My theory was that BTC was too susceptible to manipulation to issue an ETF yet. Apparently I'm wrong, which is understandable, because I make beer for a living...

My friend, you are not wrong about it, and conversely, maybe it is the beer that made you think you were wrong...lol. People and news outlets use this ETF to manipulate the market. It's no news.

kryptqnick

legendary

Activity: 3248

Merit: 1402

Join the world-leading crypto sportsbook NOW!

It's a good question, but I don't think this is the problem. The SEC just has a strong view about Bitcoin not being a security and thus not being under their regulations, and ETFs are a way of bringing Bitcoin, at least partially, under their regulations. Bitcoin has a huge market capitalization, so actually manipulating the price by operating big amounts of money is extremely hard. I guess there's no consensus in that regard, but I agree with seoincorporation about the amounts that don't have an impact. So it's not about potential price manipulations, in my opinion.

Jegileman

sr. member

Activity: 532

Merit: 250

Quote from: Harpaggie2001 on January 05, 2024, 01:19:41 PM

Is there a general consensus on how much volume it takes to move the BTC market price?
Is the SEC not worried about market manipulation?
Is there a legal framework in place to deter / reprimand BTC manipulation? - I realize this could only apply to US patrons.

My theory was that BTC was too susceptible to manipulation to issue an ETF yet. Apparently I'm wrong, which is understandable, because I make beer for a living...

Any friendly opinions welcome!

Manipulating the market is not something that a single entity can handle. It has to happen the same time by a group of people who hold large amount of BTC in their wallets. The news of Bitcoin ETF that is affecting the market is not a manipulation from SEC per say. But the news will have a lot of implications and impact to the bitcoin holders that are waiting for the verdict from SEC about bitcoin ETF.

SEC might not want to be a part of market manipulation but as it is now, the news of the spot bitcoin ETF is playing a substantial role now and affecting the movement of the market. Whatever happens, it is just a matter of time for bitcoin to recover even when the news would have caused changes to the market movement, it won’t last long because bitcoin cannot be manipulated by a single entity.

highalch

jr. member

Activity: 87

Merit: 3

Since Blackrock is a 10 trillion dollar company, they technically are able to manipulate every market in the world.

Yet, you look for the wrong places. I would not worry about ETF price manipulation, since they're highly regulated. I would rather worry about classic crypto exchanges and their fake trading activities - providing fake volume, fake orders, selling the order flow in secret, etc. In an efficient and liquid market, every exchange would provide nearly the same price for bitcoin. What do you think, why are there .5% differences? Exactly.

goldkingcoiner

legendary

Activity: 2240

Merit: 1993

A Bitcoiner chooses. A slave obeys.

Quote from: Harpaggie2001 on January 05, 2024, 01:19:41 PM

Is there a general consensus on how much volume it takes to move the BTC market price?
Is the SEC not worried about market manipulation?
Is there a legal framework in place to deter / reprimand BTC manipulation? - I realize this could only apply to US patrons.

My theory was that BTC was too susceptible to manipulation to issue an ETF yet. Apparently I'm wrong, which is understandable, because I make beer for a living...

Any friendly opinions welcome!

Market manipulation will always exist. Whether Bitcoin, traditional markets or whatever. The rich will always find a way to secretly screw over everyone else and honestly, they will probably never get caught (and even if they get caught, they probably will not face any kind of harsh punishment).

Look at exhibit A: Elon Musk and Bitcoin/Dogecoin.

bitmover

legendary

Activity: 2352

Merit: 6089

bitcoindata.science

Quote from: Harpaggie2001 on January 05, 2024, 01:19:41 PM

Is the SEC not worried about market manipulation?
Is there a legal framework in place to deter / reprimand BTC manipulation? - I realize this could only apply to US patrons.

My theory was that BTC was too susceptible to manipulation to issue an ETF yet. Apparently I'm wrong, which is understandable, because I make beer for a living...

I think it is quite the opposite.

Bitcoin will be more reliable to market manipulations when the ETF is approved.
There are some reasons for that.

Bitcoin already has a consolidate volume. There are many big players in already, and more big players coming in will mean less concentration of power in the hands of the big players.

Sec regulatory requirements may be pain in the ass and terrible for privacy, but they do work to make market manipulation more difficult.

I think an ETF is inevitable at some point. I don't know when , but it will get approved eventually. People are talking about this since 2016 or whatever.

_act_

legendary

Activity: 1064

Merit: 1298

Lightning network is good with small amount of BTC

Quote from: Harpaggie2001 on January 05, 2024, 01:19:41 PM

My theory was that BTC was too susceptible to manipulation to issue an ETF yet. Apparently I'm wrong, which is understandable, because I make beer for a living...

What you mean is that bitcoin price is more volatile to United States spot ETF news. I can remember the news took the price from $24800 to over $40000 now. But just yesterday that we read a news about the possibility that United States SEC may reject the application, bitcoin fall from over $45000 to $40200 until it increased back. That is not manipulation. It is because people having bitcoin are buying when the news is positive and selling when the news is negative. It is people and no just a single person or few people that are buying or selling that makes the price of bitcoin to be much volatile as it increased or decreased. Bitcoin marketcap is over $860 billion, that is more than what that can be used to manipulate bitcoin price.

Topic: Manipulation / ETF's (Read 240 times)