It will continue from here:
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.1400699
Topic: MMORPG using bitcoins + IMPORTANT UPDATE, MUST READ (Read 3019 times)
Cool, I want a MMORPG where people pay in BTC.
A million likes?
Most of the Bitcoin community hates those "social networks", and I believe that we don't have a million Bitcoin enthusiast that are players.
If you want more people to comment on your idea, post on the Project Development section,
Most of the Bitcoin community hates those "social networks", and I believe that we don't have a million Bitcoin enthusiast that are players.
If you want more people to comment on your idea, post on the Project Development section,
good job,keep it up
What is wrong, why nobody cares now?
Every point listed is really a reason why i wouldnt play your game 
1. Why should everyone be forced to pay? You will get 10-100 times less players.
2. A mmorpg that only runs for a limited time? Noone will invest time or money into that.
3. Yeah right lol, better dont go to the toilet
4. Uhm, why?
5. Ok this is the only one which i would agree on, maybe
1) to make sure that the bitcoin pool will be more tempting(bigger) also to make players play longer and not give up easily1. Why should everyone be forced to pay? You will get 10-100 times less players.
2. A mmorpg that only runs for a limited time? Noone will invest time or money into that.
3. Yeah right lol, better dont go to the toilet
4. Uhm, why?
5. Ok this is the only one which i would agree on, maybe
2) I think it has to be limited but we can have many runs if the first one will be successful
3) you can go to the toilet if you are just standing and not doing any skill(mining etc)
4) actually we can throw this one away but also same reason to keep players playing
5) good that you like
to everyone: its time to discuss the terms!
Every point listed is really a reason why i wouldnt play your game
1. Why should everyone be forced to pay? You will get 10-100 times less players.
2. A mmorpg that only runs for a limited time? Noone will invest time or money into that.
3. Yeah right lol, better dont go to the toilet
4. Uhm, why?
5. Ok this is the only one which i would agree on, maybe
1. Why should everyone be forced to pay? You will get 10-100 times less players.
2. A mmorpg that only runs for a limited time? Noone will invest time or money into that.
3. Yeah right lol, better dont go to the toilet
4. Uhm, why?
5. Ok this is the only one which i would agree on, maybe
Fine, everybody seems to like this idea - RPG game with bitcoin currency. I will do it but only if this page gets a million likes http://www.facebook.com/RpgMoCommunity
Good luck with that! If million likes are not reached by 1st of July then the offer is off.
Terms:
1) Everybody will have to pay a small entrance fee for it to work(about ~10 USD in BTC) to register an account and they can actually get BITCOINS for playing, I will invest $1500(+ countless developing hours) myself and other money will come from sign-ups, in-game purchases(yes you can buy better gear) and supporters of this project.
2) The game will run for 3 months or longer(until 90% of bitcoins have been paid out), I will use the 5% to cover server costs. Other 5% will be divided between players who reach top 5 in highscores, there will be 15 different categories: Total skill points, Accuracy, Strength, Defense, Health, Magic, Alchemy, Woodcutting, Farming, Fishing, Cooking, Jewelry, Carpentry, Forging, Mining.
3) There is an anti-bot system that can ask at a random time(when you are performing a skill) for captcha code. Everytime you fail to complete the captcha challenge in 180 seconds you will get a penalty point - 5 points and your account will be banned, your bitcoins will be thrown back to the game pool. There is no way to revert the penalty points to ensure that everybody plays fair.
4) If account is inactive for 30 days(no login during that) account will be closed and earned bitcoins will be placed back to pool.
5) Payouts will be done manually to avoid hackers, there will be a minimum payout amount during the game but will be removed once game round is finished(stated in 2).
Terms can change a bit and new terms might be added, but they will be final once the game starts.
Good luck with that! If million likes are not reached by 1st of July then the offer is off.
Terms:
1) Everybody will have to pay a small entrance fee for it to work(about ~10 USD in BTC) to register an account and they can actually get BITCOINS for playing, I will invest $1500(+ countless developing hours) myself and other money will come from sign-ups, in-game purchases(yes you can buy better gear) and supporters of this project.
2) The game will run for 3 months or longer(until 90% of bitcoins have been paid out), I will use the 5% to cover server costs. Other 5% will be divided between players who reach top 5 in highscores, there will be 15 different categories: Total skill points, Accuracy, Strength, Defense, Health, Magic, Alchemy, Woodcutting, Farming, Fishing, Cooking, Jewelry, Carpentry, Forging, Mining.
3) There is an anti-bot system that can ask at a random time(when you are performing a skill) for captcha code. Everytime you fail to complete the captcha challenge in 180 seconds you will get a penalty point - 5 points and your account will be banned, your bitcoins will be thrown back to the game pool. There is no way to revert the penalty points to ensure that everybody plays fair.
4) If account is inactive for 30 days(no login during that) account will be closed and earned bitcoins will be placed back to pool.
5) Payouts will be done manually to avoid hackers, there will be a minimum payout amount during the game but will be removed once game round is finished(stated in 2).
Terms can change a bit and new terms might be added, but they will be final once the game starts.
for everyone suggesting that the in-game currency should be bitcoin google Entropia Universe.
It is (was?) an mmo w a real cash economy.
I DO think that using bitcoin instead of cash could fix some of the problems that Entropia had but it would have to be VERY well implemented to work and attract players without being a huge financial sinkhole for the devs.
It is (was?) an mmo w a real cash economy.
I DO think that using bitcoin instead of cash could fix some of the problems that Entropia had but it would have to be VERY well implemented to work and attract players without being a huge financial sinkhole for the devs.
New update released - addded skills farming and carpentry. Read more from game forums or just play the game and try it out yourself at http://rpg.mo.ee
Also we have a Facebook page now http://www.facebook.com/RpgMoCommunity
Also we have a Facebook page now http://www.facebook.com/RpgMoCommunity
Well let's stay on topic and my game is free to play - bitcoins are just a way to support the game development.
I'm not planning to start paying for playing, I just dont have the funds to do that.
I'm not planning to start paying for playing, I just dont have the funds to do that.
btc as an ingame money could work.
But the back-end for that would have to be extremely beefy. You'd have to track everything (and I do mean everything) with a current value assigned.
The only way I'd see it working if it was a subscription modem. Where you turn around and pump some insane amount (like 50% or 75%) of your profit back into the game.
The idea is this. You assign a type of object (say monster loot) a bucket - then you assign a percentage of influx to that bucket (as 20%) so 20% of the value added to the game goes into that bucket. Then each monster gets a set percentage based on it's data, and anything added to the bucket would be split up accordingly. Then assuming a player loots the monster, he would get those btc (or item that he could sell to an npc for that much btc).
Anything that doesn't get looted before it decays get it's vaule re-assigned to the 'influx' as do any coin from players purchasing items from in-game vendors. Now here's the interesting part. You really is a chance for a free to play model here... provided you were willing to seed the initial btc yourself and have reasonable prices. The really great thing about it would be each account or char.
There's a ton of lee-way for getting creative about how the seeding works in an mmo tho. Maybe everything drops as bound item - not vendor sellable - and players would need to spend btc to unlock the item - allowing them to trade the item, which would allow them to sell it to another player or an npc. You could scrape a tiny bit off that transaction making money every time someone unlocked an item.
The obvious advantage would be that you wouldn't be running a 'pay to win' model and you wouldn't be selling anything "exclusive" for btc. I think about the only thing you could get away with 'selling' would be some anti-annoyance features. Things like stacks of craft components, corpse summons and maybe item repairs (but these would have to be very micro indeed to prevent them from killing the game).
But the back-end for that would have to be extremely beefy. You'd have to track everything (and I do mean everything) with a current value assigned.
The only way I'd see it working if it was a subscription modem. Where you turn around and pump some insane amount (like 50% or 75%) of your profit back into the game.
The idea is this. You assign a type of object (say monster loot) a bucket - then you assign a percentage of influx to that bucket (as 20%) so 20% of the value added to the game goes into that bucket. Then each monster gets a set percentage based on it's data, and anything added to the bucket would be split up accordingly. Then assuming a player loots the monster, he would get those btc (or item that he could sell to an npc for that much btc).
Anything that doesn't get looted before it decays get it's vaule re-assigned to the 'influx' as do any coin from players purchasing items from in-game vendors. Now here's the interesting part. You really is a chance for a free to play model here... provided you were willing to seed the initial btc yourself and have reasonable prices. The really great thing about it would be each account or char.
There's a ton of lee-way for getting creative about how the seeding works in an mmo tho. Maybe everything drops as bound item - not vendor sellable - and players would need to spend btc to unlock the item - allowing them to trade the item, which would allow them to sell it to another player or an npc. You could scrape a tiny bit off that transaction making money every time someone unlocked an item.
The obvious advantage would be that you wouldn't be running a 'pay to win' model and you wouldn't be selling anything "exclusive" for btc. I think about the only thing you could get away with 'selling' would be some anti-annoyance features. Things like stacks of craft components, corpse summons and maybe item repairs (but these would have to be very micro indeed to prevent them from killing the game).
Looks really nice. But you need to add some way to bring up a menu, so you're not logged out but you can go to the bathroom, cause I got a penalty point for going to the bathroom. 
Just lik something so i'm not in the game but I'm still logged in
If you are just afk and wont do any mining/fishing etc then you dont get the captcha. Just lik something so i'm not in the game but I'm still logged inAnd to everyone else with using BTC as in-game currency, its a good idea but can't be done because then there would be like million bots in the game.
Not more than in any other MMORPG, they all have ingame currencys which have value in USD.
The only games that have nearly no bots are dead games or games which try very hard to make it impossible to automate + reporting features etc.
Looks really nice. But you need to add some way to bring up a menu, so you're not logged out but you can go to the bathroom, cause I got a penalty point for going to the bathroom. Just lik something so i'm not in the game but I'm still logged in
If you are just afk and wont do any mining/fishing etc then you dont get the captcha. Just lik something so i'm not in the game but I'm still logged inAnd to everyone else with using BTC as in-game currency, its a good idea but can't be done because then there would be like million bots in the game.
Looks really nice. But you need to add some way to bring up a menu, so you're not logged out but you can go to the bathroom, cause I got a penalty point for going to the bathroom. Just lik something so i'm not in the game but I'm still logged in
Just lik something so i'm not in the game but I'm still logged in
A lot of money, if there where a lot of players.
Uhmm... I don't think that way, I prefer making the player to activate his/her account spending something like a 0.05BTC initial and giving to the player a free starter pack.
The rewards for early adopters can't be so great, but making a good start is a must-have.
Don't agree with monthly pays or you will make them paying for the in-game currency, or monthly income. The both can't be together, otherwise it would be too much greedy to play.
Uhmm... I don't think that way, I prefer making the player to activate his/her account spending something like a 0.05BTC initial and giving to the player a free starter pack.
The rewards for early adopters can't be so great, but making a good start is a must-have.
Don't agree with monthly pays or you will make them paying for the in-game currency, or monthly income. The both can't be together, otherwise it would be too much greedy to play.
If every purchase in the game is taxed by 5% the developers could make alot of money.
Maybe even charge a small fee for ingame trades.
Of course you would have mostly people playing for free at the beginning, earning like 1-10 satoshi from killing monsters.
But if the game is good enough to attract more players, they will start pumping bitcoins into it soon enough.
You just have to provide reasons to do so, like land in second life, or houses in ultima online.
Maybe even reward the early adopters a bit more, like giving out cheap land/houses at the beginning, and then let them sell it later when there is more demand and people put BTC into the game. You could still make money from those transactions.
This could all be in addition to paying a monthly fee of course, but if i would do it, i would try to offer it for free and only get money from fees ingame, since ingame currency has value it shouldnt be a problem (see second life).
For example you could add new land to the game and if someone wants to enter that new land, they need to go through a gate which takes a one time fee.
Maybe even charge a small fee for ingame trades.
Of course you would have mostly people playing for free at the beginning, earning like 1-10 satoshi from killing monsters.
But if the game is good enough to attract more players, they will start pumping bitcoins into it soon enough.
You just have to provide reasons to do so, like land in second life, or houses in ultima online.
Maybe even reward the early adopters a bit more, like giving out cheap land/houses at the beginning, and then let them sell it later when there is more demand and people put BTC into the game. You could still make money from those transactions.
This could all be in addition to paying a monthly fee of course, but if i would do it, i would try to offer it for free and only get money from fees ingame, since ingame currency has value it shouldnt be a problem (see second life).
For example you could add new land to the game and if someone wants to enter that new land, they need to go through a gate which takes a one time fee.
The game would need more ways of the developer earning money, maintaining an server for MMO ins't simple and low cost.
In the way you say, the game itself would be a gambling, it would be a forced Pay to Play(the game can't let people enter for free and earn money that costed BTC of other players).
In the way you say, the game itself would be a gambling, it would be a forced Pay to Play(the game can't let people enter for free and earn money that costed BTC of other players).
Not really exchange BTC -> ingame, more like BTC = the ingame currency.
Bitcoins get stored on the game servers.
Basically for a game like eve online you could just use BTC as the ingame currency name but for games like ultima online/wow etc you could have the bitcoins display as silver/gold/platin coins so it works for the roleplaying guys
Every user has his own bitcoin balance, and every bitcoin spent to NPCs or lost in gambling games etc would go to the game pool.
5% of the game pool would go to the game developer, 95% would go into monsters and quest rewards etc.
Im not into game development so i dont really have a 100% perfect concept in mind, just wondering why noone tried this.
Bitcoin would be perfect for this, much better than paypal which second life uses
Bitcoins get stored on the game servers.
Basically for a game like eve online you could just use BTC as the ingame currency name but for games like ultima online/wow etc you could have the bitcoins display as silver/gold/platin coins so it works for the roleplaying guys
Every user has his own bitcoin balance, and every bitcoin spent to NPCs or lost in gambling games etc would go to the game pool.
5% of the game pool would go to the game developer, 95% would go into monsters and quest rewards etc.
Im not into game development so i dont really have a 100% perfect concept in mind, just wondering why noone tried this.
Bitcoin would be perfect for this, much better than paypal which second life uses
It would have to be wisely tweaked of course.
But i think it would be a nice experiment, especially since if there are many games using bitcoin, you could basically earn money from it and you could switch from game to game within minutes.
I wouldnt make the leveling a too big part of the game, pvp, quests, houses and decoration items are all more fun than leveling and could all benefit from bitcoin.
With not much leveling i also mean less difference on characters, so anyone with bitcoins could 'buy in' without spending month to level.
So i dont think inflation would be needed in such games if they are created right.
Some people would want to do pvp battle for 'real cash' (bitcoins), some would want to buy nice houses or rare decoration items, and it could be all in the same game or different games.
I see Second Life as an example that there is alot of demand for such games.
Another example why i think some gamers might like that idea:
In Ultima Online (like 10years ago before they ruined the game), some people were just playing the game to collect and trade items, they didnt 'level' their characters at all.
Some of them were really rich ingame, partly from trading ingame, partly they just bought ingame gold from other players for cash.
Some bought expensive clothing to show how rich they are, some had big castles with rare and unique items which looked like museums.
And there was a million dollar market on ebay for such rare items and gold with all the typical problems like paypal chargebacks etc.
With bitcoin in the game all that items trading could be in the game, without a need for ebay, paypal etc and no middleman like those 1000s of MMORPG item/gold sellers.
But i think it would be a nice experiment, especially since if there are many games using bitcoin, you could basically earn money from it and you could switch from game to game within minutes.
I wouldnt make the leveling a too big part of the game, pvp, quests, houses and decoration items are all more fun than leveling and could all benefit from bitcoin.
With not much leveling i also mean less difference on characters, so anyone with bitcoins could 'buy in' without spending month to level.
So i dont think inflation would be needed in such games if they are created right.
Some people would want to do pvp battle for 'real cash' (bitcoins), some would want to buy nice houses or rare decoration items, and it could be all in the same game or different games.
I see Second Life as an example that there is alot of demand for such games.
Another example why i think some gamers might like that idea:
In Ultima Online (like 10years ago before they ruined the game), some people were just playing the game to collect and trade items, they didnt 'level' their characters at all.
Some of them were really rich ingame, partly from trading ingame, partly they just bought ingame gold from other players for cash.
Some bought expensive clothing to show how rich they are, some had big castles with rare and unique items which looked like museums.
And there was a million dollar market on ebay for such rare items and gold with all the typical problems like paypal chargebacks etc.
With bitcoin in the game all that items trading could be in the game, without a need for ebay, paypal etc and no middleman like those 1000s of MMORPG item/gold sellers.
I know how Ultima Online works, one of the first MMORPG's out there.
The only problem is, today there's no MMORPG that isn't focused on boring quests, lvling and doing pvp for better itens, power and cash. Maybe someone can give a shot trying this...
But I still don't understand where the BTC enters in, you say, exchange BTC -> IG Money?
Jump to: