Author

Topic: n0nce's Steel Washer Backup jig (customisable) (Read 1578 times)

legendary
Activity: 2968
Merit: 3406
Crypto Swap Exchange
I didn't modify the files from n0nce (who very kindly offered me a customised version of his jig—or was it one of the parameters in the file?). kindly offered
I thought [and also hoped] you managed to improve the original design of the jig in a way that the protruded part would slide in and out of the crevices [or rather sections] and the squarish opening.

When I said you could open and close the jig, I meant lifting and lowering the upper part.
Thank you for the clarification Smiley
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
You open the jig, insert the washer, stamp a letter, rotate the upper part, stamp the other letter and so on.
Then you open it, remove the stamped washers and insert a new one, then close it again.
So yes, it opens and closes, and you need only one jig.
Did you alter the STL file from your end [specifically referring to the jig itself (apart from your name)]? I remember thoroughly checking the STL files when @n0nce created this thread, but AFAICR the squarish opening on the jig didn't open and close [the only way to reposition it was by lifting it first].

Exactly.
I didn't modify the files from n0nce (who very kindly offered me a customised version of his jig—or was it one of the parameters in the file?). kindly offered
When I said you could open and close the jig, I meant lifting and lowering the upper part.
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
there is still a chance of finding correct order when you know 24 from total of 2048 words.
That gives 6.2*1023 possibilities. With 12 words, it's doable. With 24, it's not going to happen.
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
If you drop 24 washers without knowing the order, your backup is worthless.
There is a risk with that (additional order numbers would probably fix this) but it's not totally worthless, there is still a chance of finding correct order when you know 24 from total of 2048 words.

I was thinking something more mechanical, where you have all 26 stamps inside the machine. Sure there's going to inevitably be some flash memory required to remember the words, but this is not supposed to be a network-connected device anyway, and I believe there are methods for securely destroying flash memory when you are done with it (although that might get expensive quickly).
I don't like this because it can create more risk in overall setup.
Stainless steel washers are cheap and great, but I am coming up with alternative option for storing seed phrase, it will be released soon.

legendary
Activity: 2968
Merit: 3406
Crypto Swap Exchange
You open the jig, insert the washer, stamp a letter, rotate the upper part, stamp the other letter and so on.
Then you open it, remove the stamped washers and insert a new one, then close it again.
So yes, it opens and closes, and you need only one jig.
Did you alter the STL file from your end [specifically referring to the jig itself (apart from your name)]? I remember thoroughly checking the STL files when @n0nce created this thread, but AFAICR the squarish opening on the jig didn't open and close [the only way to reposition it was by lifting it first].
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
I was thinking maybe a device could be invented to automate many parts of this process.
Anything that automates something adds the risk of storing the data.

Quote
One part I do not understand is the serial number part. Why are you stamping that onto the washers?
If you drop 24 washers without knowing the order, your backup is worthless.

I think he’s actually referring to the washers with the serial number of the tamper-proof labels.
It is an additional layer of complexity. This is meant to avoid someone breaking the tamper-proof labels and substituting those with new ones without the necessity also to restamp the washers, which requires new identical washers, with identical labels, and stamps.
Not perfect, but I guess effective.
legendary
Activity: 1568
Merit: 6660
bitcoincleanup.com / bitmixlist.org
I was thinking maybe a device could be invented to automate many parts of this process.
Anything that automates something adds the risk of storing the data.

I was thinking something more mechanical, where you have all 26 stamps inside the machine. Sure there's going to inevitably be some flash memory required to remember the words, but this is not supposed to be a network-connected device anyway, and I believe there are methods for securely destroying flash memory when you are done with it (although that might get expensive quickly).

Anyway I'm just throwing ideas around, I'm not really sure what a good solution for this would be.
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
I was thinking maybe a device could be invented to automate many parts of this process.
Anything that automates something adds the risk of storing the data.

Quote
One part I do not understand is the serial number part. Why are you stamping that onto the washers?
If you drop 24 washers without knowing the order, your backup is worthless.
legendary
Activity: 1568
Merit: 6660
bitcoincleanup.com / bitmixlist.org
I wrote a thread, there is a gif and a video of the whole process:

Securing Your Seed Phrase with Washers

I hope that reading that you will find aclarificatiin of your doubt.
Anyway yes, the jig is meant to hold the washer you are stamping in position. You open the jig, insert the washer, stamp a letter, rotate the upper part, stamp the other letter and so on.
Then you open it, remove the stamped washers and insert a new one, then close it again.
So yes, it opens and closes, and you need only one jig.
In case, just ask.


Your thread is very helpful, and it seems that preparing the washers requires substantial amount of manual work  Smiley

I was thinking maybe a device could be invented to automate many parts of this process.

One part I do not understand is the serial number part. Why are you stamping that onto the washers? It doesn't seem at first glance to be verifying anything, especially if you're going to put all this into a tamper-proof container.
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
I am sorry for bumping this but lately I have been trying to figure out how this backup method works, so my questions about this might come across as ignorant.

I do have some CAD experience so I get the washer part, but what is that black thing that is holding the washer in place? And do I need one for each washer (i.e. word)? Huh And according to the GIF showing the thing moving, it looks like you just rotate it to hide/reveal the washer? Or does it open/close?

I wrote a thread, there is a gif and a video of the whole process:

Securing Your Seed Phrase with Washers

I hope that reading that you will find aclarificatiin of your doubt.
Anyway yes, the jig is meant to hold the washer you are stamping in position. You open the jig, insert the washer, stamp a letter, rotate the upper part, stamp the other letter and so on.
Then you open it, remove the stamped washers and insert a new one, then close it again.
So yes, it opens and closes, and you need only one jig.
In case, just ask.
legendary
Activity: 2968
Merit: 3406
Crypto Swap Exchange
I do have some CAD experience so I get the washer part, but what is that black thing that is holding the washer in place?
That's the jig part... Apart from holding the washer in place, it helps with the spacing and alignment while also providing some protection against hammering our fingers.

And do I need one for each washer (i.e. word)? Huh
No, you only need one to stamp on all of them.

And according to the GIF showing the thing moving, it looks like you just rotate it to hide/reveal the washer? Or does it open/close?
There aren't any moving parts on the jig to open/close that opening.
legendary
Activity: 1568
Merit: 6660
bitcoincleanup.com / bitmixlist.org
I am sorry for bumping this but lately I have been trying to figure out how this backup method works, so my questions about this might come across as ignorant.

I do have some CAD experience so I get the washer part, but what is that black thing that is holding the washer in place? And do I need one for each washer (i.e. word)? Huh And according to the GIF showing the thing moving, it looks like you just rotate it to hide/reveal the washer? Or does it open/close?
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
Wait, and here I thought 3D-printers would be able to print in color.... Google tells me it exists, but at a whole different price level (a few thousand to hundreds of thousands of dollars).
It's easy to order this replacement fillers online or locally, and I think you can find at least one seller that sells all different fillers even in small towns.
I know all this from ads I see and I personally ordered some simple stuff for printing... I could always choose from several color options.

I think we might be bordering on the ridiculous here, even for someone as paranoid as me.
Yeah we are Cheesy and I also said before that we entered the paranoid twilight zone territory like Rod Serling in famous tv series, we just need that theme song



legendary
Activity: 2268
Merit: 18771
but I am just brainstorming that someone could find that picture and replace it with their own fake copy anytime.
I think we might be bordering on the ridiculous here, even for someone as paranoid as me. Someone would have to know your entire system, figure out where you stored that photo, hack in to your device to view the photo, find your seed phrase, break it and then reseal it, recreate the photo you took with the same angle/lighting/surroundings/etc., and then hack back in to your device to replace the photo. And all that to only compromise one part of what is presumably a multi-layered back up.

The attacker in question will almost certainly look for a different way to target you.
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
Idea is not bad in principle but I think it needs some testing from people who owns 3d printers (read n0nce) to see how it works in real life.
Since I did it before, I can confirm it's quite trivial to manually pause a print and change filament mid-way through. There's a 'filament swap' feature in most modern printers that does it all automatically; you only need to insert the new colour.
Wait, and here I thought 3D-printers would be able to print in color.... Google tells me it exists, but at a whole different price level (a few thousand to hundreds of thousands of dollars).
You can only print with already coloured 'filament', but there exist relatively affordable models that allow to use multiple rolls of filament and automatically switch between them to make multi-colour prints.
Resin printers are also gaining popularity, which produce a smoother finish, but won't allow for any type of colour change.
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
Idea is not bad in principle but I think it needs some testing from people who owns 3d printers (read n0nce) to see how it works in real life.
Since I did it before, I can confirm it's quite trivial to manually pause a print and change filament mid-way through. There's a 'filament swap' feature in most modern printers that does it all automatically; you only need to insert the new colour.
Wait, and here I thought 3D-printers would be able to print in color.... Google tells me it exists, but at a whole different price level (a few thousand to hundreds of thousands of dollars).
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
Idea is not bad in principle but I think it needs some testing from people who owns 3d printers (read n0nce) to see how it works in real life.
Since I did it before, I can confirm it's quite trivial to manually pause a print and change filament mid-way through. There's a 'filament swap' feature in most modern printers that does it all automatically; you only need to insert the new colour.
You could even tilt the model in the slicing software before printing at a random angle, which will be tricky to replicate (though it would then print with support material, costing more and taking longer).

I finally published the translation of the guide on the language most can comprehend:
Securing Your Seed Phrase with Washers

Hope you enjoy it and I am waiting for many suggestions!
Quickly skimmed it; it seems 1:1 like the Italian one which was great as well, so no complaints from me! Wink
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
I finally published the translation of the guide on the language most can comprehend:
Securing Your Seed Phrase with Washers

Hope you enjoy it and I am waiting for many suggestions!
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
As per nail polish, or any other entropy-related scheme, you are supposed to take a picture (and safely store) to check against to the seal while opening it.
I know you need to take a picture, that is why I said that remembering something like that is not a good option long term,
but I am just brainstorming that someone could find that picture and replace it with their own fake copy anytime.

Since we're on the subject of printing custom capsules with multiple colors: how about making the capsules for each part of the multisig storage line up? Say you have 3 cylinders with metal washers. When you put those 3 cylinders together, a matching pattern occurs. That way you don't need to remember the exact details of each cylinder, but you do need to get them all together to check if any tampering took place.
Idea is not bad in principle but I think it needs some testing from people who owns 3d printers (read n0nce) to see how it works in real life.
legendary
Activity: 2268
Merit: 18771
Somehow multisig always makes me feel a bit uncomfortable: it doesn't "feel" as solid as using just one privkey for just one address.
Although I don't share those reservations I can certainly understand them, but I still think that using a standardized method which is reproducible across multiple different pieces of wallet software (or even manually) such as multi-sig or passphrases is far preferable to any other scheme such as seed splitting or Shamir's.



If you are thinking of putting something directly on to the stack of washers, then why not just use a couple of different colors of metal paint and paint over the whole stack. For someone to open the stack they would have to break them apart which would obviously damage the paint. And obviously you can take photos to ensure someone hasn't painted over your paint.
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
One problem I see here would be if you totally forget how your printed stuff looked like originally, as a result of some amnesia or other memory problem.
Since we're on the subject of printing custom capsules with multiple colors: how about making the capsules for each part of the multisig storage line up? Say you have 3 cylinders with metal washers. When you put those 3 cylinders together, a matching pattern occurs. That way you don't need to remember the exact details of each cylinder, but you do need to get them all together to check if any tampering took place.
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
Also this idea of mixing filaments is pretty cool; reminds me of fillippone's glitter nail polish idea. It will be pretty hard to replicate the 'mix' 1:1 another time. You can simply pause the print at a random time, switch the filament and repeat it however often you want.
Adding a design into the file itself would also work, but it'll be easier to replicate.
We are probably getting into paranoid twilight zone territory with something like this, but I think this is much better approach then not using any protection at all.
One problem I see here would be if you totally forget how your printed stuff looked like originally, as a result of some amnesia or other memory problem.
Combine this with something like SeedCapsule that has stem-to-be-broken, and you got yourself a damn good tamper evident setup.
As fillippone just mentioned, the idea is to photograph the 'seal' e.g. the paint coat to verify against it in the future.

I just had another idea though: if you go for tamper-evidence, and you've got seals that stick to metal as well as you mentioned earlier, you could also just put one or two directly onto the 'stack' of washers. To read the seed, you will obviously have to separate the washers from one another, breaking the sealing stickers.

Progressing with the translation of the thread. Should soon land.
Very nice! Looking forward to it; though it will be a long read if it's similar to the Italian one. Wink
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
One problem I see here would be if you totally forget how your printed stuff looked like originally, as a result of some amnesia or other memory problem.

As per nail polish, or any other entropy-related scheme, you are supposed to take a picture (and safely store) to check against to the seal while opening it.

Progressing with the translation of the thread. Should soon land.
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
Also this idea of mixing filaments is pretty cool; reminds me of fillippone's glitter nail polish idea. It will be pretty hard to replicate the 'mix' 1:1 another time. You can simply pause the print at a random time, switch the filament and repeat it however often you want.
Adding a design into the file itself would also work, but it'll be easier to replicate.
We are probably getting into paranoid twilight zone territory with something like this, but I think this is much better approach then not using any protection at all.
One problem I see here would be if you totally forget how your printed stuff looked like originally, as a result of some amnesia or other memory problem.
Combine this with something like SeedCapsule that has stem-to-be-broken, and you got yourself a damn good tamper evident setup.
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
That looks nice! But to make it tamper proof, you'll need to make sure you recognize the exact version you created. If someone can just print his own SeedCapsule to replace yours, you may not notice it.
That is true, you can always make your own custom made details that can't be printed and duplicated exactly.
It's not that hard if you have your own 3d printer, to add specific color mix or something similar like that, maybe editing stl files and making it unique.
Just let your imagination go wild.
Thanks for sharing that capsule file. Compatibility should be possible by getting the right washers for the capsule & then generating a jig for those washers using my new openSCAD file that I posted the other day.

Also this idea of mixing filaments is pretty cool; reminds me of fillippone's glitter nail polish idea. It will be pretty hard to replicate the 'mix' 1:1 another time. You can simply pause the print at a random time, switch the filament and repeat it however often you want.
Adding a design into the file itself would also work, but it'll be easier to replicate.

Sure, residue can probably be removed with some solvent depending on what surface is used on device but it's not always so easy.
I got one sticker I tested on metal plate and it was impossible to remove residue without scratching metal or removing surface color.
There is always a factor of time to consider, more the sticker is on surface more will color be different (preserved) from surrounding surface.
Actually, 3D prints will be one of the surfaces where it's hard to get off such a sticker without damaging the plastic, since it's usually soft and reactive to lots of chemicals. Prints also have lots of small ridges where the adhesive can get into nicely, so no chance of simply peeling it off cleanly either.
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
I've seen laptops with an anti-theft-sticker which covered a "Stolen Property" warning burned into the plastic. That would make it much harder to cover up tampering.
You know how easy nowadays is to buy spare plastic part for that laptop and replace it, especially cover is cheap and I even saw people adding foil over damaged covers.
Sure, residue can probably be removed with some solvent depending on what surface is used on device but it's not always so easy.
I got one sticker I tested on metal plate and it was impossible to remove residue without scratching metal or removing surface color.
There is always a factor of time to consider, more the sticker is on surface more will color be different (preserved) from surrounding surface.
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
You can buy it on amazon or ebay but you can't remove residue with void message so easy and that's the whole point.
My assumption for those stickers has always been that it's not easy to replace them. Removing residue shouldn't be that hard (using a solvent).
I've seen laptops with an anti-theft-sticker which covered a "Stolen Property" warning burned into the plastic. That would make it much harder to cover up tampering.

Quote
I was not going to use this for bitcoin seed words but for regular envelops with paper documents.
On paper, I agree that it's going to be very difficult to remove any sticker residue without leaving permanent damage.
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
I’m on the case. Latest addition to the italian OP are beyond my comfort zone.
What do you mean?



Buying an anvil is ok.
Buying glitter nail polish, and watching YouTube videos on how to apply it, it is not.
Absolute madman! Grin My personal tip though: you don't need to watch videos about everything, sometimes it's better just to try. It can avoid some pain that YouTube videos sometimes induce. Nail polish without glitter can be a helpful tool to touch up a chipped floor tile; just use that little brush and apply, it doesn't get much simpler. The idea about the glitter being at random, sounds good as well, though.

This is why I hope the next protocol advancement will make this simpler.
Are you sure it's a protocol issue? I think it's more just the software implementations. For example, BlueWallet and I think also Sparrow, give pretty good UIs for creating multisig wallets.
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
How useful is this if anyone can just buy it on Amazon? It should be more unique than that.
You can buy it on amazon or ebay but you can't remove residue with void message so easy and that's the whole point.
It is easy to customize it with different unique shapes, and I was not going to use this for bitcoin seed words but for regular envelops with paper documents.
You can also order this tapes with custom design, so for fillippone I would add custom ferrari drawing with electric power, or you can send them any design you want.
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
I’m on the case. Latest addition to the italian OP are beyond my comfort zone.
What do you mean?



Buying an anvil is ok.
Buying glitter nail polish, and watching YouTube videos on how to apply it, it is not.


As far as I know, Bitcoin is the only crypto natively supporting multisig.
That's not true, I've seen it in Byteball (now Obyte), which actually supported it from it's official wallet. From what I remember, this was much more idiot proof by default than manually setting it up in Electrum.

I knew that writing that sentence above I was exposing myself to being proven wrong by some obscure shitcoin.
Yes, byteball is an obscure shitcoin.
And yes, multisig implementation is cumbersome.
This is why I hope the next protocol advancement will make this simpler.

legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
As far as I know, Bitcoin is the only crypto natively supporting multisig.
That's not true, I've seen it in Byteball (now Obyte), which actually supported it from it's official wallet. From what I remember, this was much more idiot proof by default than manually setting it up in Electrum. It's been a few years, but what I remember is linking the different wallets from inside each wallet, which worked nicely.

Quote
I have great expectations for Taproot to make degrading multisig easy to implement for the idiot user (like me).
Electrum is confusing: If you create a multisig wallet, you can't even save your incomplete wallet before you have the master public keys from all other wallets too. I tested it earlier today, and it's disappointingly labour intensive.



I just realize talking about multisig in a topic about steel washer backups is slightly off-topic. And of course setting up multisig is much less labour intensive than 3D printing and hammering words into steel Tongue I've spent hours setting up a secure wallet and backups in the past.
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
I’m on the case. Latest addition to the italian OP are beyond my comfort zone.
What do you mean?
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
Somehow multisig always makes me feel a bit uncomfortable: it doesn't "feel" as solid as using just one privkey for just one address.


As far as I know, Bitcoin is the only crypto natively supporting multisig. Multisig are actually more se ire than single sig, only lacking a truly idiot proof interface.
I have great expectations for Taproot to make degrading multisig easy to implement for the idiot user (like me).
Something that was implemented by GreenAddress, for example, with a custom software implementation. 
A degrading 3/4 multisig would be my perfect ideal setup.



How useful is this if anyone can just buy it on Amazon? It should be more unique than that.


Absolutely correct. This is why you need at least a serial number on that.

I am going to translate the whole bunch of informations in English.
I wanted to Merit your post already, but I'll save it for the version I can actually read Smiley

I have to deliver then.
I’m on the case. Latest addition to the italian OP are beyond my comfort zone.
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
If you use a seed phrase and an additional passphrase, or a multi-sig set up, then there is a lot to be gained from having a tamper-evident container.
This makes a lot of sense Smiley I didn't consider the multisig scenario when I wrote about tamper proofness being quite useless.
Somehow multisig always makes me feel a bit uncomfortable: it doesn't "feel" as solid as using just one privkey for just one address.

I was looking to order void roll tape that is cheaper and you can customize size and shape yourself... and guess what, they have RED color  Wink
How useful is this if anyone can just buy it on Amazon? It should be more unique than that.

I am going to translate the whole bunch of informations in English.
I wanted to Merit your post already, but I'll save it for the version I can actually read Smiley
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
I should have posted a bigger picture, as this is exactly the kind of stickers I have used. Also important they have a serial number.
Don’t worry, I am going to explain everything in the English version of my thread, which has HYGE pictures.
Mamma mia!
Don't forget to accidently put red Ferrari or lot of red ripe tomatoes in background.
One question, where did you buy this kind of void stickers with serial numbers, online or locally?
I was looking to order void roll tape that is cheaper and you can customize size and shape yourself... and guess what, they have RED color  Wink



Bear with me.
I am going to translate the whole bunch of informations in English.
Today I added a paragraph regarding... Glitter Nail Polish... wondering if it is available in RED (not sure I am getting this joke, btw)
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
I should have posted a bigger picture, as this is exactly the kind of stickers I have used. Also important they have a serial number.
Don’t worry, I am going to explain everything in the English version of my thread, which has HYGE pictures.
Mamma mia!
Don't forget to accidently put red Ferrari or lot of red ripe tomatoes in background.
One question, where did you buy this kind of void stickers with serial numbers, online or locally?
I was looking to order void roll tape that is cheaper and you can customize size and shape yourself... and guess what, they have RED color  Wink

legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
I added to the washers a couple of “special ones” with the serial numbers of the tamper proof seals printed on it.
Is this Italian thing to post big images with red color like this?  Cheesy
What happens if someone removes this stickers and put them back in same place or make a copy first before doing that?
Good tamper evident stickers should leave some residue that is hard to remove from surface indicating sticker was removed aka void happened.





I should have posted a bigger picture, as this is exactly the kind of stickers I have used. Also important they have a serial number.
Don’t worry, I am going to explain everything in the English version of my thread, which has HYGE pictures.
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
I added to the washers a couple of “special ones” with the serial numbers of the tamper proof seals printed on it.
Is this Italian thing to post big images with red color like this?  Cheesy
What happens if someone removes this stickers and put them back in same place or make a copy first before doing that?
Good tamper evident stickers should leave some residue that is hard to remove from surface indicating sticker was removed aka void happened.



hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
Prompted by fillippone's latest thread, I got the motivation to finally make an open-source, easily customizable (fully parametric) design of my jig.
The code is found here.
<…>

This is a great news.
Thank you very much n0nce for this.
You're welcome!

It will be way more simple to get a jig customised on each own needs.
The stamp customisation will be of utter utility, as it will allow for easier use of “recovered” stamps without buying new ones (Opsec Reasons).
Yes, correct, I'd like people to use whatever they have already or what they can find locally so they don't have to make suspicious online purchases... Wink
Only one thing to mention: This is now designed with 30-ish millimetre or smaller outer washer diameter; the jig size doesn't change, so you can do anything that's smaller, but not really larger ones. If someone needs that, just increase the jig's outer size, which is currently coded to 54mmx54mm.
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
Prompted by fillippone's latest thread, I got the motivation to finally make an open-source, easily customizable (fully parametric) design of my jig.
The code is found here.
<…>

This is a great news.
Thank you very much n0nce for this.
It will be way more simple to get a jig customised on each own needs.
The stamp customisation will be of utter utility, as it will allow for easier use of “recovered” stamps without buying new ones (Opsec Reasons).

Also, as you mentioned it, I am soon going to translate my thread in English, once I have polished it a little bit.
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
Prompted by fillippone's latest thread, I got the motivation to finally make an open-source, easily customizable (fully parametric) design of my jig.
The code is found here.
I haven't tested it yet (printed), but from measuring the dimensions and tolerances, it should be almost a 1:1 copy of what I had previously designed in a commercial, closed-source and not free CAD program, with less parametrization.

If there are any questions or issues with the code, or maybe improvement suggestions, let me know.

[NEW!!] OpenSCAD design finalized!
Paste this following code into OpenSCAD (free, open source) and set the parameters to whatever fits your washers and stamps. Then hit F5 and F6 to preview and render the two models. Finally, export the STL file and print it out.
Code:
// n0nce's Steel Washer backup jig
// ---------- configuration ---------- //
washer_dia  = 30;    // set to your washer's diameter (mm)
washer_hole = 10.5; // set to your washer's hole diameter (mm)
washer_h    = 3;     // set to your washer's thickness (mm)
stamp_w     = 8;     // set to your stamp's width (mm)
stamp_d     = 8;     // set to your stamp's depth (mm)

// ---------- code ---------- //
tolerance = 0.25;
// ---------- outer part ---------- //
module roundedcube(xx, yy, height, radius) {
  $fn=60;
  translate([0,0,height/2])
  hull() {
    translate([radius,radius,0])
    cylinder(height,radius,radius,true);

    translate([xx-radius,radius,0])
    cylinder(height,radius,radius,true);

    translate([xx-radius,yy-radius,0])
    cylinder(height,radius,radius,true);

    translate([radius,yy-radius,0])
    cylinder(height,radius,radius,true);
  }
}

module washer() {
  cylinder(h=washer_h, r=washer_dia/2, center=false, $fn=200);
}

module outer() {
  module outer_body() {
    translate([-27, -27, 0])
      roundedcube(54, 54, 20, 3);
  }
  module slot() {
    translate([-5/2,0,washer_h])
      cube([5,23,30]);
  }
 
  difference(){
    outer_body();
   
    // main cylinder to cut out
    translate([0, 0, washer_h])
      cylinder(h=100, r=38/2, center=false, $fn=200);
   
    // washer cut out
    translate([0, 0, -1])
      scale([1, 1, 10])
        washer();
     
    // number slots cut outs
    for (i=[0,2])
      rotate(-14+i*14)
        slot();
    // letter slots cut outs
    for (i=[0:7])
      rotate(82+i*28)
        slot();
  }
}

// ---------- inner part ---------- //
module inner() {
  module inner_body() {
    // main part
    cylinder(h=20-washer_h, r=38/2-0.3, center=false, $fn=200);
    // handle
    cylinder(h=20-washer_h+8, d=9, center=false, $fn=200);
    // sticking out part
    rotate(-14) translate([-4/2,0,0])
      cube([4,22.5,20-washer_h]);
  }
 
  module puncher_hole() {
    sw=stamp_w+tolerance;
    sd=stamp_d+tolerance;
    rotate(-14) translate([-sw/2,
      (washer_dia+washer_hole)/4-sd/2,
      -10])
      cube([sw,sd,50]);
  }
 
  translate([0, 0, washer_h]) {
    difference() {
      inner_body();
      puncher_hole();
    }
  }
}
outer();
translate([70,0,0])
  inner();
legendary
Activity: 2268
Merit: 18771
If I am splitting my pass phrase across two locations (12 washers in one container in a hole drilled on a wall, the other on a well in my mountain hut, just to stay on topic), am I making my setup more secure, or less secure?
You are making it more secure from theft, but less secure from loss. The trick to any back up is finding the correct balance between the two. This will be unique to every person, their circumstances, their personal threat model, the wallets they are using, etc.

I have a couple of wallets which are secured only by a seed phrase. These wallets never contain more than I am willing to lose, such as my mobile daily spending wallet.
I also have several cold storage wallets which contain much more money and are secured by much more than a single seed phrase.
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
Being tamper proof only helps you if funds haven't moved between the moment someone tampered with it, and the moment you discover the tampering. So if you hide your transparent container well enough, you probably won't check it very often. And long before you notice someone tampered with it, you'll notice your funds suddenly disappeared.
This is true if you use a single seed phrase and nothing else. If you use a seed phrase and an additional passphrase, or a multi-sig set up, then there is a lot to be gained from having a tamper-evident container. If someone accessed one of my seed phrases, for example, even though they couldn't steal any of my coins I'd definitely want to know that they could now be attempting to brute force one of my passphrases or actively searching for another one of my back up locations so I could take the necessary steps to re-secure my wallets. I'd also want to know that a location I thought was secure had been compromised, since that could have an impact on my other storage locations.

I am always concerned about spreading pass phrases across different locations.
If I am splitting my pass phrase across two locations (12 washers in one container in a hole drilled on a wall, the other on a well in my mountain hut, just to stay on topic), am I making my setup more secure, or less secure?

Of course in a complex dead-man switch multisig setup the tamper proof is more important, but I guess the complexity of the setup is order of magnitude more critical than a simple fund storage.
legendary
Activity: 2268
Merit: 18771
Being tamper proof only helps you if funds haven't moved between the moment someone tampered with it, and the moment you discover the tampering. So if you hide your transparent container well enough, you probably won't check it very often. And long before you notice someone tampered with it, you'll notice your funds suddenly disappeared.
This is true if you use a single seed phrase and nothing else. If you use a seed phrase and an additional passphrase, or a multi-sig set up, then there is a lot to be gained from having a tamper-evident container. If someone accessed one of my seed phrases, for example, even though they couldn't steal any of my coins I'd definitely want to know that they could now be attempting to brute force one of my passphrases or actively searching for another one of my back up locations so I could take the necessary steps to re-secure my wallets. I'd also want to know that a location I thought was secure had been compromised, since that could have an impact on my other storage locations.
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
Now, when you go back to retrieve the box in the future, you can compare the photos you took before to how it looks now. If anyone has opened it to access your seed phrase, all the grains or whatever you used will have moved around and will look different to the photos.
Being tamper proof only helps you if funds haven't moved between the moment someone tampered with it, and the moment you discover the tampering. So if you hide your transparent container well enough, you probably won't check it very often. And long before you notice someone tampered with it, you'll notice your funds suddenly disappeared.
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23

Thanks, now there is another piece of gadgetry I do want.

What concerns me about the picture is not that terrorist or hackers are going to crack it. But that it simply get lost,  because the person responsible for hodling this loses access, a tech failure or other common mishaps can happen to a digital good over the years.
My idea is that the tamper proof should be locked inside the box, so that it is a self contained “circular reference”.


Since we are here, a preview of my upcoming test of n0nce jig:



I added to the washers a couple of “special ones” with the serial numbers of the tamper proof seals printed on it.

Edit:
Reduced size of the picture so sensitive users don’t get offended!
/j
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
Sorry, I am not smart enough to understand how this should work. Also, you don't need to take care of a seed, but now you need to take care of a picture?
It's not like you have to keep this image safe from terrorist or hackers, because nobody knows why you are using regular photo of grain and legumes.
There is no way you can get false positive for tamper break if you do it correctly, this is not some rocket science and you don't need lot of time or money to make it.
I remember that I saw easy instructions how to make this yourself but I can't find it right now.
Guys from EntropySeal are doing something similar:
https://www.entropyseal.com/
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23

Now, when you go back to retrieve the box in the future, you can compare the photos you took before to how it looks now. If anyone has opened it to access your seed phrase, all the grains or whatever you used will have moved around and will look different to the photos.

If I lose the picture, the proof is not effective. If somehow the box tumbles or it is moved in a “wrong way” the tamper proof would reveal a false positive.
If someone wants to check the integrity without the picture, he simply cannot.

Mhh I appreciate the design simplicity, but I don’t like it.
legendary
Activity: 2268
Merit: 18771
Sorry, I am not smart enough to understand how this should work. Also, you don't need to take care of a seed, but now you need to take care of a picture?
Take a transparent plastic food container.
Fill it half full with a variety of rice, grains, legumes, seeds, confetti, different colored ball bearings, etc.
Place your seed phrase inside.
Fill the rest of the box with more of the above until it is overflowing.
Force the lid on, sealing everything inside tightly so it can't move around.
Take photos of the box from a variety of angles.
Hide the box.

Now, when you go back to retrieve the box in the future, you can compare the photos you took before to how it looks now. If anyone has opened it to access your seed phrase, all the grains or whatever you used will have moved around and will look different to the photos.
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23

Interesting free idea is taking different colored grains and legumes in tight box container, mixing it all up and taking a picture of that mix.

Sorry, I am not smart enough to understand how this should work. Also, you don't need to take care of a seed, but now you need to take care of a picture?

legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
Making your seed tamperproof is a crucial aspect of the whole process. I found a solution, but I am far from satisfied from that.
Any tamperproof method is better than none, but let's not think that it is perfect method for protection.
Using stickers is probably cheapest way when you are using seed phrase backup on paper and custom made envelope that can't be reproduced so easy.
I know some people are selling more expensive tamper evident plastic bags that can be used for coins or for crypto, but  think this is waste of money.
Interesting free idea is taking different colored grains and legumes in tight box container, mixing it all up and taking a picture of that mix.
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
what is interesting that you can make your backup tamper evident with this method.
That looks nice! But to make it tamper proof, you'll need to make sure you recognize the exact version you created. If someone can just print his own SeedCapsule to replace yours, you may not notice it.
I have been working on this since a while (more to come later on this thread).
Making your seed tamperproof is a crucial aspect of the whole process. I found a solution, but I am far from satisfied from that.
Keep in mind that ideally many years can pass between the creation of the backup and his usage. So verification of the taper isn't trivial.
Regarding to this:
It's not that hard if you have your own 3d printer, to add specific color mix or something similar like that, maybe editing stl files and making it unique.
Just let your imagination go wild.

You have to "remember", or communicate to the third person. Which colors/pattern used for that specific seed. It is an added layer of complexity.


I'd be better to speed up and disclose my own method.
But damn... I am busy IRL.

legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
That looks nice! But to make it tamper proof, you'll need to make sure you recognize the exact version you created. If someone can just print his own SeedCapsule to replace yours, you may not notice it.
That is true, you can always make your own custom made details that can't be printed and duplicated exactly.
It's not that hard if you have your own 3d printer, to add specific color mix or something similar like that, maybe editing stl files and making it unique.
Just let your imagination go wild.
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
what is interesting that you can make your backup tamper evident with this method.
That looks nice! But to make it tamper proof, you'll need to make sure you recognize the exact version you created. If someone can just print his own SeedCapsule to replace yours, you may not notice it.
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
I found interesting project called SeedCapsule that can be useful for people who are using steel washers for holding seed words backup.
Stl files for 3d printing can be found on their github page, and what is interesting that you can make your backup tamper evident with this method.
Capsule stem must be broken to take out steel washers, and it is locked with a twist before that.
I am not sure if it is compatible with washers that n0nce used in this topic, but other people may use it also.


https://orange.surf/seedcapsule/

hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
Well, it's not a big investment is the point I'm trying to make. You can get a working, small 3D printer for probably very close to 100€. But of course it will take time to build, set up, get into the whole process for sure.
3D Printer is a great investment but I am not sure you can find decent machine for around 100 euros (if I am wrong about it please post some links).
Of course, for $100 you don't get the nicest looking and highest accuracy prints, but it will probably work just fine for a bunch of jigs.
Can an $80 3D printer be any good? EasyThreed K7 Review

For like 150, you do already get sturdier, larger machines definitely.

What I would really want to have is 3d scanner, because it's much harder to make 3d model than to print it, and scanners would help a lot with this.
3D scanners are unfortunately really bad. The idea is cool, but as of today, they're either super expensive (and still require CAD touch-up work) or very bad and not suited as an alternative to designing something by hand. The perfect application for a 3D scanner would be producing a spare part for something, but even in those cases it's faster and more accurate to use some calipers and design the part in CAD.
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
Well, it's not a big investment is the point I'm trying to make. You can get a working, small 3D printer for probably very close to 100€. But of course it will take time to build, set up, get into the whole process for sure.
3D Printer is a great investment but I am not sure you can find decent machine for around 100 euros (if I am wrong about it please post some links).
Maybe this cheap machine can work for printing jigs for steel washers or for some simple objects, but I don't think it can print more complex objects.
What I would really want to have is 3d scanner, because it's much harder to make 3d model than to print it, and scanners would help a lot with this.
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
From the few iterations o had with people printing 3D objects, and people preparing 3D files (ehehe) I had the idea the whole 3D printing process is still to clumsy, prone to errors, trial and error, mishaps and other accidents to be considered so “safe” to make such an investment.
Going forward, something definitely doing going forward.
Well, it's not a big investment is the point I'm trying to make. You can get a working, small 3D printer for probably very close to 100€. But of course it will take time to build, set up, get into the whole process for sure.
Otherwise you can also always stamp onto washers without any jig. It's just a little help... Smiley
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
privacy when buying the materials (preferably in store, paid for with cash, of course Wink).
This is something I thought about.
Of course the most difficult part was getting the 3D printed jig. But I was lucky enough that the person didn’t know anything about bitcoins (or pretended to).
We will see…
For best opsec, I think it can even make sense to buy a small 3D printer just for the purpose of printing a few of these jigs, since a printer can cost less than hardware wallets. You can also then resell the printer at half price if you're really sure not to ever need it again.

From the few iterations o had with people printing 3D objects, and people preparing 3D files (ehehe) I had the idea the whole 3D printing process is still to clumsy, prone to errors, trial and error, mishaps and other accidents to be considered so “safe” to make such an investment.
Going forward, something definitely doing going forward.
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
privacy when buying the materials (preferably in store, paid for with cash, of course Wink).
This is something I thought about.
Of course the most difficult part was getting the 3D printed jig. But I was lucky enough that the person didn’t know anything about bitcoins (or pretended to).
We will see…
For best opsec, I think it can even make sense to buy a small 3D printer just for the purpose of printing a few of these jigs, since a printer can cost less than hardware wallets. You can also then resell the printer at half price if you're really sure not to ever need it again.
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
privacy when buying the materials (preferably in store, paid for with cash, of course Wink).
This is something I thought about.
Of course the most difficult part was getting the 3D printed jig. But I was lucky enough that the person didn’t know anything about bitcoins (or pretended to).
We will see…
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
A little update from my secret location:

I got this:



I started testing:


Sweeet! That's a clean setup! I am using rusty tools and for my last backup, due to no access to the anvil at the time, resorted to using a large hammer's side profile as support for the washer. Works better than you might think. Wink

The moment I realised I bought an anvil to secure my intergenerational wealth, it was hilarious.
Same epiphany here when I did my first backup, kneeling on the ground outside hammering onto metal for hours. This caveman-type activity, with the background of securing high-tech digital decentralized online 'gold', was kind of bizarre at first, honestly! Cheesy

I am going to write a full thread on this experience.
Cool, looking forward on more opinions on this backup technique in general & also specific challenges / critiques / improvement suggestions.
It's still my favourite so far due to cheap material, perfect results (can throw away badly stamped washers) and privacy when buying the materials (preferably in store, paid for with cash, of course Wink).
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
A little update from my secret location:

I got this:



I started testing:



The moment I realised I bought an anvil to secure my intergenerational wealth, it was hilarious.

I am going to write a full thread on this experience.


legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
I am definitely going for this.
I already have a blockmit printed. I would like to do a review of your jig.
I have 24mm washers and this set of pinchers set of punchers.
Do you need anything else?
Sending you a DM.

legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
Seems after years of engineering and professional, polished ready-to-use solutions, we are going back to the roots; DIY nodes, DIY seed backups and since 2021 (right?) even DIY hardware wallets (SeedSigner, various HW wallet 'scandals')! Cheesy
I think DIY is the way to go, it's just not for everybody, because some people can only eat baby food and they can not chew for themselves Wink
Most people today prefer to trust others to do the job for them, and it's not just related with Bitcoin stuff, it's the same with everything else.
Probably one of the best things you can have today is nice 3D printer, learn basic soldering, working with tools, and you are good to go.
It's not that hard to make your own hardware signing device, seed words backup on metal, your own bitcoin node with 3d printed case, etc.
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
Excuse me for asking, maybe I a don't understanding this correctly, but are you planning to make this washers with seed words on them and then sell them to other people?
It's always better to teach a man how to fish, than to give him the wish... even if he is lazy  Cheesy
Pretty sure such a product exists and there's definitely a place for it. Since it takes probably 2h to stamp a backup and even more time to get all the stuff needed, people might prefer buying just a set of all seed words and only having to number them correctly.
But I still believe for better opsec, for reducing waste and saving money, the DIY approach is king.

Seems after years of engineering and professional, polished ready-to-use solutions, we are going back to the roots; DIY nodes, DIY seed backups and since 2021 (right?) even DIY hardware wallets (SeedSigner, various HW wallet 'scandals')! Cheesy
legendary
Activity: 4326
Merit: 8950
'The right to privacy matters'
And for OPSEC it's much better to buy normal washers than have someone hammer them with wallet seed words.
I think that he said that he will do what n0nce did, that means he will put seed words on washers himself, and that is not so hard to do if you have the right tools.

I am lazy but would think you would be fairly secure making 2 wallets and using 48 of the 60 washers.
Would be very hard to crack. It could be affordable for a buyer and makable for a fabricating guy. I wonder what the math would be on 48 of 60 good words for 2 wallets. Once set up I would think it is about 1 hours labor to make the 60 washers.
I don't see the problem of using the full list of words, and it's not very good idea to be lazy about this.
Excuse me for asking, maybe I a don't understanding this correctly, but are you planning to make this washers with seed words on them and then sell them to other people?
It's always better to teach a man how to fish, than to give him the wish... even if he is lazy  Cheesy


maybe depends on how easy it is to do.
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
And for OPSEC it's much better to buy normal washers than have someone hammer them with wallet seed words.
I think that he said that he will do what n0nce did, that means he will put seed words on washers himself, and that is not so hard to do if you have the right tools.

I am lazy but would think you would be fairly secure making 2 wallets and using 48 of the 60 washers.
Would be very hard to crack. It could be affordable for a buyer and makable for a fabricating guy. I wonder what the math would be on 48 of 60 good words for 2 wallets. Once set up I would think it is about 1 hours labor to make the 60 washers.
I don't see the problem of using the full list of words, and it's not very good idea to be lazy about this.
Excuse me for asking, maybe I a don't understanding this correctly, but are you planning to make this washers with seed words on them and then sell them to other people?
It's always better to teach a man how to fish, than to give him the wish... even if he is lazy  Cheesy
legendary
Activity: 4326
Merit: 8950
'The right to privacy matters'
you only need assemble a nut 24 correct washer bolt
Without numbers, you lose your money if you drop the washers. I wouldn't like that risk.

true good point
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
you only need assemble a nut 24 correct washer bolt
Without numbers, you lose your money if you drop the washers. I wouldn't like that risk.
legendary
Activity: 4326
Merit: 8950
'The right to privacy matters'
If you were to give a list of 60 words from below knowing that 48 of them covered 2 wallets you could have someone make the 60 words for you.
I am lazy but would think you would be fairly secure making 2 wallets and using 48 of the 60 washers.
Would be very hard to crack. It could be affordable for a buyer and makable for a fabricating guy. I wonder what the math would be on 48 of 60 good words for 2 wallets.
Just 24 words give 620448401733239439360000 possibilities if you don't know the order, but there's a bigger problem: you need to remember the order by yourself. So if you ask someone to make very nice looking washers with perfectly spaced words in there, you'll need to hammer in the numbers 01 to 24 by yourself.
And for OPSEC it's much better to buy normal washers than have someone hammer them with wallet seed words.

If you give a list of 60 words.

48 good words for 2 full seed backups. you only need assemble a nut 24 correct washer bolt

you don’t need to punch.  but the fabricator would know you sent  for the set of 60 words.


So you would be safe more or less from the two wallets getting cracked.

but the risk of five dollar wrench attack is heightened
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
If you were to give a list of 60 words from below knowing that 48 of them covered 2 wallets you could have someone make the 60 words for you.
I am lazy but would think you would be fairly secure making 2 wallets and using 48 of the 60 washers.
Would be very hard to crack. It could be affordable for a buyer and makable for a fabricating guy. I wonder what the math would be on 48 of 60 good words for 2 wallets.
Just 24 words give 620448401733239439360000 possibilities if you don't know the order, but there's a bigger problem: you need to remember the order by yourself. So if you ask someone to make very nice looking washers with perfectly spaced words in there, you'll need to hammer in the numbers 01 to 24 by yourself.
And for OPSEC it's much better to buy normal washers than have someone hammer them with wallet seed words.
legendary
Activity: 4326
Merit: 8950
'The right to privacy matters'
Extraordinary
I already had a tough on the topic.

I looked at op's idea and decided to do this.

I ordered washers
I ordered bolts

I ordered punches

I have the other gear.

I am going to do my own thread as this one inspired me.
Cool! I'm not 100% sure yet how it's going to work, so I'll check out your topic once it's up.
Feel free to link it here as well! Smiley

Edit: How I understood, what will keep the washer in place will be 2 screws instead of this plastic jig. I must admit, your solution will probably hold it in place better, while being less good at holding the stamps square, not allowing to re-stamp easily in the exact same location (sometimes you don't hit it hard enough) and not allowing to stamp on a metal 'base' which is much better suited in my experience. But I'm intrigued to see it in action nonetheless! Grin


yeah I am certain I will have the washer held solid via 2 screws. center and six o'clock.

washers came today along with bolts and nuts.

I think I have a great jig Idea that will rig off your rig idea.

I will hold back on that idea until I see if it works.


How big is the full list of words?

24 of ?

@ dkbit98

I got this. these are 18/8  vs  316

https://www.mcmaster.com/90313A109/   got 2 packs of 25

https://www.mcmaster.com/90313A108/ got 1 pack of 50

https://www.mcmaster.com/91249A726/ got 1 pack of bolts

https://www.mcmaster.com/97149A100/ got 1 pack of 50

so 100 washers will allow me four sets.

I know that 18/8 is not as rust resistant  as 316


but some lithium grease will offer more protection.

I can field test it easy peasy. Just put one outside for a few months time.


My washer choice is from this company

https://www.mcmaster.com/washers/oversized-washers-9/

I got the punch set below

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01I0P8ADA?psc=1&ref=ppx_yo2_dt_b_product_details


edit list length is 2048 words

if you had 2 separate wallets with 48 words you could make 2 of these for under 20 bucks and labor.

If you were to give a list of 60 words from below knowing that 48 of them covered 2 wallets you could have someone make the 60 words for you.
I am lazy but would think you would be fairly secure making 2 wallets and using 48 of the 60 washers.
Would be very hard to crack. It could be affordable for a buyer and makable for a fabricating guy. I wonder what the math would be on 48 of 60 good words for 2 wallets. Once set up I would think it is about 1 hours labor to make the 60 washers.

Yeah I know it is only decently secure vs using the full list.

Code:

abandon
ability
able
about
above
absent
absorb
abstract
absurd
abuse
access
accident
account
accuse
achieve
acid
acoustic
acquire
across
act
action
actor
actress
actual
adapt
add
addict
address
adjust
admit
adult
advance
advice
aerobic
affair
afford
afraid
again
age
agent
agree
ahead
aim
air
airport
aisle
alarm
album
alcohol
alert
alien
all
alley
allow
almost
alone
alpha
already
also
alter
always
amateur
amazing
among
amount
amused
analyst
anchor
ancient
anger
angle
angry
animal
ankle
announce
annual
another
answer
antenna
antique
anxiety
any
apart
apology
appear
apple
approve
april
arch
arctic
area
arena
argue
arm
armed
armor
army
around
arrange
arrest
arrive
arrow
art
artefact
artist
artwork
ask
aspect
assault
asset
assist
assume
asthma
athlete
atom
attack
attend
attitude
attract
auction
audit
august
aunt
author
auto
autumn
average
avocado
avoid
awake
aware
away
awesome
awful
awkward
axis
baby
bachelor
bacon
badge
bag
balance
balconyboil
ball
bamboo
banana
banner
bar
barely
bargain
barrel
base
basic
basket
battle
beach
bean
beauty
because
become
beef
before
begin
behave
behind
believe
below
belt
bench
benefit
best
betray
better
between
beyond
bicycle
bid
bike
bind
biology
bird
birth
bitter
black
blade
blame
blanket
blast
bleak
bless
blind
blood
blossom
blouse
blueblur
blush
board
boat
body
boil
bomb
bone
bonus
book
boost
border
boring
borrow
boss
bottom
bounce
box
boy
bracket
brain
brand
brass
brave
bread
breeze
brick
bridge
brief
bright
bring
brisk
broccoli
broken
bronze
broom
brother
brown
brush
bubble
buddy
budget
buffalo
build
bulb
bulk
bullet
bundle
bunker
burden
burger
burst
bus
business
busy
butter
buyer
buzz
cabbage
cabin
cable
cactus
cage
cake
call
calm
camera
camp
can
canal
cancel
candy
cannon
canoe
canvas
canyon
capable
capital
captain
car
carbon
card
cargo
carpet
carry
cart
case
cash
casino
castle
casual
cat
catalog
catch
category
cattle
caught
cause
caution
cave
ceiling
celery
cement
census
century
cereal
certain
chair
chalk
champion
change
chaos
chapter
charge
chase
chat
cheap
check
cheese
chef
cherry
chest
chicken
chief
child
chimney
choice
choose
chronic
chuckle
chunk
churn
cigar
cinnamon
circle
citizen
city
civil
claim
clap
clarify
claw
clay
clean
clerk
clever
click
client
cliff
climb
clinic
clip
clock
clog
close
cloth
cloud
clown
club
clump
cluster
clutch
coach
coast
coconut
code
coffee
coil
coin
collect
color
column
combine
come
comfort
comic
common
company
concert
conduct
confirm
congress
connect
consider
control
convince
cook
cool
copper
copy
coral
core
corn
correct
cost
cotton
couch
country
couple
course
cousin
cover
coyote
crack
cradle
craft
cram
crane
crash
crater
crawl
crazy
cream
credit
creek
crew
cricket
crime
crisp
critic
crop
cross
crouch
crowd
crucial
cruel
cruise
crumble
crunch
crush
cry
crystal
cube
culture
cup
cupboard
curious
current
curtain
curve
cushion
custom
cute
cycle
dad
damage
damp
dance
danger
daring
dash
daughter
dawn
day
deal
debate
debris
decade
december
decide
decline
decorate
decrease
deer
defense
define
defy
degree
delay
deliver
demand
demise
denial
dentist
deny
depart
depend
deposit
depth
deputy
derive
describe
desert
design
desk
despair
destroy
detail
detect
develop
device
devote
diagram
dial
diamond
diary
dice
diesel
diet
differ
digital
dignity
dilemma
dinner
dinosaur
direct
dirt
disagree
discover
disease
dish
dismiss
disorder
display
distance
divert
divide
divorce
dizzy
doctor
document
dog
doll
dolphin
domain
donate
donkey
donor
door
dose
double
dove
draft
dragon
drama
drastic
draw
dream
dress
drift
drill
drink
drip
drive
drop
drum
dry
duck
dumb
dune
during
dust
dutch
duty
dwarf
dynamic
eager
eagle
early
earn
earth
easily
east
easy
echo
ecology
economy
edge
edit
educate
effort
egg
eight
either
elbow
elder
electric
elegant
element
elephant
elevator
elite
else
embark
embody
embrace
emerge
emotion
employ
empower
empty
enable
enact
end
endless
endorse
enemy
energy
enforce
engage
engine
enhance
enjoy
enlist
enough
enrich
enroll
ensure
enter
entire
entry
envelope
episode
equal
equip
era
erase
erode
erosion
error
erupt
escape
essay
essence
estate
eternal
ethics
evidence
evil
evoke
evolve
exact
example
excess
exchange
excite
exclude
excuse
execute
exercise
exhaust
exhibit
exile
exist
exit
exotic
expand
expect
expire
explain
expose
express
extend
extra
eye
eyebrow
fabric
face
faculty
fade
faint
faith
fall
false
fame
family
famous
fan
fancy
fantasy
farm
fashion
fat
fatal
father
fatigue
fault
favorite
feature
february
federal
fee
feed
feel
female
fence
festival
fetch
fever
few
fiber
fiction
field
figure
file
film
filter
final
find
fine
finger
finish
fire
firm
first
fiscal
fish
fit
fitness
fix
flag
flame
flash
flat
flavor
flee
flight
flip
float
flock
floor
flower
fluid
flush
fly
foam
focus
fog
foil
fold
follow
food
foot
force
forest
forget
fork
fortune
forum
forward
fossil
foster
found
fox
fragile
frame
frequent
fresh
friend
fringe
frog
front
frost
frown
frozen
fruit
fuel
fun
funny
furnace
fury
future
gadget
gain
galaxy
gallery
game
gap
garage
garbage
garden
garlic
garment
gas
gasp
gate
gather
gauge
gaze
general
genius
genre
gentle
genuine
gesture
ghost
giant
gift
giggle
ginger
giraffe
girl
give
glad
glance
glare
glass
glide
glimpse
globe
gloom
glory
glove
glow
glue
goat
goddess
gold
good
goose
gorilla
gospel
gossip
govern
gown
grab
grace
grain
grant
grape
grass
gravity
great
green
grid
grief
grit
grocery
group
grow
grunt
guard
guess
guide
guilt
guitar
gun
gym
habit
hair
half
hammer
hamster
hand
happy
harbor
hard
harsh
harvest
hat
have
hawk
hazard
head
health
heart
heavy
hedgehog
height
hello
helmet
help
hen
hero
hidden
high
hill
hint
hip
hire
history
hobby
hockey
hold
hole
holiday
hollow
home
honey
hood
hope
horn
horror
horse
hospital
host
hotel
hour
hover
hub
huge
human
humble
humor
hundred
hungry
hunt
hurdle
hurry
hurt
husband
hybrid
ice
icon
idea
identify
idle
ignore
ill
illegal
illness
image
imitate
immense
immune
impact
impose
improve
impulse
inch
include
income
increase
index
indicate
indoor
industry
infant
inflict
inform
inhale
inherit
initial
inject
injury
inmate
inner
innocent
input
inquiry
insane
insect
inside
inspire
install
intact
interest
into
invest
invite
involve
iron
island
isolate
issue
item
ivory
jacket
jaguar
jar
jazz
jealous
jeans
jelly
jewel
job
join
joke
journey
joy
judge
juice
jump
jungle
junior
junk
just
kangaroo
keen
keep
ketchup
key
kick
kid
kidney
kind
kingdom
kiss
kit
kitchen
kite
kitten
kiwi
knee
knife
knock
know
lab
label
labor
ladder
lady
lake
lamp
language
laptop
large
later
latin
laugh
laundry
lava
law
lawn
lawsuit
layer
lazy
leader
leaf
learn
leave
lecture
left
leg
legal
legend
leisure
lemon
lend
length
lens
leopard
lesson
letter
level
liar
liberty
library
license
life
lift
light
like
limb
limit
link
lion
liquid
list
little
live
lizard
load
loan
lobster
local
lock
logic
lonely
long
loop
lottery
loud
lounge
love
loyal
lucky
luggage
lumber
lunar
lunch
luxury
lyrics
machine
mad
magic
magnet
maid
mail
main
major
make
mammal
man
manage
mandate
mango
mansion
manual
maple
marble
march
margin
marine
market
marriage
mask
mass
master
match
material
math
matrix
matter
maximum
maze
meadow
mean
measure
meat
mechanic
medal
media
melody
melt
member
memory
mention
menu
mercy
merge
merit
merry
mesh
message
metal
method
middle
midnight
milk
million
mimic
mind
minimum
minor
minute
miracle
mirror
misery
miss
mistake
mix
mixed
mixture
mobile
model
modify
mom
moment
monitor
monkey
monster
month
moon
moral
more
morning
mosquito
mother
motion
motor
mountain
mouse
move
movie
much
muffin
mule
multiply
muscle
museum
mushroom
music
must
mutual
myself
mystery
myth
naive
name
napkin
narrow
nasty
nation
nature
near
neck
need
negative
neglect
neither
nephew
nerve
nest
net
network
neutral
never
news
next
nice
night
noble
noise
nominee
noodle
normal
north
nose
notable
note
nothing
notice
novel
now
nuclear
number
nurse
nut
oak
obey
object
oblige
obscure
observe
obtain
obvious
occur
ocean
october
odor
off
offer
office
often
oil
okay
old
olive
olympic
omit
once
one
onion
online
only
open
opera
opinion
oppose
option
orange
orbit
orchard
order
ordinary
organ
orient
original
orphan
ostrich
other
outdoor
outer
output
outside
oval
oven
over
own
owner
oxygen
oyster
ozone
pact
paddle
page
pair
palace
palm
panda
panel
panic
panther
paper
parade
parent
park
parrot
party
pass
patch
path
patient
patrol
pattern
pause
pave
payment
peace
peanut
pear
peasant
pelican
pen
penalty
pencil
people
pepper
perfect
permit
person
pet
phone
photo
phrase
physical
piano
picnic
picture
piece
pig
pigeon
pill
pilot
pink
pioneer
pipe
pistol
pitch
pizza
place
planet
plastic
plate
play
please
pledge
pluck
plug
plunge
poem
poet
point
polar
pole
police
pond
pony
pool
popular
portion
position
possible
post
potato
pottery
poverty
powder
power
practice
praise
predict
prefer
prepare
present
pretty
prevent
price
pride
primary
print
priority
prison
private
prize
problem
process
produce
profit
program
project
promote
proof
property
prosper
protect
proud
provide
public
pudding
pull
pulp
pulse
pumpkin
punch
pupil
puppy
purchase
purity
purpose
purse
push
put
puzzle
pyramid
quality
quantum
quarter
question
quick
quit
quiz
quote
rabbit
raccoon
race
rack
radar
radio
rail
rain
raise
rally
ramp
ranch
random
range
rapid
rare
rate
rather
raven
raw
razor
ready
real
reason
rebel
rebuild
recall
receive
recipe
record
recycle
reduce
reflect
reform
refuse
region
regret
regular
reject
relax
release
relief
rely
remain
remember
remind
remove
render
renew
rent
reopen
repair
repeat
replace
report
require
rescue
resemble
resist
resource
response
result
retire
retreat
return
reunion
reveal
review
reward
rhythm
rib
ribbon
rice
rich
ride
ridge
rifle
right
rigid
ring
riot
ripple
risk
ritual
rival
river
road
roast
robot
robust
rocket
romance
roof
rookie
room
rose
rotate
rough
round
route
royal
rubber
rude
rug
rule
run
runway
rural
sad
saddle
sadness
safe
sail
salad
salmon
salon
salt
salute
same
sample
sand
satisfy
satoshi
sauce
sausage
save
say
scale
scan
scare
scatter
scene
scheme
school
science
scissors
scorpion
scout
scrap
screen
script
scrub
sea
search
season
seat
second
secret
section
security
seed
seek
segment
select
sell
seminar
senior
sense
sentence
series
service
session
settle
setup
seven
shadow
shaft
shallow
share
shed
shell
sheriff
shield
shift
shine
ship
shiver
shock
shoe
shoot
shop
short
shoulder
shove
shrimp
shrug
shuffle
shy
sibling
sick
side
siege
sight
sign
silent
silk
silly
silver
similar
simple
since
sing
siren
sister
situate
six
size
skate
sketch
ski
skill
skin
skirt
skull
slab
slam
sleep
slender
slice
slide
slight
slim
slogan
slot
slow
slush
small
smart
smile
smoke
smooth
snack
snake
snap
sniff
snow
soap
soccer
social
sock
soda
soft
solar
soldier
solid
solution
solve
someone
song
soon
sorry
sort
soul
sound
soup
source
south
space
spare
spatial
spawn
speak
special
speed
spell
spend
sphere
spice
spider
spike
spin
spirit
split
spoil
sponsor
spoon
sport
spot
spray
spread
spring
spy
square
squeeze
squirrel
stable
stadium
staff
stage
stairs
stamp
stand
start
state
stay
steak
steel
stem
step
stereo
stick
still
sting
stock
stomach
stone
stool
story
stove
strategy
street
strike
strong
struggle
student
stuff
stumble
style
subject
submit
subway
success
such
sudden
suffer
sugar
suggest
suit
summer
sun
sunny
sunset
super
supply
supreme
sure
surface
surge
surprise
surround
survey
suspect
sustain
swallow
swamp
swap
swarm
swear
sweet
swift
swim
swing
switch
sword
symbol
symptom
syrup
system
table
tackle
tag
tail
talent
talk
tank
tape
target
task
taste
tattoo
taxi
teach
team
tell
ten
tenant
tennis
tent
term
test
text
thank
that
theme
then
theory
there
they
thing
this
thought
three
thrive
throw
thumb
thunder
ticket
tide
tiger
tilt
timber
time
tiny
tip
tired
tissue
title
toast
tobacco
today
toddler
toe
together
toilet
token
tomato
tomorrow
tone
tongue
tonight
tool
tooth
top
topic
topple
torch
tornado
tortoise
toss
total
tourist
toward
tower
town
toy
track
trade
traffic
tragic
train
transfer
trap
trash
travel
tray
treat
tree
trend
trial
tribe
trick
trigger
trim
trip
trophy
trouble
truck
true
truly
trumpet
trust
truth
try
tube
tuition
tumble
tuna
tunnel
turkey
turn
turtle
twelve
twenty
twice
twin
twist
two
type
typical
ugly
umbrella
unable
unaware
uncle
uncover
under
undo
unfair
unfold
unhappy
uniform
unique
unit
universe
unknown
unlock
until
unusual
unveil
update
upgrade
uphold
upon
upper
upset
urban
urge
usage
use
used
useful
useless
usual
utility
vacant
vacuum
vague
valid
valley
valve
van
vanish
vapor
various
vast
vault
vehicle
velvet
vendor
venture
venue
verb
verify
version
very
vessel
veteran
viable
vibrant
vicious
victory
video
view
village
vintage
violin
virtual
virus
visa
visit
visual
vital
vivid
vocal
voice
void
volcano
volume
vote
voyage
wage
wagon
wait
walk
wall
walnut
want
warfare
warm
warrior
wash
wasp
waste
water
wave
way
wealth
weapon
wear
weasel
weather
web
wedding
weekend
weird
welcome
west
wet
whale
what
wheat
wheel
when
where
whip
whisper
wide
width
wife
wild
will
win
window
wine
wing
wink
winner
winter
wire
wisdom
wise
wish
witness
wolf
woman
wonder
wood
wool
word
work
world
worry
worth
wrap
wreck
wrestle
wrist
write
wrong
yard
year
yellow
you
young
youth
zebra
zero
zone
zoo

legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
yeah stainless steel can rust
Only if you scrub the surface or cut it with other metal, or if you use some chemicals for cleaning.
There are different types and grades of SS with different percentage of iron, chromium, nickel and carbon... in simple terms more nickel means better anti-corrosion.
I think that Jameson Lopp used all kinds of testing when he tested metal seed backups, including acid with other torture methods and stainless steel survived all of them.
One material that would outlive stainless steel would probably be titanium but that is expensive and I never heard of titanium washers so far Wink

I am going to do my own thread as this one inspired me.
Great to hear and I just love reading about DIY projects, especially here in forum.
What exact type of steel washers you purchased?
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
Extraordinary
I already had a tough on the topic.

I looked at op's idea and decided to do this.

I ordered washers
I ordered bolts

I ordered punches

I have the other gear.

I am going to do my own thread as this one inspired me.
Cool! I'm not 100% sure yet how it's going to work, so I'll check out your topic once it's up.
Feel free to link it here as well! Smiley

Edit: How I understood, what will keep the washer in place will be 2 screws instead of this plastic jig. I must admit, your solution will probably hold it in place better, while being less good at holding the stamps square, not allowing to re-stamp easily in the exact same location (sometimes you don't hit it hard enough) and not allowing to stamp on a metal 'base' which is much better suited in my experience. But I'm intrigued to see it in action nonetheless! Grin
legendary
Activity: 4326
Merit: 8950
'The right to privacy matters'
Extraordinary 🙂
I already had a tough on the topic.

I looked at op's idea and decided to do this.

I ordered washers
I ordered bolts

I ordered punches

I have the other gear.

I am going to do my own thread as this one inspired me.

newbie
Activity: 66
Merit: 0
Extraordinary 🙂
I already had a tough on the topic.
legendary
Activity: 4326
Merit: 8950
'The right to privacy matters'
Please note if I think I gave credit for the image correctly. I pulled it from:

https://www.mcmaster.com/90313A109/





how about using a fender washer.
use center hole screw washer to plywood

drill second hole screw washer in both holes

put new hole at six o'clock

wrap the word at 7-9-11-1-3-5

cost is a piece of plywood.
25 washers
a nut and bolt

when done lightly grease the coins to slow rusting. white lithium grease is good.

(yeah stainless steel can rust)


and you can make a  jig  that holds the punches  using this

https://www.amazon.com/Mending-Stainless-Straight-Connector-Thickness/dp/B08DNMK7W5/ref=sr_1_1?c

hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
Awesome!
I stumbled on this thread almost by chance and this is definitely something I would like to test in the near future.
Low tech, durable way, of storing bitcoin is definitely something I would like to test.

I already had a tough on the topic,

Gifting satoshis to future generations

Now, trying first hand is now on my 2022 project list.
That's cool! If you're interested in such a jig as well, feel free to tell me the dimensions of your washers & I can send you STL files to print Smiley
I didn't get around to making an easy customizable OpenSCAD file for it. With that, anyone could customize the file by themselves for free, but the file I have right now is only for (paid) Autodesk Fusion.
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 17063
Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23
Awesome!
I stumbled on this thread almost by chance and this is definitely something I would like to test in the near future.
Low tech, durable way, of storing bitcoin is definitely something I would like to test.

I already had a tough on the topic,

Gifting satoshis to future generations

Now, trying first hand is now on my 2022 project list.


 
legendary
Activity: 2968
Merit: 3406
Crypto Swap Exchange
And I didn't hurt any finger even once! Wink
That should also be one of the main reasons for using a Blockmit jig Wink

I appreciate the sketch, but I am not sure I understand it except of 'well, align it with the edges of the washer', or am I missing something? Huh
Sorry, I should've been clearer but I believe you got it right [e.g. no uneven sides when you check the spaces from the top].
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
I don't think the main purpose of the jig is to hold the washer in place. Otherwise, of course a clamp would do a good job easily.
I forgot to add "to an extent" when I said it'd defeat the purpose of printing it [my bad].
All good! Grin

since jig holds the bit perfectly perpendicular and you can re-stamp in the exact same location.
You have a point but you can still get good results without the jig [or a tool bit boring bar and a holder], provided that you don't have a hand & arm tremor and as for the re-stamping part [CMIIW], I don't think there's a need for one if you hit it three to four times with enough force [in quick succession].
Heheh, you have a point there. No tremor on my side, but I have to confess I am not the most proficient 'hammer-er'. It's probably simply due to me overall preferring screws and almost everything I build is made of screws instead of nails. So the jig definitely helps to get every letter perpendicular and straight. I did a few steel backups in the past and the letters always came out bad, not nearly as good as on these washers with this jig. And I didn't hurt any finger even once! Wink

Secondly, the jig helps you align the rotation and spacing between letters. So no letter ends up tilted to one side or way too close to another.
Since the majority of the letter stamps, come with right-angled [or squarish] shafts, then with a proper technique you can still get almost perfect results in round shape washers...
I appreciate the sketch, but I am not sure I understand it except of 'well, align it with the edges of the washer', or am I missing something? Huh

There's no doubt that the "Blockmit jig" is a great product, but you can still achieve good results without having one!
For sure, I guess it depends on technique / experience.
legendary
Activity: 2968
Merit: 3406
Crypto Swap Exchange
I don't think the main purpose of the jig is to hold the washer in place. Otherwise, of course a clamp would do a good job easily.
I forgot to add "to an extent" when I said it'd defeat the purpose of printing it [my bad].

since jig holds the bit perfectly perpendicular and you can re-stamp in the exact same location.
You have a point but you can still get good results without the jig [or a tool bit boring bar and a holder], provided that you don't have a hand & arm tremor and as for the re-stamping part [CMIIW], I don't think there's a need for one if you hit it three to four times with enough force [in quick succession].

Secondly, the jig helps you align the rotation and spacing between letters. So no letter ends up tilted to one side or way too close to another.
Since the majority of the letter stamps, come with right-angled [or squarish] shafts, then with a proper technique you can still get almost perfect results in round shape washers...

  • This should be the view from the top:


There's no doubt that the "Blockmit jig" is a great product, but you can still achieve good results without having one!
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
How about a more classic way to hold the washer in place: a screw Smiley
Drill a hole from the side, taper inner thread, put a screw in it.
You sir, are a genius! Grin To be continued... Wink

Disclaimer: I have no idea how strong 3D-printed plastic is.
You can screw directly into a slightly undersized hold and it holds very well, it's also possible to insert heat-fitted inserts. Both are about equally as strong last I checked Smiley

unfortunately it is indeed pretty tedious to use tape, since it has to be replaced frequently.
How about a more classic way to hold the washer in place: a screw Smiley
LoyceV's comment reminded me of something that would defeat the purpose of printing the jig part: Clamps [it'd require covering 1/3rd of the washers]
I don't think the main purpose of the jig is to hold the washer in place. Otherwise, of course a clamp would do a good job easily. The 2 main factors over not using a jig (after some experience with steel plates and no jigs): the letters come out well almost 100% of the time, since jig holds the bit perfectly perpendicular and you can re-stamp in the exact same location. Secondly, the jig helps you align the rotation and spacing between letters. So no letter ends up tilted to one side or way too close to another.
legendary
Activity: 2968
Merit: 3406
Crypto Swap Exchange
unfortunately it is indeed pretty tedious to use tape, since it has to be replaced frequently.
How about a more classic way to hold the washer in place: a screw Smiley
LoyceV's comment reminded me of something that would defeat the purpose of printing the jig part: Clamps [it'd require covering 1/3rd of the washers]

  • Off the top of my head, I can only name a few out of the hundred clamp types, so I'd suggest using a "G-clamp" or an "in-line clamp" for holding the washers in place [if you have one].
    Note: There might be better clamp types than the ones I've mentioned above.

Out of curiosity, do you have a CNC machine [apart from the 3D printer]?
- If you do, then just use its clamps.
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
How about a more classic way to hold the washer in place: a screw Smiley
Drill a hole from the side, taper inner thread, put a screw in it.

One pointy screw at the right place should keep it in place:


Even better if you can tighten it by hand:




Disclaimer: I have no idea how strong 3D-printed plastic is.
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
Small update: After doing a few backups, unfortunately it is indeed pretty tedious to use tape, since it has to be replaced frequently. By the washer being hammered into the underlying metal support, it damages the tape around its perimeter and it's hard to remove & reuse it without ripping.

5mm diameter neodymium magnets however don't hold the washer in place too well; I will maybe need stronger / larger ones to get a satisfying result. Will update when I got something new; maybe simply stronger tape would help as well (ran out of electrical tape).

I suspect the bad performance of the magnets is due to low ferrite content in the metal, so especially if you find very 'good' stainless steel, magnets won't work.
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
An idea to achieve tamper evidence and protection (though we had the discussion if it's even a good idea or not): weld on the nut.
What about rust? I know that's usually not a problem with washers I've had laying around forever, but if it holds crucial information, I wouldn't mind oiling them before bolting them together. Especially since this won't be in a normal drawer but probably somewhere well hidden.
Yes, for sure, protecting the material should be taken into consideration, but it depends on the washers' metal type, so I provided no information so far about that. I am under the assumption that mine are stainless steel, however after reading your suggestion, I tried to see if they're magnetic and they are, just a bit.

Quote
Protection: Not everyone just has an angle grinder.
I can just imagine myself getting my angle grinder to buy something Cheesy
That's how we roll! Bring your battery powered grinder to the store

I don't really see another way to hold a round object in place other than friction to be honest.
Have you considered a magnet? They're available in many sizes and shapes on AliExpress and can probably fit somewhere inside the 3D design. Unless you're going for stainless steel washers, but I assume those are too hard to stamp.
I am pretty sure mine are stainless steel, similarly to many commercial 'steel backups', which is quite good for backups. Stainless steel can be magnetic and I had not thought about using magnets so far, great idea.
However, the washer has to be held either from the top or the bottom (side is too shallow I think). From the bottom is tricky because then you'd be hammering onto the magnet, not sure if they're made to withstand that. From the top won't work, because the top is not covered by the 'outside' part of the jig, instead by the (removable) inside. We need a way to stick the washer to the outside part instead.

I have one idea which would require re-seating the washer for applying the numbers though, since I'd put a magnet in that location roughly. So you would need to do the number first, rotate the washer by 180 degrees and then do the words.



I prefer to customise it for you and sell you a print or printable file Smiley
Cool project and I think I saw similar thing recently when I wrote about metal seed backups.
I see you written nice Bitcoin Talk, so do you have your own stamping tools and letters or you borrowed it?
Thanks for the feedback! I mentioned where I found the idea in the starter post; it's not mine. As far as I know, the BlockMit guys are the ones who came up with it. I just recreated a new jig in Fusion with parametric values for everything, compared to their Tinkercad model that was hard to modify.

The tools I used were 2 hammers and normal 6mm high letter stamps! I got them when I made my first steel backup for around 30€ with all numbers and letters.
2 hammers? I don't have an anvil, but a washer is so small it can fit on the side of a larger hammer. This way you don't need to hit them as hard as when using a wooden workbench as support, since that absorbs a ton of energy.

My stamps are from 'Gravurem': https://www.heidenpeter.de/en/products/handschlagstempelsaetze/gravurems-standard/
At least in the 6mm variant, the tip is a bit taller than the bit's actual size, so I created the jig with this in mind. So the stamp is inserted into the inner circle 'from below'. But in case your stamps are equal sized from top to bottom, I will adapt the file to reflect that geometry.

Edit: Ordered some magnets, will try something that would require no tape, once they arrive Smiley
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
I prefer to customise it for you and sell you a print or printable file Smiley
Cool project and I think I saw similar thing recently when I wrote about metal seed backups.
I see you written nice Bitcoin Talk, so do you have your own stamping tools and letters or you borrowed it?

What about rust? I know that's usually not a problem with washers I've had laying around forever, but if it holds crucial information, I wouldn't mind oiling them before bolting them together. Especially since this won't be in a normal drawer but probably somewhere well hidden.
They are stainless steel washers, rostfrei, meaning free from rust, but it is possible to develop some rust during long periods of time, under special conditions or if weaker alloy is used.
I think that painting would be a better protection solution than oiling them.
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
An idea to achieve tamper evidence and protection (though we had the discussion if it's even a good idea or not): weld on the nut.
What about rust? I know that's usually not a problem with washers I've had laying around forever, but if it holds crucial information, I wouldn't mind oiling them before bolting them together. Especially since this won't be in a normal drawer but probably somewhere well hidden.

I don't really see another way to hold a round object in place other than friction to be honest.
Have you considered a magnet? They're available in many sizes and shapes on AliExpress and can probably fit somewhere inside the 3D design. Unless you're going for stainless steel washers, but I assume those are too hard to stamp.
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
I wanted to tackle that issue by using "square washers" instead [I do know it's probably not worth the trouble to modify everything in order to integrate a different shape into the design, but it'll solve that problem completely].
Note: I'm not vouching for the website that I've included as an example.
I didn't know these existed, but it seems an option as well! In general the cool thing about these products is that the price / weight of stainless steel is so so cheap. I don't think they would stay on a screw as nicely as round washers, but it would be doable. When I'll find time to sit at the CAD again, I might give it a shot, though I don't have such washers here to try / experiment with.

I don't really see another way to hold a round object in place other than friction to be honest.
It would be a significant amount of additional work for very marginal gains, but you could cut a small wedge out of each washer and modify your jig design so there is a small piece which sticks out in to the wedge cut-out to hold the washer in place. Almost certainly not worth the time, though. Your other option would be to buy square or other non-round washers, but again, you would obviously need to redesign your whole jig.

It sounds like your set up works fine with tape though. If you really mess up a washer by trying to punch it twice and being out of alignment, then you can just make a new one - it's not like you've messed up the entire back up as you might have done with a single steel plate.
I agree; the gain is small and it's really easy to put a piece of tape there. Or not, but then maybe only stamp a letter once. Modifying the round washers in any way will 100% take more time than using tape. One idea would be to drill a small hole into the washers using an appropriate hole in the jig to make it square and to use it to keep the washer aligned afterwards. But I think everything we can come up with is more involved than a piece of tape (it can be reused after each washer).

I'm not even sure how the suggestion of using some tape is such a big concern to be honest Grin For me, after reading the BlockMit article, it was a no-brainer to just keep that concept since it seemed so easy and quick to do anyway.

As you said, it's great that each word has its own washer with costs just a few pennies, so even if a letter comes crooked due to omitting tape, just take another washer. I have to say; I never had such a good looking steel backup..

I know, you can create a jig for a steel plate backup as well, but if you still mess up, you will need a new $20 plate.
legendary
Activity: 2268
Merit: 18771
I don't really see another way to hold a round object in place other than friction to be honest.
It would be a significant amount of additional work for very marginal gains, but you could cut a small wedge out of each washer and modify your jig design so there is a small piece which sticks out in to the wedge cut-out to hold the washer in place. Almost certainly not worth the time, though. Your other option would be to buy square or other non-round washers, but again, you would obviously need to redesign your whole jig.

It sounds like your set up works fine with tape though. If you really mess up a washer by trying to punch it twice and being out of alignment, then you can just make a new one - it's not like you've messed up the entire back up as you might have done with a single steel plate.
legendary
Activity: 2968
Merit: 3406
Crypto Swap Exchange
Because sometimes it rotates just a slight bit.

But it's really not a big issue in my opinion with the tape; quite easy with normal packing tape or wide transparent tape Smiley
I'd be glad to hear any recommendation / improvement suggestions though!
~Snipped~
I don't really see another way to hold a round object in place other than friction to be honest.
You're right... I wanted to tackle that issue by using "square washers" instead [I do know it's probably not worth the trouble to modify everything in order to integrate a different shape into the design, but it'll solve that problem completely].
Note: I'm not vouching for the website that I've included as an example.
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
(tape holds washer in place)
Before starting the hammering, the mold that I have created has a small defect that I have not really been able to correct without adding anything external. And it is that when hammering the first character and extracting the moving part to do it in the second, the washer moves and the final result is quite bad. To fix this I use a little electrical tape, making the result look good by not moving the washer during the whole process.
Have you tried stamping it without any tape? I'm curious to know how it moves? Does it turn or it comes out slightly when you remove the moving part?
- Depending on the answer, I could help in finding a solution for each, but it would probably require modifying almost everything [if you want, I can provide the STL file on Monday (assuming that you still have some old filaments to spare)].
Yes, I tried without tape as well. Due to the good friction fit, it doesn't come out, but it can move a little. At least in my version, that is. Had no way of trying the blockmit so far Grin
So in theory, it would work without tape, as long as you don't need to punch a letter twice often. Because sometimes it rotates just a slight bit.

But it's really not a big issue in my opinion with the tape; quite easy with normal packing tape or wide transparent tape Smiley
I'd be glad to hear any recommendation / improvement suggestions though!

I was already thinking of modifying the file so that you can screw the jig into a piece of metal beam, but then it would be tedious to get the washer out and to replace the tape when needed. I don't really see another way to hold a round object in place other than friction to be honest.
legendary
Activity: 2968
Merit: 3406
Crypto Swap Exchange
(tape holds washer in place)
Before starting the hammering, the mold that I have created has a small defect that I have not really been able to correct without adding anything external. And it is that when hammering the first character and extracting the moving part to do it in the second, the washer moves and the final result is quite bad. To fix this I use a little electrical tape, making the result look good by not moving the washer during the whole process.
Have you tried stamping it without any tape? I'm curious to know how it moves? Does it turn or it comes out slightly when you remove the moving part?
- Depending on the answer, I could help in finding a solution for each, but it would probably require modifying almost everything [if you want, I can provide the STL file on Monday (assuming that you still have some old filaments to spare)].
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
This is very cool. Great project!

Remember to also stamp on the position number of each word in your seed phrase. The last thing you want is to drop the whole thing when trying to recover your seed phrase and end up with 24 washers on the floor in a random order, which will be impossible to brute force.

In terms of welding the nut on and then cutting it off again - what is the risk that you damage your back up by doing this? I suppose you could always use a longer bolt with some extra washers, so they are still tight and can not be read while the device is sealed, but giving you some dead space between where you are welding/cutting and the washers containing your words.
Thanks for your feedback!

Yes, word index is part of the blockmic design and I incorporated it as well (see the 2 notches above the 8 notches - those are for the index) Smiley
However I later noticed I should have done a stamp with such a number on it, to display how it will look Grin
I will do it tomorrow if I remember Smiley

Dead space for angle grinding sounds good to me!
legendary
Activity: 2268
Merit: 18771
This is very cool. Great project!

Remember to also stamp on the position number of each word in your seed phrase. The last thing you want is to drop the whole thing when trying to recover your seed phrase and end up with 24 washers on the floor in a random order, which will be impossible to brute force.

In terms of welding the nut on and then cutting it off again - what is the risk that you damage your back up by doing this? I suppose you could always use a longer bolt with some extra washers, so they are still tight and can not be read while the device is sealed, but giving you some dead space between where you are welding/cutting and the washers containing your words.
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
Works in Progress:
  • Recreating it another time in OpenSCAD - models are 'coded', parameters can be changed by modifying some variables easily.
  • Testing with neodymium magnets which would eliminate the need for tape. Turns out it's too complicated and good tape (can be partly peeled & reused) & hard stamping surface is totally fine.
  • Trying double-sided stamping to further reduce cost by half & make backup smaller.

How to get?
To make sure it really works correctly, I'd prefer selling the customized and printed jig.
If I gave the file it could give you headache since I pieced it together quickly and tolerances are quite important when printing it out.. Cheesy
But if you're experienced in modifying designs, printing them or are overseas etc. just send me a DM!

Get the fresh clean source code below and print it yourself or if interested, I can print for you and ship it to a PO box or something. For best privacy, buying or borrowing a cost-effective printer would be recommended.

[NEW!!] OpenSCAD design finalized!
Paste this following code into OpenSCAD (free, open source) and set the parameters to whatever fits your washers and stamps. It's important to measure the stamp's outside size, not the letter height which is usually given on the product page. Then hit F5 and F6 to preview and render the two models. Finally, export the STL file and print it out.
Code:
// n0nce's Steel Washer backup jig
// ---------- configuration ---------- //
washer_dia  = 30;    // set to your washer's diameter (mm)
washer_hole = 10.5; // set to your washer's hole diameter (mm)
washer_h    = 3;     // set to your washer's thickness (mm)
stamp_w     = 8;     // set to your stamp's width (mm)
stamp_d     = 8;     // set to your stamp's depth (mm)

// ---------- code ---------- //
tolerance = 0.25;
// ---------- outer part ---------- //
module roundedcube(xx, yy, height, radius) {
  $fn=60;
  translate([0,0,height/2])
  hull() {
    translate([radius,radius,0])
    cylinder(height,radius,radius,true);

    translate([xx-radius,radius,0])
    cylinder(height,radius,radius,true);

    translate([xx-radius,yy-radius,0])
    cylinder(height,radius,radius,true);

    translate([radius,yy-radius,0])
    cylinder(height,radius,radius,true);
  }
}

module washer() {
  cylinder(h=washer_h, r=washer_dia/2, center=false, $fn=200);
}

module outer() {
  module outer_body() {
    translate([-27, -27, 0])
      roundedcube(54, 54, 20, 3);
  }
  module slot() {
    translate([-5/2,0,washer_h])
      cube([5,23,30]);
  }
 
  difference(){
    outer_body();
   
    // main cylinder to cut out
    translate([0, 0, washer_h])
      cylinder(h=100, r=38/2, center=false, $fn=200);
   
    // washer cut out
    translate([0, 0, -1])
      scale([1, 1, 10])
        washer();
     
    // number slots cut outs
    for (i=[0,2])
      rotate(-14+i*14)
        slot();
    // letter slots cut outs
    for (i=[0:7])
      rotate(82+i*28)
        slot();
  }
}

// ---------- inner part ---------- //
module inner() {
  module inner_body() {
    // main part
    cylinder(h=20-washer_h, r=38/2-0.3, center=false, $fn=200);
    // handle
    cylinder(h=20-washer_h+8, d=9, center=false, $fn=200);
    // sticking out part
    rotate(-14) translate([-4/2,0,0])
      cube([4,22.5,20-washer_h]);
  }
 
  module puncher_hole() {
    sw=stamp_w+tolerance;
    sd=stamp_d+tolerance;
    rotate(-14) translate([-sw/2,
      (washer_dia+washer_hole)/4-sd/2,
      -10])
      cube([sw,sd,50]);
  }
 
  translate([0, 0, washer_h]) {
    difference() {
      inner_body();
      puncher_hole();
    }
  }
}
outer();
translate([70,0,0])
  inner();

A note on material choice:
When you are talking about extreme weather conditions, I don't know if you know this but 304 stainless steel can easily be corrupted if exposed to salt water, so if you are living in area near sea water I would opt out for better 316 stainless steel.
I am not sure if Jameson Lopp did any tests with salt water, but I believe that is much more realistic threat for some parts of the world compared to acid exposure.

Not all stainless steel is made the same, there are different types and grades, so while 316 SS is better for salt water it does have slightly lower melting point compared to 304 SS:

Grade 304 melting points: 1400-1450°C (2552-2642°F)
Grade 316 melting points: 1375-1400°C (2507-2552°F)
Grade 430 melting points: 1425-1510°C (2597-2750°F)
Grade 434 melting points: 1426-1510°C (2600-2750°F)
Grade 410 melting points: 1480-1530°C (2696-2786°F)
Grade 420 melting points: 1450-1510°C (2642-2750°F)

Pick 304 if you want high temperature resistance, or pick 316 if you want high corrosion resistance.
hero member
Activity: 910
Merit: 5935
not your keys, not your coins!
n0nce's Steel Washer Backup jig


    Very nicely readable 6mm letters (tape holds washer in place) | Prototypes & final version. Improved letter spacing & tolerances.



This is pretty much how it works

Backup pure material cost: 4€
Requirements: stamps ~20€, jig ~10€
Go big or go home! 30x10.5mm washers!
6mm tall letters
Edit: Any size of washer and stamp is now possible using the openSCAD file I provide for free below. Enjoy!


The idea is inspired from econoalchemist's blog post Securing a Bitcoin seed phrase in stainless-steel washers. and it's very great:
  • Materials cost under 5 bucks (€, $, £, it's always the same ballpark). I paid around 3€ for 32 washers and maybe 1€ for the screw and nut.
  • No shipping cost since everyone has a hardware store nearby.
  • Anonymous since nobody knows what you use basic metal hardware for.
  • All stainless steel, quite durable, on par with commercial Bitcoin backup products.
  • Greater thickness than some commercial products

Backstory:
After reading the aforementioned blog post, I went to download the file for the jig from blockmic. It can be found in their Thingiverse and they wrote a very good article about it.

But: For one, I wanted to use larger washers. In fact, I think I got the largest that I could find in the first hardware store I walked into. A reason for this is that larger washers are usually also thicker and thus more durable, and the other reason is simply because the stamps I already had were too large for such small washers.

I have 6mm high letters and the stamps are 9x9mm in size.

So I did the natural thing: create a new 3D design from scratch, which is completely parametrized. This allows me to adapt it for anyone with different sized washers and / or stamps! Smiley Then did a few iterations, as shown here, and now it's ready to rock!

It's really the most pleasent stamping experience (only did plates without any jig so far), since the stamp is held in place very well, while still being able to slide and of course it's perfectly square. The inner and outer parts are also designed such that there is not much friction when assembling them, but there is no wobble when stamping. So you can actually go back and re-stamp a letter if it didn't come out perfect for example!



PSA: I can achieve much better print quality than what you see in the images, but I am finishing up some old rolls which have taken a lot of humidity so the results don't look as good. Also, I used more perimeters than CryptoCloaks since it makes things more sturdy. Finally, the darker colour you use, the more print lines show (especially when photographed) Grin


An idea to achieve tamper evidence and protection (though we had the discussion if it's even a good idea or not): weld on the nut.
Protection: Not everyone just has an angle grinder.
Evidence: Someone would need to weld it back on which is visible, or redo the backup identically, thus needing a welder AND a 3D printer and all the same supplies that you used. Otherwise the letter size would be different for example.
Jump to: