Topic: New Child Board for banned users... - page 2. (Read 638 times)

I've never said it's against the rules, I wrote that it stays in compliance with rule 25, but considering the large amount of these threads moving them into one Child Board would clean a bit Meta. It's only a little organizational change. I think I would be also more comfortable for for them because getting into Meta they would immediately know where they should put their thread and what also important - having all similar threads in one place some of them maybe first read some other threads before writing their own.



According rule 25 "The only exception is creating a thread in Meta about your ban." so they can't post in others threads...


Why not ;-)


Great we already have a first pinned message for this Child Board...

Thats the reason why i am created this thread https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/your-account-got-banned-look-first-here-5043370 !

To reduce the threads maybe a bit for every single banned account asking !

Would be a nice thing to have a board for all Asking why are  Accounts Banned !

Can we call it The Swamp?

I think it would be a good idea since we will be done with all the posts about banned accounts etc.
But if you think about it, It's like you are not banning them anymore, you just quarantine them in a subforum topic that they can keep spamming.

Just like you said and rule number 25 states that a banned user/account is only allowed to make a single thread here in meta about his/her ban

And that's exactly what this users/members did/are doing,and I do not see anything wrong in it, probably making more than one thread or persistently commenting on the thread made,then it's definitely against the rules

Having numerous threads about it is acceptable considering the fact that it's the right section for it, I guess we're having more of it because our MODs are cracking down on more cheaters,copy/past posters and plagiarist saving Tman the stress of swearing at them..

Thanks to hard work of administrators, moderators and many volunteer reporters very often forbidden behaviors are disclosed and punished by bans. Unfortunately as the number of users and bans increase, more and more banned users complain about their situation or look for its reason by writing new threads in Meta section. I’ve checked only first three pages (last few days) of Meta section and found more than 30 single threads regarding someone's problem in this matter. I didn't check more but I'm sure that it could be close to hundred of them every month. It makes real mess in the Meta board…

The realize how many of them there are look the list below (only last 4 pages)
1.   hay hay i have been banned, please somebody explain to me (-_-')
2.   Good day I would like to appeal my banned account.
3.   My Legendary account has been banned, any Modo to tell me why ?
4.   Unreasonable account ban
5.   My account had been banned,what should i do??
6.   Requesting mods to reconsider the banning of our project's account.
7.   Please Help
8.   Account lockout. Why ??
9.   My Account has been Banned, Why ??  
10.  Ban appeal
11.  account fullmember in read-only mode for more than 9 months. theymos not react
12.  Autoban. Help
13.  Hello Please Help me for My account
14.  help me figure out where I broke the rules
15.  Ban Duration
16.  Account Banned
17.  Recovery of my account zefirka
18.  For that ban???
19.  Why was my account banned?
20.  I was very silly and consequently my account was blocked
21.  Account banned
22.  Why my account get banned?
23.  Can Someone Tell Me why My Account Get Banned?
24.  Can you explain ban evasion ?
25.  Account lockout
26.  Account blocked, why?
27.  Why was my account blocked?
28.  The reason why the account is blocked, why ??
29.  Auto ban!!!
30.  My account got banned and wanna know the reason.


Of course I do understand that being banned could be a disaster for each user and there have to be a place for threads related to this matter (and the meta section seems the most appropriate). What even more important creating a thread about banned account in Meta section is the only permitted activity for banned people (rule 25th). But maybe considering a really large amount of similar threads, it would be a good solution to create a Child Board especially for this...  I think it could clean a bit Meta board...

If you like this idea please vote... If not please do it as well.