Pages:
Author

Topic: philosophical question (Read 722 times)

newbie
Activity: 6
Merit: 0
June 30, 2017, 08:04:40 PM
#28
I think it was that bad, maybe in their countries they wouldn't have jobs, but i don't think agressions have been part of their lifes.
sr. member
Activity: 1036
Merit: 279
June 30, 2017, 02:52:15 PM
#27
It was helpful for the Americans, or at least those in the South where the economy is reliant on labor. Was it helpful to blacks? Well probably not, they were enslaved, at least the generation before abolition. Even after that, there was segregation.

I think the question is similar to "is colonization helpful?". We can always say that colonized people were exposed to Western science and technology and were able to get past their tribal political structure...
sr. member
Activity: 644
Merit: 299
June 30, 2017, 11:24:36 AM
#26
I don't mean any offence or to offend anybody at all, it's simply a question.

Was slavery in the US that bad? By having slaves and abolishing slavery later on, yes it was cruel and wrong BUT with slavery they've saved the many generations of africans from potentially dying from a disease, war,etc... and gave the new generations of slaves to live a normal and a lot more happy life in the US later on. So was slavery actually that bad?

I hope that you've understood the question I wanted to ask, really sleepy right now but wanted to hear your opinion on this one.

None taken! Apparently what you are saying is that at the long run, the future generation of the slaves ended up benefitting from the sufferings their forefathers had to go through? Going back in time, it was bad. I am pretty sure most of them were used as animals without human sympathy and feeling. Some died in the process while some got lucky maybe, but however it is, slavery ain't ever and will never be a good thing. Moreover, not like the offsprings ending up in the U.S is a big deal. Why paint it like being in their own country will limit them from being what they wanna become.
copper member
Activity: 1442
Merit: 529
June 30, 2017, 09:41:42 AM
#25
Slavery is always bad. No one has the right to decide for any other human being life. That concept is from the middle ages and I find it strange there are people here mentioning it like it is something good, this is shocking to say the least. In South Africa life has improved considerably and I have a few friends studying there which only speaks good about Johannesburg.

However real slavery is right now in our days where the employer do not give a damn for the employee , he wants to use it even more than a slave, that is what capitalism is unfortunately.
hero member
Activity: 1764
Merit: 584
June 30, 2017, 08:27:24 AM
#24
If you think of it now, yes, blacks in the US definitely have it better than those in say, Sudan or Sierra Leone. But that is only a fluke. What would have happened if slavery was never abolished? Many European countries has already started abolishing it at the time, but what would have happened if the US lagged, like how some countries in Africa (the irony) still practice it now?
Estimates largely suggest that India has the largest amount of slaves in the present day.  See Wikipedia's article on contemporary slavery.

Unfortunately capitalist societies result in slavery, because multinational corporations try to find the cheapest labour possible to produce a product with a competitive price, which often involves moving to the third world in order to subvert Western workers' rights and unions.

It's still practiced in many third world countries. Heck even in the Middle East. There are many reports of domestic helpers being locked in by employers and not given pay.

As for capitalistic practices, it is technically not slavery, since they are getting paid but yes, worker's rights are not as well protected in those countries. Reminded me of the incident in Bangladesh where a factory collapsed, killing many workers in it.

Even in China where many factories are at least better than Bangladesh, it seem that workers still feel bad. Saw a video of the iPhone factory, they even have screens everywhere to prevent workers from jumping to death. If people would commit suicide in those fairly better looking facilities, just imagine the condition in sweat shops in Africa and South Asia.
legendary
Activity: 1148
Merit: 1048
June 29, 2017, 11:54:08 PM
#23
Quote from: GreenBits
Your potential for growth is limited, it kind of makes you just want to give up. People assume they know your character because of how you look, it's frustrating to say 'Hello Ma'am' to an older white lady in Walmart, and have her glare at you.
I'm white, and it's hilarious to see some white people assume that they know whether black people experience racism.  The only group you can ask about if black people experience racism is black people, and if a large amount of them say yes then they do.  That's just basic logic.

I thought Greenbits was black. I believe I heard him mention somewhere that he's from Africa. Starts with M, I think it's Mozambique.
That was intended to be support for his views, because of all the people trying to discredit what he says about the existence of racism.  I can see how it might have been confusing now.

Hehe, thanks bruvs, and yes I'm Black, but I reside in North Carolina, by way of Louisiana. I think it's Slow Death (the guy with the ant in an army hat avatar) that lives in Africa, I might be mistaken though.

We haven't even talked about the Chinese and American Railroad construction. Or the Irish.

and Oburkabinladin, I apologize for dismissing you this morning. I had a rough start, took that out on you, and you responded poorly, but I initiated all of that. To actual respond to you, I think genocide is a retroactive destination, that is legislative policy, or cultural practice that physically harms and reduces the genetic viability of a specific population of people. For example. I don't think the monolithic intent of the Trail of Tears was genocide (we will ignore the smallpox blanket shaped elephant for the sake of this argument), but we can't argue that was the effect. An exercise in relocation turned into a decimation. Same with California's foray into eugenics:

Quote
As an early leading force in the field of eugenics, California became the third state in the United States to enact a sterilization law. By 1921, California had accounted for 80% of the sterilizations nationwide. This continued until World War II, after which the number of sterilizations began to decrease, largely due to the fallout of Hitler's eugenics movement.[1] There were about 20,000 forced sterilizations in California between 1909 and 1963.[2]

If that's not genocide, I have plenty of other colorful words for it. Eradication. Extermination. Genetic repression. Dire harm with malicious intent.

But you did make my day with that cuck Wink And you still get those cookies.

Mome and Iranus can have a cookie as well, and can sit with us (I invited Mome to sit with us a while back, but I have never interacted directly with you Iranus. I do follow your posts though Smiley )
legendary
Activity: 1078
Merit: 1014
June 29, 2017, 08:33:09 PM
#22
bad for america because it saddled that country with the burden of taking care of millions of blacks up until the present day, bad for the blacks who were forced to live in a country where they were never wanted and to which they will never fully belong, the slavery experience itself wasn't so terrible for most of them but thats not the point
hero member
Activity: 1792
Merit: 534
Leading Crypto Sports Betting & Casino Platform
June 29, 2017, 04:18:02 PM
#21
Quote from: GreenBits
Your potential for growth is limited, it kind of makes you just want to give up. People assume they know your character because of how you look, it's frustrating to say 'Hello Ma'am' to an older white lady in Walmart, and have her glare at you.
I'm white, and it's hilarious to see some white people assume that they know whether black people experience racism.  The only group you can ask about if black people experience racism is black people, and if a large amount of them say yes then they do.  That's just basic logic.

I thought Greenbits was black. I believe I heard him mention somewhere that he's from Africa. Starts with M, I think it's Mozambique.
That was intended to be support for his views, because of all the people trying to discredit what he says about the existence of racism.  I can see how it might have been confusing now.
If you think of it now, yes, blacks in the US definitely have it better than those in say, Sudan or Sierra Leone. But that is only a fluke. What would have happened if slavery was never abolished? Many European countries has already started abolishing it at the time, but what would have happened if the US lagged, like how some countries in Africa (the irony) still practice it now?
Estimates largely suggest that India has the largest amount of slaves in the present day.  See Wikipedia's article on contemporary slavery.

Unfortunately capitalist societies result in slavery, because multinational corporations try to find the cheapest labour possible to produce a product with a competitive price, which often involves moving to the third world in order to subvert Western workers' rights and unions.
hero member
Activity: 1764
Merit: 584
June 29, 2017, 03:42:38 PM
#20
If you think of it now, yes, blacks in the US definitely have it better than those in say, Sudan or Sierra Leone. But that is only a fluke. What would have happened if slavery was never abolished? Many European countries has already started abolishing it at the time, but what would have happened if the US lagged, like how some countries in Africa (the irony) still practice it now?

Also, the intent. They were never intended to be equals. They were chattel. Some people even point out that they were selected for traits. There is a theory on why African-Americans have a high rate of hypertension compared to blacks in Africa. It involves artificial selection. There were illustrations that seem to support it, images of slave traders licking the sweat off slaves in the market. Apparently they were tasting for salt. Those that retain water better during long voyages are less likely to die of dehydration, meaning the trader don't lose money.

Of course the reasoning was backward since those with saltier sweat are those that don't retain salt well but then again that was before modern science. The fact remains that they tried to select for a trait that they believed would maximize profit.

Quote from: GreenBits
Your potential for growth is limited, it kind of makes you just want to give up. People assume they know your character because of how you look, it's frustrating to say 'Hello Ma'am' to an older white lady in Walmart, and have her glare at you.
I'm white, and it's hilarious to see some white people assume that they know whether black people experience racism.  The only group you can ask about if black people experience racism is black people, and if a large amount of them say yes then they do.  That's just basic logic.

I thought Greenbits was black. I believe I heard him mention somewhere that he's from Africa. Starts with M, I think it's Mozambique.
hero member
Activity: 1792
Merit: 534
Leading Crypto Sports Betting & Casino Platform
June 29, 2017, 02:59:56 PM
#19
Was slavery in the US that bad? By having slaves and abolishing slavery later on, yes it was cruel and wrong BUT with slavery they've saved the many generations of africans from potentially dying from a disease, war,etc... and gave the new generations of slaves to live a normal and a lot more happy life in the US later on. So was slavery actually that bad?
The real comparison is slavery vs equality.

At the time, a lot of people who were freed from slavery actually found that their lives were extremely shit afterwards.  Black people, for an extremely long time in the US, found that they were born into families with little money and that earning it was difficult because of discrimination from citizens and employers.

The reason that I view the comparison as being between slavery and equality is because the abolition of slavery (legally), was just one tiny step towards equality.  While it may not have been that good for the slaves in the short term, the political effects of that decision have been felt ever since it happened.

Quote from: GreenBits
Your potential for growth is limited, it kind of makes you just want to give up. People assume they know your character because of how you look, it's frustrating to say 'Hello Ma'am' to an older white lady in Walmart, and have her glare at you.
I'm white, and it's hilarious to see some white people assume that they know whether black people experience racism.  The only group you can ask about if black people experience racism is black people, and if a large amount of them say yes then they do.  That's just basic logic.
hero member
Activity: 621
Merit: 500
June 29, 2017, 01:17:19 PM
#18
I don't mean any offence or to offend anybody at all, it's simply a question.

Was slavery in the US that bad? By having slaves and abolishing slavery later on, yes it was cruel and wrong BUT with slavery they've saved the many generations of africans from potentially dying from a disease, war,etc... and gave the new generations of slaves to live a normal and a lot more happy life in the US later on. So was slavery actually that bad?

I hope that you've understood the question I wanted to ask, really sleepy right now but wanted to hear your opinion on this one.


Hahaha, the Allmighty God rules supremely. We are all of us, all colors ...His slaves. At any moment, anywhere, and without notice the Supreme Ruling God can strike with pestilence, war, disease and calamity. Potentially, He can do this to any people group He wishes, or if He is going totally crazy, to all of humanity, all at once. Let's heed and pray, for redemption and salvation, and, if for nothing else, preservation.


To date, theft issues have long been closed, but the black skinned people still continue to be very strongly oppressed and they are not considered equal citizens of the country. Why is this tendency observed so far? I do not understand.
sr. member
Activity: 441
Merit: 278
It's personal
June 29, 2017, 12:45:05 PM
#17
I don't mean any offence or to offend anybody at all, it's simply a question.

Was slavery in the US that bad? By having slaves and abolishing slavery later on, yes it was cruel and wrong BUT with slavery they've saved the many generations of africans from potentially dying from a disease, war,etc... and gave the new generations of slaves to live a normal and a lot more happy life in the US later on. So was slavery actually that bad?

I hope that you've understood the question I wanted to ask, really sleepy right now but wanted to hear your opinion on this one.


Hahaha, the Allmighty God rules supremely. We are all of us, all colors ...His slaves. At any moment, anywhere, and without notice the Supreme Ruling God can strike with pestilence, war, disease and calamity. Potentially, He can do this to any people group He wishes, or if He is going totally crazy, to all of humanity, all at once. Let's heed and pray, for redemption and salvation, and, if for nothing else, preservation.

sr. member
Activity: 630
Merit: 272
June 29, 2017, 10:59:42 AM
#16
I don't mean any offence or to offend anybody at all, it's simply a question.

Was slavery in the US that bad? By having slaves and abolishing slavery later on, yes it was cruel and wrong BUT with slavery they've saved the many generations of africans from potentially dying from a disease, war,etc... and gave the new generations of slaves to live a normal and a lot more happy life in the US later on. So was slavery actually that bad?

I hope that you've understood the question I wanted to ask, really sleepy right now but wanted to hear your opinion on this one.
I have a feeling you are white because if you are not, there is no reason to justify what you have just said that despite the good life as you have rightly noted,  every black citizen in the US going back one or two generations cannot but identity with the fact that they are there as a result of slavery and nothing else and they will not go away even till the present day because how do judge the various racial incidents still happening in all facets of Americans lives from Hollywood to Military among other sections.
In fact, the problems between white and black reversible. There are neighborhoods densely populated by blacks and there have problems white. Racial intolerance has nothing to do with slavery. It seems to me that slavery is only when a man against his will exploit, and I'm in the US not seen.
legendary
Activity: 1148
Merit: 1048
June 29, 2017, 10:55:21 AM
#15
Greenbits,

the fact, that you are race obssessed cuck, doesnt mean, that all of us on Bitcointalk forum are also.

Your little racist brain wouldnt even consider majority of our global community "white" enough to bother with arguing.

The fact is, that African Americans owe their very existence to the past, that along time ago, african slave traders made a deal with greedy Anglo-Saxon and Jewish bussinessmen. An evil pact for sure, but one, that paved way for formation and accomplishments of one of those most prominent groups of United States of America. African-american people. Now, 40 million strong.

They did it all even without you patronizing them. And speaking about them as "third seaters". You are not helping them, just making yourself looking like a commie homo. On bitcointalk forum, place for profit and learning.

"colored people breeding scares the dog shit out of y'all"

Then go watch interracial porn for Gods sake! Your mental disease with cocks of one particular color is of no public interest.

Yezzir Wink

I have officially been called a cuck. I'm seriously about to go take a shot, you just made my day good sir.

Fuck it, you get a baker's dozen of fucking cookies Smiley I just gots to quote this my man, this is truly a badge of honor. I'm not trolling you, me and the Miss think the fact that cuck is a mainstream insult now, especially given the origins of the contemporary usage, is fucking hilarious. We call each other cuck like an inside joke; to be fair, it was after y'all adopted it, it was parody at first but we fond it so amusing we still do it out of habit. I haven't shown her this post yet, but bruv, we are going to laugh about this shit for a minute. Everyone that not familiar with cuck, please go look this shit up on Google. Specifically, search alt right + cuck + origins. Mad interesting Smiley

I agree with everything you say. I'm a race obsessed cuck that considers everyone colored. And African Americans benefited immensely from slavery. You can tell now, it's obvious. Oh, and I like dick too, and Communism. Greenbits: lover of socialism, race baiting, and dick. I like what you did there Cool

When I look at porn, I'm pretty much oblivious to the fact that there is a guy there, let alone his race, so interracial porn is like any other straight porn. I've never like, specifically searched interracial porn , but I will concede I haven't seen a race of females that I don't find attractive, I can't exclude any off the top. A bad bitch is a bad bitch, I don't care what color they are dipped in myself. As long as they are thick..

Oh wait, I'm a huge fag, I forgot. Cock and dick and such Smiley

I'm smiling and nodding profusely.

Please go on, we are all watching Wink I want to hear you defend slavery more, this is actually interesting now.

switching over to the ADEX campaign. Going to take a break from the Politics section for a while, dont want to say anything too controversial Cheesy I'll be back.
hero member
Activity: 1330
Merit: 569
June 29, 2017, 10:50:26 AM
#14
I don't mean any offence or to offend anybody at all, it's simply a question.

Was slavery in the US that bad? By having slaves and abolishing slavery later on, yes it was cruel and wrong BUT with slavery they've saved the many generations of africans from potentially dying from a disease, war,etc... and gave the new generations of slaves to live a normal and a lot more happy life in the US later on. So was slavery actually that bad?

I hope that you've understood the question I wanted to ask, really sleepy right now but wanted to hear your opinion on this one.
I have a feeling you are white because if you are not, there is no reason to justify what you have just said that despite the good life as you have rightly noted,  every black citizen in the US going back one or two generations cannot but identity with the fact that they are there as a result of slavery and nothing else and they will not go away even till the present day because how do judge the various racial incidents still happening in all facets of Americans lives from Hollywood to Military among other sections.
hero member
Activity: 574
Merit: 506
June 29, 2017, 08:47:10 AM
#13
Greenbits,

the fact, that you are race obssessed cuck, doesnt mean, that all of us on Bitcointalk forum are also.

Your little racist brain wouldnt even consider majority of our global community "white" enough to bother with arguing.

The fact is, that African Americans owe their very existence to the past, that along time ago, african slave traders made a deal with greedy Anglo-Saxon and Jewish bussinessmen. An evil pact for sure, but one, that paved way for formation and accomplishments of one of those most prominent groups of United States of America. African-american people. Now, 40 million strong.

They did it all even without you patronizing them. And speaking about them as "third seaters". You are not helping them, just making yourself looking like a commie homo. On bitcointalk forum, place for profit and learning.

"colored people breeding scares the dog shit out of y'all"

Then go watch interracial porn for Gods sake! Your mental disease with cocks of one particular color is of no public interest.
legendary
Activity: 1148
Merit: 1048
June 29, 2017, 08:21:31 AM
#12
I don't mean any offence or to offend anybody at all, it's simply a question.

Was slavery in the US that bad? By having slaves and abolishing slavery later on, yes it was cruel and wrong BUT with slavery they've saved the many generations of africans from potentially dying from a disease, war,etc... and gave the new generations of slaves to live a normal and a lot more happy life in the US later on. So was slavery actually that bad?

I hope that you've understood the question I wanted to ask, really sleepy right now but wanted to hear your opinion on this one.

I'll bite Wink I love these, and no offense taken. Also, in before the racist crew comes out to play Wink

Life in America isn't normal or happy for some black people. It's hard to explain, and I'll sound butthurt, but suffice it to say this is not the American dream. Your potential for growth is limited, it kind of makes you just want to give up. People assume they know your character because of how you look, it's frustrating to say 'Hello Ma'am' to an older white lady in Walmart, and have her glare at you. And then repeat yourself politely, because surely she didnt hear me, she reacted wrong, and have the lady pfft and glare and leave. I hate it that my skin bothers people so much sometimes they want to harm me.

Slavery was no gift. The horrors of slavery engendered social policy that persists to this day. We aren't in chains, but a prison does not always require bars.

So no, I don't think systematic torture, rape and genocide is justified by a third place seat in modern America. Also, from a numbers perspective, the breeding potential that was usurped to create more slaves would have more than made up for those lost to misadventure/calamity.

Would you be a slave?



Genocide? Do you even know meaning of that word?

The 'Age of Totalitarianism' included nearly all of the infamous examples of genocide in modern history, headed by the Jewish Holocaust, but also comprising the mass murders and purges of the Communist world, other mass killings carried out by Nazi Germany and its allies, and also the Armenian genocide of 1915. All these slaughters, it is argued here, had a common origin, the collapse of the elite structure and normal modes of government of much of central, eastern and southern Europe as a result of the First World War, without which surely neither Communism nor Fascism would have existed except in the minds of unknown agitators and crackpots.
— William Rubinstein, Genocide: a history

You should educate yourself more before throwing arund such a strong terms. There is over 40 million african american people today, despite the fact, that at the time, when transatlantic slave trade with west african warlords ended, there were around one million.

African Americans persisted quite well until 1960´, when liberalization and secularization destroyed notion of black family. They need you white knights stop patronizing them, not throwing "genocides" around.



Yeah, OK Wink what ever you say bro. Not fielding this silly shit Wink don't have the energy this morning. Too bad you don't like my term.

Its genocide. Sorry don't agree, honestly, no fucks given.

And colored people breeding scares the dog shit out of y'all Sad
legendary
Activity: 2590
Merit: 3014
Welt Am Draht
June 29, 2017, 07:18:41 AM
#11
I would vastly prefer to take my own chances and die free.

One of my great great great whatevers owned an army of slaves in the West Indies.

My dad showed me a letter from him written when slavery was abolished. He was bloody delighted. He no longer had to feed, house, educate or medicate them. All he had to do was pay them.


In fact, the concept of slavery is relative. A lot of people are now considered to be free, but live as slaves, sometimes even worse than they are. How can you call life in third countries of people with a salary of 100 dollars a month? And that's not the worst option.

I'd say there was a rather big difference between being imprisoned by necessity and circumstances and being owned by another human being. Things can change in your favour.
hero member
Activity: 574
Merit: 506
June 29, 2017, 04:54:42 AM
#10
I don't mean any offence or to offend anybody at all, it's simply a question.

Was slavery in the US that bad? By having slaves and abolishing slavery later on, yes it was cruel and wrong BUT with slavery they've saved the many generations of africans from potentially dying from a disease, war,etc... and gave the new generations of slaves to live a normal and a lot more happy life in the US later on. So was slavery actually that bad?

I hope that you've understood the question I wanted to ask, really sleepy right now but wanted to hear your opinion on this one.

I'll bite Wink I love these, and no offense taken. Also, in before the racist crew comes out to play Wink

Life in America isn't normal or happy for some black people. It's hard to explain, and I'll sound butthurt, but suffice it to say this is not the American dream. Your potential for growth is limited, it kind of makes you just want to give up. People assume they know your character because of how you look, it's frustrating to say 'Hello Ma'am' to an older white lady in Walmart, and have her glare at you. And then repeat yourself politely, because surely she didnt hear me, she reacted wrong, and have the lady pfft and glare and leave. I hate it that my skin bothers people so much sometimes they want to harm me.

Slavery was no gift. The horrors of slavery engendered social policy that persists to this day. We aren't in chains, but a prison does not always require bars.

So no, I don't think systematic torture, rape and genocide is justified by a third place seat in modern America. Also, from a numbers perspective, the breeding potential that was usurped to create more slaves would have more than made up for those lost to misadventure/calamity.

Would you be a slave?



Genocide? Do you even know meaning of that word?

The 'Age of Totalitarianism' included nearly all of the infamous examples of genocide in modern history, headed by the Jewish Holocaust, but also comprising the mass murders and purges of the Communist world, other mass killings carried out by Nazi Germany and its allies, and also the Armenian genocide of 1915. All these slaughters, it is argued here, had a common origin, the collapse of the elite structure and normal modes of government of much of central, eastern and southern Europe as a result of the First World War, without which surely neither Communism nor Fascism would have existed except in the minds of unknown agitators and crackpots.
— William Rubinstein, Genocide: a history

You should educate yourself more before throwing arund such a strong terms. There is over 40 million african american people today, despite the fact, that at the time, when transatlantic slave trade with west african warlords ended, there were around one million.

African Americans persisted quite well until 1960´, when liberalization and secularization destroyed notion of black family. They need you white knights stop patronizing them, not throwing "genocides" around.

sr. member
Activity: 658
Merit: 254
For campaign management, please pm me.
June 29, 2017, 03:50:40 AM
#9
If being a slave is a help. Then helping is not an act of kindness.
They are humans with the same right as everyone. It would save them just to be fitted on another misery. Don't they have a choice of having a free life?  (Just opinion.)

This is a really nice topic. Smiley
Pages:
Jump to: