Predicting Flash crashes (solution found?)

sherbyspark

hero member

Activity: 910

Merit: 1000

Quote from: Mikcik on October 25, 2014, 11:05:46 AM

Hello i just want to share an idea and hear feedback, i must have been said here before but neverthless:

Is looking on blockchain (or similiar sites) and monitoring incoming huge ammounts of BTC to the accounts of major exchanges (bitstamp, bitfinex, those chinesse ones etc.) a good way for predicting a flat crash...? I got a "hint" that some of the more experienced users might do so... As far as i know, major exchanges have only limited and probably by this time well known bitcoin adresses, so if someone monitors them on blockchain and seesa huge ammount of incoming BTC to these adress (thousand of btc for example), that might be quite a good indication that the exchange is heading for a major flash crash...

Is this basic idea a good way for predicting flash crashes of BTC price?

It might mean something, but the person might just be transferring funds.
An if he doesn't sell, you could just be standing there with all coins sold, without anything happening to the price.

darkmind

full member

Activity: 182

Merit: 100

If it comes in a flash crash, that be better than slow death. Plus we spring back with flash. Maybe skyrocket!

BootstrapCoinDev

full member

Activity: 154

Merit: 100

Quote from: ThomasCrowne on October 31, 2014, 01:56:41 AM

Quote from: bounst on October 31, 2014, 12:19:40 AM

why the price inarease $15 yesterday?

I guess Moolah got spooked trying to cash out all that coinage.

Lol .. Mainstream media won't give a damn. Moolah hogs 5000+ btc and probably should now be dumping, its weird to see growth in price. Bitcoin Trader and Moolah went down at the same time so Bitcoin Trader should dump their stake too.

ThomasCrowne

full member

Activity: 210

Merit: 100

★☆★ 777Coin - The Exciting Bitco

Quote from: bounst on October 31, 2014, 12:19:40 AM

why the price inarease $15 yesterday?

I guess Moolah got spooked trying to cash out all that coinage.

Or perhaps the con-man behind Bitcoin-trader.biz finally ran out of his Ponzi scheme coins. Maybe Fat ass Karpeles fell down and broke his crown and can't sell bitcoins no mo!

*Hopefully all of the above

bounst

full member

Activity: 228

Merit: 100

why the price inarease $15 yesterday?

Mieehayii

hero member

Activity: 490

Merit: 500

No one can predict that FlashCrashes were always coming inadvertently

fewcoins

full member

Activity: 126

Merit: 100

Quote from: cbeast on October 25, 2014, 11:33:19 AM

Bitcoin price has nothing to do with the blockchain. All market trading is done with imaginary tallies in a trading program. No bitcoins are actually traded from markets. They are only deposited and withdrawn depending on how well you play their trading computer game.

+1

Mikcik

sr. member

Activity: 742

Merit: 250

Quote from: inca on October 27, 2014, 02:25:41 PM

Quote from: Mikcik on October 27, 2014, 02:16:21 PM

Im not sure if i understand it correctly...

The only way to get BTC to an exchange to "sell" them is via sending them from some (my personal for example) wallet, and this transaction is always visible on blockchain...

Or am i wrong, thats the only way to get BTC to exchange?

One route to sell coins is to send them with a blockchain transaction to the exchange over the bitcoin network. But you can wire fiat currency to the exchanges. For example you could wire 10 million dollars to bitfinex if you were stupid enough. You might then loan btc from someone in a swap and sell them on the exchange - you might manipulate the price downwards significantly. You could then close your short contracts for profit. You then take your money out of the exchange. End result the price moved, but no bitcoins moved on the blockchain.

Thanks, this is usefull and straightforward, didnt know about this possibility on bitfinex (that you can "swap fiat for BTC" "outside" the normal market on exchange, interesting).

Why didnt anybody tried it already on bitfinex? it seems as a nice way to make money, and it should work... didanybody tried it already, are there any rumours surrounding this

yayayo

legendary

Activity: 1806

Merit: 1024

Doing reliable predictions in any market is very difficult. Especially short time fluctuations are almost impossible to predict with certainty.

Staying away from short term trading is a good advice for almost anyone. Because the probability to loose is huge. Most traders tend to overestimate their abilities with disastrous consequences.

Better buy based on fundamentals and hold longer term. It's much less stress and more rewarding.

ya.ya.yo!

jook

newbie

Activity: 47

Merit: 0

Quote from: Mikcik on October 25, 2014, 04:53:09 PM

[...] People do with high accuracy know what adresses (wallets) belong to the exchanges. Im not sure on the last one, but i think it is true, big exchanges have only few adresses/wallets (they do not create a special wallet for each customer), and these are known, or am i mistaken?

Virtually all exchanges handle it this way: For each deposit a fresh address is or can be generated by the user. There has to be at least one user-specific bitcoin address, otherwise the deposit couldn't be assigned to the user's account.

You can identify the cold and hot wallets of an exchange and monitor the transactions going there. But these are not the addresses users deposit their bitcoins to directly. So you'd need to discover if your target exchange forwards the deposited bitcoins to its own wallets instantly (or at least very quickly).

Provided that you are able to identify the forwarding transaction to the exchange wallet before the deposit is credited to the user's account, you could possibly utilize that knowledge. But you would be making a lot of assumptions there: The deposit is made to dump the coins (not a swap), the exchange's deposit forwarding works in a predictable way, it's an actual deposit (not an internal transfer between wallets), etc.

As already pointed out, it is not a perfect science. Not at all.

inca

legendary

Activity: 1176

Merit: 1000

Quote from: Mikcik on October 27, 2014, 02:16:21 PM

Im not sure if i understand it correctly...

The only way to get BTC to an exchange to "sell" them is via sending them from some (my personal for example) wallet, and this transaction is always visible on blockchain...

Or am i wrong, thats the only way to get BTC to exchange?

One route to sell coins is to send them with a blockchain transaction to the exchange over the bitcoin network. But you can wire fiat currency to the exchanges. For example you could wire 10 million dollars to bitfinex if you were stupid enough. You might then loan btc from someone in a swap and sell them on the exchange - you might manipulate the price downwards significantly. You could then close your short contracts for profit. You then take your money out of the exchange. End result the price moved, but no bitcoins moved on the blockchain.

Mikcik

sr. member

Activity: 742

Merit: 250

Im not sure if i understand it correctly...

The only way to get BTC to an exchange to "sell" them is via sending them from some (my personal for example) wallet, and this transaction is always visible on blockchain...

Or am i wrong, thats the only way to get BTC to exchange?

inca

legendary

Activity: 1176

Merit: 1000

Quote from: cbeast on October 26, 2014, 12:58:30 PM

Quote from: inca on October 26, 2014, 12:07:50 PM

You are right and wrong. Blockchain analysis could be helpful but someone with lots of coins/fiat on exchange could massively move the price and because it is 'off chain' not leave a blockchain imprint.

If bitcoin days destroyed rockets upwards, if there are documented cases of huge numbers of coins moving to or from an exchange then perhaps something is afoot and you could predict a major market move. But it is not a perfect science.

Markets don't use the blockchain. Watching bitcoin days destroyed or large transactions has no corellation to markets. You can only corellate them after the fact, but nobody has ever researched this to conclude any probability of that phenomenon. It's right up there with "The Weekend Dip." It's just magical thinking. You can massively move the market without ever even having a Bitcoin wallet and I suspect that's a lot of what is going on.

I think we actually are in agreement cbeast.

cbeast

donator

Activity: 1736

Merit: 1014

Let's talk governance, lipstick, and pigs.

Quote from: inca on October 26, 2014, 12:07:50 PM

You are right and wrong. Blockchain analysis could be helpful but someone with lots of coins/fiat on exchange could massively move the price and because it is 'off chain' not leave a blockchain imprint.

If bitcoin days destroyed rockets upwards, if there are documented cases of huge numbers of coins moving to or from an exchange then perhaps something is afoot and you could predict a major market move. But it is not a perfect science.

Markets don't use the blockchain. Watching bitcoin days destroyed or large transactions has no corellation to markets. You can only corellate them after the fact, but nobody has ever researched this to conclude any probability of that phenomenon. It's right up there with "The Weekend Dip." It's just magical thinking. You can massively move the market without ever even having a Bitcoin wallet and I suspect that's a lot of what is going on.

inca

legendary

Activity: 1176

Merit: 1000

You are right and wrong. Blockchain analysis could be helpful but someone with lots of coins/fiat on exchange could massively move the price and because it is 'off chain' not leave a blockchain imprint.

If bitcoin days destroyed rockets upwards, if there are documented cases of huge numbers of coins moving to or from an exchange then perhaps something is afoot and you could predict a major market move. But it is not a perfect science.

Mikcik

sr. member

Activity: 742

Merit: 250

Does "my" approach apply or not?

Mikcik

sr. member

Activity: 742

Merit: 250

Quote from: zoinky on October 25, 2014, 04:14:02 PM

Quote from: Mikcik on October 25, 2014, 03:13:46 PM

Quote from: cbeast on October 25, 2014, 11:33:19 AM

Bitcoin price has nothing to do with the blockchain. All market trading is done with imaginary tallies in a trading program. No bitcoins are actually traded from markets. They are only deposited and withdrawn depending on how well you play their trading computer game.

Useless post, talking about absolutelly other topic...

If you have a lot of BTC you can move the market
If you have a lot of BTC you wont keep them on Bitstamp wallets, you will move them to your own personal wallets/adressses whatever
If you want to sell a lot of BTC via "normal markets" you have to move them to their wallets (Bitstamps e.g.)
All moves are publicly visible on blockchain
People know, or are pretty sure which wallets belong to the biggest exchanges

What is that you do not understand in this simple case sherlock... :-( ?

Could someone verify what i said?

You are assuming a market maker isn't already established on the exchange and has to move coins. Thats an assumption. Blockchain transactions could be anything, you are just wildly speculating that its moving to an exchange with the intent to sell.

Sure its possible, and I've seen people speculate on transactions before dips in the past, especially on this chart https://blockchain.info/charts/bitcoin-days-destroyed, but there is no direct correlation.

I do not understand, my assumptions:

If you have a lot of coin (big investors), you are not stupid and you do not keep it on exchange accounts, but your own. Thus when you want to sell some of these (for whatever reason), you have to move them to the exchange (to exchange wallets), all transactions are visible on blockchains. People do with high accuracy know what adresses (wallets) belong to the exchanges. Im not sure on the last one, but i think it is true, big exchanges have only few adresses/wallets (they do not create a special wallet for each customer), and these are known, or am i mistaken?

So is it this was or not, im not sure if i do express my questions so stupidly (english is not my native language), or are the people here stupid :-)?

zoinky

hero member

Activity: 811

Merit: 1000

Web Developer

Quote from: Mikcik on October 25, 2014, 03:13:46 PM

Quote from: cbeast on October 25, 2014, 11:33:19 AM

Bitcoin price has nothing to do with the blockchain. All market trading is done with imaginary tallies in a trading program. No bitcoins are actually traded from markets. They are only deposited and withdrawn depending on how well you play their trading computer game.

Useless post, talking about absolutelly other topic...

If you have a lot of BTC you can move the market
If you have a lot of BTC you wont keep them on Bitstamp wallets, you will move them to your own personal wallets/adressses whatever
If you want to sell a lot of BTC via "normal markets" you have to move them to their wallets (Bitstamps e.g.)
All moves are publicly visible on blockchain
People know, or are pretty sure which wallets belong to the biggest exchanges

What is that you do not understand in this simple case sherlock... :-( ?

Could someone verify what i said?

You are assuming a market maker isn't already established on the exchange and has to move coins. Thats an assumption. Blockchain transactions could be anything, you are just wildly speculating that its moving to an exchange with the intent to sell.

Sure its possible, and I've seen people speculate on transactions before dips in the past, especially on this chart https://blockchain.info/charts/bitcoin-days-destroyed, but there is no direct correlation.

Mikcik

sr. member

Activity: 742

Merit: 250

Quote from: sbrzol on October 25, 2014, 01:56:34 PM

I am interested in bitstamp "addresses", so if anybody knows where to find which addresses should i monitor, share it , thx Wink

I do not remember them but i know they are floating around the net somewhere, but as i said, and would love to get that verrified, its useless since people found out about this possibility and try to manipulate/take an advantage of this.

They move a lot of btc to exchange, little more informed but naive people see that, expect a sale-off, sell their BTC, other poeple see it, sell theirs, the price gets lower, the original "manipulator" buys another BTCs and sends those "BIG BTC ammounts" back to his adress.

At least that is how i interpret the things that have been said. Can someone verify it???

Mikcik

sr. member

Activity: 742

Merit: 250

Quote from: cbeast on October 25, 2014, 11:33:19 AM

Bitcoin price has nothing to do with the blockchain. All market trading is done with imaginary tallies in a trading program. No bitcoins are actually traded from markets. They are only deposited and withdrawn depending on how well you play their trading computer game.

Useless post, talking about absolutelly other topic...

If you have a lot of BTC you can move the market
If you have a lot of BTC you wont keep them on Bitstamp wallets, you will move them to your own personal wallets/adressses whatever
If you want to sell a lot of BTC via "normal markets" you have to move them to their wallets (Bitstamps e.g.)
All moves are publicly visible on blockchain
People know, or are pretty sure which wallets belong to the biggest exchanges

What is that you do not understand in this simple case sherlock... :-( ?

Could someone verify what i said?

Topic: Predicting Flash crashes (solution found?) (Read 3086 times)