I spoke quite a bit with the Ripple team at the San Jose conference. The core guys are bigtime Bitcoin guys and geniuses. In my opinion nothing about Ripple is intended to work against Bitcoin. Ripple's features are complimentary to Bitcoin and have the potential to significantly boost functionality and adoption. Since they're giving away XRP for free, I have no clue how anyone can argue it's a scam.
I learned that ~1.2% of all XRP have already been given away. I think this shows that OpenCoin is making good on the promise to distribute XRP fairly over time. It's VERY early. A big goal of the distribution of XRP is to ensure the price of XRP keeps moving up throughout the process. It's an ingenious strategy which I'm assuming will require a nimble implementation.
I got a demo of the
Federation Protocol in action in a way I hadn't seen, and was offered a copy of the Ripple source code. Also, Jed Mccaleb (CTO/Ripple creator) told me that if he had it his way he would release the source immediately.
You don't need to hold more than ~$1 worth of XRP in order to use Ripple (to cover network fees). You can then pop in and out of the system in any currency you prefer.
Chris Larsen (CEO) spoke on the Alt-Chain panel and nobody attacked him or asked him tough questions about Ripple being a scam. It became clear during that panel that there's a need for more decentralized payment processing layers in the eco-system than Bitcoin alone, and that Ripple will be playing a valuable role.
I came to ripple open minded and thought its good idea until i started reading about ripples (XRP). Its nonsense. They premined it and said they will be handing it for free. So i was looking where i can get some. And guess what. I cant get it. Others advised me to buy it. Why i have to buy it when i was supposed to get it for free?
But its not all. You say that its enough to have $1 worth of XRP to cover transaction fees. But how many XRP should it be if its value is 0? They have the same problem as bitcoin. In order to transfer value you have to use item that already have some value. But if XRP is handed for free then it has no value at all. Then its impossible to transfer anything valuable because you will always end with 0 if you multiply anything by 0.
And here we come injustice. How are you going to give people XRP for free so everybody will get equal value to be fair for all? You cant do this. Then its not surprising that people are calling it a scam. Maybe its not a scam but something is really wrong with ripples and i am not going to use it in shape it is now. And i am not going to pay even $0.01 to buy ripples ever.