Topic: Satoshi Speaks. Real? Hoax? - page 4. (Read 4879 times)

yes, no doubt he would sign his message.

i read nearly all of his writings and

THIS IS FAKE!

obviously this is a big FAKE, Mr. sn will never send us a message without sign it, he already know how things are going on in this forum...

so i finally doubt that this  is real, btw what call my attention is the big numbers of ppl that beleive on it...

it seems that this email was not fake and maybe is real from Satoshi

Technical analysis of the Satoshi Nakamoto email #bitcoin

http://pastebin.com/Ct5M8fa2

i personally will never consider these things as the real deal unless i see a signed message from satoshi's known keys.
the email can easily be fake / hacked / or even an spoofed email.

exactly 


HOAX!

His account in p2pfoundation.ning.com has been hacked before, in 2014:

http://p2pfoundation.ning.com/forum/topic/listForContributor?user=0ye0gncqg772o

"Reply by Satoshi Nakamoto on September 8, 2014 at 23:10
Dear Satoshi. Your dox, passwords and IP addresses are being sold on the darknet. Apparently you didn't configure Tor properly and your IP leaked when you used your email account sometime in 2010. You are not safe. You need to get out of where you are as soon as possible before these people harm you. Thank you for inventing Bitcoin."

The same could have happened to his email account. If he wants us to be sure this is him, he should sign the message.

Why would any experienced member believe this to be real? It's obvious Satoshi never post anything without a signed message after many years.

Interesting to say the least, but I think it's fake for sure since the writing differs a bit too much from his earlier real posts.

It's false, if you have read Satoshi's authentic posts on this thread then you'll see this:-  
He did in fact foresee pools and how there would be an arms race for mining that could spin way beyond what an individual could afford. Also you'll note the lack of a signature, and the most glaring problem with this post:-


Whoa...like, just whoa !!!!!!! This is not Satoshi speak. Let's ignore the fact that he left and is never coming back, and let's ignore ALL the posts where he clearly outlined that block size would have to be adjusted and let's pretend that he thinks he ha the power to declare it a failed project.

The first thing would be, satoshi knows consensus is reached by majority, so no matter what he says which ever fork has the most nodes wins.  That would fall in line with the socialist statement, but directly contradicts the "declare failure" statement.

This is a sad attempt , either by the Elements squad or their supporters to sway public opinion by invoking his name as though he's some sort of god.

While i am concerned about the fork, i do also believe that their home grown solution (sidechains) is not an adaquate answer, neither is increasing the blocksize without a follow up plan. A 8 MB block + sidechains sounds more like a technical solution rather than this political nonsense they are all trying to peddle.

satoshi holds the private keys to a lot of bitcoins. Should there be a fork in the future, he can single-handedly devastate whichever side of the fork he doesn't agree with by tainting his coins with coins from a new block from that fork and then dumping them on the market. In a 1-2 punch he can then use the proceeds from that sale to purchase additional coins on the side of the fork he does agree with. In other words, satoshi doesn't have to use his words in this case.

I don't think that this "work" is a "work" of Satoshi Nakamoto. If it would be it were be more and more rumor and discussion by to many important people of the world of bitcoin. I don't want to discuss about the content of email because this is the job of the specialist but I don't think that this simple thing will obligated Satoshi to come out from his anonymity.

Undoubtedly this email is fake. I think Satoshi must not come back again to involve in BTC in any way.

I dont know if is him but it has a nice point to what he say. He cant one ore two developer fork bitcoin just like that.. In the other way this is the power of bitcoin. Someone try to fork it and if everyone follow then this that we have is democracy.

He's an absentee landlord and this situation is of his own making. I find it extremely dubious that he'd choose to chime in and proclaim that he'd have to call it a "failed project" if things didn't go his way. Tell that to the VCs that have poured hundreds of millions of dollars into the ecosystem, so far. Besides that, nobody's going to believe this was really written by Satoshi (whoever he is). Sign the message with one of the addresses that contains part of your million Bitcoin hoard, then I'll buy that it's you...and then, I won't really care what you have to say about it, because you've long since abandoned the project anyway.

yeah, I've read about it. but it doesn't change the fact that people won't be willing to accept anyone that claims to be satoshi without some sort of proof.

TBH he never ever signed anything. Probably on purpose 

The real satoshi would have signed a message, no questions asked. This has to be a fake.

i don't think this is really satoshi. this smells more like some one is trying to trigger panic sellers to sell. it is a failed attempt. people are wise enough to see that this isn't real.

Wow its really crazy I think it can be really him because of the email he used and I hope it was him a lot of time have passed since we heard last time from satoshi I hope he's back

It doesn't even sound like Satoshis earlier posts.. It is just a rant of somebody who is not agreeing with how it is going.. Just ignore it