That is why advanced replacement w/ security deposit (CC, bank wire, bitcoin) is the only viable option. Hopefully if KNC wants to keep playing dumb and pretending it can't be done other comeptitors will see an oppertunity to provide a better service.
As for bar, please don't make yourself look silly providing really weak and easily countered excuses you come up with off the top of your head. There is nothing to "game". A customer could not order and claim to or they could order and claim they never got the product. OH NOES ordering stuff can be gamed I guess KNC will stop selling products. KNC deals with the "risk" of being gamed on orders but can't on RMA.
What is the difference between an order and a RMA? Simple the first one makes you money. There is nothing more complicated about a "company ship first" RMA than a "customer ship first RMA" other than securing a deposit to ensure the customer returns the defective unit.
It's a standard back to base warranty.
What your suggesting is a total ball-ache.
You then need to block trace every payment, which become entirely more convoluted and confusing for customer service.
Keep it simple. Ship it, can you fix it? or is it something more involved? in which case ship a replacement - get it out the door as soon as poss.
If Redacted wants to share his original tracking code, and is happy with us sharing the return code - you'll see for yourself - turn around the same day.