Pages:
Author

Topic: The Antminer S17 Pro: Is it worth buying? (Read 532 times)

newbie
Activity: 24
Merit: 3
October 29, 2019, 12:24:06 PM
#24
Why going for this miner which isn't that friendly in all way round?
When you get tired of it, what are you going to do?
In my own opinion, if energy is cheaper or friendly in your location, you can give GPU a trial as it offers more benefits such as no noise, algorithm switching, can be customized and you can also resale when the need arises.


actually if power is cheap  you should do some gpu and some asic

if power is cheap (or free) it's better to choice S9
10 x S9 = about $2000 = 140Tx 13 kW/h
2 x S17Pro = about $5000 or more = 125Tx 6 kW/h

and we have ~3000 dollars to pay for cheap electricity Wink

Also got to remember that you have huge amps to contend with for the 10x S9 option.
13kW is minimum 55A

And S9 is closer to 1500W per unit than 1300W, driving that amperage up to over 60A which potentially puts you in need of some professional electrician and modifications to existing circuits.

The S17 option you mention, which is more likely to draw around 2200W per unit depending on the model you go for, would leave you needing less than 20A. Even most homes could handle that as an addition to your regular domestic circuit.
copper member
Activity: 407
Merit: 59
Its not the best price per hash, but surely if you have expensive power and are crazy to mine bitcoin then this miner will be your biggest bet.
newbie
Activity: 1
Merit: 0
Why going for this miner which isn't that friendly in all way round?
When you get tired of it, what are you going to do?
In my own opinion, if energy is cheaper or friendly in your location, you can give GPU a trial as it offers more benefits such as no noise, algorithm switching, can be customized and you can also resale when the need arises.


actually if power is cheap  you should do some gpu and some asic

if power is cheap (or free) it's better to choice S9
10 x S9 = about $2000 = 140Tx 13 kW/h
2 x S17Pro = about $5000 or more = 125Tx 6 kW/h

and we have ~3000 dollars to pay for cheap electricity Wink

Where are you finding 10 x S9 for $2000?

I see these: https://eurominers.eu/antminer-s17-53th.html

That's about $2,100 USD ( I guess you have to pay some import costs?).
full member
Activity: 630
Merit: 101
If you are betting on Bitcoin, then I think that now is a good time to buy new asics. I think that these asics will be relevant for at least two years.
full member
Activity: 1400
Merit: 103
next halving is next year... With free electricity it could be but i'd rather buy BTC right now and expect a rise in price rather than mining less and less BTC with the price rising.
Well, in a market like this now it makes sense, but at the end of November 2018 you were also sure that the purchase of the crypto will bring more?
jr. member
Activity: 557
Merit: 5
next halving is next year... With free electricity it could be but i'd rather buy BTC right now and expect a rise in price rather than mining less and less BTC with the price rising.
sr. member
Activity: 980
Merit: 270
Why going for this miner which isn't that friendly in all way round?
When you get tired of it, what are you going to do?
In my own opinion, if energy is cheaper or friendly in your location, you can give GPU a trial as it offers more benefits such as no noise, algorithm switching, can be customized and you can also resale when the need arises.


actually if power is cheap  you should do some gpu and some asic

if power is cheap (or free) it's better to choice S9
10 x S9 = about $2000 = 140Tx 13 kW/h
2 x S17Pro = about $5000 or more = 125Tx 6 kW/h

and we have ~3000 dollars to pay for cheap electricity Wink

It really is better to take a workhorse. The only reason to take s17 and not s9 is the desire to work for long term. If you are planning a year ahead and then review investments depending on the market, it is better to take s9.
full member
Activity: 644
Merit: 145
Why going for this miner which isn't that friendly in all way round?
When you get tired of it, what are you going to do?
In my own opinion, if energy is cheaper or friendly in your location, you can give GPU a trial as it offers more benefits such as no noise, algorithm switching, can be customized and you can also resale when the need arises.


actually if power is cheap  you should do some gpu and some asic

if power is cheap (or free) it's better to choice S9
10 x S9 = about $2000 = 140Tx 13 kW/h
2 x S17Pro = about $5000 or more = 125Tx 6 kW/h

and we have ~3000 dollars to pay for cheap electricity Wink
legendary
Activity: 4256
Merit: 8551
'The right to privacy matters'
Why going for this miner which isn't that friendly in all way round?
When you get tired of it, what are you going to do?
In my own opinion, if energy is cheaper or friendly in your location, you can give GPU a trial as it offers more benefits such as no noise, algorithm switching, can be customized and you can also resale when the need arises.


actually if power is cheap  you should do some gpu and some asic
full member
Activity: 925
Merit: 100
Why going for this miner which isn't that friendly in all way round?
When you get tired of it, what are you going to do?
In my own opinion, if energy is cheaper or friendly in your location, you can give GPU a trial as it offers more benefits such as no noise, algorithm switching, can be customized and you can also resale when the need arises.
jr. member
Activity: 57
Merit: 1
the low energy consumption ratio and advanced performance are the two main advantages of the Antminer 17 series miners. Compared to existing mining rigs, the new Antminer S17 series can greatly improve mining profit, making previous mining rigs less competitive
sr. member
Activity: 980
Merit: 270
There is a stir for this reason the price is too high. I would still be looking for cheaper options at the moment.
This is how to choose between BMW and Toyota. I would take a few used Toyota than one BMW. But there are who would do the opposite.
hero member
Activity: 723
Merit: 501
Sometimes, I see buying those expensive mining hardwares as a form of insurance. Buying bitcoin or some altcoins don't always pay off and sometimes you might even make some huge profits from bitcoin or altcoins but you may endup wasting the money on some bullshit! It happened to me April 2018, God!

for that price tag you can buy a whole bunch of s9 and t9+ on ebay and amazon.   i think there price is to high for what they are offering.
copper member
Activity: 658
Merit: 284
Sometimes, I see buying those expensive mining hardwares as a form of insurance. Buying bitcoin or some altcoins don't always pay off and sometimes you might even make some huge profits from bitcoin or altcoins but you may endup wasting the money on some bullshit! It happened to me April 2018, God!
legendary
Activity: 4256
Merit: 8551
'The right to privacy matters'
Yes and no or as someone else said (mindrust) it depends.

For me no buying these I am subject to the trump tax of 27.6% far worse then vat tax it prices me out of buying the gear.

If I had my setup in Canada  it would be worth it. Tax would be 5%  not 27.6%

My deal is spilt coins with my power/host location.

So 2 s17s = 1 s17 for free 62 th  would earn earn both units in 438 days.

I have 22 s9's at full power
I have  8 m10's
I have  4 s7ln's
I have  2 A721's
I have  1 a921
I have  1 m20
I have  1 t2turbo

this is about 680th  of which 340th is mine at no power cost.

so adding some s17's  and dropping the s9's down to lower hash rates would work if not for the damn trump tax.

There is a big correlation Hash rate peaked in oct 2018  trump tax started late sept 2018.

that 27.6%  killed off USA purchases of gear bigly.
member
Activity: 418
Merit: 21
It will be worthless much faster. Expect a massive pricedrop after a few months. A year later they are even worthless on Ebay, so they will have no resale value. This means Bitcoin have to jump massively in price to earn some money here, which wont really happen that fast.

Buying Asics is a high risk and gambling. Also they are noisy as hell, hold that in mind!

Other problem with ASICs...they just arent any fun at all.  You plug them in, point them at a pool and then....well, that's basically all you do with them other than cleaning them every so often or maybe replacing a fan.  No spontaneous software conflicts to deal with, no optimization tweaking, no algo switching, etc.  Different people mine for different reasons.  Immediate/medium/long term profits, supporting the ecosystem, whatever.  For me it's basically just a great big video game I had to build a massive computer network to play.

I have 20 GPU rigs across three different locations (electricity deals).  One of those rigs rotates to my home office every week so I can do maintenance, tinker with settings, decide what algo it's going to be on, etc.  I know what cards are in each of them, etc.  Hell, I even gave them all names instead of numbers (Autobots = Nvidia, Decepticons = AMD =D) because for some goofy reason it's easier for me to keep track of them in my head.  Rig one means nothing...but Optimus Prime is memorable!

I have two z9 minis.  They just run, I never even look at them.  To be completely honest, off the top of my head I couldn't even tell you where they are.

This is true! Zero fun with Asics, Zero learning with Asics... With GPU's you have something to do every single day.
jr. member
Activity: 36
Merit: 5
It will be worthless much faster. Expect a massive pricedrop after a few months. A year later they are even worthless on Ebay, so they will have no resale value. This means Bitcoin have to jump massively in price to earn some money here, which wont really happen that fast.

Buying Asics is a high risk and gambling. Also they are noisy as hell, hold that in mind!

Other problem with ASICs...they just arent any fun at all.  You plug them in, point them at a pool and then....well, that's basically all you do with them other than cleaning them every so often or maybe replacing a fan.  No spontaneous software conflicts to deal with, no optimization tweaking, no algo switching, etc.  Different people mine for different reasons.  Immediate/medium/long term profits, supporting the ecosystem, whatever.  For me it's basically just a great big video game I had to build a massive computer network to play.

I have 20 GPU rigs across three different locations (electricity deals).  One of those rigs rotates to my home office every week so I can do maintenance, tinker with settings, decide what algo it's going to be on, etc.  I know what cards are in each of them, etc.  Hell, I even gave them all names instead of numbers (Autobots = Nvidia, Decepticons = AMD =D) because for some goofy reason it's easier for me to keep track of them in my head.  Rig one means nothing...but Optimus Prime is memorable!

I have two z9 minis.  They just run, I never even look at them.  To be completely honest, off the top of my head I couldn't even tell you where they are.
hero member
Activity: 1120
Merit: 554
What they are saying is that Asic miners will have very little resale value compared to GPUs. ASICS are made for one thing while GPUS are used by gamers/ miners/ animators.  Buying gpus is a lot less risky because the demand is much higher.
member
Activity: 418
Merit: 21
It will be worthless much faster. Expect a massive pricedrop after a few months. A year later they are even worthless on Ebay, so they will have no resale value. This means Bitcoin have to jump massively in price to earn some money here, which wont really happen that fast.

Buying Asics is a high risk and gambling. Also they are noisy as hell, hold that in mind!

If you want to invest, buy BTC, LTC, ETH instead and enjoy your profit soon.
legendary
Activity: 3276
Merit: 2442
At the end of its lifespan you will end up with a worthless brick.
Lol... A worthless brick? No. I think in a year or two I can make my initial investment back but the problem is the cost of maintenance and the power cost. The time and effort to be put together, I don't know if they're all worth it!

Bitbustah is right. It will be worthless in 2-3 years.

You also gave the best answer to your problem.

When you add up all those problems, it is clearly a better idea to buy bitcoin instead. The only scenario where it is a better idea to buy miners is if you have either free or near free electricity. If you are going to pay the regular rates which is around $0.08-0.012 (depending on where you live), forget about it.

By purchasing those miners you are only helping bitmain to make more money. That's unless you have free electricity of course.
Pages:
Jump to: