Topic: The DEX (Decentralized Exchange) Thread - page 4. (Read 24439 times)

There are well over 100 decentralized exchanges, in operation or as projects. So OP's list is incomplete - but it's understandable due to the sheer quantity of DEX projects. Etherdelta, however, is one of the biggest "intra-chain" exchanges (without cross-chain abilities), so I would support its addition to this list here at Bitcointalk.

Does NEX have cross-chain capabilities?

In my opinion, in the future decentralized exchanges will be superseded by ordinary ones. I like this idea, but I have not seen a single word about the future exchange of NEX, based on the NEO platform.

https://s31.postimg.cc/hxdafhekb/Dex.png

Where is Etherdelta, IDEX, Radar Relay in this list?

Supernet still being developed on top of NXT?  We gathered that the lead dev is dropping NXT due to some API issues in one of the upgrades.  And that the Supernet lead dev was the one responsible for dumping all that NXT to its lows.

And what about IDEX, I dont see IDEX on your list and IDEX is pretty big, there are many ICOs listed here.
In the future hope there will be also MIDEX .

Bancor has opened their first fiat gateway, so you can now but Ethereum with a credit card directly from wallet, and then convert it to any token listed on the platform. I think this is the best decentralized exchange for ERC20 tokens out there, at least for now. Developers are adding lots of features lately, and now this credit card option. All is looking good.

I appreciate this initiative and I see that there were some newer exchanges added in the last months.

However, I would divide it in at least two sections: one-blockchain-exchanges and multi-blockchain-exchanges.

One-blockchain DEX's are quite old, I think the oldest was Ripple in 2013, or maybe Mastercoin (Omni), or even one of the early "coloured coins" implementations. They have gained traction again with the ERC20 boom in 2017 but they continue to be a relatively simple and limited technology. There are now over 50, maybe 100 different one-blockchain exchange protocols (as some like Counterparty were cloned on many platforms) and I consider it impossible to follow the development of them all.

The most interesting technologies for me are multi-blockchain exchanges. They really connect the blockchain world and are the only technology that really could replace altcoin exchanges. So at least I would like to see a separation of both technologies in this thread.

For those that know German, I have created a similar thread in German some months ago here: https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/liste-dezentrale-borsen-und-handels-losungen-updated-22018-1542761

BTW: BarterDEX is missing, it seems at this moment the most advanced multi-blockchain DEX, with a relatively easy-to-use GUI.

I believe that decentralized exchanges will become very popular in future. But not all of the listed above will survive. Most likely, there will be 3-5 large and popular decentralized exchanges. Now it is difficult to guess which of the projects will begin to develop more actively.

You mean The Token Store. It's far better than Forkdelta and IDEX in terms of functionality (the node actually works well) and has a slick and simple UI

Thanks for the recommendations. Those names have come up before up-thread, but I just haven't had time to check them out... hopefully I can soon.

I just added Bancor too. TBH, I am pretty impressed with the simple and straightforward approach of it. It also provides a novel solution to the liquidity problem most DEXs and decentralized/autonomous stablecoins face.

Bancor
- Status: Released
- Website: https://www.bancor.network/
- BCT Thread: https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/ann-bancor-protocol-for-smart-tokens-solving-the-liquidity-problem-1789222
Strengths:
- Working implementation
- Fully autonomous and decentralized
- Allows straightforward and simple (Shapeshift-like) exchanges
- A novel and elegant solution to the liquidity problem most DEXs and decentralized/autonomous stablecoins face
Weaknesses:
- Only compatible with Ethereum and/or ERC-20 tokens

Some have come up. The likes of IDEX, Forkdelta, Token Market are some good ones. I'm particularly impressed by IDEX's UI and hitchfree trading although the minimum withdraw funds are higher than most I've seen in other dexs

0x has been added to the list:

0x Protocol
- Status: Released
- Website: https://0xproject.com/
- Exchange: https://0xproject.com/portal
- Whitepaper: https://0xproject.com/pdfs/0x_white_paper.pdf
Strengths:
- Working implementation
- Fully autonomous and decentralized
- 0x is a DEX "fat protocol" that other projects are building on top of, thus liquidity will be shared among multiple exchanges
Weaknesses:
- Only compatible with Ethereum and/or ERC-20 tokens

I love the concept of decentralized exchanges, this is for sure the future of exchanging cryptos. BarterDex project look to be promising. I also look forward when Binance changes itself to be decentralized - they've got plans to do that.

It's not vapoware! BarterDex has been live on mainnet since november, a small selection of the pairs is listed on CMC too: https://coinmarketcap.com/exchanges/barterdex/

All main Bitcoin-based coins are supported and Eth/Erc20 in next version



That is outdated, this weekend there will be a new Komodo website online

Because there are so many tokens on commercial decentralized sites, so the transaction volume is very large, leading to transaction delays and high transaction costs. If the commercial pages overcome these two things, the success rate is huge.

I haven't added it to the list yet, but it has certainly been discussed in this thread. I have not been able to see or use it yet. I am no longer adding vaporware DEXs to the list since enough DEXs are functional and exist already.


https://www.komodoplatform.com/en/barterdex

^^^ This says I can sign up to be notified when it is released. Ping me when it is so that I can evaluate it.

Unfortunately, yes... this thread is unpopular. Everyone is having a hard time understanding why DEXs are so important. They are beginning to come around though. I have been seeing a lot more chatter around Crypto Twitter about DEXs recently. Sadly I haven't had much time to update this thread though. I will try to do better...


Thanks... I have not heard of either of these DEXs!

Tech inevitably improves upon itself. I mostly agree with you, but you also need to consider that well-funded incumbent (such as already existing DEXs) can and will implement new technology.


I can agree with all of that. They are not optimal, and never will be, but they will be improved upon slowly. We need to still support the DEXs that currently exist even though they are not perfect. Liquidity will not move from centralized to decentralized if there is little/no liquidity on the DEXs.


Never heard of it. I am glad there are so many DEXs I haven't heard of!!

Interesting, thanks for sharing. The Etherdelta phishing attack was certainly unfortunate. At least the Smart Contract itself has been resilient thus far!

I have been using ForkDelta lately which gives you access to the contracts that underpin EtherDelta but with a site that is better maintained.

IDex.market is a user-friendly exchange.

I agree, DEX like BarterDEX are not for every crypto user, if you don't mind kyc regulations and don't mind some risk from hacks and scams from using centralised exchanges then DEX is probably a lot more trouble than it's worth in many ways, slow and requires effort to learn new way of thinking based on things like utxo and atomic swaps. Maybe 80% of small-medium traders will not bother to learn, but DEX niche will still be substantial.


I disagree though, BarterDEX fees are cheaper, and security issues are non existent, you always control your private keys, and there's no central website, so no chance of phishing or dns spoofing.