Pages:
Author

Topic: The Lending Bubble (Read 5114 times)

hero member
Activity: 518
Merit: 500
May 04, 2012, 12:12:51 AM
#53
His defenders are profiting (at least on paper) from the Ponzi.  Who would you trust?





Hmmm, yes, who would I trust?

In my bank account, I have a lot of dollars.  It's not "on paper" as my wife sees it in the bank account.

It might interest you to know that my deposit with pirate, paying out well over 100% now, is not the most lucrative or highest paying investment I have here, and they certainly are not ponzi schemes.
vip
Activity: 574
Merit: 500
Don't send me a pm unless you gpg encrypt it.
May 03, 2012, 11:38:11 PM
#52
As of today, Bitcoin Savings and Trust has now been around 7 months if the Nov 3 post thread date is accurate.  I'd be happy to hear the official start date if I'm wrong on this one.

As for proof that it is a Ponzi scheme, I will openly admit that I am speculating. However unlike Pirate, I'm willing to share my analysis and am not making any money on this.  Pirate refuses to share any meaningful business model and wants to take your money.  His defenders are profiting (at least on paper) from the Ponzi.  Who would you trust?

What's your analysis? that you cannot fathom a business plan that pays 1% a day?  That explains why pirate's starting ventures and you're just trolling the forums.
legendary
Activity: 1867
Merit: 1023
May 03, 2012, 11:35:26 PM
#51
As of today, Bitcoin Savings and Trust has now been around 7 months if the Nov 3 post thread date is accurate.  I'd be happy to hear the official start date if I'm wrong on this one.

As for proof that it is a Ponzi scheme, I will openly admit that I am speculating. However unlike Pirate, I'm willing to share my analysis and am not making any money on this.  Pirate refuses to share any meaningful business model and wants to take your money.  His defenders are profiting (at least on paper) from the Ponzi.  Who would you trust?



hero member
Activity: 518
Merit: 500
May 01, 2012, 07:55:36 PM
#50
If I exclude my personal Pirate deposit from the other stuff I do with bitcoin I am still making monthly returns comparable and higher to annual returns in local currency.  While many people think Pirate is the lynch-pin for the lending and returns, that is simply not the case.  Yes, it would certainly place a big hole in things, but other thefts have been larger and the economy survives.

Expectation: rates will come down, and I have that in my medium term plan.  But while returns are still high elsewhere from productive activities, rates stay high.  It is what the market is prepared to pay.
What kind of "other stuff"? If it is related to Bitcoin lending, there is the problem that the rates you can demand are affected by the availability of pirate interest rates.

I have thought this over and must agree it can be viewed as a bubble. The relevant question for me is whether interest rates will be maintained for as long as possible, and collapse all of a sudden, or if they will gradually decrease.

With regard to the BTC/USD price, I believe that the former option would be bearish, while the latter one would dampen price increases.

Other stuff:
I have long-term enduring investments with several people.
GLBSE has been a source of some great trading profits during April.
There are some BTC backed loans for non-BTC ventures.
I invested in a manufacturer recently - returns yet to be determined.
Lots of the loans in my book are for equipment/trading/non-lending arbitrage.

If I didn't have my Pirate account, the remainder of the coins would still be working hard, and people borrowing are prepared to pay 10-15%/month currently.  My own expectation is that the rates will decline slowly.  But for now, I'm able to pay around 7%/month on deposits and make a margin.
vip
Activity: 574
Merit: 500
Don't send me a pm unless you gpg encrypt it.
May 01, 2012, 07:52:25 PM
#49
I'm now thinking this is mostly about the Pirate bubble  (the Bitcoin Savings and Trust ponzi scheme).

How long do Ponzi schemes typically last?  Are there any research studies done on this matter?  I'm guessing that the higher the interest rate, the shorter the duration.

It looks like the original Charles Ponzi scheme lasted around 8 months. He was doubling investments in 90 days.

The first MMM ponzi (Russia 1994) lasted 6 or 7 months.

The second MMM ponzi (Stock Generation) lasted two years - because they had rules that let them arbitrarily reduce the amount in your account (even down to zero).

The Romanian Caritas ponzi lasted 2 years and 4 months.  8 times return in 6 months (same as 100% in two months).

The Madoff scheme lasted a very long time (20-48 years), but gave much lower returns (as low as 10%/year).

Bitcoin Savings and Trust is almost 6 months old and returns 34%/month.

It seems that giving out 40% interest per month is fairly typical for Ponzi schemes.  There is probably a balance between having a very high rate to get people to join, and actually being able to pay it out - which is why they don't promise 100% monthly returns.





First off, FPS&T/BS&T has been around longer than 6 months. 

Second, you've yet to actually prove its a ponzi, therefor the rest is just idle speculation.  What else you got?
N12
donator
Activity: 1610
Merit: 1010
May 01, 2012, 07:40:55 PM
#48
If I exclude my personal Pirate deposit from the other stuff I do with bitcoin I am still making monthly returns comparable and higher to annual returns in local currency.  While many people think Pirate is the lynch-pin for the lending and returns, that is simply not the case.  Yes, it would certainly place a big hole in things, but other thefts have been larger and the economy survives.

Expectation: rates will come down, and I have that in my medium term plan.  But while returns are still high elsewhere from productive activities, rates stay high.  It is what the market is prepared to pay.
What kind of "other stuff"? If it is related to Bitcoin lending, there is the problem that the rates you can demand are affected by the availability of pirate interest rates.

I have thought this over and must agree it can be viewed as a bubble. The relevant question for me is whether interest rates will be maintained for as long as possible, and collapse all of a sudden, or if they will gradually decrease.

With regard to the BTC/USD price, I believe that the former option would be bearish, while the latter one would dampen price increases.
hero member
Activity: 518
Merit: 500
May 01, 2012, 04:24:26 PM
#47
If I exclude my personal Pirate deposit from the other stuff I do with bitcoin I am still making monthly returns comparable and higher to annual returns in local currency.  While many people think Pirate is the lynch-pin for the lending and returns, that is simply not the case.  Yes, it would certainly place a big hole in things, but other thefts have been larger and the economy survives.

Expectation: rates will come down, and I have that in my medium term plan.  But while returns are still high elsewhere from productive activities, rates stay high.  It is what the market is prepared to pay.
legendary
Activity: 1867
Merit: 1023
May 01, 2012, 03:49:27 PM
#46
I'm now thinking this is mostly about the Pirate bubble  (the Bitcoin Savings and Trust ponzi scheme).

How long do Ponzi schemes typically last?  Are there any research studies done on this matter?  I'm guessing that the higher the interest rate, the shorter the duration.

It looks like the original Charles Ponzi scheme lasted around 8 months. He was doubling investments in 90 days.

The first MMM ponzi (Russia 1994) lasted 6 or 7 months.

The second MMM ponzi (Stock Generation) lasted two years - because they had rules that let them arbitrarily reduce the amount in your account (even down to zero).

The Romanian Caritas ponzi lasted 2 years and 4 months.  8 times return in 6 months (same as 100% in two months).

The Madoff scheme lasted a very long time (20-48 years), but gave much lower returns (as low as 10%/year).

Bitcoin Savings and Trust is almost 6 months old and returns 34%/month.

It seems that giving out 40% interest per month is fairly typical for Ponzi schemes.  There is probably a balance between having a very high rate to get people to join, and actually being able to pay it out - which is why they don't promise 100% monthly returns.



vip
Activity: 574
Merit: 500
Don't send me a pm unless you gpg encrypt it.
April 19, 2012, 11:39:52 PM
#45
or be like me and do both!
hero member
Activity: 518
Merit: 500
April 19, 2012, 10:08:31 PM
#44
Well, I didn't mean to imply that OTC is a requirement to exchange funds, but that's how it is being read, seemingly.

OTC is not the only way to build trust, that is why you guys were able to do without it.

No, we were observing, as you have, that there are multiple ways of doing things.
legendary
Activity: 1694
Merit: 1006
April 19, 2012, 10:06:13 PM
#43
Well, I didn't mean to imply that OTC is a requirement to exchange funds, but that's how it is being read, seemingly.

OTC is not the only way to build trust, that is why you guys were able to do without it.
hero member
Activity: 518
Merit: 500
April 19, 2012, 08:29:18 PM
#42
Most things that are worth doing are not easy. OTC registration is one of them. Its just like many aspects of the business world - if you want to taken seriously, you have to jump through a few hoops first.
Oddly enough, I've received >$10k in deposits and never registered for the damn thing.

Similar - did a lot of business before doing the OTC thing.  I have done some ratings recently (only took 30 minutes), but playing with a few other bits and pieces.

I do have people send me BTC500 deposits as that's a sensible level, and they get paid back too.  (had 1000 coins returned to happy owners in the past few weeks)
Currently, I'm paying interest on more than 3000 coins (that's about 0.0001/sec if I bother to watch in real time) and have some nice interest payments arriving regularly from different loans.
donator
Activity: 1218
Merit: 1015
April 19, 2012, 07:50:59 PM
#41
Most things that are worth doing are not easy. OTC registration is one of them. Its just like many aspects of the business world - if you want to taken seriously, you have to jump through a few hoops first.
Oddly enough, I've received >$10k in deposits and never registered for the damned thing.
legendary
Activity: 1694
Merit: 1006
April 19, 2012, 02:40:04 PM
#40
I'm impressed.  This thread looks like 90%+ of the lending business (lenders) contributing to the OP misnomer.  I can think of a couple that haven't written something, or who don't need to.

btw - I agree with znort - having been talked through GPG signing by INAU in slightly under two hours and going on IRC, I haven't been back since.  It was a giant PITA.

I hate it, I dont have the time, I read the the directions..  And im no slouch with computers..

Its a PITA, and my time is valuable.  in other words...  Fuck that noise..


BOUNTY!

10 bitcoins to a OTC type system for bitcoin lending and trades that is easier than microwave popcorn


Thunderbird with Enigmail.


You mean using an actual mail client like in the 90's ?
How quaint and charming Smiley




Lol, Yes as opposed to IRC from the 80's.

He did ask for Easy.

Most things that are worth doing are not easy. OTC registration is one of them. Its just like many aspects of the business world - if you want to taken seriously, you have to jump through a few hoops first.
full member
Activity: 167
Merit: 100
April 19, 2012, 10:13:36 AM
#39

Case in point: a currency that can be divided down to
8 decimal places has never existed before. All physical
currencies (USD, Gold, etc ...) get to a point where they
become unusable if deflation persists (you can't pay with
a millionth of a gram of gold).


This - of course - is not true with fiat currencies like the dollar.

You can bring 500, 1.000, 10.000 or 1.000.000 USD banknotes in circulation to keep up with inflation.
See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperinflation for numerous examples in recent history.

Similarly US dollars can be subdivided by the federal bank to infinity.
Nothing prevents the FED from printing 1 cent, 1 mCent, or 1 uCent banknotes if deflation requires their daily use.
full member
Activity: 167
Merit: 100
April 19, 2012, 05:18:08 AM
#38
btc loans help the btc economy

They do, but in an unexpected way:

The largest obstacle to a vivid economy is deflation and hoarding. Why would you spend a BTC now when you expect it to be worth more tomorrow? Why not spend USDs instead when you expect USDs to be worth less tomorrow? A commodity that is too dear to spend is useless as a currency.

The majority of the BTCs are concentrated in the few hands of the BTC rich. If their loans would work out they would control even more BTCs over time (due to high compound interest rates). That would suck the BTCs out of circulation like a black hole sucking in all the available matter.

Luckily the solution is simple: the black hole explodes spilling the collected BTCs all over the place. Loans go bad and BTCs spread out: from the hoarding few to the careless many. The law of entropy applies and the money remains in circulation. Everybody wins: except the few BTC rich who keep the economy alive by loosing their money on bad loans. But even they win: loosing half of your BTCs on bad loans but keeping the economy alive is still better then having 2x as many BTCs that became worthless because the underlying economy has stopped.
vip
Activity: 490
Merit: 271
March 28, 2012, 03:46:15 AM
#37
I'm impressed.  This thread looks like 90%+ of the lending business (lenders) contributing to the OP misnomer.  I can think of a couple that haven't written something, or who don't need to.

btw - I agree with znort - having been talked through GPG signing by INAU in slightly under two hours and going on IRC, I haven't been back since.  It was a giant PITA.

I hate it, I dont have the time, I read the the directions..  And im no slouch with computers..

Its a PITA, and my time is valuable.  in other words...  Fuck that noise..


BOUNTY!

10 bitcoins to a OTC type system for bitcoin lending and trades that is easier than microwave popcorn


Thunderbird with Enigmail.


You mean using an actual mail client like in the 90's ?
How quaint and charming Smiley




Lol, Yes as opposed to IRC from the 80's.

He did ask for Easy.
vip
Activity: 490
Merit: 271
March 28, 2012, 01:42:17 AM
#36
I'm impressed.  This thread looks like 90%+ of the lending business (lenders) contributing to the OP misnomer.  I can think of a couple that haven't written something, or who don't need to.

btw - I agree with znort - having been talked through GPG signing by INAU in slightly under two hours and going on IRC, I haven't been back since.  It was a giant PITA.

I hate it, I dont have the time, I read the the directions..  And im no slouch with computers..

Its a PITA, and my time is valuable.  in other words...  Fuck that noise..


BOUNTY!

10 bitcoins to a OTC type system for bitcoin lending and trades that is easier than microwave popcorn


Thunderbird with Enigmail.



You are missing just a few steps... like the whole OTC part...


Didn't think I did. OTC - Over the Counter, Mailing List (you know like the one everyone has on a regular basis)

Make Offer -> Click Reply All -> Accept Offer -> Click Reply All : Send P2P for details -> Complete Trade : Click Send All -> Confirm Deal : Wait for next Offer.

Plus with the caveat of it all being encrypted.
hero member
Activity: 742
Merit: 500
March 28, 2012, 01:26:50 AM
#35
I'm impressed.  This thread looks like 90%+ of the lending business (lenders) contributing to the OP misnomer.  I can think of a couple that haven't written something, or who don't need to.

btw - I agree with znort - having been talked through GPG signing by INAU in slightly under two hours and going on IRC, I haven't been back since.  It was a giant PITA.

I hate it, I dont have the time, I read the the directions..  And im no slouch with computers..

Its a PITA, and my time is valuable.  in other words...  Fuck that noise..


BOUNTY!

10 bitcoins to a OTC type system for bitcoin lending and trades that is easier than microwave popcorn


Thunderbird with Enigmail.



You are missing just a few steps... like the whole OTC part...
vip
Activity: 490
Merit: 271
March 28, 2012, 01:16:12 AM
#34
I'm impressed.  This thread looks like 90%+ of the lending business (lenders) contributing to the OP misnomer.  I can think of a couple that haven't written something, or who don't need to.

btw - I agree with znort - having been talked through GPG signing by INAU in slightly under two hours and going on IRC, I haven't been back since.  It was a giant PITA.

I hate it, I dont have the time, I read the the directions..  And im no slouch with computers..

Its a PITA, and my time is valuable.  in other words...  Fuck that noise..


BOUNTY!

10 bitcoins to a OTC type system for bitcoin lending and trades that is easier than microwave popcorn


Thunderbird with Enigmail.


Pages:
Jump to: