Pages:
Author

Topic: The three main concerns I have about bitcoin - page 2. (Read 2862 times)

legendary
Activity: 1176
Merit: 1003
2) The supply is fixed at 21 million, but bitcoins themselves are not permanent. People die all the time without wills. People die with btc on a computer/flashdrive that no one knows about, they're gone. People don't make backups, their computer crashes, they're gone. You might think this is great, because now your btc are more valuable. But for a currency, it's not such a good thing, to have the supply eroding over time. Theoreticly, the amount of btc could eventually go to zero.
This issue keeps showing up every now and then... Well here's the thing: it doesn't matter how many (or how little) bitcoins there are in existence!

The limit of 21 million bitcoins (or 2.1 quadrillion satoshis actually, with the current 8 decimal precision) is just an arbitrary number. Bitcoin is digital and therefore infinitely divisible. The 8 decimals are just a limitation in the current software, which can be increased if the need arises at some point in the future.

It doesn't matter if there are 11.6 million bitcoins in existence, or 400, or just 0.03, it's enough. Even if it goes to zero, literally, i.e. all current bitcoins would be magically destroyed, it's still not a problem as new (fractions of) bitcoins are always being mined.

By definition there is NO shortage of supply, period.
sr. member
Activity: 252
Merit: 250
Do yourself a favor and check out Ripple.  Ripple + Bitcoin = Brilliant!   Wink
newbie
Activity: 53
Merit: 0
Thanks for all the responses. As I said, I posted these concerns in order to learn, not because I was convinced of their validity. I'm off to read the wiki now. Thanks again.
legendary
Activity: 1708
Merit: 1006

I know people want to get rich. I must say, i never thought I would hear is so commonly and with no shame, "were not trying to fix the world, money and profits are all I/we care about." That is a disease that nature will eventually deal with.

He wasn't speaking for everyone, stop twisting his words.

Besides, we all know its in our nature to want to control our own destiny. Wealth gives us the hope that its possible.

And that's what bitcoin is about, to take control away from irresponsible people who have too much wealth and power.
legendary
Activity: 905
Merit: 1000

I know people want to get rich. I must say, i never thought I would hear is so commonly and with no shame, "were not trying to fix the world, money and profits are all I/we care about." That is a disease that nature will eventually deal with.

Greed is good.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ONXpaBQnBvE
sr. member
Activity: 350
Merit: 250
from here going forward, how does bitcoin ensure new adoption and capital inflows until the world itself trades in Bitcoin

We can't ensure it.


Have you heard of a marketing campaign. Yes you can ensure it. Six flags builds a new multimillion dollar rollercoaster everyother year not because its COOL, but because it ensures new and repeat business.
sr. member
Activity: 350
Merit: 250
Bitcoin being traded for Fiat seems as if it defeats the purpose, but most of you 'early adopters' have no desire to address this as the speculative world makes you fascinatingly richer every time the price increases by $1-$5

Well, for many of us that is the point then, isn't it?

Rich and all that.

I'm not trying to change the World; only make some money.

Preferably a lot of money.

My $.02.

I know people want to get rich. I must say, i never thought I would hear is so commonly and with no shame, "were not trying to fix the world, money and profits are all I/we care about." That is a disease that nature will eventually deal with.
legendary
Activity: 905
Merit: 1000
from here going forward, how does bitcoin ensure new adoption and capital inflows until the world itself trades in Bitcoin

We can't ensure it.  It is not a sure thing.

sr. member
Activity: 350
Merit: 250
from here going forward, how does bitcoin ensure new adoption and capital inflows until the world itself trades in Bitcoin
sr. member
Activity: 476
Merit: 250
Bitcoin being traded for Fiat seems as if it defeats the purpose, but most of you 'early adopters' have no desire to address this as the speculative world makes you fascinatingly richer every time the price increases by $1-$5

Well, for many of us that is the point then, isn't it?

Rich and all that.

I'm not trying to change the World; only make some money.

Preferably a lot of money.

My $.02.
sr. member
Activity: 350
Merit: 250
Bitcoin being traded for Fiat seems as if it defeats the purpose, but most of you 'early adopters' have no desire to address this as the speculative world makes you fascinatingly richer every time the price increases by $1-$5
sr. member
Activity: 350
Merit: 250
The wiki covers all of this beautifully. I'm not sure why someone is willing to sift through forum responses to find an answer(because I believe they ask the question after they have come to an early conclusion), when they can just look at the Myths page. https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Myths

I've read the wiki, I am still curious as some of these questions unnerve.

Security, keylogging, lack of a bitcoin supply chain worry me.

Would off chain transaction lead to counterfeit?

I do not exactly understand how moving the decimal places helps. Everyones prices just add or drop a zero, back to square one.
member
Activity: 109
Merit: 10
The wiki covers all of this beautifully. I'm not sure why someone is willing to sift through forum responses to find an answer(because I believe they ask the question after they have come to an early conclusion), when they can just look at the Myths page. https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Myths
legendary
Activity: 905
Merit: 1000
Maybe these have already been addressed, but here they are.

1) Early adopters may have stashes of millions of bitcoin. If widely adopted a few super rich could have a huge influence over the whole bitcoin economy. Imagine owning 5% of all USD in circulation(with no fed to inflate).

2) The supply is fixed at 21 million, but bitcoins themselves are not permanent. People die all the time without wills. People die with btc on a computer/flashdrive that no one knows about, they're gone. People don't make backups, their computer crashes, they're gone. You might think this is great, because now your btc are more valuable. But for a currency, it's not such a good thing, to have the supply eroding over time. Theoreticly, the amount of btc could eventually go to zero.

3) Speed of transactions. If btc becomes very widely adopted, can it handle billions of transactions a day without speed becoming an issue?

Don't get me wrong. I love bitcoin and the whole concept behind it. These are just questions of someone looking to learn more.

Don't worry about any of those things.  The fall will probably kill you.
http://www.ign.com/videos/2011/06/01/butch-cassidy-and-the-sundance-kid-the-fall-will-kill-you
legendary
Activity: 1722
Merit: 1003
Maybe these have already been addressed, but here they are.

1) Early adopters may have stashes of millions of bitcoin. If widely adopted a few super rich could have a huge influence over the whole bitcoin economy. Imagine owning 5% of all USD in circulation(with no fed to inflate).

2) The supply is fixed at 21 million, but bitcoins themselves are not permanent. People die all the time without wills. People die with btc on a computer/flashdrive that no one knows about, they're gone. People don't make backups, their computer crashes, they're gone. You might think this is great, because now your btc are more valuable. But for a currency, it's not such a good thing, to have the supply eroding over time. Theoreticly, the amount of btc could eventually go to zero.

3) Speed of transactions. If btc becomes very widely adopted, can it handle billions of transactions a day without speed becoming an issue?

Don't get me wrong. I love bitcoin and the whole concept behind it. These are just questions of someone looking to learn more.


Echoing some other responses...

1) I think the upper-bound is Satoshi with a *max* estimated 1 million coins. Not likely the other early folks have more than a couple hundred thousand. That is indeed huge influence, but an order of magnitude less than you're worrying about. Those balances are likely to disperse a good deal as bitcoin value increases.

2) Divisibility is really important. In a currency that's a pain to divide and transport, yeah, diminishing supply becomes problematic. But with bitcoin's divisibility, the world could function fluidly on 1 million coins if necessary (and divisibility can theoretically be increased by orders of magnitude too).

3) This rightly gets a lot of attention, with a lot of proposed solutions. Off chain transactions, various remedies to 0-confirms, Open Transactions, etc... Solutions will arise as the need becomes paramount.
newbie
Activity: 42
Merit: 0
1st point valid other points invalid
hero member
Activity: 518
Merit: 500
I think you make some very good points...all three of them.  And especially the fact that transactions take long enough as it is, so double or triple that and it really get absurd.
legendary
Activity: 4270
Merit: 4534
Maybe these have already been addressed, but here they are.

1) Early adopters may have stashes of millions of bitcoin. If widely adopted a few super rich could have a huge influence over the whole bitcoin economy. Imagine owning 5% of all USD in circulation(with no fed to inflate).
and once they sell their 5% of BTC the buyers of that 5% then have the control.. look at gold.. initially the US owned most of it in fort knox. now you can buy it at vending machines in dubai...

2) The supply is fixed at 21 million, but bitcoins themselves are not permanent. People die all the time without wills. People die with btc on a computer/flashdrive that no one knows about, they're gone. People don't make backups, their computer crashes, they're gone. You might think this is great, because now your btc are more valuable. But for a currency, it's not such a good thing, to have the supply eroding over time. Theoreticly, the amount of btc could eventually go to zero.
think about all the gold in peoples teeth fillings and in motherboards, and jewellry which are now in coffins/landfill underground, lost forever. eventually one day in many decades someone may have a fast enough computer to unhash a private key from its public key, and redeem the lost coins.. anythings possible.. calm down getting to zero is something your grand kids wont even have to worry about

3) Speed of transactions. If btc becomes very widely adopted, can it handle billions of transactions a day without speed becoming an issue?
this is probably the first valid worry that would appear in your lifetime. but there are multiple solutions to it. such as using paperwallets as bearer bond certificates. handing them across to trusted parties away from the network. also off the chain exchanges such as mtgox use to do, swapping mtgox codes between users instead of transactions on the blockchain. plus many other solutions to grow in the future

Don't get me wrong. I love bitcoin and the whole concept behind it. These are just questions of someone looking to learn more.
hero member
Activity: 672
Merit: 500
Maybe these have already been addressed, but here they are.

1) Early adopters may have stashes of millions of bitcoin. If widely adopted a few super rich could have a huge influence over the whole bitcoin economy. Imagine owning 5% of all USD in circulation(with no fed to inflate).

There's only 11.2 million BTC that have been mined to date so it stands to reason that it's not possible for adopters (plural) to have "stashes of millions of bitcoin."  Millions of dollars in Bitcoin, but not millions of Bitcoin.  Also, the blockchain is public ledger so you can see which addresses hold the most amount of coins.  Granted, an early adopter may own numerous "whale" addresses, but I think if you look them over, you'll still see it's not possible that a small handful of people are holding millions of coin.

Quote
2) The supply is fixed at 21 million, but bitcoins themselves are not permanent. People die all the time without wills. People die with btc on a computer/flashdrive that no one knows about, they're gone. People don't make backups, their computer crashes, they're gone. You might think this is great, because now your btc are more valuable. But for a currency, it's not such a good thing, to have the supply eroding over time. Theoreticly, the amount of btc could eventually go to zero.

Theoretically supply can go to zero but not practically.  Remember that Bitcoin is currently divisible to the 8th decimal (and this can be increased) so you shouldn't look at it as 21 million and no more.  The supply is fixed, this is true, but since you can divide each "coin" into fractional amounts, there's enough to service the world's needs if needed.

Quote
3) Speed of transactions. If btc becomes very widely adopted, can it handle billions of transactions a day without speed becoming an issue?

Don't get me wrong. I love bitcoin and the whole concept behind it. These are just questions of someone looking to learn more.

I think this is and will continue to be an evolving process as we are currently seeing with "dust" transactions.  Wider adoption means more miners and a stronger network so I think you need to account for the increase in network and infrastructure that would arise only in a mass adoption scenario.
newbie
Activity: 42
Merit: 0
Most of your cknerns really arent valid
Pages:
Jump to: