Pages:
Author

Topic: Users that you should merit - page 2. (Read 2035 times)

legendary
Activity: 2394
Merit: 6581
be constructive or S.T.F.U
July 24, 2019, 08:01:06 PM
#65
I apologize for taking so long with this request.

All good , glad you are back,safe and sound.

Quote
I'm assuming you meant to exclude the Arabic altcoins board.

Yes that was exactly what i needed, I wanted to know if there is anyone who is doing just fine with merit and whom I have not merited yet,turns out that the list consists of

-banned users
-inactive users ( either inactive on the local board or the forum as a whole)

kind of what I expected since I do spend a lot of time digging for good posts to merit in the local board.

Thanks a lot SM. Kiss
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
July 24, 2019, 07:20:05 PM
#64
Thank you for much appreciated detailed review Smiley

Taking in account that my portfolio is 99% Bitcoin,
I agree with you 100% but I do play with shitcoins from time to time, I admit Wink
legendary
Activity: 3892
Merit: 11105
Self-Custody is a right. Say no to"Non-custodial"
July 24, 2019, 07:09:55 PM
#63
@JayJuanGee
Any smart advices you have for me?
Fell free to inspect my profile.
I try to contribute Bitcointalk as much as I can, and as time allows it.

Thanks in advance

Surely there are guys here (and perhaps a gal or two, too) who are much more capable and talented than me to provide an assessment of your post history, and there are going to be a lot of personal variation too, including if you are inclined to post in languages other than English.

Sometimes posting in languages, other than English could be a useful service, but there might not be as high of a ratio of members in those sections who have  a sufficient number of smerits that they can spend.

By the way, like I tried to say in my earlier post, you are not really limited in your ability to post good content or to even receive a lot of informational value from the forum in terms of  the number  of merits that you have, but I suppose the number of merits could be ways to benefit in terms of lording over status or even some abilities to financially benefit. 

On a personal basis, I don't really ascribe a lot of self assessment based on my receiving smerits, but there is a kind of appreciation that is felt when other members send merits, even if I don't necessarily feel worth of merits in some of my posts... so the whole smerit system is a little bit of a weird dynamic that does seem to, at least, make the forum a bit better as a kind of tool to weed out some of the abilities of spam and shit posters to farm accounts and takes away some incentives to benefit from mere quantity of posts versus causing incentives to improve post quality... which any longer term member is going to appreciate when s/he has to sort through less bullshit in order to find guys (and the occasional gal or two... kind of an inside joke  Cheesy Cheesy Cheesy Cheesy) posting content that is genuine and/or from thought through personal experiences.

Likely, I did not find your posts too repugnant because a bit over a week ago, I sent one of your posts an smerit, and that was as a result of a post in which you had pointed out some of your historical contributions to the forum, a way of seeking merit(s).

Possibly, I would not have come across your posts otherwise, because it does look like you have historically spent a decent amount of time in the bounty hunting section and also just in various altcoin sections, and those areas of the forum that are not of much interest to me and likely not too many members with smerits are going to be hanging out in those sections of the forum or wanting to spend their merits regarding those kinds of begging topics.

The suggestions that I gave to Decimation, above, were somewhat generic which means that those kinds of suggestions should be applicable to anyone, and in sum if you post in areas that are of interest to you, and you provide substantive insight regarding real issues - rather than pumping bullshit ICOs or alts, then you are more likely to build credibility over time which will likely inspire other members (including members with smerits that they can spend) to appreciate your contributions.... and get to know you, as a poster, too.

Actually, I have one more personal bias that seems to be shared by a decent number of members here, but if you spend a considerable amount of time focusing your attention on bitcoin, attempting to learn about bitcoin, looking through the whole space with bitcoin being the main game in town while other projects are frequently distinguishably less valuable than bitcoin while they are engaging in attempts to denigrate bitcoin to pump their own.. and frequently a lot of smoke and mirrors there, then you are likely going to get a decently long way to improving your own understanding of the space which will likely filter down to your getting more credibility and the respect of other forum members.  Don't get me wrong, I am not suggesting that there is completely no value that comes from altcoins, and various scam projects, but I do believe that members who attempt to focus on bitcoin and to take altcoin, ICOs, bounties or whatever with a BIG ASS grain of salt are going to more likely personally profit from their abilities to attempt to focus in that kind of way.
legendary
Activity: 3654
Merit: 8909
https://bpip.org
July 24, 2019, 06:18:28 PM
#62
Suchmoon can I get a list of users who earned more than 50 merit on the Local Arabic board whom I haven't merited (excluding altcoins section) , and if that brings an empty list please change the number of merit earned to 10.

Thank you.

I apologize for taking so long with this request. My life over the last week was a reenactment of Planes, Trains & Automobiles. And buses but no bicycles. Finally got back to my home PC.

I'm assuming you meant to exclude the Arabic altcoins board. Let me know if that's not the case.

   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. hamade                         50    385  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   2. LBX                            28  1155  Trust  BPIP      
   3. HAKHALI                        24    323  Trust  BPIP      
   4. xlm19877                       20    312  Trust  BPIP      
   5. 7ossam7afez                    19    313  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   6. lotfiuser                      16  1114  Trust  BPIP      
   7. MiiDoViic                      15    383  Trust  BPIP      
   8. Mohammad alsmadi               15    189  Trust  BPIP      
   9. DJANAS                         11    136  Trust  BPIP      
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
July 24, 2019, 06:12:47 PM
#61
@JayJuanGee
Any smart advices you have for me?
Fell free to inspect my profile.
I try to contribute Bitcointalk as much as I can, and as time allows it.

Thanks in advance
legendary
Activity: 3892
Merit: 11105
Self-Custody is a right. Say no to"Non-custodial"
July 24, 2019, 01:31:21 PM
#60
Dammit dude, I really need to up my quality I guess. I feel bad and I'm only at 200 posts, some of these absolute legends are at 2k+ and have less than a 100 merit. Sad I'm really trying but I just don't feel like I deserve anything after seeing how much these guys have contributed. I just need to figure out a topic I can provide some insight into that hasn't already been done...

You could likely provide insight to any topic that is of interest to you.  You follow such topic or even create threads on such topic, and thereby, even if there are 100s of members that know more about the topic than you, you can still provide value based on your own perspectives, opinion, view of facts and logic.  

You don't even need to recreate the wheel or create another coin or ICO in order to accomplish such.

For example, this forum has bitcoin in its name, and a whole hell of a lot of members are interested in bitcoin.  Sometimes they pump other bullshit projects in order to acquire more bitcoin, but still, in the end, they might be pumping some baloney bullshit while really understanding that bitcoin is the kingdaddy.

So, whether you are enthusiastic about bitcoin or some other coin, you don't necessarily have to discover something novel, because if you really explore your own interests and attempt to genuinely provide your own insight while attempting to be responsive to other members, likely merits would follow from that.

Finally, there should be no reason to necessarily judge other members by their number of merits, but of course, a lot of merits would likely demonstrate that the member puts a decent amount of time and thought into forum contributions - but there surely are a lot of members who might not have a lot of merits, but they also might feel that it is  NOT productive for their own use of time to spend a lot of time on the forum or their contributions.

Edit:  By the way, I just did a quickie glance at some of your recent posts, and you do seem to have a tendency to post a lot of bullshit, just short posts with hardly any substance nor analysis contained therein.  

So, yeah "upping your game" could be a beneficial thing for you, in terms of possibly inspiring other members to merit your contributions,.... not in terms of the quantity of your posts, but instead attempting to provide better quality per post that might come from reading more and attempting to actually provide content that is responsive to a member's or multiple members' concerns that you might be able to identify in the threads that you read (beyond just reading the title of the thread or whatever other random thought that comes into your mind that might of might not be relevant to any point(s) raised in the thread), if you were not seeming to bounce around so much from topic to topic in such a short period of time.  

Surely, I would not be arguing that all posts need to have high quality, but if you have a few posts of decently high quality, you might find that some members become inspired to send you an smerit or two because they gain confidence in your contributions (or abilities to contribute).. Sometimes, I will send smerits to low quality posts, while recognizing that the member has a tendency to provide decent quality and/or insights to the forum, but not necessarily good quality in the post that I am meriting.
member
Activity: 244
Merit: 43
July 24, 2019, 11:55:53 AM
#59
Dammit dude, I really need to up my quality I guess. I feel bad and I'm only at 200 posts, some of these absolute legends are at 2k+ and have less than a 100 merit. Sad I'm really trying but I just don't feel like I deserve anything after seeing how much these guys have contributed. I just need to figure out a topic I can provide some insight into that hasn't already been done...
legendary
Activity: 2184
Merit: 1302
July 24, 2019, 11:39:27 AM
#58
I am fairly certain you have never merited me before. But I can't easily check on my mobile device. But if you did merit me it's probably only 1 or 2 merit and I think deserve more...
Suchmoon hardly gives less than four merits at a go Grin, he's adopted the "4" trademark.
People can get merits for funny posts in WO. Yes, human need to smile and funny posts serve its role to help people have funny moments. Hence, such posts deserve merits.
And I do not see anything wrong with it at all, giving merits is subjective, and if a user finds a post funny, comical, interesting and whatever or however it catches their interest, giving out merits isn't wrong at all, doesn't matter the thread it is.
legendary
Activity: 2310
Merit: 4085
Farewell o_e_l_e_o
July 24, 2019, 08:03:05 AM
#57
The WO is just a special environment, where both good post as good memes and shared stuff can get merited, still its important to keep stuff like that in there and don't use it all over the forum.... The WO is a place where we can be a little bit human more I guess Roll Eyes
People can get merits for funny posts in WO. Yes, human need to smile and funny posts serve its role to help people have funny moments. Hence, such posts deserve merits.

WO is a big thread, and within a few minutes, we can see it moves to next page(s). That thread is an unique one, we can not find other threads like this in the forum.
Quote
Still a good post posted in the WO is always a win as its been read by many people and probably educate a lot of readers so keep them coming filippone Cheesy
I don't know there are posts in WO deleted due to off-topic or not. If there are screening procedures or report(s) on off-topic posts in WO, there are thousands of off-topic posts, I believe.
legendary
Activity: 2772
Merit: 3284
July 19, 2019, 08:55:02 PM
#56
I am fairly certain you have never merited me before. But I can't easily check on my mobile device. But if you did merit me it's probably only 1 or 2 merit and I think deserve more. Lol

I would love to see that little list that is being created for me

Close: suchmoon merited you once and gave 4 merits.
hero member
Activity: 2254
Merit: 960
100% Deposit Match UP TO €5000!
July 19, 2019, 06:12:41 PM
#55
I am fairly certain you have never merited me before. But I can't easily check on my mobile device. But if you did merit me it's probably only 1 or 2 merit and I think deserve more. Lol

I would love to see that little list that is being created for me
legendary
Activity: 2394
Merit: 6581
be constructive or S.T.F.U
July 19, 2019, 05:22:05 PM
#54
Suchmoon can I get a list of users who earned more than 50 merit on the Local Arabic board whom I haven't merited (excluding altcoins section) , and if that brings an empty list please change the number of merit earned to 10.

Thank you.
legendary
Activity: 1428
Merit: 1166
🤩Finally Married🤩
July 17, 2019, 06:02:10 AM
#53
-snipped
ahm, I think there is something wrong with the given list (PILIPINAS)... I am pretty sure that some of them was already awarded by me, anyways I will just check my history later on, Thanks for this list, will also make a review on their posts later on.

Click on the Merits number - it will open LoyceV's site with the full merit history for each user. I double-checked all 10 and you haven't sent merits to any of them Smiley


You we're right, pardon me. Already checked their history, I t really seems I missed this users, I don't know why, maybe because I was to busy checking some other good posters.
Quite good enough to have a thread like this, I'm greatful for this.

Good Day!

(Now, time to spend my sMerits)



I think some of them are abusing Merit System... (Just a Hunch)
legendary
Activity: 3654
Merit: 8909
https://bpip.org
July 17, 2019, 05:42:34 AM
#52
-snipped
ahm, I think there is something wrong with the given list (PILIPINAS)... I am pretty sure that some of them was already awarded by me, anyways I will just check my history later on, Thanks for this list, will also make a review on their posts later on.

Click on the Merits number - it will open LoyceV's site with the full merit history for each user. I double-checked all 10 and you haven't sent merits to any of them Smiley
copper member
Activity: 2996
Merit: 2371
July 17, 2019, 01:35:20 AM
#51

Your list is inaccurate. I have 712 merit. You claim to listing everyone with merit above 435, but you clearly did not do this.

1) Users who earned more than N merits but you never merited them. N = 100 is ~700 users, N = 30 is ~2000 users.

Pamoldar has merited you.
It was unclear by his request (and in your OP) that you are excluding those who have received merit from the requestor in all cases.


In the future, please read the OP properly before trying to bash anyone you don't like..
How could you possibly say that? You literally scammed someone because you did not like the type of business they are in....






Speaking of which, I'm still trying to come up with criteria without relying on existing merits (improving on example #4 in the OP), i.e. finding the elusive never-merited good posters. Here is what I'm thinking:

  • User who made at least 50 posts in the last 6 months (just to eliminate some throw-away accounts)
  • Excluding posts on Bounties and Press boards (any other completely useless boards?)
  • Excluding posts shorter than 100 characters (not sure about this one)
  • Has to have quoted someone at least 10 times (to show engagement in discussions and not just drive-by spamming)
  • Never received merits

Any other ideas?
(legitimate feedback)

I would not exclude someone from possibly giving them merit solely because they have received a single merit from you in the past. Perhaps a person should be excluded from consideration if they have received more than xx merit from you previously (possibly AND need at least yy additional merit to achieve the next rank, ignoring activity). 

I also would not give anyone merit "automatically" if they have not received merit previously. IMO a better criterion would be the person has already received x merit from y people. Anyone who does not have existing merit should IMO be reviewed and good judgement should be considered if they are putting a decent effort into their posts. There are probably enough people who have zero/1 merit who are not deserving of merit that it would probably be difficult to filter enough of them out.

To account for engagement, I would suggest that the person should be quoted by someone else. An additional sign of engagement would be that the person made a subsequent post after being quoted. To eliminate sockpuppetary, a requirement that a certain number of unique people need to quote the person (who have above a threshold of merit, possibly from a certain number of unique people).
legendary
Activity: 1428
Merit: 1166
🤩Finally Married🤩
July 16, 2019, 09:44:02 PM
#50
-snipped
ahm, I think there is something wrong with the given list (PILIPINAS)... I am pretty sure that some of them was already awarded by me, anyways I will just check my history later on, Thanks for this list, will also make a review on their posts later on.
asu
legendary
Activity: 1302
Merit: 1136
July 16, 2019, 11:22:53 AM
#49
Since the list above already includes users with >50 merits that you didn't merit, this list will have everyone (including those that you have merited and yourself). Let me know if you meant something different.

...

Lovely & superb.

Only 14 Huh i’m actually hoping it’s more than 30. It seems we need more... decent poster and as well merit circulation in our local board.

legendary
Activity: 3654
Merit: 8909
https://bpip.org
July 16, 2019, 11:05:18 AM
#48
Could I get the top ten users who have earned the most merit that I've never merited in Pilipinas?
Could I get like this also?

  #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban
   1. JaoBadjap                     132   1042  Trust  BPIP      
  2. Polar91                        96   3022  Trust  BPIP      
   3. ximply                        64    955  Trust  BPIP      
  4. ChardsElican28                63    112  Trust  BPIP      
   5. Dyanggok                      60    346  Trust  BPIP      
  6. Nerobasta                      50    130  Trust  BPIP  Ban
   7. AdoboCandies                  44    407  Trust  BPIP      
  8. zenrol28                      29    852  Trust  BPIP      
   9. FlightyPouch                  27   3025  Trust  BPIP      
 10. eldrin                        27   1272  Trust  BPIP      
and
3) Users who earned more than 50 merits on Pilipinas

Since the list above already includes users with >50 merits that you didn't merit, this list will have everyone (including those that you have merited and yourself). Let me know if you meant something different.
   #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban 
   1. theyoungmillionaire           306    361  Trust  BPIP      
  2. asu                           255    986  Trust  BPIP      
   3. finaleshot2016               250   1302  Trust  BPIP      
  4. sheenshane                   182   2173  Trust  BPIP      
   5. yazher                       181    727  Trust  BPIP      
  6. JaoBadjap                     132   1042  Trust  BPIP      
   7. GreatArkansas                 123   1325  Trust  BPIP      
  8. cabalism13                   122   1661  Trust  BPIP      
   9. Polar91                        96   3022  Trust  BPIP      
 10. crwth                          90   5018  Trust  BPIP      
  11. ximply                        64    955  Trust  BPIP      
 12. ChardsElican28                63    112  Trust  BPIP      
  13. Dyanggok                      60    346  Trust  BPIP      
 14. Mr. Big                        54   3303  Trust  BPIP      




Could I get the top ten users who have earned the most merit that I've never merited in Pilipinas
Thanks!


Same goes for me, TIA suchmoon.

  #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban
   1. JaoBadjap                     132   1042  Trust  BPIP      
  2. Polar91                        96   3022  Trust  BPIP      
   3. ximply                        64    955  Trust  BPIP      
  4. ChardsElican28                63    112  Trust  BPIP      
   5. Dyanggok                      60    346  Trust  BPIP      
  6. Nerobasta                      50    130  Trust  BPIP  Ban
   7. AdoboCandies                  44    407  Trust  BPIP      
  8. FlightyPouch                  27   3025  Trust  BPIP      
   9. eldrin                        27   1272  Trust  BPIP      
 10. YouShallNotPass                26    712  Trust  BPIP  Ban

Additional TOP 10 on BEGINNERS AND HELP please.

This excludes users that you merited. Again - let me know if you had something different in mind.

  #  User                       Merits  Posts  Trust  BPIP  Ban
   1. shorena                       268  10952  Trust  BPIP      
  2. pooya87                       232  11040  Trust  BPIP      
   3. iasenko                       212   2767  Trust  BPIP      
  4. logfiles                     139    630  Trust  BPIP      
   5. whotookmycrypto               134    169  Trust  BPIP      
  6. wwzsocki                     110   3500  Trust  BPIP      
   7. Sharon121212                 109    370  Trust  BPIP      
  8. mocacinno                      99   3163  Trust  BPIP      
   9. bob123                        90   3846  Trust  BPIP      
 10. OmegaStarScream                75   9292  Trust  BPIP      
legendary
Activity: 1428
Merit: 1166
🤩Finally Married🤩
July 16, 2019, 09:20:45 AM
#47
Could I get the top ten users who have earned the most merit that I've never merited in Pilipinas
Thanks!


Same goes for me, TIA suchmoon.



Additional TOP 10 on BEGINNERS AND HELP please.
staff
Activity: 2408
Merit: 2021
I find your lack of faith in Bitcoin disturbing.
July 16, 2019, 09:14:02 AM
#46
I'm including only users that you haven't merited. Let me know if that's not what you wanted.


It's perfect. I was expecting a shorter list Smiley

Thx.
Pages:
Jump to: