[edited out]
yes..I'm just 'tossing' a guess out there with the $18k mark or some such. This is however IS based in 'some' fact...when watching Bitcoin in the Summer of 2013 while waiting for my miner, it seems a 'lot' of folks that a year previously that were getting their BTC mined for pennies on the $$$ 'cracked' that summer and took their Million USD instead when it got to the 'insane' $64 usd price. Much 'lamenting' on BFL Chat Room and other places of how they screwed up in the Fall let me tell you..but I see the same 'possibility' of 'too far' and 'too fast' ... I mean if you got like those guys the 'majority' of your coin on a CPU at less than a buck..well.. $64 looked pretty insane.. I think BTC was already like $11 bucks in Jan of 2013 as well. So that is my 'guess' of a cracking point...once the 'weak hands' lets call it that, were to wash out..then my 'guess' would be you might not see such again till 80k or 100k Bitcoin. But much 'wrestling' with the fact with these 'whales' back in 2013..the 'insane' pump in Bitcoin Price and it had to be a bubble. I just see the stressors now as the same at about 18K and 20K...
It seems to me that a few points are worth noting, if we are attempting to account for 2013 in regards to what might happen.
I will concede to you that there is more than one way that an exponential curve could play out in the four year fractal and still largely be within free market parameters of expectations. Accordingly, 2013 does represent a double top kind of model, and 2017 represents a single top kind of model.
So, sure, it is possible that we could end up having a 2020/21/22/23 run up that has more than one top, and the various corrections during the process of getting to the ultimate blow off top might cause a shakening of a lot of weak hands along the way. So surely there could be various ways in which HODLers sell way too many coins too soon, and actually, if you think about the matter, more deeply, these kinds of tactics might be the better ways that the status quo rich may be able to lessen (even if they cannot completely prevent) some of the impacts of one of the likely largest transfers of wealth that the world has ever seen.
There could be all kinds of tragedies along the way in which some HODLers are tricked into selling way too many coins too soon... and if you are 50, 60, 70 or 80 years old, you might not give as many shits about any of those matters (except to the extent that you might have been planning to pass some of your wealth to your descendants) because your own timeline is NOT long enough, and you are still able to figure out ways to considerably profit from however you play your bitcoin cards. So of course, the more years that you have, the more that you would likely want to have more power in whatever ways that you choose to allocate your wealth for the longer time-frame of what you expect your life to be or the estate (legacy) that you might want to plan to pass down to your heirs.
So, in some sense, I may be kind of agreeing with you about various ways that weak hands could be shaken from some or all of their coins - but I still do NOT buy into any story that you might be wanting to outline that attempts to ascribe power to the weak hands bringing down the market or stories that they BTC price is failing to go up because too many weak hands are ready, willing and able sell their coins.
Sure, there is always a dynamic in which peeps with wealth (sometimes referred to as bearwhales) are going to want to employ resources to keep BTC prices down as low as they can and for as long as they can, but still some of the dynamics of how much they are able to keep the price down or to keep it down may also be limited - including that we still remain in relatively early stages of adoption and some of the other peeps with money (and even regular joe blow public, retail) are going to continue to contribute to ongoing upward price pressures on lil fiend, even if some folks, that you seem to be relating to, Searing, are nervous, valuing their wealth in lockability dollars, but they are still likely to be overwhelmed by ongoing adoption rather than really causing inabilities for BTC prices to significantly rise beyond previous all time highs.
As I already mentioned, similar kinds of stories were told in 2015/2016 regarding how so many folks were supposedly going to be selling around $1k blah blah blah... and how it took so much more capital to push BTC prices above $1k as compared to how much capital it had taken to push BTC prices above $100 blah blah blah...
nonsense...
We continue to witness entrances of new players into bitcoin who are going to help to contribute to likely inevitable and ongoing upwards BTC price pressures, evn if we are getting into BTC prices that currently seem too difficult to sustain.. whether referring to $25k prices or $100k prices or even higher prices such as $500k or $1 million that may well end up being way more sustainable than previously thunk.
hell, damn, I'm will be tempted as such, and I'm retired and NOT living on my crypto anymore (unlike when I retired in Jan 2018) ..thus...I can imagine pressures of job/wife/money here 7 years later with that kinda growth..getting to anyone. Also all I say, if I am unclear, I am 'clueless' ..I rant, I rave, I say this, I say what if this happens..it has about as much continuity as calling a race at a Greyhound Track....but my 'guess' and observations were, from back in the day..way back newbie days...that $60 or around 5x the price from Jan 2013, I seem to think a lot of folk were dumping in chat groups and taking the usd and running..it happened again at 1k later that year then the panic dumps...then at ..IMHO..guess..just as big at 10K up / down the times it has bounced there so long since 2013....and now my next guess is it will again happen at around $18K TO $20K..even if it is 'just' a little 'pruning' of say 5% of the portfolio as a 'real-life-is-weird-in-2020-pandemic-hedge. Thus it will add up and 'soften' the curve up into 2021...again, my frigging guess. Which along with 50c will buy you a can of soda...means zip.
Anyway, tossing it out there for 'ammo' in the future and people can call me on it ...as being wrong..on my hope too that I am dead, frigging wrong.
But hey, it may be a crummy position..but at least I'm 'hodl'ing' too it!
(I'm such a twit..er I mean wit..really I meant wit! Damn it! I meant wit!. wanders off....kicks a 'throw pillow' at the cat...mumbling to self.)
Brad
On a personal level you can do what you like.
Personally, I have never suggested completely HOLDING everything through BTC price appreciation periods, but instead shaving some off along the way, and how much to shave off should be contemplated by projecting out scenarios such as the BTC price rising very quickly and/or the BTC price rising slowly and going through interim painstaking correction cycles - including longer 2-3 year correction cycles that cause some peeps to regret NOT having had sold more BTC in the arena of blow of top prices. I personally believe that those of us who have been through previous BTC cycles and even including peeps who may not have been through previous cycles but have enough imagination when they look at previous charts, we have enough information to be able extrapolate various scenarios, even extreme scenarios and attempt to pee pare our lil selfies for those various extreme scenarios.. and having had gone through a few of these kinds of outrageous extreme scenarios, many of us have come to realize both that it can seem surreal as fuck to actually be going through an extreme scenario that you had projected as NOT very likely, while at the same time, if a relatively small number of us had a "kind of workable" plan in place, then we end up feeling much better for having had made such a plan and we even feel better if we make various tweaks to the plan along the way because the plan put us in a way better position than what we would have been in, if we had not created such a plan and had not tried to largely follow such plan.
Of course, each of us also have our own limitations in creativity in terms of how much we are really able to extrapolate what we are going to do under various scenarios and we might well even end up gravitating towards scenarios that end up NOT playing out.. and then we feel that we have not prepared enough.. so I am NOT even suggesting that everyone is going to be able to really plan for all of the scenarios.. even though there may be ways that anyone could do better at least outlining some extreme scenarios so they are not totally caught off guard by selling too much too soon or the employment of other gambling techniques that may not feel too good if they end up NOT playing out very well... I am not saying to use margin.. even though some folks become so confident that they end up using margin to screw their own selfies in situations where they did not need to be screwed.. why get greedy when bitcoin already has asymmetric probabilities sitting right in front of us.. (I am surely NOT suggesting that you, Searing, are someone who is inclined to employ margin even though you may be someone who might still end up having regrets because of lack of adequately pee paring for certain scenarios that are outside of your expectations).
PS... By the way, I have heard some fairly prominent bitcoin folks assert that people should consider selling all or large portions of their BTC holdings if it would result in
"life changing" impacts upon them... And, personally, I believe this "life changing impacts" concept would likely cause too many BTC HODLers to employ inadequately contemplated actions that involve selling too much bitcoins too soon... It is not a good parameter, especially if they are failing to figure out some kind of balance for what they might be doing with the money, whether it is buying real estate, investing in a business, investing in education of oneself, buying PMs, getting into equities, buying an annuity, keeping more money in fiat, or buying some consumer goods. Of course, not all uses of money are equal, and frequently when we are young, we need to put our capital to work in various and if we are ONLY invested in bitcoin, it may well be prudent to diversify a bit more outwardly into other assets, even if many of them might NOT hold their value too well or be too much dependent upon fiat values or the lack of value that is given to so much debt being out there in circulation in our current society... Still some investments are better than others, and I suppose in the end, I had largely created this particular
PS because I wanted to quibble with the vague concept of
"life changing impacts" because it remains an inadequate concept on its own, without at least attempting to explore whether you might be allocating away from bitcoin because of needs to invest in yourself, in investment goods or in consumption goods.. good to determine what you are investing in and also analyzing other particular circumstances that are pertinent to your situation including cashflow, other investments, view of bitcoin compared with other investments, risk tolerance, timeline and time, skills abilities to plan learn along the way and to tweak your strategies along the way including reallocating and whether and the extent that you trade at all.