Topic: Way to get round the 5 post limit... - page 8. (Read 10381 times)

@Inedible I think you have part of the answer to the 5 post problem in the initial question. This thread is the solution !!! I don't mind 5 post, and I'm pretty sure no one else does as long as its not wasting time by posting worthless stuff. The newbie section should be put to use with thread like these that could help the bitcointalk community. Just start engaging threads like these to help solve problem around the community, find solution and get new idea and benefit from the input how people who are trying to get out of the newbie jail. Their time will be put to good use and it's a great way to get people engaged early in the community !!

First 15 posts require captcha, after 5 posts and 4 hours they get access to 1 forum or subforum outside of newbie area.  After another 20 posts and 20 hours they have access to everything.

5 posts is not a lot to get around. It's only frustrating to people who would like 30 aliases and now have to make 150 posts

If you knew about the 5 post limit and 4 hour wait, why didn't you register earlier then for when you eventually needed to ask a question in a different part of the forum?

or maybe qualify for reading 100 plus pages?  To show you may have attempted to bring yourself up todate on the topic you are posting about

I would be happy to see a donation to get around the posts limit with the majority of payments going to some sort of charity or project supported by the community.

My only suggestion would be to really highlight the fact you need to be logged in to show active browsing to meet the time requirement.

Maybe it is highlighted when you sign up and I'm just an idiot, however I've been lurking since I joined (about 1.5 months) but never logged in: I believe I misread it as membership time. This will resolve itself fairly quickly for me, but still, I think unless people come in as experts (the minority) they should understand how the forums work with that sort of lurking time.

Post count is useless, as can be observed by reading any thread in the newbie forum.

I think it is a it anniing as you probably have been here for some hours before you want to post something

While I can see your point, most people aren't going to give the newbie forum a second thought once they are out of it so asking in the main forums isn't likely to garner any useful responses at all.  At least there have been some suggestions given by the people directly affected by the current rules.  I can't speak for the OP but I would guess that's the reason for posting it here rather than elsewhere.

Maybe it's not the best idea to ask for suggestions in the Newbie forum. You can expect these kind of reactions here.

From my point of view, the only thing wrong with the current system is that it is not flexible enough to NOT waste the time of those who have what to contribute, but just happen to have joined recently the forum.

It's not really a huge problem, as 4 posts are easily made in the newbies threads (even without shouting like spoiled kids lemme out) and the hours - well, they too shall pass.

However, assuming that the point is to delay (for everybody's benefit) only newbies and not just everybody, why not consider also something along the lines of recommendation from a trusted/hero member or wot rating (would need linking the account to a username there, but it can be done with a signing challenge)?

I mean: those with a good wot rating or trust from several trusted members here can directly post everywhere.

Pixilatedbtc

I'm not pointing anyone out specifically but I've seen a lot of "I hate the 5 post requirement" or "I don't think it works" posts in this thread, which is completely counter to
a) the spirit of the OP, and;
b) the actual request of the OP.

Obviously people have complained/had issues with the five posts/four hour requirement, otherwise this thread wouldn't be here...nobody is saying anything new and frankly, not helping the conversation.  This isn't a petition drive people so "me too" hold exactly zero water and in many cases proves the rule.

Think of the mods as management.  At work, do you go to your Supervisor or Manager and say "This sucks, change it!"?  Not more than once you don't.  Any manager worth their salt wants you to come to them with your problems, obviously, but they appreciate it when you come to them with ideas on how to fix what's broken instead of just complaining.  Is four hours of active browsing the forums too long?  If so, articulate why you think so and not just "because it's hard/boring".  I'm not saying it isn't hard or boring but I'm saying come up with a cogent, reasonable argument for why the time should be shortened.

I had a couple of questions that I really wanted to ask before I joined the forum and I'd been reading it for several months before I created an account.  While I was waiting, I was just chomping at the bit to ask and, in some cases, reply to threads that I was just sure I had to reply to (I'm an incurable wise-ass).  Turns out that all three of my vital questions that I just couldn't wait to ask had already been answered...multiple times, one of which in the newbie forum.     Not saying people haven't searched already because search can be difficult to get the terms right, but it's amazing how much ground has already been trod.

If you have a suggestion, that's what the OP is asking for.  If you're just going to mitch and bone to raise your post count...take 10 seconds in another thread and at least try to be constructive.

don't get me wrong...the required time of trolling the forums has taught me a lot...just wish I could ask some questions in certain threads.

don't think this works

I think it is pretty simple to do 5 posts and I am learning along the way so I am good...

i agree

it would be nice to be able to donate a small amount of BTC to get around the 5 posts.

I'm not happy about this newbie status and restrictions on communicating. I'm not a newb in the world of BTC and mining. I need the ability to communicate with others ASAP!

Nice algorithm - the implementation is going to be a bummer though lol

And what was it that needed figuring out that wasn't in the Newbie readme? Or did you not spend anytime reading?