Pages:
Author

Topic: What is the point of 5 worthless posts? - page 8. (Read 6074 times)

hero member
Activity: 504
Merit: 500
It's pretty easy to also tell people who spammed their 5 posts to get our of newbie section. If you look @ someone's first 5 posts, if they're just there to get out of newbie section it makes it much more likely they're a scammer.
newbie
Activity: 9
Merit: 0
I would imagine that non-Newbie status posters rarely take a look at this forum. While I agree with some sort of mechanism to insure that new accounts are legitimate users that have a positive interest in things, I feel the current mechanism only fills the the Newbie section with fluff and non important topics, and only provides a 4 hour wait time for bots/spammers to do any damage.

I don't have a cure all answer to this problem, maybe a time based system where posts are initially limited and additional posting cap razed as the account matures by age or # of posts. Also maybe implement the ability to reduce an accounts posting cap if any of the posts are flagged as spam or offensive.

Just some thoughts from a newbie who needs to make 5 posts to be able to use this forum, while simultaneously trying to suggest improvements to the process in the spirit of the forum.
newbie
Activity: 7
Merit: 0
I think this is for the betterment of the forum.
hero member
Activity: 602
Merit: 500
R.I.P Silk Road 1.0
4 hours is annoying .

Yeah but they'll be over quick if you'd actually search the forums to learn. You may be restricted from posting elsewhere but you're not restricted from reading. Go learn a few things and it'll make your 4 hours fly quicker. I'm not sure but i think you can still mark a thread as watched. So if you bump into an interesting thread while you wait to complete your 4 hours you can keep an eye on that thread and participate in it once you graduate from the nube section. The key is to be productive. If you complain a lot bout being "stuck" in the nube section it seems that you won't be of much help to the community. Just keep all this in mind.
legendary
Activity: 1450
Merit: 1013
Cryptanalyst castrated by his government, 1952
I already know a lot about BTC so there's not much I want to post in Newbies!

I remember having a similar feeling, but look at it this way...

If you can't think of anything worthwhile to say - any worthwhile contribution to make - while you're in newbie quarantine, then why would that change if you were suddenly allowed to post anywhere?

The best way out of your dilemma is to think of useful things to post - form a habit that will make people eager to read your stuff no matter what thread it's in.

I think newbies have the impression that only newbies read the newbie forum and that only other newbies will read their posts. Not so - many/most/all of the regulars read newbie stuff. Everyone was a newbie at some point.

Bottom line to OP's question though - the only point of making 5 worthless posts is to depict yourself as someone who makes worthless posts. It's a much wiser tactic to make five worthwhile posts, but everyone has to figure things out in their own way.
newbie
Activity: 11
Merit: 0
second post HURRAY
newbie
Activity: 34
Merit: 0
4 hours is annoying .
hero member
Activity: 602
Merit: 500
R.I.P Silk Road 1.0
Ahhh the newbie board. Good times...good times.  Cool
legendary
Activity: 1450
Merit: 1013
Cryptanalyst castrated by his government, 1952
Still don't get it?... Many people earn permanent "ignore" status before they even get out of the newbie quarantine zone.

For others, the "ignore" button gets pushed later, after they try a few troll posts and readers give them the benefit of a small doubt by looking up their post history.

If you post worthless posts, you will be treated as a worthless poster sooner or later, after which you just post into a vacuum. Not a bad system, all in all.

Post away!



So what happens if they hit ignore?  That doesn't seem like punishment to me at all. The forum has tons of users and you are guaranteed to piss of some of them no matter what you say.

It's not "punishment". It's just that in this forum nobody needs to read posts from people they perceive to be making worthless noise. No emotion needed. You can ignore whomever you wish, but they can ignore you too.

Someone who posts nothing but junk eventually winds up talking only to himself/herself and nobody cares. Someone who pushes the "ignore" button out of spite or mean-spiritedness locks himself out of reading potentially-valuable posts. That's OK too - self-inflicted wounds.

People can always turn "ignore" back on or off if they change their minds about the nature of a poster.
newbie
Activity: 13
Merit: 0
*insert worthlessness here*
hero member
Activity: 1132
Merit: 536
well there is no point to have 5 post rules sorry bt tht sucks ... bt i think been online for 4hrs is nice idea for stopping bots and scammer.
newbie
Activity: 13
Merit: 0
Still don't get it?... Many people earn permanent "ignore" status before they even get out of the newbie quarantine zone.

For others, the "ignore" button gets pushed later, after they try a few troll posts and readers give them the benefit of a small doubt by looking up their post history.

If you post worthless posts, you will be treated as a worthless poster sooner or later, after which you just post into a vacuum. Not a bad system, all in all.

Post away!



So what happens if they hit ignore?  That doesn't seem like punishment to me at all. The forum has tons of users and you are guaranteed to piss of some of them no matter what you say.
newbie
Activity: 13
Merit: 0
This is a worthless post too but I don't know how many more worthless posts I have make.

Then again a worthless noob forum deserves to have worthless posts.

At least I am not trying to scam people by promising bitcoins for clicks and then not delivering.
sr. member
Activity: 252
Merit: 250
post1  Grin
newbie
Activity: 5
Merit: 0
It stops junkers coming in and spamming the main board immediately.
The 4hours I understand but yeah maybe not the posts...
I already know a lot about BTC so there's not much I want to post in Newbies!
newbie
Activity: 57
Merit: 0
Still don't get it?... Many people earn permanent "ignore" status before they even get out of the newbie quarantine zone.

For others, the "ignore" button gets pushed later, after they try a few troll posts and readers give them the benefit of a small doubt by looking up their post history.

If you post worthless posts, you will be treated as a worthless poster sooner or later, after which you just post into a vacuum. Not a bad system, all in all.

Post away!



You've made my ignore list. Congrads, u b z 1st.
newbie
Activity: 11
Merit: 0
post 5...
newbie
Activity: 11
Merit: 0
Why can't we just pay to prove we're not spam accounts >.< Would much rather pay like 0.01BTC or something!
legendary
Activity: 1450
Merit: 1013
Cryptanalyst castrated by his government, 1952
Still don't get it?... Many people earn permanent "ignore" status before they even get out of the newbie quarantine zone.

For others, the "ignore" button gets pushed later, after they try a few troll posts and readers give them the benefit of a small doubt by looking up their post history.

If you post worthless posts, you will be treated as a worthless poster sooner or later, after which you just post into a vacuum. Not a bad system, all in all.

Post away!

newbie
Activity: 11
Merit: 0
There's nothing I want to post in the newbie section

Same happen to me here. Pretty boring.
Pages:
Jump to: