Pages:
Author

Topic: Why Arming the Ukrainians is a Bad Idea - page 2. (Read 2427 times)

legendary
Activity: 3752
Merit: 1217
February 04, 2015, 11:46:51 PM
#23
Ooops! Transcarpathia is ancient Hungarian land Smiley! (...and I'm pretty sure Romanians will also discover some evidence of ancient daco-romanian settlements around Kiev.)

Just wait till Ukraine gets the EU membership. 90% of the population will emigrate to Germany and the UK. The Hungarians and Romanians can resettle Ukraine with their own people.
legendary
Activity: 1680
Merit: 1014
February 04, 2015, 05:00:14 PM
#22
It's funny you talk about western propaganda while using language like this:

what Kiev-nazis do with US support is in effect an ethnic cleansing.

Amidst the other Russian propaganda in your post. You have no credibility to talk about propaganda when your own posts are so full of it.

It's not called propaganda, it's called stating the obvious, stating the facts. And I don't need to post any kind of propaganda at all - I make do sticking to verifiable truth.

For the quote above, that you designate as propaganda, please study the following articles:
http://www.globalresearch.ca/the-u-s-has-installed-a-neo-nazi-government-in-ukraine
http://fortruss.blogspot.com.es/2015/02/ukraine-we-target-civilians-separatists.html

In conjunction they factually cover my statement pretty well.

But once we are on the topic of propaganda, can you, please, point out exactly the other cases of it in my post - you sound as if it's full of it.
legendary
Activity: 2044
Merit: 1115
★777Coin.com★ Fun BTC Casino!
February 04, 2015, 03:47:39 PM
#21
let's not start ww3 over a quarrel between far away peoples of which we know nothing, didn't we learn the last time


Unless the aim of fomenting that quarrel over the last 25+ years by use of various American "democracy-promoting" grants, was exactly to start a WW3... In which case I can see US going in full monty, as they are are doing now.



The following bit of the OP article is still conformant to the mainstream Western propaganda line:

Quote
Steve and Strobe’s article (and the supporting report with several other prominent authors) rings with fury at Russian actions. And Russian actions are indeed outrageous. But moral indignation, no matter how righteous and satisfying, is not a strategy. A strategy needs to describe just how provision of American arms would make the situation better.

Rather than such a description, the article suggests that a just cause and the Ukrainian need and desire for weapons are enough to justify their provision. But it is hardly surprising that the Ukrainians want American arms in their war against Russia and Russian-backed separatists—they face the possibility of territorial dismemberment and would run any risk to preserve their state intact.

The Ukrainian calculus is one of immediate desperation. But the United States needs to think for the longer-term. And if U.S.-provided weapons fail to induce a Russian retreat in Ukraine and instead cause an escalation of the war, the net result will not be peace and compromise.

The real intellectual break-through in the West will be when they realise that Russia is not present in Ukraine and is not at war with Ukraine. Rather Ukraine is in an imaginary war with Russia. So there is no Russia to retreat in the first place.

What we have in Donbass, are people, who have lived there for centuries, and who have nowhere to go. Yes, they are Russian by ethnicity, so yes, what Kiev-nazis do with US support is in effect an ethnic cleansing. But the people of Donbass are fighting back for their own land and for their right to live, not for Russia.

The "outrageous" actions by Russia so far include: peace brokerage, several hundred thousand tonnes of humanitarian aide, split over 13 convoys, being host to close to a million refugees from the war-zone, and now taking in thousands of young men from Ukraine of conscript age, who don't want to die in a war, imposed on them by Western-backed Nazis.

It's funny you talk about western propaganda while using language like this:

what Kiev-nazis do with US support is in effect an ethnic cleansing.

Amidst the other Russian propaganda in your post. You have no credibility to talk about propaganda when your own posts are so full of it.
legendary
Activity: 868
Merit: 1006
February 04, 2015, 02:36:05 PM
#20
Arming uninformed, pissed off people is always a bad idea regardless nationality.
full member
Activity: 182
Merit: 123
"PLEASE SCULPT YOUR SHIT BEFORE THROWING. Thank U"
February 04, 2015, 01:50:11 PM
#19
War does not determine who is right - only who is left.

thank you, some will need to learn it the hard way, including the following poster :

In which case I can see US going in full monty, as they are are doing now. (you don't have the accreditation necessary to understand yet what full monty means. I don't know what you will tell your loved ones when you will discover it, however I am not sure you will the time to share this new knowledge with said people)
...

What we have in Donbass Syria, are people, who have lived there for centuries, and who have nowhere to go. Yes, they are Russian Semites by ethnicity, so yes, what KievDamascus-nazis do with US Russian support is in effect an ethnic cleansing. But the people of DonbassSyria are fighting back for their own land and for their right to live, not for Russia the Empire.


so for this simple mistake, you or people like you nemo will have to explain war the American way to your children and loved one. you may not have the time to prepare them, may you chose the way of the sleep like former manipulator or execution, so I advise you to seriously think about it now, before learning what was done those last 25+ years and the 200 before btw Cheesy. r.i.p.r., for the obstination of one man. Everyone is too afraid to say to him to stop? you don't want to understand that the cost of facing the murders of the north is getting less costly every day than not facing him, and I don't speak in BTC terms.

and because you are of the ilk that love to lie to exploit, and for me :

What we have in Donbass Iran, are people, who have lived there for centuries, and who have nowhere to go. Yes, they are Russian Persians by ethnicity, so yes, what KievMollah-nazis do with USRUSSIAN support is in effect an ethnic cleansing lack of freedom and oppression. But the people of Donbass Iran are fighting back for their own land and for their right to live, not for Russia America.

I now they are not ethnic Russian as such they can die, or be refugees, or be bombarded or what ever... Russian Military doctrine exposed 101.

Ohh and nemo btw you seems smart, you must get a lot in (expected) returns... What are you after? Puttin succession?
legendary
Activity: 1680
Merit: 1014
February 04, 2015, 12:19:21 PM
#18
The pedant in me wants to make only one quite small correction to the very amusing rendition of Kievan history by Snail2 Smiley

Not "a viking guy", but "a varjag guy". Wink
legendary
Activity: 1512
Merit: 1000
February 04, 2015, 12:06:08 PM
#17
I always thought that Kiev was born out of Kievan RUS. 500 AD Are you saying that Romanian settlements around Kiev are older than this?

Actually Kiev was a small remote slavic settlement between the 5th and mid-9th century, usually a tributary of the nearest khaganate (huns, avars, gokturks, kahazars, whoever was the boss on the steppes in a given time). In the mid-9th century a viking guy called Oleg got really drunk, wandered quite far with his buddies and woke up in a pub f*ckin far from home with a bunch of killed khazar herdsman and pretty blondes around. That place was Kiev. After realizing where they really are they tought that's actually a good place for establishing a trading post as it's about on the half way between the Black Sea ports and the land of the Novgorod rus. ...and this is the story how Kiev been built Smiley.
legendary
Activity: 3108
Merit: 1359
February 04, 2015, 11:05:00 AM
#16
I always thought that Kiev was born out of Kievan RUS. 500 AD Are you saying that Romanian settlements around Kiev are older than this?
1) "Kievan Rus" isn't a name of state, it's a name for historical period since 882 until 1240 A.D.
2) Originally Kiev was a part of Khazar Khaganate. In 882 it was annexed by Oleg of Novgorod and then he declared this city as the capital of Rus.

 Roll Eyes
legendary
Activity: 1512
Merit: 1000
February 04, 2015, 10:44:57 AM
#15
I always thought that Kiev was born out of Kievan RUS. 500 AD Are you saying that Romanian settlements around Kiev are older than this?

Well, romanians used to say such things about neighbouring countries when they see an opportunity for a landgrab (e.g. in the case of Transylvania) Smiley.
newbie
Activity: 55
Merit: 0
February 04, 2015, 09:51:25 AM
#14
I always thought that Kiev was born out of Kievan RUS. 500 AD Are you saying that Romanian settlements around Kiev are older than this?
legendary
Activity: 1512
Merit: 1000
February 04, 2015, 09:34:07 AM
#13
I think Ukraine should immediately give Lwow back to Poland. Hasn't Poland suffered enough, between Hitler's nazi goons and Stalin's bolshevik goons?- that it has to suffer from Hitler's progeny in Kiev now?

Ukraine has no claim over Lwow. Give it back, you abortion of a nation of Demjanjuks!

Western Ukraine to Poland, Eastern Ukraine to Russia! Leave a little concentration camp somewhere in the center, herd them all into it and set it ablaze! Justice will finally be done.

Ooops! Transcarpathia is ancient Hungarian land Smiley! (...and I'm pretty sure Romanians will also discover some evidence of ancient daco-romanian settlements around Kiev.)
newbie
Activity: 49
Merit: 0
February 04, 2015, 09:32:46 AM
#12
"And Russian actions are indeed outrageous"HuhHuh

What are you talking about? The US removed the democratically elected President of Ukraine by way of a Military coup de tat!
Next, that new government embraced Fascism and decided to kill the Russian speaking Ukrainian citizens in Eastern Ukraine!
Russia's actions have always been defensive. They protected the citizens of Crimea who by the way all speak Russian like in Eastern Ukraine. If Crimea hadn't become part of Russia Kiev would be bombing them too right now!

Russia's actions! Russia's actions! What about Kiev's actions! What about America's actions?

NO BODY EVER MENTIONS THAT THE US CAUSED THIS ENTIRE MESS!!
hero member
Activity: 532
Merit: 500
February 04, 2015, 08:22:16 AM
#11
I think Ukraine should immediately give Lwow back to Poland. Hasn't Poland suffered enough, between Hitler's nazi goons and Stalin's bolshevik goons?- that it has to suffer from Hitler's progeny in Kiev now?

Ukraine has no claim over Lwow. Give it back, you abortion of a nation of Demjanjuks!

Western Ukraine to Poland, Eastern Ukraine to Russia! Leave a little concentration camp somewhere in the center, herd them all into it and set it ablaze! Justice will finally be done.
legendary
Activity: 1014
Merit: 1001
February 04, 2015, 07:55:32 AM
#10
War does not determine who is right - only who is left.
legendary
Activity: 1680
Merit: 1014
February 04, 2015, 07:36:50 AM
#9
let's not start ww3 over a quarrel between far away peoples of which we know nothing, didn't we learn the last time


Unless the aim of fomenting that quarrel over the last 25+ years by use of various American "democracy-promoting" grants, was exactly to start a WW3... In which case I can see US going in full monty, as they are are doing now.



The following bit of the OP article is still conformant to the mainstream Western propaganda line:

Quote
Steve and Strobe’s article (and the supporting report with several other prominent authors) rings with fury at Russian actions. And Russian actions are indeed outrageous. But moral indignation, no matter how righteous and satisfying, is not a strategy. A strategy needs to describe just how provision of American arms would make the situation better.

Rather than such a description, the article suggests that a just cause and the Ukrainian need and desire for weapons are enough to justify their provision. But it is hardly surprising that the Ukrainians want American arms in their war against Russia and Russian-backed separatists—they face the possibility of territorial dismemberment and would run any risk to preserve their state intact.

The Ukrainian calculus is one of immediate desperation. But the United States needs to think for the longer-term. And if U.S.-provided weapons fail to induce a Russian retreat in Ukraine and instead cause an escalation of the war, the net result will not be peace and compromise.

The real intellectual break-through in the West will be when they realise that Russia is not present in Ukraine and is not at war with Ukraine. Rather Ukraine is in an imaginary war with Russia. So there is no Russia to retreat in the first place.

What we have in Donbass, are people, who have lived there for centuries, and who have nowhere to go. Yes, they are Russian by ethnicity, so yes, what Kiev-nazis do with US support is in effect an ethnic cleansing. But the people of Donbass are fighting back for their own land and for their right to live, not for Russia.

The "outrageous" actions by Russia so far include: peace brokerage, several hundred thousand tonnes of humanitarian aide, split over 13 convoys, being host to close to a million refugees from the war-zone, and now taking in thousands of young men from Ukraine of conscript age, who don't want to die in a war, imposed on them by Western-backed Nazis.
legendary
Activity: 1078
Merit: 1014
February 04, 2015, 04:35:34 AM
#8
let's not start ww3 over a quarrel between far away peoples of which we know nothing, didn't we learn the last time
full member
Activity: 182
Merit: 123
"PLEASE SCULPT YOUR SHIT BEFORE THROWING. Thank U"
February 04, 2015, 02:48:20 AM
#7
fuck off, this is lies you know it. the bashar Baathist experienced as failed. they should have been all together, Syrians first... the truth as soon as the people of the Sunnah started to ask for a little freedom and power and wealth and prosperity from their allawites masters they receive sinpers round, children arrest, women jailed and finally tnt from the air backed by the Russian who have love affairs with Syrian girls from ussr, and want to stop pipeline from wahabit land... who care iran will get nuked, moskow will get nuked, then we will be able to move to peace.

p.s. and you are not an emperor but a slave. always have always be. Only God is the Greatest.

and that tell anything I need to learn about those that pretend to be pious... aka IRAN I know what you did... will see what the USMIIC will give you, I vote for... ahaha.
legendary
Activity: 3752
Merit: 1217
February 04, 2015, 02:41:38 AM
#6
personally, I except that at one point the Russian will move to outright terrorism... (like they supported in Syria, from the regime aircraft and the growth of the various group to get support)

Wow... In Syria, the Russians are supporting the secular Assad regime, while the Americans and their Wahabist allies are arming the ultra-fanatic Al Nusra and ISIS. Who is the real terrorist here? 
full member
Activity: 182
Merit: 123
"PLEASE SCULPT YOUR SHIT BEFORE THROWING. Thank U"
February 04, 2015, 02:20:46 AM
#5
If the Americans arm the Kiev junta, it will just encourage the Russians to pour in more and more advanced weapons to the militia. The war will never end and the civilians will suffer terribly.

personally, I except that at one point the Russian will move to outright terrorism... (like they supported in Syria, from the regime aircraft and the growth of the various group to get support), so if you think that Charlie trashpapers or 9.11 for the matter are big, you have never seen Russian combat groups in action... with the end of the Motherland at stakes. be aware, it will be tough.

that's were FIRST STRIKES enter the arena. brutal meet brutaler... until both are exhausted.

to avoid the annihilation of the Russian landmass, both camp have to lose big, one way is to let out gaz from Russian tool box, we let gmo and unclean fracking out. peace, or Russian wants to fuck the world with what ever come next, The Empire find counter solutions, become feed up with the negative aspect, the cost and risk of annihilating Russia are lesser, let's roll. and that's what Russian leadership doesn't want to understand... they want to game and win. they may have already played, now it may time to lose.
legendary
Activity: 3752
Merit: 1217
February 03, 2015, 11:47:49 PM
#4
If the Americans arm the Kiev junta, it will just encourage the Russians to pour in more and more advanced weapons to the militia. The war will never end and the civilians will suffer terribly.
Pages:
Jump to: