Topic: Will the transfers to the Saudi league become a problem for European football? (Read 718 times)

There are increasing rumors that many prominent players want to leave the Saudi league and return to Europe in the coming summer transfer-season. All this despite the fact that the Saudis offer so much more money than the european clubs, but even in europe top players earn more than they can spend in a normal life and presumably most of them don't want to live restricted like in Saudi Arabia. By the way, I recently even read that the saudi prince personally wants to contact Mbappe. But I doubt that a young Kylian would move to this league and end his entire career with this move.

The biggest obstacle for this Saudi Arabian league is its culture, which is very different from Europe's culture, and also the fact that the Saudi Arabian government is not a democratic government, they use religion as law, so that in itself already puts This whole project of bringing in players from outside the country is a huge failure in the long term. This is because no good young player who plays in a major European league will leave Europe to go and play in a country like Saudi Arabia where despite receiving a lot of money, he will not have the freedom to do what he wants and will not have a successful career. . We just need to see that the players who have played in Europe are involved in many controversies, from sleeping with many women to cheating controversies with their wives.

The wives of most of the players who play in Europe have posted photos with little clothing, they have dressed in the street with little clothing, because in this way they think they are enhancing their bodies, they consider themselves sexy. This has become so normal in Europe that it is already part of European culture, but this in Arab countries can lead to women being arrested and if the foreign player who plays in Saudi Arabia makes the mistake of drinking alcohol and sleeping with many women in Saudi Arabia, hotel, then he will be punished based on religion. Countries like Saudi Arabia are dictatorships. It is impossible to be happy in a dictatorship country. That's why, in my opinion, players who go to Saudi Arabia will go because they are old

They will go to retire, nothing more, and I believe that the day Ronaldo retires, many people will stop following this league and many players will not go to this league and the Arabs will not be able to pay these high salaries for a long time. This project is doomed to failure. Europe has the best leagues and will be like that for many years. other continents have many problems such as corruption and dictatorships and this is destroying sport too

Saudi league will bust in a few years. The teams aren't profitable. The viewership isn't there and the overall quality isn't rising in spite of all the popular player transfers.
To say that it'll be a problem to european leagues, would mean that transferring the most popular players out would ruin the entire culture of football in Europe...

I just think that the over saturation in big money to big players is actually doing more damage though. If european leagues have to utilize the talent pool at lower leagues and also academies to get more good players. I'm all for it actually. Saudis get all the overpaid players so we can bring out more local talent. Meanwhile it would take like a couple of generations to build a football culture. Saudi Arabia's football scene will probably collapse before that can happen

Saudi Arabian clubs knows too well that the only way they can bring many European based players to their league is by spending more than European clubs will do and that's what they've been doing over the last three transfer windows. But despite the huge amount of money that Saudi leagues uses to get these European based players they are still not on the same class with European football at least for now and that's why a lot of young European based footballs are still not accepting offers to join the Saudi league despite the mouthwatering deals they offer.
Gone are those days when football is majorly played for passion of the game but that's actually not now because at the moment, a lot of footballers at just playing for the money and that's why they're easily convinced to leave their former clubs because of their excessive love for money

In the short term, all the shopping of all the expensive players last summer hasn't changed much. European football remains the most popular in the world and the Saudi league doesn't even come close. The question that arises is how long the Saudis will continue to pay extremely large sums of money. Many players are also dissatisfied with their situation. It's not just the cultural difference that matters, but also the weather. I can now imagine that the peak for the saudi league has been reached.

The money played the big role in the game of the Saudi Arabia league as compared to the European football league.The football players who had enough experience in the game was hired by the Saudi Arabia league.The huge money reason for the Saudi Arabia League was the government of Saudi Arabia had helped the Saudi Arabia Club in the funds based.This was the big lesson for the European nation to sponsor their country owned club to avoid of good players moved to the Saudi Arabia League for the money purpose.

most of players who transfer to Saudi league, want lot of money  the european football create always new players young players
the players have limited time of best playing of their life  , the same format very dificult at an old age , most athletes get tired after a period of play and effort

What you wrote is 100% true but the Saudis don't plan for short term either. In some cases, the players receive contracts for the period after their active career so that they can better build up the local system with their help. It won't be possible to become dangerous to European football overnight, but what will happen in 5-10 years? Many European clubs are heavily in debt, while Saudi clubs are essentially printing money with oil. Money doesn't matter for them and with the right strategy the SPL could become a threat.

By the way, there are now >30 well-known players that I at least know

The reason behind the Saudi League buying the top class European players like Ronaldo to try to dominant their supremacy over the other team.This also include the European Football Federation,because many players of Europe was in Saudi Arabia League.This was the master move by the Saudi Arabia League and their government of Saudi Arabia Football club.The Saudi Arabia League are ready to get the contract of players till ten years and the player may not back at the ten year contract.This was the big move by the Saudi Arabia League and can be find only by the old football fans.

right answer and this is what I want that we have to think positively about this scenario even though there will be a large transfer carried out by the saudi arabia league it does not mean there will be a loss and for sure it will be mutually beneficial in the future and we have to leave the worries about the bad that It will happen when some European star players move to Saudi Arabia, it not mean Europe will lose star players because Europe is always building new talents with younger and very reliable players like Haaland, Mbappe etc who are currently still in Europe and I'm sure Europe not lack of star players and also will not lose its popularity because we all know that almost all European football has academics to get new talent with very reliable talent.

That's a natural instinct, whenever you feel like you are losing control over something you start blaming others for it, and you won't be able to see what you did in the past that might have caused something similar to another entity. Similarly, they were obviously happy to see good players coming to Europe and joining their clubs as they had improved the quality of football in the region and brought in a lot of fans and money for the clubs and their sponsors, etc.

And now when they see they are losing their key players to another country or region, they can't digest that and I don't blame them for not being able to do that because it's not easy seeing all the good players moving out and taking their fans and everything with them and the quality of football reducing as well.

Isn't it really still negligible? There was a time when some starts went to China and there was a time when some stars went to the MLS, but none of those leagues has really turned into serious competition for Europe. If I am not completely mistaken, the players that now went to the SPL are what, 15 or 20 or how many? This doesn't change much. It kind of reminds me of forks and I have read this somewhere else already, you can't fork the ecosystem, but you can fork the blockchain.

Europe has not just been Messi + Ronaldo. It has been so much more and there is a reason it is the most prestigious place on Earth to play football. Messi vs. Ronaldo in La Liga is not the same as Messi vs. Ronaldo in the SPL.

Let's assume that La Liga from 10 years ago would have been integrated into the SPL. And then? Nothing would be the same anymore, no more Champions League between  Liverpool and Barcelona or Madrid and Manchester City. This - if at the SPL they really plan to become a global competitor - will take at least a decade to build something visible. It won't be done with just transferring 20 players per season from Europe to Saudi Arabia.

Top European players have very good potential to strengthen the team so that almost all Saudi teams are willing to spend a very large budget to be able to sign some of these top European players but not all of the top European players who go with the Saudi team are senior players or players who are nearing retirement because there are also many young players joining and interested in playing in the Saudi League.
This is like a diamond trade for the Saudi League which only attracts most of the star players to stop by and compete there but also has a bad impact on the development of the European League which can only rely on the few star players which was previously has.

Saudi important people strive to make their football league comparable with those found in Europe. They keep making enormous enticing offers for European players and signing them over, which in my opinion is not how to increase the team's excellence. Everything is an extended procedure, and we get tremendous results if they focus first on creating the structures of these teams before bringing in European players who are only here to earn treble or quadruple salaries compared to their previous ones they earned in Europe. Saudi Pro League clubs are aggressively scouting promising players and making beneficial signings during the transfer window.

You could ask yourselves what it is that's at the bottom of it all, because the transfers are the effect, but what is the cause?
IMO it's the money that Saudis have in abundance, but how did they get that much money? Because they're controlling oil prices and the whole world is bidding for it.

How could they change this situation?
They could buy it from other countries, but those that have oil deposits would require money to build infrastructure, and the West doesn't want to invest in unstable land like Venezuela, which has more oil than SA but we all know what's going on there.

They could also force people to use alternative energy sources like electric cars and that's what the EU is trying to do.

The players are businessmen, they'll work for the one who pays the most. I don't blame them and I don't blame the EU managers who can't pay as much as the Saudis. It's mainly the problem of SA making the world depend on their oil and getting filthy rich in the process while the US was printing petro dollars to pay for it all.

Many good players in the European football was taken by the Saudi Arabia league by the contract with the players.When the contractor was closes at the next summer,the most of the gamblers will back to the the European football.This Saudi is the part of the game to them,they had their own national game.Currently the European football had lack of some star players,but this was the temporary one.The players who at the age of retirement had joined the Saudi league to earn some money for their days after the retirement.Many experienced players like Ronaldo,Maples was hired by Saudi Arabia League.This players had their unique games including the Ronaldo hat trick goals.

That's what I've been saying, you couldn't deny the fact that there will be major downsides to this since these are star players, these are A-list athletes with years of experience and prowess that's transferring to a different league leaving the European Futbol with a massive spot to fill in. No doubt this will definitely subside in due time especially since we get no shortages of amazing football talents from everywhere but it would take time for the whole league to recover, until these new bloods get their big breaks and are recognized by the public.

It's one thing to be optimistic about things, it's another to be blindsided to the reality of the whole scenarios, you won't get another Messi nor Leonardo in a snap of a finger, these players take time.

In fact, it will benefit them because their league can have popular players from Europe who can make the matches even more interesting. As for the stadium, I'm sure Saudi Arabia will make a very magnificent stadium that may not exist in other countries. We know that Saudi Arabia's financial resources are very large, making it possible for the country to have all the best.

Maybe some conditions will be given by the Arab government to these famous players, but it seems that it is not a problem because it is not a matter of principle. On the other hand, these famous players will feel comfortable playing in the Saudi League because they will be given facilities that exceed what they got in the previous league.

Saudi Arabia Pro League wants to dominate the football market, and they are trying to attract players to their league. Let's say they continue to spend money on players for the next ten years. Does the European Football Federation have any stars willing to stay?
FIFA needs to step in to manage the Saudi Arabia Pro League transfer market. Otherwise, the consequences will be unpredictable.

There is another interesting fact. If Saudi Arabia can host the Fifa World Cup, don't think they will earn revenue from the World Cup event. Let's talk about the Qatar World Cup 2022. The total cost was around 220 Billion US Dollars while Fifaf earned around $7.5 Billion Dollars from the World Cup event. How much money Qatar may have earned? What do you think about it?

Qatar was unable to collect even 30 billion dollars yet this is the most successful world cup so far. So why countries still organize world cup while they lose 90% of their investment. I will leave this interesting question here.