Yes it is, I just can't figure why he's pushing XT? Anybody with the technical skills to re-code p2pool with a 42% improvement in speed should have the good sense to stay away from this XT nonsense.
This isn't really the right thread or forum for that discussion. I'll give a brief bullet-point answer. If you want to have a conversation about this, we should probably move it to a different forum or a separate thread so as not to derail this one.
1. Because I think that large blocks are technically feasible, and will not make Bitcoin insecure, inaccessible, or excessively centralized.
2. Because I think that Bitcoin can handle much larger blocks (up to about 32 MB) and transaction volumes than we currently have without any code changes (except the block size limit) or exotic hardware.
3. Because I think that there are enough possible optimizations in both code and semi-exotic hardware to bring us safely up to 8 GB blocksizes in 5 years if we try hard, and in 20 years if we are lazy.
3. Because I think that BIP101 is better than BIP100 or any other proposal out there due to its simplicity, predictability, and because I think its growth rate is reasonable and unlikely to require later changes. BIP100 would be a distant second place in my opinion if it were implemented.
4. Because I think that large blocks are the most feasible method of paying miners enough in fees once the block subsidy drops below 12.5 BTC.
5. Because I do not think that consensus among developers is a reasonable method for making technical decisions for large or controversial projects.
6. Because I do not think that consensus among any group is a reasonable method for making political decisions, much less consensus among a subset of developers.
7. Because I like the way Gavin thinks about technical and political problems.
8. Because, although I think his conduct could be more gracious and polite, I think that Mike Hearn has been right about a lot of technical and political issues lately.
You can also see some of my comments on the issue here:
https://www.reddit.com/user/jtoomim/