Guys, I just removed all the addnodes from my .conf file and started the v1.1.1.2 binary with just the hardcoded nodes to connect to. Then I let it connect and typed "getpeerinfo" into the debug console.
I think I found the culprit:
getpeerinfo
15:00:18

{
"addr" : "70.176.73.232:13931",
"services" : "00000003",
"lastsend" : 1391975633,
"lastrecv" : 1391975637,
"bytessent" : 1943,
"bytesrecv" : 14644,
"blocksrequested" : 0,
"conntime" : 1391975633,
"version" : 70002,
"subver" : "/Satoshi:1.1.1.2/",
"inbound" : false,
"startingheight" : 12660,
"banscore" : 0,
"syncnode" : true
},
{
"addr" : "64.188.167.211:13931",
"services" : "00000003",
"lastsend" : 1391975661,
"lastrecv" : 1391975663,
"bytessent" : 229,
"bytesrecv" : 8607,
"blocksrequested" : 0,
"conntime" : 1391975661,
"version" : 70002,
"subver" : "/Satoshi:1.1.1.2/",
"inbound" : false,
"startingheight" : 12384,
"banscore" : 0
},
{
"addr" : "162.243.225.132:13931",
"services" : "00000003",
"lastsend" : 1391975691,
"lastrecv" : 1391975869,
"bytessent" : 229,
"bytesrecv" : 7226,
"blocksrequested" : 0,
"conntime" : 1391975690,
"version" : 70002,
"subver" : "/Satoshi:1.1.1.2/",
"inbound" : false,
"startingheight" : 12384,
"banscore" : 0
},
{
"addr" : "50.147.39.37:13931",
"services" : "00000003",
"lastsend" : 1391975697,
"lastrecv" : 1391975704,
"bytessent" : 229,
"bytesrecv" : 8607,
"blocksrequested" : 0,
"conntime" : 1391975696,
"version" : 70002,
"subver" : "/Satoshi:1.0.0.1/",
"inbound" : false,
"startingheight" : 8211,
"banscore" : 0
},
{
"addr" : "68.43.46.243:13931",
"services" : "00000003",
"lastsend" : 1391975949,
"lastrecv" : 1391975974,
"bytessent" : 6515,
"bytesrecv" : 111250,
"blocksrequested" : 0,
"conntime" : 1391975702,
"version" : 70002,
"subver" : "/Satoshi:1.1.1.2/",
"inbound" : false,
"startingheight" : 12713,
"banscore" : 0
},
{
"addr" : "78.130.202.203:13931",
"services" : "00000003",
"lastsend" : 1391975975,
"lastrecv" : 1391975975,
"bytessent" : 5395,
"bytesrecv" : 7531,
"blocksrequested" : 0,
"conntime" : 1391975770,
"version" : 70002,
"subver" : "/Satoshi:1.1.1.2/",
"inbound" : false,
"startingheight" : 12714,
"banscore" : 0
},
{
"addr" : "71.105.130.10:13931",
"services" : "00000003",
"lastsend" : 1391975772,
"lastrecv" : 1391975773,
"bytessent" : 229,
"bytesrecv" : 6925,
"blocksrequested" : 0,
"conntime" : 1391975770,
"version" : 70002,
"subver" : "/Satoshi:1.1.1.2/",
"inbound" : false,
"startingheight" : 12660,
"banscore" : 0
},
{
"addr" : "149.210.168.71:13931",
"services" : "00000003",
"lastsend" : 1391975974,
"lastrecv" : 1391975974,
"bytessent" : 473,
"bytesrecv" : 11981,
"blocksrequested" : 0,
"conntime" : 1391975871,
"version" : 70002,
"subver" : "/Satoshi:1.1.1.2/",
"inbound" : false,
"startingheight" : 12716,
"banscore" : 0
}