But SIA still does not let me announce... So it would seem the problem lies with SIA?
Taek, any take on this? My ISP will see if they can update my firmware so maybe that could do something and SIA will also work after that, but I will let you all know how that turns out...
If it makes you feel any better, you are not the only one who has had this problem. If canyouseeme.org can find your service, then it's probably a problem with Sia.
There is a chance that you've put in the wrong local ip address. For example, one of the computers on our network is 10.0.0.35, one is 10.0.0.26, etc. They are all on different endpoints, perhaps you've selected the wrong endpoint.
My router shows the IP for that PC on the connected equipments list. Also when I run ipconfig on that same PC it tells me IPv4 Address is that same one. So that has to be the correct local IP right? What else could it be?
I'm really curious as to why people are having these problems. Most of our testing is done on Linux so it could be a Windows problem. Hard to say for sure if I can't reproduce it locally.
Maybe until we have UPnP support we should just add a "--force" option that allows you to announce even if Sia doesn't think you're reachable. I'm not sure that's a great idea though.
I don't believe its a windows issue. I had no problems once I had the local ISP flash the firmware in my basic DSL phone line type modem (not cable) and get it hard written into their server. Once done, ports are open. They have to see the device (PC that's hosting) attached to the modem, and its mac address and IP.
*I am plugging directly in to the ISP issued DSL modem for my hosting PC only. My home router plugs into it as well, but allows me to have a separate network for all other computers as an added layer of security. Keep in mind I also have a static IP.
Also, if some have DHCP set in their personal routers (which most probably do) the IP will change to the PC doing the SIA hosting occasionally if they do a reboot on router and that could issue a new IP to their hosting PC and the ports may show as closed as a result. Best to add a "reserved DHCP IP address in your personal router making the hosting PC retain a permanent IP to their SIA computer.
But this will not open the ports in your DSL modem unless you are bridged with your personal router. Most ISP modems will not allow you to edit the ports freely or directly, and if you do or can, they may be reset by the ISP back to their default settings unless they are permanently flashed as mentioned earlier.
Never had to touch windows firewall. W7 64 bit
Now if someone is using Norton etc. with a firewall feature turned on that may change the equation some?
ok, Just food for thought
ya its a bit confusing.
Obviously this is an issue going forward with using the wallet for hosting. At some point it will have to be made dummy proof for all users. Especially for large scale use as we all want and need it to be