I get different results:
YEA: 606
NAY: 5
ABSTAIN: 1872
YEA: 606
NAY: 5
ABSTAIN: 1872
Maybe Otoh just voted LOL
Topic: [ANN][DASH] Dash (dash.org) | First Self-Funding Self-Governing Crypto Currency - page 2212. (Read 9723926 times)
May 07, 2015, 11:36:52 AM
Maybe Otoh just voted LOL
May 07, 2015, 11:29:48 AM
While masternode list votes shows all the nodes, these are not working:
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c YEA
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c NAY
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c ABSTAIN
What am I doing wrong?
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c YEA
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c NAY
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c ABSTAIN
What am I doing wrong?
They don't work for me either, and I updated, so..........? I thought this chart: http://178.254.18.153/~pub/Dash/masternode_payments_stats.html would show the vote, but it doesn't. Maybe that could be included?
try :
./dashd masternode list votes | grep -c YEA
./dashd masternode list votes | grep -c NAY
./dashd masternode list votes | grep -c ABSTAIN
YEA : 657
NAY : 14
ABSTAIN : 1839
May 07, 2015, 11:26:51 AM
While masternode list votes shows all the nodes, these are not working:
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c YEA
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c NAY
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c ABSTAIN
What am I doing wrong?
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c YEA
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c NAY
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c ABSTAIN
What am I doing wrong?
Are you using the latest wallet? 11.2.23?
May 07, 2015, 11:22:24 AM
So my masternodes are all in separate wallets (i know, i need to take the time to combine). Is there a way I can use the vote-many command or do I have to open each one of them up? Also, do I vote from the cold wallet or the masternode itself?
I think you should take time now to make a masternode.conf file with the correct information from your nodes.
This way you will be able to vote with any wallet.
Later you only need to consolidate your private keys in one wallet and use the masternode.conf file already created.
In your current situation it's my understanding that you need to vote from the cold wallet (real masternode)
May 07, 2015, 11:13:24 AM
So my masternodes are all in separate wallets (i know, i need to take the time to combine). Is there a way I can use the vote-many command or do I have to open each one of them up? Also, do I vote from the cold wallet or the masternode itself?
I believe u will need to vote from each wallet and the wallet needs to be on v....23.
May 07, 2015, 11:12:07 AM
We need some action:
Otoh is on Sark, there are about 10 people who live there. If we all phone around, we could probably get someone to walk down and let him know he needs to vote
Otoh is on Sark, there are about 10 people who live there. If we all phone around, we could probably get someone to walk down and let him know he needs to vote
OTOH is in Amsterdam, I will ask him tommorow night ;-)
May 07, 2015, 11:09:59 AM
We need some action:
Otoh is on Sark, there are about 10 people who live there. If we all phone around, we could probably get someone to walk down and let him know he needs to vote
Otoh is on Sark, there are about 10 people who live there. If we all phone around, we could probably get someone to walk down and let him know he needs to vote
OTOH is in Amsterdam, I will ask him tommorow night ;-)
May 07, 2015, 11:07:46 AM
So my masternodes are all in separate wallets (i know, i need to take the time to combine). Is there a way I can use the vote-many command or do I have to open each one of them up? Also, do I vote from the cold wallet or the masternode itself?
May 07, 2015, 10:53:35 AM
While masternode list votes shows all the nodes, these are not working:
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c YEA
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c NAY
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c ABSTAIN
What am I doing wrong?
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c YEA
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c NAY
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c ABSTAIN
What am I doing wrong?
They don't work for me either, and I updated, so..........? I thought this chart: http://178.254.18.153/~pub/Dash/masternode_payments_stats.html would show the vote, but it doesn't. Maybe that could be included?
May 07, 2015, 10:51:18 AM
The vote requires 51% of the total masternodes to go through. Abstain is the default, so it means those nodes have not voted.
Geepers, it's like nobody saw this, and on page 5000 no less!!!
May 07, 2015, 10:43:12 AM
While masternode list votes shows all the nodes, these are not working:
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c YEA
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c NAY
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c ABSTAIN
What am I doing wrong?
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c YEA
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c NAY
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c ABSTAIN
What am I doing wrong?
May 07, 2015, 10:40:54 AM
We need some action:
Otoh is on Sark, there are about 10 people who live there. If we all phone around, we could probably get someone to walk down and let him know he needs to vote
BigR is probably in the tasting room, flat out drunk because he refuses to spit out the stuff he's been growing for a few months. Might have to wait until tomorrow for his votes
Otoh is on Sark, there are about 10 people who live there. If we all phone around, we could probably get someone to walk down and let him know he needs to vote
BigR is probably in the tasting room, flat out drunk because he refuses to spit out the stuff he's been growing for a few months. Might have to wait until tomorrow for his votes
Just posted up my votes.
I did some last night and I did the rest today. Cheers. 
May 07, 2015, 10:29:09 AM
RE: Voting. Right now I'm set to abstain. How do I participate in a vote?
[Wallet = v0.11.2.23, MN on v0.11.2.22) Do the NNs need to be upgraded to 23?
the vote command returns:
Error upon calling SetKey
the list vote command works just fine but looks like everyone is set to abstain. (masternode list votes)
[Wallet = v0.11.2.23, MN on v0.11.2.22) Do the NNs need to be upgraded to 23?
the vote command returns:
Error upon calling SetKey
the list vote command works just fine but looks like everyone is set to abstain. (masternode list votes)
Your MN does not need to be upgraded. Only the QT needs to be at .23. If you have more than one masternode listed in your local masternode.conf file, use masternode vote-many yea
Thanks, I was looking at the single MN command and not the many. All is well, voted.
Voted as well.
May 07, 2015, 10:25:31 AM
I am Hoping this post gets moved to page 5000 :p
May 07, 2015, 10:19:24 AM
We need some action...
“PATIENCE YOU MUST HAVE my young padawan”
Quote from: eduffield, post: 53499, member: 104
Hello Everyone!
Voting will begin immediately and be open for 2 weeks.
Voting will begin immediately and be open for 2 weeks.
May 07, 2015, 10:16:39 AM
We need some action:
Otoh is on Sark, there are about 10 people who live there. If we all phone around, we could probably get someone to walk down and let him know he needs to vote
BigR is probably in the tasting room, flat out drunk because he refuses to spit out the stuff he's been growing for a few months. Might have to wait until tomorrow for his votes
He probably is gusting the Pinot which will be brought on the table once you`ll come with your friends to consume all these 7500 liter of wine Otoh is on Sark, there are about 10 people who live there. If we all phone around, we could probably get someone to walk down and let him know he needs to vote
BigR is probably in the tasting room, flat out drunk because he refuses to spit out the stuff he's been growing for a few months. Might have to wait until tomorrow for his votes
May 07, 2015, 10:15:27 AM
I get different results:
YEA: 606
NAY: 5
ABSTAIN: 1872
YEA: 606
NAY: 5
ABSTAIN: 1872
Interesting. How are you checking results.
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c YEA
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c NAY
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c ABSTAIN
EDIT: My daemon wasn't updated. Your results were correct.
Let me get this straight.
51% Yea is required to pass.
However, 1872 Abstain? That means no pass.
Or, are we saying 1872 have yet to vote because vote starts with default set to abstain?
Or, are we saying 51% yea votes vs. nay votes, ignoring abstainers?
Sorry, only got one brain cell, and its thinking about the one thing it likes to think about most.
"Voting will begin immediately and be open for 2 weeks. We will consider the vote successful if at any time we have 51% of the masternodes support."
https://dashtalk.org/threads/vote-self-sustainable-decentralized-governance-by-blockchain.4825
So it means ABSTAIN counts as NAY.
Relax, Evan words are not carved in stone. We are in the firsts steps of a huge change in crypto.
we need to experiment, learn and change if necessary.
My opinion is that the ABSTAIN don't count. Not for yes or for no.
btw. welcome
Abstain shouldn't count for yay or nay but they shouldn't be ignored from the count either. The successful vote should require 51% of total nodes voting yay.
If you only look for 51% support from nodes that actually vote, what happens if only a total of 500 nodes vote and 51% of those 500 are yay? Heck, what if only 10 nodes voted on something and 6 of those 10 voted yes?
Only looking for 51% of the total votes that are either yay or nay isn't a fair system. Projects should be important enough to require an overall majority approval. If you cannot gain an overall majority, the project is not worth funding.
Very correct. IF the community is PRO the change they must MANIFEST that clearly. There must be 51% YEA votes: ABSTAIN means no clear manifestation of YEA, ergo it must count as NAY.
These rules (no matter what are the rules) should be agreed previously to all the votes, and the community must have some STANDARD rules, in order to avoid confusion/misunderstandings.
That's our first time, as it is normal that we will eventually err and learn... it's drinking and learning...
I don't agree.
I suggest for a votation to be valid should vote the 51% of the masternodes ("yes" or "no"). Nothing more.
Then the majority of "yes" and "no" decide.
May 07, 2015, 10:12:36 AM
We need some action:
Otoh is on Sark, there are about 10 people who live there. If we all phone around, we could probably get someone to walk down and let him know he needs to vote
BigR is probably in the tasting room, flat out drunk because he refuses to spit out the stuff he's been growing for a few months. Might have to wait until tomorrow for his votes
Otoh is on Sark, there are about 10 people who live there. If we all phone around, we could probably get someone to walk down and let him know he needs to vote
BigR is probably in the tasting room, flat out drunk because he refuses to spit out the stuff he's been growing for a few months. Might have to wait until tomorrow for his votes
May 07, 2015, 10:00:53 AM
I get different results:
YEA: 606
NAY: 5
ABSTAIN: 1872
YEA: 606
NAY: 5
ABSTAIN: 1872
Interesting. How are you checking results.
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c YEA
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c NAY
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c ABSTAIN
EDIT: My daemon wasn't updated. Your results were correct.
Let me get this straight.
51% Yea is required to pass.
However, 1872 Abstain? That means no pass.
Or, are we saying 1872 have yet to vote because vote starts with default set to abstain?
Or, are we saying 51% yea votes vs. nay votes, ignoring abstainers?
Sorry, only got one brain cell, and its thinking about the one thing it likes to think about most.
"Voting will begin immediately and be open for 2 weeks. We will consider the vote successful if at any time we have 51% of the masternodes support."
https://dashtalk.org/threads/vote-self-sustainable-decentralized-governance-by-blockchain.4825
So it means ABSTAIN counts as NAY.
Relax, Evan words are not carved in stone. We are in the firsts steps of a huge change in crypto.
we need to experiment, learn and change if necessary.
My opinion is that the ABSTAIN don't count. Not for yes or for no.
btw. welcome
Abstain shouldn't count for yay or nay but they shouldn't be ignored from the count either. The successful vote should require 51% of total nodes voting yay.
If you only look for 51% support from nodes that actually vote, what happens if only a total of 500 nodes vote and 51% of those 500 are yay? Heck, what if only 10 nodes voted on something and 6 of those 10 voted yes?
Only looking for 51% of the total votes that are either yay or nay isn't a fair system. Projects should be important enough to require an overall majority approval. If you cannot gain an overall majority, the project is not worth funding.
Very correct. IF the community is PRO the change they must MANIFEST that clearly. There must be 51% YEA votes: ABSTAIN means no clear manifestation of YEA, ergo it must count as NAY.
These rules (no matter what are the rules) should be agreed previously to all the votes, and the community must have some STANDARD rules, in order to avoid confusion/misunderstandings.
That's our first time, as it is normal that we will eventually err and learn... it's drinking and learning...
May 07, 2015, 09:55:01 AM
I get different results:
YEA: 606
NAY: 5
ABSTAIN: 1872
YEA: 606
NAY: 5
ABSTAIN: 1872
Interesting. How are you checking results.
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c YEA
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c NAY
dashd masternode list votes | grep -c ABSTAIN
EDIT: My daemon wasn't updated. Your results were correct.
Let me get this straight.
51% Yea is required to pass.
However, 1872 Abstain? That means no pass.
Or, are we saying 1872 have yet to vote because vote starts with default set to abstain?
Or, are we saying 51% yea votes vs. nay votes, ignoring abstainers?
Sorry, only got one brain cell, and its thinking about the one thing it likes to think about most.
"Voting will begin immediately and be open for 2 weeks. We will consider the vote successful if at any time we have 51% of the masternodes support."
https://dashtalk.org/threads/vote-self-sustainable-decentralized-governance-by-blockchain.4825
So it means ABSTAIN counts as NAY.
Relax, Evan words are not carved in stone. We are in the firsts steps of a huge change in crypto.
we need to experiment, learn and change if necessary.
My opinion is that the ABSTAIN don't count. Not for yes or for no.
btw. welcome
Abstain shouldn't count for yea or nay but they shouldn't be ignored from the count either. The successful vote should require 51% of total nodes voting yea.
If you only look for 51% support from nodes that actually vote, what happens if only a total of 500 nodes vote and 51% of those 500 are yea? Heck, what if only 10 nodes voted on something and 6 of those 10 voted yes?
Only looking for 51% of the total votes that are either yea or nay isn't a fair system. Projects should be important enough to require an overall majority approval. If you cannot gain an overall majority, the project is not worth funding.
Jump to: