1.2% of the current supply. Not significant.
snip-
In fact, something less than 2.5% of maxcoins spewing out at launch seems to be an acceptable number.
Try again. 450K LTC is 0.5% of the the maxcoins (84m) of LTC. The Dash instamine is now (by your calculation) 9% of the maxcoins of Dash (i.e. 18x as large). That is an enormous difference. (Not to mention that LTC didn't have a bug that created extra coins nor was the money supply cut to increase early miners' shares retroactively.)
It would not only not be safe to say, it wouldn't be correct. At all.
The bullshit you come up with about Bitcoin being "easy to mine" at the beginning is irrelevant and blatantly misleading. It is not the difficulty that is the question for an instamine, it is the rate that coins are created. In fact Bitcoin was mined extra slowly at the very beginning, because the difficulty was too high for a while, not too low.
Also, please comment about the extra coins that were produced in Dash due to a bug where the reward formula was too high (stuck at 500 when it "should" have been much lower). In Bitcoin when a bug created extra coins, the bug was fixed and the chain was rolled back erasing the extra coins. The same thing was done in Dash right? No?
As far as the proposal to change the parameters of Monero, you are missing three things:
1. It was rejected, twice, in large part because the community decided not to create a retroactive instamine. Exactly the opposite happened here.
2. The proposal was to reduce the rate of emission, but there was never a proposal to reduce the money supply, just spread out the same coins over a longer period. Instead you multiplied the early miners' share of the money supply by 4x at a keystroke like some sort of central bank. That was and is obscene.
3. Monero is entirely irrelevant to the question of the Dash instamine and money supply manipulations. You are clearly pathologically obsessed to keep bringing it up on this thread. Or perhaps deluded enough to think that is an effective confusion and obfuscation technique to shift attention from the "problem" (Evan's word) of the first 24 hours here.