At the moment this problem of the OC and temperatures is causing me great problems. there are already two RIGs, the rig of the RTX there is a card, which is more in the background that even reaches 87 and turn off the miner in security.
But I start observing the FAns in GPU, and I see that suddenly I'm at 84 and fans are lowered to 65% because it has picked up the temperature of another card, according to my rules at 84 degrees it would go to 90% fan, and repende is lowered to 65%, because that card reaches the maximum temperature of 87 and turns off the miner.
I hope you have a solution or I will have to drive MSI aftherburner again. But I really like this native solution. You should only take the value of the hottest card in the RIG and do not go changing card reading
At the same time I'm going to have to leave the fixed fans something I do not want, but of course it's a big mistake that I take the temperature data from different cards, so it can not be efficient.
Please, if you are not going to fix it, tell me already and I will change to the old system with Aftherburner or a fixed fan.
But I start observing the FAns in GPU, and I see that suddenly I'm at 84 and fans are lowered to 65% because it has picked up the temperature of another card, according to my rules at 84 degrees it would go to 90% fan, and repende is lowered to 65%, because that card reaches the maximum temperature of 87 and turns off the miner.
I hope you have a solution or I will have to drive MSI aftherburner again. But I really like this native solution. You should only take the value of the hottest card in the RIG and do not go changing card reading
At the same time I'm going to have to leave the fixed fans something I do not want, but of course it's a big mistake that I take the temperature data from different cards, so it can not be efficient.
Please, if you are not going to fix it, tell me already and I will change to the old system with Aftherburner or a fixed fan.
One of the two is wrong. Right now, like this one, you do not look at just one card, you look at all of them. Then a card, the hottest one that should be sent, is activated at 90% fan at 80 degrees, but now it turns out that another card of the same rig reaches 75 degrees and I lower the fans to 70% .. Is it more important to reduce 75 degrees or reduce 80 degrees?
Therefore the concept of temperature for a rig, should take into account only 1 card, the hottest. Because the change of speed is applied to ALL THE RIG. If the speed of the fans was independent by card, his vision would be accurate, but as it is not so, it is wrong.
I suppose I could use Atherburner only for the fans, its solution to put rules that jump at different temperatures is not valid. It can not be that I have a card at 84 degrees that would correspond to 100% of FAN, and suddenly because another card of the rig reaches 75 degrees, I lower all the rig to 75% of Fan. Obviously the card that is in 84 degrees will rise and to 86 I turn the miner to avoid problems of breakage by temperature.
Here there are only 3 solutions:
1- that the rules affect each card independently, it would be very good.
2 - Always take the value of the hottest card, this would be the optimal point, that always in the rules send the FAN the card with the highest temperature. This would be the best solution and faster in programming.
3.- re-use Aftherbuner at the same time as the native, only to control the fans.
You understand that as it is now, even with rules, if I have not activated the heat protection rule, I could have damaged cards. I like your native OC a lot, but the temperature should send the card with more heat, whatever it is inside the rig, and just follow that. If suddenly another card in the same rig exceeds the previous one in temperature, then that new card is the one that would take control of the entire RIG. TAl as it is now, yesterday I skipped the rigs every few minutes and they stopped. I could not give credit to my eyes, to see cards at 84 degrees to 100% and suddenly went down to 65% because another card had reached the goal of a rule and applied to the whole rig, that does not matter as you explain it But it's not good.
You give a greater control of fan as aftherburner or you guide by the card of more temperature of the rig, because if not, cards of those people who do not have rules of stopping the miner can be broken if it reaches 86 degrees as I have.
This kind of situations did not happen with the complete solution of aftherburner, although the connection with the main program is very bad, so I will use the native and I will see that I think so, use a fan speed curve in aftherburner, but this is already ahead of time It will be a problem for many as soon as the heat arrives.
If you have multiple Device Temperature triggers and two of them have met the conditions at the same time - there are no concept where Awesome Miner makes a guess which one of you actions that would make most sense to run - it will simply run the defined actions.
I think what you are asking for is basically a more specialized way to setup the clocking based on conditions, and the rules are very generic purpose way of doing operations and may not be refined enough for this level of per-device control.
As pointed out earlier, making the rules more device-aware could be a way forward in the future.
Update: Please also see my answer below that is a bit more solution-oriented.
You understand but half. If AM only takes the value of the hottest card, whatever is inside the rig, problem solved. You know it but you do not say it.
But right now I do not care anymore. The fan control system in AM does not work well and works perfectly Aftherburner, I do not change anymore. I stay with Aftherburner for the fans, since it takes into account each card by independent and can be curved. I tried to emulate the curve with rules, but as any card triggers contrary rules, it is a disaster.
To me now if it fixes or I do not care, I will not use it anymore. Fan control only by aftherburner.
These past weeks I have purchased professional ARTIC brand coolers to reduce the temperature for summer, but I see that AM is not up to scratch. There are other important things and in all the functions AM can not be the best. Right now native OC + Aftherburner in each machine in car and with custom curve reduces in much the temperature of each rig.
Thanks for your prompt help!