Pages:
Author

Topic: Bitcoin millionaires, tell us your story! - page 2. (Read 20532 times)

legendary
Activity: 4760
Merit: 1283
My CPA assures me that capital gains do not 'back-feed' and become earned income.

This is tricky.

From what I've read, capital gains are stacked on top of your normal income, so they will not push your regular income into a higher bracket.

But... let's say your regular income is $4000 short of the amount needed to put you in a 25% tax bracket (thus 15% tax on capital gains). If you have $10,000 in capital gains, $4000 of that will be taxed at 0% and the $6000 that puts you into the next bracket will be taxed at 15%. Your regular income is still taxed at 15%. Is that what your CPA told you?

Typical disclaimer that this is not tax advice and one should seek professional tax advice, blah blah blah.

This does NOT seem to be the message I was getting in my case.

It is critically important the my Bitcoin speculation is not associated with any form of business but is rather just a private individual adventure but I forgot the exact technical term used.  If the profits are associated with a business things get very ugly very quickly.

As always, standard disclaimer, get professional tax help and some idiot on a forum does not qualify.


As a follow-up:

My CPA's current read is that the long term capital gains DO 'back-feed' into ones income and push them into a higher bracket where the 0% rate does not apply.  She says that the verbiage has been changed slightly this year or last, and it is still a bit nebulous.

Also, I neglected to think much about my state tax.  It's 9% across the board and they don't pay any attention to the long term capital gains nonsense.

So, I'm looking at either 24% or 34% of my sales going to taxes.  It's still less by percentage than your average working stiff and less than I paid when I was one.  This is especially the case when one blows all their income on trinkets which are significantly taxed in most states, so I'm not really complaining all that much.

Had I not been pretty conservative in my financial planning when I took some BTC profits I very well could be looking at a situation where I had to sell at today's (hopefully) shitty prices.  Even so, my CPA didn't do me any favors by changing her interpretation.  The initial assurtion was a strong factor in my selling regime, and I would have massaged what in retrospect was recent peak prices more rather than waiting until 2014 to start.

Now that more people have doubtlessly been talking to their CPA's, I'd be most interested in whether other's have a different interpretation about whether capital gains impact one's tax bracket.

newbie
Activity: 59
Merit: 0
December 03, 2013, 10:51:11 PM
#86
I wish I was one of them to tell you  a story  Grin ,but sadly I am a bit late to the party. Still, trying my best to earn and invest some. Its inspiring to see other people's stories posted here. You'v been quite lucky guys.
member
Activity: 112
Merit: 10
December 03, 2013, 10:34:23 PM
#85
Well it all started in 2009 when i started bitcoin up...
sr. member
Activity: 308
Merit: 251
Giga
December 03, 2013, 08:07:40 PM
#84
Why do people dream of retiring and being "set for life" anyway. Its a pretty boring way to live.

completely agree, i'll always work even after 65 i plan to work till the end. However it doesn't mean a 9-5 year round kind of scenario i'm thinking more like work 7 months, 5 months holiday
legendary
Activity: 4760
Merit: 1283
December 03, 2013, 07:34:19 PM
#83
yeah you could hold them for a year and pay only 15%.

This is thus far the most tax-optimal strategy I've seen.

If you make less than $70,000 joint ($36,000 single?) other than your bitcoins then you can pay 0% capital gains.  So make sure that you hold them for at least a year.

I notice that the most recent Forbes article steps around mentioning the long term capital gains rate (0%) in the lower two brackets:

  http://www.forbes.com/sites/greatspeculations/2013/12/03/the-tricky-business-of-taxing-bitcoin/

Gee, I wonder why?  What scum.

hero member
Activity: 991
Merit: 500
November 29, 2013, 08:36:20 PM
#82
I'm 21, I made $10,000 from selling 2x BFL Singles I bought (I was within the first month). That's about the most I've made at one time. It felt good XD.

At one point I had 1000BTC back in 2011. I would be a BTC millionare.

Funny thing is that I tried to get so many people into BTC but no one wanted to invest/make GPU rigs. They kept telling me BTC was a scam, blah blah blah. Then when it hit the news, everyone came back to me wanting to know more info. Too bad.
sr. member
Activity: 364
Merit: 253
November 29, 2013, 07:35:10 PM
#81
If you would just treat BTC as savings, then IRS wouldn't that big of a problem. But if you start withdrawing huge lump sum. It would ring all the bells and brings the spotlight to you.
sr. member
Activity: 434
Merit: 250
November 29, 2013, 02:24:42 PM
#80
My CPA assures me that capital gains do not 'back-feed' and become earned income.

This is tricky.

From what I've read, capital gains are stacked on top of your normal income, so they will not push your regular income into a higher bracket.

But... let's say your regular income is $4000 short of the amount needed to put you in a 25% tax bracket (thus 15% tax on capital gains). If you have $10,000 in capital gains, $4000 of that will be taxed at 0% and the $6000 that puts you into the next bracket will be taxed at 15%. Your regular income is still taxed at 15%. Is that what your CPA told you?

Typical disclaimer that this is not tax advice and one should seek professional tax advice, blah blah blah.

This does NOT seem to be the message I was getting in my case.

It is critically important the my Bitcoin speculation is not associated with any form of business but is rather just a private individual adventure but I forgot the exact technical term used.  If the profits are associated with a business things get very ugly very quickly.

As always, standard disclaimer, get professional tax help and some idiot on a forum does not qualify.



That begs the next question, at what point should someone seek the advice of a tax professional? If you've made $10k I would think not.

The tricky part of this is that everyone's situation is different and everyone would have a different point at which they go to a CPA.
legendary
Activity: 4760
Merit: 1283
November 29, 2013, 02:09:40 PM
#79
My CPA assures me that capital gains do not 'back-feed' and become earned income.

This is tricky.

From what I've read, capital gains are stacked on top of your normal income, so they will not push your regular income into a higher bracket.

But... let's say your regular income is $4000 short of the amount needed to put you in a 25% tax bracket (thus 15% tax on capital gains). If you have $10,000 in capital gains, $4000 of that will be taxed at 0% and the $6000 that puts you into the next bracket will be taxed at 15%. Your regular income is still taxed at 15%. Is that what your CPA told you?

Typical disclaimer that this is not tax advice and one should seek professional tax advice, blah blah blah.

This does NOT seem to be the message I was getting in my case.

It is critically important the my Bitcoin speculation is not associated with any form of business but is rather just a private individual adventure but I forgot the exact technical term used.  If the profits are associated with a business things get very ugly very quickly.

As always, standard disclaimer, get professional tax help and some idiot on a forum does not qualify.

legendary
Activity: 4760
Merit: 1283
November 28, 2013, 11:55:58 PM
#78
yeah you could hold them for a year and pay only 15%.

This is thus far the most tax-optimal strategy I've seen.

If you make less than $70,000 joint ($36,000 single?) other than your bitcoins then you can pay 0% capital gains.  So make sure that you hold them for at least a year.

Doesn't seem to be sinking in.  As they say, 'you can lead a horse to water, but you cannot make it drink.'  -shrug-

To the guy who just replied as I was writing this (Ah, my old friend Holliday.)  See the wikipedia article on long term capital gains in the U.S., and also a document put together by someone running http://www.bitcointax.info' (who deserves a tip one of these days.)  In particular, note when the tax rate is 0%.  My CPA assures me that capital gains do not 'back-feed' and become earned income.

As always, though, seek qualified tax advice.  For my part, I will also be putting aside enough money to pay a significant tax bill should it come up as a result of different interpretations about what qualifies as LTCG half way through the year or something.  That's just the way I roll.  I'm not planning to throw away a good thing as happened to many of my fellow temporarily rich friends in the dotcom bubble.

 edit - fee -> feed and recognized my buddy.
sr. member
Activity: 434
Merit: 250
November 28, 2013, 11:34:57 PM
#77
By the way, if you held your Bitcoins longer than a year, in the US they should qualify as a capital asset and therefore you would be subject only to the capital gains tax, which is 20% a year plus some additional percentage (<5) if over $200k.



move to germany while holding on to your coins for 12 months. overhere NO CAPITAL GAINS TAX in bitcoin gains if you hold longer than 12 months. you save 200 k $. after a few months, move back...

http://www.coindesk.com/german-government-relieves-capital-gains-tax-on-bitcoin-positions/


speaking of future bitcoin millionaires: here is the party you shouldn´t miss:

https://btc1k.com/
I sent you a PM on this but ill ask publicly too in case anyone else with info can comment.  Can one just hop on a plane to Germany, get a crappy little apartment (or even stay in a hotel), and cash out all their bitcoins free of capital gains tax?  Don't you have to be a citizen, and open a Bank account?   And can you really withdraw hundreds of thousands of dollars without the german bank asking questions, blocking it, accusing you of money laundering, or simply rejecting it?  These matters are usually a lot more complex than that.  And when you go back home, how exactly do you bring hundreds of thousands of dollars with you?   

pm sent.

residency is obligatory i think. easy for u.s.americans to establish here in germany. of course there will be questions by the local authorities, but since it perfectly legal. choose a bitcoin friendly bank such as fidor bank. they have contracts with exchanges like bitcoin.de or kraken.

I would love to live in Germany for a few months. My brother lived there for awhile and loved it. I am of German heritage mostly so it would be good for me to explore my roots.

I tried to get dual American/German citizenship become of my German heritage and found out one has to be either first or second generation in order to get residency there which I am not.

If you want to avoid the taxes I believe you have to give up your US citizenship because you are still taxed as an American citizen no matter where you live.  The theory is that you are still protected by the US government and you can go into an embassy anywhere in the world as a citizen.

http://money.cnn.com/2013/09/04/news/citizenship-us-tax/

Now that I remember, I don't think you have to go to those extremes to be tax free. I believe the US government releases any tax liability if you spend at least 10 months of the year working overseas.
sr. member
Activity: 378
Merit: 255
November 28, 2013, 09:36:41 PM
#76
yeah you could hold them for a year and pay only 15%.

This is thus far the most tax-optimal strategy I've seen.

If you make less than $70,000 joint ($36,000 single?) other than your bitcoins then you can pay 0% capital gains.  So make sure that you hold them for at least a year.
sr. member
Activity: 378
Merit: 255
November 28, 2013, 09:34:44 PM
#75
Why do people dream of retiring and being "set for life" anyway. Its a pretty boring way to live.

Because I would rather do the programming projects in my head and not have to worry about making money.  Instead, right now, I have to solve other people's problems that I really don't care about and I have to work with narcissistic jerks who care more about building up some imaginary kingdom at work that doesn't matter instead of serving the client's needs.

That's why.
legendary
Activity: 1918
Merit: 1570
Bitcoin: An Idea Worth Spending
November 28, 2013, 09:27:51 PM
#74
Quote
Have you done anything special or extravagant with your money?

Sure have! I kept my three wallets on InstaWallet totally 1,123+ BTC (probably really 1,132+ BTC), and to this day have yet heard a peep as to what the status is with them, even resubmitting two of the bigger claims, with the smaller claim having multiply claims on it. But, since davout is a mod here, and Boussac released the police report on the same day it was filed, I'm sure my ~$1,335,760 USD is secured, seeing that, according to the "block chain", InstaWallet is still in control of over $2M USD.

Bruno Kucinskas
sr. member
Activity: 434
Merit: 250
November 28, 2013, 07:59:37 PM
#73
By the way, if you held your Bitcoins longer than a year, in the US they should qualify as a capital asset and therefore you would be subject only to the capital gains tax, which is 20% a year plus some additional percentage (<5) if over $200k.



move to germany while holding on to your coins for 12 months. overhere NO CAPITAL GAINS TAX in bitcoin gains if you hold longer than 12 months. you save 200 k $. after a few months, move back...

http://www.coindesk.com/german-government-relieves-capital-gains-tax-on-bitcoin-positions/


speaking of future bitcoin millionaires: here is the party you shouldn´t miss:

https://btc1k.com/
I sent you a PM on this but ill ask publicly too in case anyone else with info can comment.  Can one just hop on a plane to Germany, get a crappy little apartment (or even stay in a hotel), and cash out all their bitcoins free of capital gains tax?  Don't you have to be a citizen, and open a Bank account?   And can you really withdraw hundreds of thousands of dollars without the german bank asking questions, blocking it, accusing you of money laundering, or simply rejecting it?  These matters are usually a lot more complex than that.  And when you go back home, how exactly do you bring hundreds of thousands of dollars with you?   

pm sent.

residency is obligatory i think. easy for u.s.americans to establish here in germany. of course there will be questions by the local authorities, but since it perfectly legal. choose a bitcoin friendly bank such as fidor bank. they have contracts with exchanges like bitcoin.de or kraken.

I would love to live in Germany for a few months. My brother lived there for awhile and loved it. I am of German heritage mostly so it would be good for me to explore my roots.

I tried to get dual American/German citizenship become of my German heritage and found out one has to be either first or second generation in order to get residency there which I am not.
sr. member
Activity: 294
Merit: 250
November 28, 2013, 02:04:51 PM
#72
I don't know about USA; maybe a million dollars are not enough to retire there. But I can retire comfortably here in India with just 200 BTC.

Let me explain.

Consider the price of a Bitcoin going up to 1000 dollars in near future. That would give me $200,000. With current exchange rate (1 $ = 62 INR), it gives me 1,24,00,000 INR. Cutting down 30% tax, I will end up having around 87,00,000 INR. I can spend 700k of them right now which is enough to buy a car. I will put 50,00,000 in a bank. Believe me or not, the banks give 9% interest per year. So I'll receive 45k INR per MONTH just by sitting and doing nothing, which is how much I currently make by doing my job (and it is considered a good salary here at the  age of 30). The rest 30,00,000 I can invest in real-estate. If you know where to invest, you can easily double your money in 4-5 years here. I have my own house, so I don't have to worry about house-buying expense.

With 45k INR per month, you can have a fairly easy life in urban India. We're not talking about buying a yacht or flying different parts of world every now and then. But you can rent a good house (if you don't have your own), eat what you want, pay your bills & your kids' education, have a maid for house chores, and take your kids for a trip to different parts of India during their vacations. The returns on my real-estate investments will allow me to adjust for inflation.

So basically with 200 BTC, I retired at the age of 30 for the rest of my life. Now I if I want, I can still work for whatever job gives me joy of working.

So there you go. I have a full-proof plan. Now I just need 200 BTC. Donations are welcome at 12LEhtP1Ty9hwMDkoHJ97DkbCXHCENpdzH

Grin Cheesy
Yeah, that's the small problem, you need 200 BTC first! Cheesy
But oh well, I could live in India when I become a bitcoin-milionare! Smiley
sgk
legendary
Activity: 1470
Merit: 1002
!! HODL !!
November 28, 2013, 04:08:02 AM
#71
I don't know about USA; maybe a million dollars are not enough to retire there. But I can retire comfortably here in India with just 200 BTC.

Let me explain.

Consider the price of a Bitcoin going up to 1000 dollars in near future. That would give me $200,000. With current exchange rate (1 $ = 62 INR), it gives me 1,24,00,000 INR. Cutting down 30% tax, I will end up having around 87,00,000 INR. I can spend 700k of them right now which is enough to buy a car. I will put 50,00,000 in a bank. Believe me or not, the banks give 9% interest per year. So I'll receive 45k INR per MONTH just by sitting and doing nothing, which is how much I currently make by doing my job (and it is considered a good salary here at the  age of 30). The rest 30,00,000 I can invest in real-estate. If you know where to invest, you can easily double your money in 4-5 years here. I have my own house, so I don't have to worry about house-buying expense.

With 45k INR per month, you can have a fairly easy life in urban India. We're not talking about buying a yacht or flying different parts of world every now and then. But you can rent a good house (if you don't have your own), eat what you want, pay your bills & your kids' education, have a maid for house chores, and take your kids for a trip to different parts of India during their vacations. The returns on my real-estate investments will allow me to adjust for inflation.

So basically with 200 BTC, I retired at the age of 30 for the rest of my life. Now I if I want, I can still work for whatever job gives me joy of working.

So there you go. I have a full-proof plan. Now I just need 200 BTC. Donations are welcome at 12LEhtP1Ty9hwMDkoHJ97DkbCXHCENpdzH

Grin Cheesy
member
Activity: 84
Merit: 10
November 27, 2013, 01:28:02 AM
#70
Nope, 1 million is pocket change....  OH, and if anyone wants to feel generous, I could use a million bucks.  Just pm me, I'll even travel to pick up the money.
legendary
Activity: 2338
Merit: 2106
November 26, 2013, 05:59:00 PM
#69
By the way, if you held your Bitcoins longer than a year, in the US they should qualify as a capital asset and therefore you would be subject only to the capital gains tax, which is 20% a year plus some additional percentage (<5) if over $200k.



move to germany while holding on to your coins for 12 months. overhere NO CAPITAL GAINS TAX in bitcoin gains if you hold longer than 12 months. you save 200 k $. after a few months, move back...

http://www.coindesk.com/german-government-relieves-capital-gains-tax-on-bitcoin-positions/


speaking of future bitcoin millionaires: here is the party you shouldn´t miss:

https://btc1k.com/
I sent you a PM on this but ill ask publicly too in case anyone else with info can comment.  Can one just hop on a plane to Germany, get a crappy little apartment (or even stay in a hotel), and cash out all their bitcoins free of capital gains tax?  Don't you have to be a citizen, and open a Bank account?   And can you really withdraw hundreds of thousands of dollars without the german bank asking questions, blocking it, accusing you of money laundering, or simply rejecting it?  These matters are usually a lot more complex than that.  And when you go back home, how exactly do you bring hundreds of thousands of dollars with you?   

pm sent.

residency is obligatory i think. easy for u.s.americans to establish here in germany. of course there will be questions by the local authorities, but since it perfectly legal. choose a bitcoin friendly bank such as fidor bank. they have contracts with exchanges like bitcoin.de or kraken.
legendary
Activity: 2324
Merit: 1125
November 26, 2013, 05:22:40 PM
#68
By the way, if you held your Bitcoins longer than a year, in the US they should qualify as a capital asset and therefore you would be subject only to the capital gains tax, which is 20% a year plus some additional percentage (<5) if over $200k.



move to germany while holding on to your coins for 12 months. overhere NO CAPITAL GAINS TAX in bitcoin gains if you hold longer than 12 months. you save 200 k $. after a few months, move back...

http://www.coindesk.com/german-government-relieves-capital-gains-tax-on-bitcoin-positions/


speaking of future bitcoin millionaires: here is the party you shouldn´t miss:

https://btc1k.com/
I sent you a PM on this but ill ask publicly too in case anyone else with info can comment.  Can one just hop on a plane to Germany, get a crappy little apartment (or even stay in a hotel), and cash out all their bitcoins free of capital gains tax?  Don't you have to be a citizen, and open a Bank account?   And can you really withdraw hundreds of thousands of dollars without the german bank asking questions, blocking it, accusing you of money laundering, or simply rejecting it?  These matters are usually a lot more complex than that.  And when you go back home, how exactly do you bring hundreds of thousands of dollars with you?   

I'd say you'd at least need a residence permit.
Pages:
Jump to: