Bitcoins only exist in the cyberworld without it, there is no validation to it. So of course it cant survive without the internet. Though there will always be a way to connect to the internet and the internet will always be around as there is millions if not billions of businesses that rely on it. So I would worry about that!
BTC The Future
Topic: Can bitcoin survive without the Internet? - page 5. (Read 10943 times)
you could implement freenet in bitcoin, so you don't need centralized internet anymore
If that ever happen dark age will start. We will have to adopt on new changes.
Quote from: cryptofan5
What if someone (governments together with banks) would decide to shut down the Internet? Would bitcoin survive? Is it possible to transfer directly p2p somehow? Any thoughts? How strong this whole industry is really?
Bitcoin is an online decentralized currency. 
What if someone (governments together with banks) would decide to shut down the Internet? Would bitcoin survive? Is it possible to transfer directly p2p somehow? Any thoughts? How strong this whole industry is really?
lol
would you survive without internet?
If the internet was to ever be intentionally shut down I would be very shocked however if it were to be shut down I don't feel bitcoin would survive. I would be very stunned if they found a way for it to thrive still away from the internet.
Radio waves could work, but let's assume no wireless communication...
Bitcoin could probably survive without internet per-se, but there would still have to be a Bitcoin network. Perhaps people could print out signed transactions and deliver or mail them to their local node, which would exchange with some other nodes (either on paper of digital media such as SD cards). Each region/nation could have a "supernode" clearing-houses which would receive local transactions and send them to foreign supernodes (maybe via telegraph cables? If we are generous to ourselves) and vice-versa in order to speed the regular node-to-node propagation.
(*Sigh*, when I started this post I didn't realize how ridiculous this would sound)
I have little idea how mining would work because I don't know enough about how it works now, but presumably blocks could be distributed by the same methods, although mining might have to be done by super-nodes exclusively.
In that situation, I'd say paper currency is probably better, BUT I would like to see the look on my face when I get a letter in the snail-mail letting me know that "You've received a Bitcoin payment for 125 mBTC!" or "Your payment of 125 mBTC to 1CBNHbNNJ4C3dTELRJq312hXFwUqxg7bnm has been confirmed!"
A letter in the mail would not allow you to know if the TX was actually confirmed, nor would it allow you to check for double spends and reject the TX if your letter is a double spend.Bitcoin could probably survive without internet per-se, but there would still have to be a Bitcoin network. Perhaps people could print out signed transactions and deliver or mail them to their local node, which would exchange with some other nodes (either on paper of digital media such as SD cards). Each region/nation could have a "supernode" clearing-houses which would receive local transactions and send them to foreign supernodes (maybe via telegraph cables? If we are generous to ourselves) and vice-versa in order to speed the regular node-to-node propagation.
(*Sigh*, when I started this post I didn't realize how ridiculous this would sound)
I have little idea how mining would work because I don't know enough about how it works now, but presumably blocks could be distributed by the same methods, although mining might have to be done by super-nodes exclusively.
In that situation, I'd say paper currency is probably better, BUT I would like to see the look on my face when I get a letter in the snail-mail letting me know that "You've received a Bitcoin payment for 125 mBTC!" or "Your payment of 125 mBTC to 1CBNHbNNJ4C3dTELRJq312hXFwUqxg7bnm has been confirmed!"
You'd get a letter several days later letting you know that "Your payment of 125 mBTC to 1CBNHbNNJ4C3dTELRJq312hXFwUqxg7bnm has been confirmed!"
The nodes would. I'm sure there would probably be a fee to "connect" to nodes as well. Increased costs are to be expected any time there is a massive reduction in technology.
If Internet has shut down, the whole world will affect not only bitcoin. So I think living without the Internet nowadays is impossible to happened.
Yes, it's possible if some authority decide to shut down Internet but hope this will never happen.
Radio waves could work, but let's assume no wireless communication...
Bitcoin could probably survive without internet per-se, but there would still have to be a Bitcoin network. Perhaps people could print out signed transactions and deliver or mail them to their local node, which would exchange with some other nodes (either on paper of digital media such as SD cards). Each region/nation could have a "supernode" clearing-houses which would receive local transactions and send them to foreign supernodes (maybe via telegraph cables? If we are generous to ourselves) and vice-versa in order to speed the regular node-to-node propagation.
(*Sigh*, when I started this post I didn't realize how ridiculous this would sound)
I have little idea how mining would work because I don't know enough about how it works now, but presumably blocks could be distributed by the same methods, although mining might have to be done by super-nodes exclusively.
In that situation, I'd say paper currency is probably better, BUT I would like to see the look on my face when I get a letter in the snail-mail letting me know that "You've received a Bitcoin payment for 125 mBTC!" or "Your payment of 125 mBTC to 1CBNHbNNJ4C3dTELRJq312hXFwUqxg7bnm has been confirmed!"
A letter in the mail would not allow you to know if the TX was actually confirmed, nor would it allow you to check for double spends and reject the TX if your letter is a double spend.Bitcoin could probably survive without internet per-se, but there would still have to be a Bitcoin network. Perhaps people could print out signed transactions and deliver or mail them to their local node, which would exchange with some other nodes (either on paper of digital media such as SD cards). Each region/nation could have a "supernode" clearing-houses which would receive local transactions and send them to foreign supernodes (maybe via telegraph cables? If we are generous to ourselves) and vice-versa in order to speed the regular node-to-node propagation.
(*Sigh*, when I started this post I didn't realize how ridiculous this would sound)
I have little idea how mining would work because I don't know enough about how it works now, but presumably blocks could be distributed by the same methods, although mining might have to be done by super-nodes exclusively.
In that situation, I'd say paper currency is probably better, BUT I would like to see the look on my face when I get a letter in the snail-mail letting me know that "You've received a Bitcoin payment for 125 mBTC!" or "Your payment of 125 mBTC to 1CBNHbNNJ4C3dTELRJq312hXFwUqxg7bnm has been confirmed!"
You'd get a letter several days later letting you know that "Your payment of 125 mBTC to 1CBNHbNNJ4C3dTELRJq312hXFwUqxg7bnm has been confirmed!"
Radio waves could work, but let's assume no wireless communication...
Bitcoin could probably survive without internet per-se, but there would still have to be a Bitcoin network. Perhaps people could print out signed transactions and deliver or mail them to their local node, which would exchange with some other nodes (either on paper of digital media such as SD cards). Each region/nation could have a "supernode" clearing-houses which would receive local transactions and send them to foreign supernodes (maybe via telegraph cables? If we are generous to ourselves) and vice-versa in order to speed the regular node-to-node propagation.
(*Sigh*, when I started this post I didn't realize how ridiculous this would sound)
I have little idea how mining would work because I don't know enough about how it works now, but presumably blocks could be distributed by the same methods, although mining might have to be done by super-nodes exclusively.
In that situation, I'd say paper currency is probably better, BUT I would like to see the look on my face when I get a letter in the snail-mail letting me know that "You've received a Bitcoin payment for 125 mBTC!" or "Your payment of 125 mBTC to 1CBNHbNNJ4C3dTELRJq312hXFwUqxg7bnm has been confirmed!"
A letter in the mail would not allow you to know if the TX was actually confirmed, nor would it allow you to check for double spends and reject the TX if your letter is a double spend.Bitcoin could probably survive without internet per-se, but there would still have to be a Bitcoin network. Perhaps people could print out signed transactions and deliver or mail them to their local node, which would exchange with some other nodes (either on paper of digital media such as SD cards). Each region/nation could have a "supernode" clearing-houses which would receive local transactions and send them to foreign supernodes (maybe via telegraph cables? If we are generous to ourselves) and vice-versa in order to speed the regular node-to-node propagation.
(*Sigh*, when I started this post I didn't realize how ridiculous this would sound)
I have little idea how mining would work because I don't know enough about how it works now, but presumably blocks could be distributed by the same methods, although mining might have to be done by super-nodes exclusively.
In that situation, I'd say paper currency is probably better, BUT I would like to see the look on my face when I get a letter in the snail-mail letting me know that "You've received a Bitcoin payment for 125 mBTC!" or "Your payment of 125 mBTC to 1CBNHbNNJ4C3dTELRJq312hXFwUqxg7bnm has been confirmed!"
You'd get a letter several days later letting you know that "Your payment of 125 mBTC to 1CBNHbNNJ4C3dTELRJq312hXFwUqxg7bnm has been confirmed!"
What if someone (governments together with banks) would decide to shut down the Internet? Would bitcoin survive? Is it possible to transfer directly p2p somehow? Any thoughts? How strong this whole industry is really?
When they shut down the internet, they shut down their own system in that area. No banks, not ATM, not Cellular phones, no phones, nothing, nada, bla, puff.
Or do you talk about the world wide web?
p2p directly? when you have two computers and connect them together you have a p2p network. Do you have a clue, what you are talking about? Me not.
There is no chance in hell that internet will be "shut down", there can be variations on the theme of censorship, blocking the bitcoin traffic, but that would fail,
as people would allways find a way to go around.
Thinking that anyone would go as far as shutting down whole internet to kill bitcoin, is like trying to kill a fly with a nuke
as people would allways find a way to go around.
Thinking that anyone would go as far as shutting down whole internet to kill bitcoin, is like trying to kill a fly with a nuke
as long as there is some way of connecting peers with enough other peers.
can be done in many ways.
internet is just the most practical approach we know of.
although one could argue any type of connection between multiple computers is internet, and they would be right.
so yes, you need internet, but not necessarily the same internet.
can be done in many ways.
internet is just the most practical approach we know of.
although one could argue any type of connection between multiple computers is internet, and they would be right.
so yes, you need internet, but not necessarily the same internet.
I don't think there is a business nowadays which does not exist and does not make any profit through the Internet.
But in the case of Bitcoin, it is a cryptocurrency. Of course it can't exist without the world wide web.
But in the case of Bitcoin, it is a cryptocurrency. Of course it can't exist without the world wide web.
If Internet has shut down, the whole world will affect not only bitcoin. So I think living without the Internet nowadays is impossible to happened.
Yes, it's possible if some authority decide to shut down Internet but hope this will never happen.
Yeah because without North America the internet, nay the world could not survive!
legendary
Activity: 2884
Merit: 1115
Leading Crypto Sports Betting & Casino Platform
Thats the weirdest hypothetical situation i have seen on these forums
Then you have not seen can we use Bitcoin for transactions from mars to earth.
In a form can Bitcoin survive without the internet probably not but apply it to space as well.
If Internet has shut down, the whole world will affect not only bitcoin. So I think living without the Internet nowadays is impossible to happened.
Yes, it's possible if some authority decide to shut down Internet but hope this will never happen.
Thats the weirdest hypothetical situation i have seen on these forums
i do not think so
No.
Of course not, bitcoin can't survive without internet connection
and if internet has been shutdown the world like night without the moon
but i think we can use local connection, but it only use in the small scale
Of course not, bitcoin can't survive without internet connection
and if internet has been shutdown the world like night without the moon
but i think we can use local connection, but it only use in the small scale
Jump to: