Topic: Can we expect some active mod in India forum? (Read 1413 times)

So, as soon as you created a Telegram group, where you are the owner, you do not a need a moderator anymore! Being the defacto leader of your telegram group, your are crying decentralization here!

@Heisenberg_Hunter To achieve your mission to be the moderator and merit source of Indian board, you have lost the track of your lies. Watch your steps buddy.

If the reports were made for an Indian language, the report gets marked as unhandled and none of the mods would act upon them since they are not really aware of the language. That's the bigger problem which lies in the Indian Board. The English reports are getting handled quite often as they are meant to be and there seems to be not much problem associated with that. We also need to note that we don't need to report posts in Off-Topic (India) unless they are promotional spams.

mitzie or Rickbig (Not sure)

Cryptocurrency forum like bitcointalk.org may be a 10 year old but it does not mean that it could address all the problems in the forum especially when it comes to languages and the differences of the users coming from around the world.

In the case of OP still needs to be patient as the forum still growing and who knows one day theymos might consider giving every local forums to have another sub forums classified in the likes of major section of bitcointalk loke the SMT, owns a meta sub board, Technical discussions and etc.

Again, for now let us be patient. Remimder that patient is a virtue.

Could be possible that mod acted on the basis of the report that someone already made prior to report made by you. Maybe in that case his report was  marked as "Good" and yours as "Unhandled" because yours didn't needed any action afterwards since it was already settled.

I don't usually report now but I was into it last year I guess and I still have 4-5 unhandled reports from that time. 

There are certain aspects that i have to mention here buddy since i am seeing these type of thread too often regarding a moderator. Is it possible to clear the entire mess, yes it is possible if you spend some days to clear everything up.

I will show you one aspect of my report history where one moderator passed  and market as Unhandled with my report while i did report again with detailed explanation on what to do with the post and it went through. I was planning to clean up everything but then when i saw that some of the post takes a longer time to get resolved mainly older post, i took a break from reporting older posts even though they are trash, i know i am bugging the mod with my reports  but will clean everything up in due time.

After reading the  eality below reply , erikalui , I can say that "Unhandled report " in your case is soft bad.Mods are unsure whether they should take action on it or not. So it will remain unhandled forever.

I think this is a bigger problem that has been left unhandled even after a year it was observed and reported. There is now another thread opened about similar issue here https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/need-advice-from-respected-big-rank-members-for-cleaning-indian-local-board-5147676

Theymos should see this as a necessity and act.

I guess enough time has passed ,since the removal of the Indian Moderator. Theymos ,please appoint someone as a moderator in Indian subboard.

You can find the name of some recommended members here.

^My unhandled reports have remained the same since a week. I don't know if there is any time limit for these reports but I stopped reporting after that as I felt no mod will handle them.

To be quite true, the board is transforming itself into a off-Topic Local Board.   Most of the topics started in the Indian Board are just for post count and either is unnecessary to the forum as a whole. Why do we need to know When we bought our first bitcoin?. Topics like this does generate spam and people around there are just posting  to complete their post quota per week. Since they aren't being moderated, they are free to talk shit and get away with the money.

Reports in the Indian Section should be considered for a moderator to be appointed for that board, if they aren't willing to report much they are not fit to be a moderator. theymos is the only guy who can provide us these stats!

 legenster is a good to be made a moderator, but we are not really sure he is ready to accept the position and work for that. He was literally inactive for most of the time last year, so what if he becomes inactive after he was appointed as a MOD?  Similarly with amishmanish, (a really good poster who has better knowledge on btc and forum workings) but he isn't really active from last year.


Not true. I reports around 20-30 spams and malicious links per month for the past 1 year from the Indian Board and just 2 of them were unhandled till now. One was the Unofficial Rules, and the other was the CURA Network translation.


Handling reports doesn't work that way. Initially you report a spam, they get accumulated in the unhandled queue of the global moderators (since India board doesn't have a moderator). They handle the report when they feel like the comment you gave is right for the topic/post to be trashed. For instance, if hilarious doesn't handle the report it goes to mprep and if he doesn't handle them it reaches out to rickbig. If all the 3 have rejected them, it remains in the unhandled state forever.


Benson was from south and probably he wasn't good in Hindi. This is why the Altcoins(India) sub-board and the Translations weren't moderated right from the beginning.

The only solution to this could be, theymos should hire 2 forum users as Indian moderators. One should handle only the translations and other one should manage all the other Indian sub-boards. The Translator MOD should receive higher pay than the normal guy.

^ I don't know even why that signature campaign is paying for posts in the Indian section when the section is almost dead.

All my reports from the Local Indian board have been unhandled. It's almost instant now means the moment anyone reports, it is marked unhandled. 

However, translators even before never did a proper job as Benson never handled any reports. His Hindi was itself bad:

Lot of grievances coming from the Indian boards.

People are posting low quality to get bonus for posting in local boards.

Translators are not doing the job properly.

It is more than year passed that Indian board is without Mod after Coinsecure hack.

This is true that most Indian do not visit that board because when you access the global boards that are using same language( English) then better to discuss in global boards instead of posting in local board unless your issue is local.
Moderators are not elected but appointed by theymos.



If you need any help in Hindi, you can ask me. I am native Hindi speaker.
I suspect there might be many Indians like me that never created a single post there and rarely(or not at all) visit that board.

There is not much active threads coming up in India local board and most of my reports are sorted by global mods, overall I have 920 reports with 99% accuracy and if they find it as a hectic job they will appoint someone to share the duties. There is a lot of sorting to be done as well as new child boards are needed to clear the entire mess. It is possible to revamp everything by trashing the spam and meriting users who take an effort thereby creating a healthy local board.

That will be tough to get one, or 3 different mod will be required, lol. India has a lot of local languages and it will be impossible for a person to handle most of them.

The Indian board has always been a hotbed for spammers, shitposters and more importantly scammers to promote their shitty scammy exchanges and offers. Benson was active in managing the spams only during 2017 and the board became bad right back in the start of 2018. After the coinsecure hack I guess he won't just get back to the forum to moderate the board or has become quite busy lately.

Topics similar to these generate insane amount of spam by newbies and signature spammers to fill their post count criteria. Moreover such kind of topics doesn't help anyone and is more or less a spam generation topic which must be locked after certain replies or must be trashed. Also framing this as a legimate topic is not exactly right. On top of that topics like these, bring referral spammers to share their link. These newbie referral spammers probably necro bump very old topics to share their links to earn a few pennies.

I don't really post anything on the Indian board but I am a regular visitor to merit few good posts (which I rarely find) and trash the shit present out there. From what I have identified after 9 months of reporting hundreds of posts is that

1. The board lacks few sub boards such as Altcoin Announcements, Scam Accusations and Reputation Board. These are literally important since Altcoin Announcements are being spammed in the Regional Languages Board and Altcoins(India) Board.
The regional board should be used for discussing about Btc in Regional Languages.

2. The Altcoins (India) board is full of translation spams and most of them are being completely translated by Google Translator. Apart from very few trusted translators like erikalui who do their work sincerely, almost all the other translators are using Google Translator and lack the basic language skills to translate announcements. I can bring out those guys to limelight, but I am not a native Hindi guy and my assumptions might be wrong. If they are to be caught, those translations are to be removed and they should be painted red from DT.

3. A moderator is just a volunteer and not a defacto leader of the community. Most of the Indians believe that the Mods are leaders to govern them. A MOD is only for rearranging posts in right board, prevent spams at a larger extent and nuke newbies if they believe they are plagiarising or promoting scams.

4. Indian board is populated by newbie spammers (spambies with activities not higher than 1) and there isn't literally any real discussion taking place. There are few handful of good posters (TheUltraElite, avikz, amishmanish, legendster, newIndia, deadly,botany, Joel_Jantsen) who rarely visit the board (probably being more inactive) to share their thoughts and involve in discussion.

5. Most of them lack the knowledge to indulge in discussion and talk bullshit without reading previous replies. One liner spams, duplicate posting has been common in most of the topics in Indian board.

6. Most of the topics created in the board are for promoting new scam exchanges, a futuristic spam topic which would be populated soon enough by spambies.
This forum is for discussing and expressing thoughts and not for discussing shits to spam the forum.

It is clear that an elected mod can only clear the ongoing spams but can never bring back the board as it was used to be Benson period. Clearly stating that, the board lacks good posters/ the posters have moved on to main board and doesn't want to get themselves squinted with the ongoing spams.

And we need to take into account that India is a nation where centralization plays a major role. The elected moderator must not suppress the other members through his power. He must act as a fellow member along with others and needs to bring back old good posters who were active in the Indian board during Benson era.

IMHO The board is currently controllable with reports (assuming they are getting handled quite quickly). If the situation gets out of hands i.e reports are not regularly handled then we should pressurize theymos for appointing someone.

P.S could anyone spot an instance of at least one referral code spam in the Indian Board right now? It won't be, because I along with other reporters report them quite often and they are getting handled at a faster rate. The only child board which isn't moderated/reported right now is Altcoins (India) child board. There are huge google translation spams taking place, but since I am not a native Hindi guy (but can speak,read and write Hindi to quite an extent) I may still be bad at my decisions. I am open to PM from reputed native Hindi speaking Indians if they are willing to work with me to bring out those translation spammers.

P.P.S I have been viewing this topic since the time it was posted, and was reading through all the replies. I guess this should be the right time to appoint a MOD since the translators are getting out of control.

@theymos could you give us the statistics of who reports quite often in the Indian Board?

Not many senior or legendary Indian member hangout in Indian board. very handful member visits the local thread regularly. we surely need Indian guy who can Moderate local thread and who can understand at least 3 local languages(Tamil, Bangla, Hindi). otherwise, we need more than one.

I vote for the same. It's been a long time since BensonSamuel was removed from his position as moderator of Indian Board. I  also don't mind if BensonSamuel again holds of that position if the Coinsecure incident was settled to the satisfaction.

Same discussion: https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/indian-sub-new-moderator-recommendations-welcome-3319980

Yes, you are correct anyone is posting anywhere due to which most of the members of India are not even looking to Indian Board. If we try to re-elect the moderator then it would be good

Done - https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/why-my-topic-was-removed-5094774

In connection with the needs of the new moderators in the Indian forum, I also support this thread topic, as a means for members especially in India, whether on forums, ICOs, etc., in general or moderators in particular (new moderators, I hope you don't mind advice from thmember, for the good of the india forum for the sake of togetherness too). Because remember, members who submit criticism are answered for suggestions to be made in place to avoid spamming, fraud, scammers, etc.

I think to be able to make the Indian forum a free forum, to express opinions as long as the topics discussed are still related to the main topic of the Indian forum.

For that Moderator, in the most basic and simple sense is a person who is given the mandate to regulate the course of the forum. It is indeed difficult, at least, the mod can represent three interests: the interests of the organizing committee, understanding of the participants, and the interests of the speaker,

I regret:
For now there are still frequent misunderstandings, the moderator is considered the second caste in a forum, under the speaker. This is a wrong understanding.

The truth is:
Mod responsibilities, functions, and moderator duties are very important, so the degree is the same as the speaker, sometimes even higher, I also hope there is a solution for the Indian forum section.

Create a new topic for it. This topic is for getting Moderator. I do not think any global moderator will look inside this topic to reply to you.

Sorry to wake up this Zombie. India subforum now needs a dedicated mod more than ever. Not only the sub is getting full of unrelated topics, legitimate topics are being removed!

Here is an instance, where I have been a victim. Following is from BitcoinTalk Modlog (http://archive.vn/QKmpX)...

Remove topic: Where did you buy your first bitcoin from? in topic #5092398 by member #237466

May I know why the above said topic of mine was removed?

But you can see that almost all signature campaigns or bounty campaigns dont entertain local post in their campaigns. That is why not most of them are really interested in posting in their respective local boards. Even Local boards are mainly used for translation purpose only if i am not wrong.

I don't think we don't have any trusted community member from that local board to have him as moderator and I don't know how much active members in that local board which needs an speparate merit source for now but it is important to add merit source too all the local boards in the upcoming future to keep the balance among the local speech with the main discussion boards.

I don't think theymos is putting much priority on those. However, I think Indian subforum needs an active moderator.
It can be the OP himself or legendster. legendster is an active one. He can be good candidate.

Benson Samuel is no more the moderator of the Indian Board. (after Coinsecure scam/(or hack) not very sure). So right now Indian Board is without moderator. Few days back I look statistics of merits in Indian local board, look like they do not have merit source also.
I think both factors should be demotivating for anybody posting there.

This can only be solved by the Admin appointed moderator but Benson is long time not active and as everyone knows that he is involved in Coinsecure exchange so i think he wont be back to his job as right now cryptocurrency is in the legal battle and till their is no result i think nothing will be solved.

This^ + Pinned threads on the main board are pretty old and outdated. Most of the services referred in those threads do not exist anymore. But, as we do not have an admin, there is no one to unpin those threads.

After six months of reporting...

A. Current state of Main Board - http://archive.is/zUjCi

1. Ethereum Ponzi - PANDORA.gives - 1098% per year or 3% every day, decide for yourself

2. Nothing to do with India - How to make money from bounty

3. ICO Scam - Pexo exchange launches ICO - Private sale is live

4. Nothing to do with India - Telegram messenger service Iran's scammer group active

5. Post should go under Regional Languages (India) - Any tamil speaking person here?

6. Post should go under Alt Coins (India) - Free ways to get ETH

7. Nothing to do with India - Register and you can earn coins immediately! Our crypto exchange welcomes you.

B. Regional Languages (India) is full of meaningless spam & scam - http://archive.is/VrWQj

C. Buyer/ Seller Reputations (India) has turned into an alternative to Marketplace (India)

Personally I think Bitcointalk is not what it used to be anymore. There are some active members but almost everyone is into signature campaigns which leads to spam posts etc.
However I agree that mod should be active enough to remove spam/trash from this subforum.

There are a lot of problems with Indian sub forum and the problem you highlighted is the major. I also see a lot of senior members making posts there which are not relevant to that section.

For instance consider this:

https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/what-is-merit-and-how-will-it-help-you-get-promoted-2945634

It is a good post but it should have been posted in meta in my opinion.

This site, Stake.com, is spamming in all local sections. They create a post and daily post spam on that post or create a new one. When there are no active moderators, nobody can do anything.

It is necessary to pay more attention to these local sections if we want the forum to grow in an organized way. Have more trusted moderators, have more sources of merit, have more subsections.

After one month of reporting...

A. Local language topics are one Main Board instead of Regional Languages (India) - http://archive.is/Me35I

i. हमारी टीम आईसीओ परियोजनाएं प्रदान करने मे

ii. "लोगों के cyberwar के खिलाफ भ्रष्टाचार"


B. Regional Languages (India) is full of ICO Announcements - http://archive.is/PFMb9


C. Gambling spams are running on Marketplace (India) - http://archive.is/LDBW0

i. Stake.com | Bitcoin Casino | Mines, Blackjack, Roulette, Baccarat + 8 games

ii. Primedice#1 Bitcoin Gambling Website | 100% provably fair | over 112 BTC Jackpot

I visited the India forum once but never posted there because:

1) It is full of scams. There are a number  of promotional posts there from different members. Some are promoting their shady exchanges and some want to teach tricks through their blogs full of copied content.

2) I also observed that very less posts are merited there. There are few good posts there and they get no attention. This might be the reason for genuine users not being much active there and posting in other sections like "Bitcoin Discussion".

Looks like nothing has changed in last 14 days. Current state of the board - http://archive.is/Xv8va.

Alt coin & ICO discussions are still rampant on the main board.

1. Any other reliable exchange for Ethereum

2. We translated the site in Hindi, is it important or do we waste money?

3. Any Real ICO in India?

4. New coin - JIOCOIN

5. Telegram TON Gram ICO!

6. 🚀🚀🇨🇭🇨🇭ADENIUM.IO🇨🇭🇨🇭🚀🚀NEW LENDING PLATFORN🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

7. What is Ethereum?

8. The translator is needed!

9. Jio coin in India

10. Which is best- Bitcoin, Ripple or Ethereum?

100% agreed. Benson was a pretty active mod a few years back. But, now, most probably due to his involvement with CoinSecure, he barely works on the India forum. User newIndia himself/herself is far more active in the India forum and hence, I believe, he/she should take up the responsibility now.

True, there is so much spam in Indian sub forum these days, even many post in wrong section or just spam to increase their ranks.

P.S. If Theymos think, I am eligible, I can give sometime to moderate Indian sub forum.

Yes exactly. The change is needed for sure. Even the market place is filled with discussions or people promoting their referral links to earn pennies. Discussions are filled with lame questions which are not even worth answering. Benson is one of the pioneers of the Indian Bitcoin community and there is no denying it. But he has not been that active here lately (looking at his posts) maybe because of his personal life and busy schedule (as he runs one of the major Indian exchanges).

I am pretty confident there are a lot of active legendary members here form India who would volunteer to be a mod along side Benson to clean up the mess.

A few of the big local boards probably need an additional moderator. It's a lot of work just for one person and it can become overwhelming pretty quickly and Benson Samuel doesn't really seem to be active much at all so I can see why there'd be issues. When users realise they can get away with spam they quickly abuse it with bots and spam etc like we're seeing in the Chinese section.

Forum: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?board=89.0 - http://archive.is/RJPL4


Alt coin & ICO discussions are taking over the main board. Mods are not moving them to Alt Coins (India)...

1. Fake Indian Ico !!

2. Ripple : The next Bitcoin

3. List of Indian Ico's

4. When is Jio Coin Launching?

5. Indian ICO Listing website?

6. Ripple can become next Bitcoin?

7. What are the factors one should think before investing in a ico?

8. Daily Airdrops

9. Any Real ICO in India?


Referral spams are running on the main board for weeks...

1. Primedice #1 Bitcoin Gambling Website | 100% provably fair

2. Stake.com | Bitcoin Casino | Mines, Blackjack, Roulette, Baccarat + 8 games

3. Synereo AIRDROP:Guaranteed Profit$ | Listed On Big EXCHANGES/COINMARKETCAP

4. SHARD [SCRYPT] [POS/POW] High % ROI Staking with a Purpose


Due to the low quality posts on this sub, I had to stop directing people in India to check the same.