I have outlined a plan for mitigating the potential of BTC Guild obtaining 51% of the network, by attacking the problem with increasing severity at 40% and 45% of the network. The current plan can be found here:
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/ann-btc-guilds-mitigation-plan-168108Current users will mostly be affected by the proposal to increase fees on the pool, if BTC Guild's share of the network continues to increase. This was not in the original proposal, but talking with several people, it seems to be the most effective way to shave off some of the pool's hash rate without FORCING miners to leave. The key points for current users are:
1) At 40% of the network (using blockorigin.pfoe.be as the indicator): PPS fee will be increased to 7% for all new miners. Old miners will see the new fee at the next difficulty as well. The fee will be dropped back to 5% when the pool drops back down under 40%.
2) At 45% of the network: Getwork pools will be shut down within 24 hours. This means users on BTC Guild will need to upgrade to a Stratum based miners or use a Stratum proxy on their machines to continue mining if they are not already doing so. mergedmining.btcguild.com WILL remain online as a getwork pool at first, but may also get taken down.
3) If 40% of the network happens again after removing getwork (will need time for the 2016 block average to adjust): PPLNS fees will be increased to 4%. Again, this fee will be dropped back down once the pool has dropped back down to a sub-40% level.
I am doubtful #2 and #3 will be required. I think the problem is getting enough attention at this point, but a plan is needed so miners are not caught off guard by sudden changes.
I hope the loyal and long time Guild miners understand why these steps are necessary for the Bitcoin network as a whole. I hate the idea of pushing people away forcefully, but steps must be taken to make other pools seem more appealing if BTC Guild grows too large.
I would like to thank all the current miners for what the pool has become today. I never expected a project that started as a LAMP server running on mining rig in my dining room to grow into something like this.