Hi Steve,
thank you for the further questions.
I have a related question: It seems like the amount withdrawn from an account (net of Fees) should match the amount deposited in another wallet. If that is correct, it follows that fees associated with a transfer should reduce the balance in the sending account just like the amount transferred out does. This does not appear to be the case in CoinTracking. To test this, I manually changed the fee for a transfer out from .002 to 40 Dash to see what would happen. The balance for that currency did not change in CoinTracking. What am I missing here?
Thanks,
Steve
All values entered on Cointracking are with fees included. They are gross.
To change the value of the fee you would have to change the whole amount of the coin. Thus, the field where you can adjust the fee is not taken for calculation purposes. It´s only an informational value. If you change it, it does not change your balance. We decided to do this because you want to see how much money you spent overall and not just the net worth.
I have a strange one. I don't know if it is a problem with the export from Bittrex, a reporting problem on the exchange, or a problem with CoinTracking or all of the above. I have two DASH transactions. On each trade, I purchased DASH and then almost immediately transferred it to my own wallet. In each transaction, the Bittrix account online shows that the net amount transferred out is .002 less than the net purchase, which I presume reflects a network fee, but no fee is reflected in the Transfer out transactions. The transfer in transactions on my wallet match the net send transactions from Bittrex. Since there is no fee reflected in the out transactions, I might think the Dash balance on Bittrex would be .004 DASH. But it's not, the Bittrex balance is zero Dash. Which would be correct if the .004 difference is network fees, despite the fact that transfer fees aren't accounted for anywhere. Now here is the really strange part: The Dash balance shown in CoinTracking is .002 Dash. One would think that it would either be .004 or zero, but NOT .002.
Also, if I edit the Bittrex out transactions to reflect the presumed .002 network fee, it has no impact on the coin balance in CoinTracking, which I guess makes sense.
Any idea what is going on?
Thanks,
Steve
Please take a look at this page:
https://cointracking.info/feedback.php under "How do I enter my fees" for more information, about this question and the previous one.
Most exchanges only show you the net worth of your transactions, because they don´t like to show the costs they charge you. We at Cointracking want to show our users the gross value. This is more realistic and we handle it the same way as banks or other institutions do it. It´s just the way we decided to do things.
I hope this is helpful for you.
Best regards,
Keven