Topic: GROUP ACTION: CRYPTSY EXHANGE NEGLIGENCE - TAKE ACTION - page 5. (Read 20160 times)

I completely agree. Currently the altcoin community is fairly dependent on Cryptsy and shutting them down or entangling them with regulators is probably not a good first step. They know we need them right now and are counting on it, otherwise no one would tolerate this service.  I think with coordinated community pressure we can achieve the same effect without further putting the community at risk. Again my goal here is not to harm Cryptsy but to put pressure on them to improve the way their user base is treated, and improve the reliability of their servers and related systems.

How to change when they are holding our money, son.

This is for the sake of the community, not for personal gain. I see you are a selfish money-grabbing bastard. Now go away.

Change exchange if you don't like cryptsy.

taking actions to shut down another exchange doesnt seem all that beneficial to the community.  Maybe instead some ideas on what steps they need to take to solve their current issues and some possible workaround for them that they havent come up with.  In an ideal world of course this shouldnt be necessary but keep in mind how undeveloped this community/ network still is.  We need to build not destroy.

So that when you need them they cannot be withdrawn and get stolen. That's the sort of people from which Cryptsy profits from.

The bitcoin forums is probably not the best place to actually take action.
I've never had a problem with Cryptsy.  But then again I've never needed to deal with their customer service department.

Accoriding to occ.gov they're registered as a money transmitter, I can't find anything showing they are registered as a broker/dealer though which is something that I assume would be nessecary for them to operate an exchange.  The best bet is to file a report directly with Fincen, explain that they are a money transmitter and they are failing to actually transmit money.  You could also complain to the SEC and mention that the site seems to indicate that they are a broker/dealer but they are failing to execute their responsibilties or are acting with malfeasance.  I'm not sure what the SEC could really do here if they aren't registered, but it's something I would do in a similar situation.

Finally florida has their own financial regulation office.  http://www.flofr.com/  looks like they have a division to deal with securities dealers and another to deal with money transmitters, not sure which would actually apply here, but it couldn't hurt to give them a call at (850) 487-9687 and ask them under what license Project Investors Inc DBA Cryptsy is operating under and who the dispute arbitration body is.  Then file a dispute there.

Again I've personally transacted hundred of thousands of DOGEs and other altcoins through there on autosale from a pool I was mining at and never had more than a 24hr delay.
I've been mining on multipool.us with auto payouts going to cryptsy and then autosales from cryptsy into BTC.  Perhaps a few hundred dollars worth in total and never had more than a 24hr delay.

Still it might be good for someone to do some digging and if you have a problem those are the right places to take action, I think.

We are talking about trading, not storing. Why would you store coins in online exchange?

well as i say never store a hugh amount of coins in online exchance websites,
i dont say i do not trust them but incase of this you would loose to muts coins


pay fee for transactions ok but a 2,5 % or 1,5 % fee for transactions is alot then wen you want to withdraw coins you get if <0.1 no withdraw becouse they dont win on your coins .....


there should be no limits to withdraws at leat you can pay fee for that : no Limits !!

Thanks for starting this thread, this is a huge eye opener for anyone new starting out..

I agree with this. I've been burned trying to do any arb involving their exchange because deposits and withdrawls take forever, and any time I want to use it, deposits are broken, or withdrawls aren't working. That, or their useless fucking trading engine is showing sell orders far below the current buy price, or I have to tell it 10 fucking times to trade something before it actually goes through, then it buys it %10 higher than what I even set the price at.

The only thing they have going for them in my eyes is the fact that they have always eventually credited my account what was owed, even if I didn't miss it.

I was one to get screwed over cryptsy last month when their servers glitched over the Quark overload, I've sent Bitjohn numerous requests and other mails to which I got an automated response and they have not solved my issue. The overall result was over negative .2 BTC and -100 WDC which I had to repay on top of the depreciation of Quarks had. I was patient for over a week until I gave up hope. My original ticket said "resolved" and I can't find the original claim but here is what I left BitJohn in the other thread "cryptsy stealing money", to which of course I got no response...

@BitJohn I can say your support is terrible on cryptsy, and at one of the most critical times where people have been stiffed, including myself. What can you say to the fact that many people have lost money due to your server negligence, system delays, balance issues? Was it my fault that I placed an order at night and somehow it got doubled, and I could not cancel and was left with negative balances that I had to pay out of my own pocket? Is that fair, no. I almost sought out legal aid because despite your server crashes and system malfunctions it is not my fault as a trader to bear crytpsy's faults. Yeah for those two weeks what did I get? Automated messages telling me to audit my account (which did not work) and my account unable to trade for a portion of that which made me go crazy thinking I've been scammed, which technically I did. Cryptsy must really be enjoying their profits, as I'm sure their system is running a lot better.

They holding my coins since 22nd, bunch of fking non-responding cowards.

Or maybe they enabled it on purpose and stole all your coins!

Would be great if someone from Cryptsy would please look at support ticket #80321 - Been 24 hours since submission and still unable to login due to 2FA being somehow enabled. Problem is that I never supplied a mobile number to receive the Auth code it is asking me to enter on the login page.

Am losing hundreds of dollars by not being able to login and trade and that means Cryptsy is also losing money from my transaction fees.

Would be extremely grateful if you guys could sort this out - have supplied answers to the secret questions on the ticket to help speed things up.

Thanks!

I hope Crpytsy goes under. Terrible service and hundreds of complaints of lost, delayed funds.

I don't think a protest would change anything but a brute force social media campaign might, including creating a few dozen tickets per person on their support page.

I think the biggest problem is that cryptsy has hardly any comp. THIS IS THE WORST THING EVER. Why? Think of it like your telephone company or cable company... they realize you have no other options, so you either suck it up and deal with the crap service or you dont have it. The same is with cryptsy, no comp, you want to trade alts ... guess what... no other options.

Cryptsy support has been pretty bad lately. Ever since they gave up their IRC Support, they have been taking a turn for the worse.

I now have several tickets open for deposits that have been delayed for over 6 days at present. I got a canned response from "Jim", and replied back re-giving him the info he requested (it was in the original ticket).

Nothing since.. This was 3 days ago. I've bumped the ticket, I've tweeted @cryptsy, nothing I do gets a response.

Absurd.

Been waiting 5 days for my 8.5 million IFC withdrawal (still pending), this was the response I was given

"We apologize for the delay in response to your ticket. IFC is currently experiencing a problem with the chain and will be repaired soon. Please be patient as we repair the issue and get your withdraw moving to you. Please let us know when your withdrawal has gone thru."

Even though I tested a really small withdrawal an hour after the first and it worked perfectly,so the problem is clearly not with the chain.

I was told this also which doesn't make any sense, "We apologize for the delay. Yes, large amount takes longer than withdrawals with smaller amounts (999999 or less)"

Ticket #77161

OK, I've had my share of issues with them as well.  And, for me, the lack of response gets the worst parts of my mind thinking bad thoughts.  So, I'm very glad to hear something went well.

I'm still quite skeptical (the bad parts of my brain) - but I"m glad to see action.