Author

Topic: Is Bitcoin money? - page 128. (Read 112172 times)

full member
Activity: 332
Merit: 103
April 18, 2017, 05:54:58 PM
I think right now bitcoins are more of an asset then money. To me it doesn't matter what form my spending power is in wiether it's in gold bitcoins or sticks. I'm just concerned for the value and how much it will increase so I use Bitcoin as I believe it has the best value then any other form of asset.
hero member
Activity: 686
Merit: 521
April 18, 2017, 04:53:35 PM
Bitcoin is definitely money. You can use it to buy and sell items which definitely classifies it as money. Also, it is worth a lot of USD.

But Bitcoin is not like real money, Dollar etc. Bitcoin is not yet accepted in any country for a official money.
So, in my opinion, Bitcoin will be a real money when accepted soon as official money in our country in the future.
wait a minute here....you mean to say that because some counties do not accept bitcoin as ''official money'' is the reason it will not be considered as money?? I know for sure that some fiat currencies can not be exchanged or accepted in some counties but are still valid forms of money.

So just like bitcoin it has value just like any other currency out there despite not having a physical form and qualifies to be real money.
full member
Activity: 136
Merit: 100
I don’t care
April 18, 2017, 04:36:53 PM
Bitcoin is a crypto currency, you can consider it money to a certain extent, but at the end of the day it's not ACTUAL money, it's more something you invest in which can make you earn real money.
Investing in crypto currencies is like buying something relatively cheap and reselling it to make profit in my opinion.
member
Activity: 77
Merit: 10
April 18, 2017, 03:48:13 PM
It IS money.  If not, you can give your bitcoin to me.  Grin
legendary
Activity: 1302
Merit: 1027
April 18, 2017, 03:35:20 PM
Bitcoin is definitely money. You can use it to buy and sell items which definitely classifies it as money. Also, it is worth a lot of USD.

But Bitcoin is not like real money, Dollar etc. Bitcoin is not yet accepted in any country for a official money.
So, in my opinion, Bitcoin will be a real money when accepted soon as official money in our country in the future.

Tell that to Japanese Cheesy.  How about having an effort to google search what money is then see how Bitcoin is doing at this point.  Maybe you will be convinced that Bitcoin is money.  When it is used as payment method and/or acknowledged by even a single country as money then it is really a real money.

ya it is true that Bitcoin is a online web currency through which you can do all the things which you are doing through fiat currency. So it is called web currency which is good for online purchased and lot of other things can be done through bitcoins.
sr. member
Activity: 1498
Merit: 271
DGbet.fun - Crypto Sportsbook
April 18, 2017, 02:38:56 PM
Bitcoin is definitely money. You can use it to buy and sell items which definitely classifies it as money. Also, it is worth a lot of USD.

But Bitcoin is not like real money, Dollar etc. Bitcoin is not yet accepted in any country for a official money.
So, in my opinion, Bitcoin will be a real money when accepted soon as official money in our country in the future.

Tell that to Japanese Cheesy.  How about having an effort to google search what money is then see how Bitcoin is doing at this point.  Maybe you will be convinced that Bitcoin is money.  When it is used as payment method and/or acknowledged by even a single country as money then it is really a real money.
legendary
Activity: 3514
Merit: 1280
English ⬄ Russian Translation Services
April 18, 2017, 02:20:49 PM
It is illegal here in the US to deface, destroy and alter money

Also, i think the concept of fiat being an IOU is way above your head

So you can't explain how the concept of fiat is related to an IOU

But somehow I'm not surprised. People which can't explain some concept in simple terms typically just don't understand it themselves, as simple as that. Regarding the US dollar specifically, it may be illegal to destroy, deface, and alter it as well as counterfeit it or whatever, but there is no Federal law that would demand any private business to accept dollars as a means of payment or even trade with you. In fact, any such business can just choose not to give a damn fuck about you. As I told you, go and read what the US Treasury department says on this issue. If you come to disagree, you may want to post a link to such a law



We love you, Murrica!
legendary
Activity: 3514
Merit: 1280
English ⬄ Russian Translation Services
April 18, 2017, 02:12:59 PM
Bitcoin is definitely money. You can use it to buy and sell items which definitely classifies it as money. Also, it is worth a lot of USD.

But Bitcoin is not like real money, Dollar etc. Bitcoin is not yet accepted in any country for a official money.
So, in my opinion, Bitcoin will be a real money when accepted soon as official money in our country in the future.

I dont agree with your statement. Even if bitcoin is not used everywhere and not being accepted by all the govt. yet,  this does not mean it is not a currency. If USD is used less, will you say it is not a currency  Grin
Bitcoin is a currency of course and no one can deny this fact

This is in fact debatable

As I would say in such cases, money is what money does. And does here refers to money being used as money. If something has all required qualities and prerequisites to be a currency (say, Bitcoin) and it was even conceived to be used as a currency, we still can't say that it is a currency. In other words, the primary criterion is usage, and alas, Bitcoin doesn't cut it quite well as a full-fledged currency. It is mostly used as a vehicle for speculation, and, what seems to be even more important here, most of its value comes from this usage specifically, not from using it as a means of payment or exchange, which is what makes something into money
legendary
Activity: 1470
Merit: 1024
April 18, 2017, 01:56:12 PM
Bitcoin is definitely money. You can use it to buy and sell items which definitely classifies it as money. Also, it is worth a lot of USD.

But Bitcoin is not like real money, Dollar etc. Bitcoin is not yet accepted in any country for a official money.
So, in my opinion, Bitcoin will be a real money when accepted soon as official money in our country in the future.

If Bitcoin is accepted by a country, it will not be a non-centralized or uncontrolled system. Official money means that one country or a government can intervene in a marketplace, value of the currency etc etc. It is completely contrary from the manifesto of Bitcoin.
legendary
Activity: 3052
Merit: 1273
April 18, 2017, 01:52:04 PM
As per your concerns, there are a few things which I would like to make you clear.
Bitcoin, tbh, should really not be considered as money, but something that has been given a monetary value in terms of usage for anything from goods to services and as there is too much speculation in this, it can be termed as an "investment instrument" or "asset" or "stock" that gets traded for the purpose of making profits. Trust me, most people are in Bitcoins just to grow their capital, having more Bitcoins means having more "money" in your pockets due to its value, but still it cannot be termed as money.
legendary
Activity: 3234
Merit: 1214
Vave.com - Crypto Casino
April 18, 2017, 01:50:44 PM
Bitcoin is definitely money. You can use it to buy and sell items which definitely classifies it as money. Also, it is worth a lot of USD.

But Bitcoin is not like real money, Dollar etc. Bitcoin is not yet accepted in any country for a official money.
So, in my opinion, Bitcoin will be a real money when accepted soon as official money in our country in the future.

I dont agree with your statement. Even if bitcoin is not used everywhere and not being accepted by all the govt. yet,  this does not mean it is not a currency. If USD is used less, will you say it is not a currency  Grin
Bitcoin is a currency of course and no one can deny this fact.
Yeah same as every currency it has got its value. That too higher than any other currencies, so it can be considered as a currency. Another thing is that bitcoin has got different usages, one among that is the payment of bills. So when we get increased spending chance people accept it as money.
legendary
Activity: 3136
Merit: 1172
Leading Crypto Sports Betting & Casino Platform
April 18, 2017, 01:46:50 PM
Bitcoin is definitely money. You can use it to buy and sell items which definitely classifies it as money. Also, it is worth a lot of USD.

But Bitcoin is not like real money, Dollar etc. Bitcoin is not yet accepted in any country for a official money.
So, in my opinion, Bitcoin will be a real money when accepted soon as official money in our country in the future.

I dont agree with your statement. Even if bitcoin is not used everywhere and not being accepted by all the govt. yet,  this does not mean it is not a currency. If USD is used less, will you say it is not a currency  Grin
Bitcoin is a currency of course and no one can deny this fact.
legendary
Activity: 1470
Merit: 1024
April 18, 2017, 01:40:39 PM
Bitcoin really is money, because
1. Some people can -whatever u say- mine, produce Bitcoin, like money which has accepted by states, governments, state oriented organizations etc.
2. It has a value like normal currencies.
3. Many people use Bitcoin as an exchange tool.
4. Payments can be made through Bitcoin. For example, there are many famous websites which accepts Bitcoin and I learned that some restaurants accepts it also.
It is inevitable that Bitcoin would be a part of a monetary service or tool.
sr. member
Activity: 784
Merit: 250
April 18, 2017, 01:26:20 PM
Bitcoin is definitely money. You can use it to buy and sell items which definitely classifies it as money. Also, it is worth a lot of USD.

But Bitcoin is not like real money, Dollar etc. Bitcoin is not yet accepted in any country for a official money.
So, in my opinion, Bitcoin will be a real money when accepted soon as official money in our country in the future.
legendary
Activity: 1442
Merit: 1008
April 18, 2017, 12:55:31 PM
Bitcoin is a product that can be traded for good and services. Much the same as tulips, jewels, auto, silver, gold, orange juice, pretty much anything you can consider. But, can we think of it as money?

No, we can't. Bitcoin is a denominated commodity that is electronically tradable. It is not electronic dollars. It is more similar to digital gold or digital wheat for that matter. There are 21 million of them. Each can further be divided into 100,000,000 subsections (8 decimal places). That is 2,100,000,000,000,000 bitcoins, or 2.1 quadrillion pieces.
then can you buy a cup of coffee with a silver? you can buy t-shirt, laptop, house and almost anything with bitcoin. for me as long as it could be used to buy something then it's a money. bitcoin even more than just money, it's a revolutionary money that unusual but become popular nowadays as an investment but also a lot of people used it to shopping onlin , trade online etc.
Yes that is one of the benefits of using bitcoin is you can use it as a secondary money and buy the things that you want online or in the real world if you like to. Bitcoin can be the future of money because the government might make a digital money to use it online and transfer remittances online and that is what bitcoin have.
yeah people love to spend bitcoin to buy stuff due its easy access and the flexibility where most currency have a lot of step to do especially when you want to spend it online , anyway about the future money i think bitcoin would not replace fiat , but it could be the first currency choice after fiat. bitcoin sure it's a revolutionary and future of money with its definition.

If bitcoin is the second choice of the people that means that it has not replaced fiat and fiat is still on the mainstream and people will use bitcoin as their secondary currency and even if bitcoin becomes more popular in future I don't think it can ever replace fiat.
i'm not saying that , bitcoin could replace fiat as people daily tool to pay something as i believe nothing impossible . but of course the proccess requires a lot of times not soon , people are overoptimistic about bitcoin . at least we have to think realistic too , a new thing like bitcoin could changed anytime just keep an eye on it.
newbie
Activity: 29
Merit: 0
April 18, 2017, 12:16:40 PM
Bitcoin isn't money unless the Government says it is. We would have have to wait till the Government approves Bitcoin.

This is partially true:

BTC IS money, to a small portion of the world.

In the US (where i live), it is NOT money (according to my govt)

Case in point:

Say i am a store owner and someone wants to buy a computer i have advertised for $1000, for $1000 in cash. I tell them no, gtfo. They can actually get various police / courts involved to enforce this

You claim to live in the US but you don't know the laws of your own country

I refer to specific laws regulating the trade and currency in which the trade should be made. The US dollar is legal tender in the US, but that just means that the government is obliged to accept the American dollars as a payment "for all debts, public charges, taxes, and dues". But that doesn't mean that you, as a private seller, can't refuse to have business with anyone (for example, if he wishes to pay you with dollars), and that basically means that the purchaser cannot call police to force you to accept payments in the US dollars

Now it is a piece of paper that is an IOU that the government says, "this is our property and we are giving it to you so you can purchase things in this country"

Which property is owed exactly, a piece of paper? And why should government owe you anything in the first place? Typically, it is you who owes them some amount of money, for example, taxes


Hmmmm...i dont think you know what youre talking about.

It is illegal here in the US to deface, destroy and alter money.

Also, i think the concept of fiat being an IOU is way above your head
member
Activity: 79
Merit: 10
April 18, 2017, 10:28:30 AM
It is important how we define the concepts.
Money is a change tool. We buy goods and services for money.
Bitcoin is also a change tool. We can buy goods and services with Bitcoin.

Bitcoin = Money
full member
Activity: 238
Merit: 100
April 18, 2017, 09:54:31 AM
I think whatever the name is that important can be exchanged for money. like bitcoin is gold in the form of money.
hero member
Activity: 3024
Merit: 745
Top Crypto Casino
April 18, 2017, 05:55:40 AM
Money is something generally accepted as a medium of exchange, a measure of value, or a means of payment. It can have different forms. Just as stone bracelets used to represent money back in ancient times why can't bitcoin serve as such?

And the same thing with the usual money or fiat that we are using for buying different things that we want and need. Bitcoin is considered as real money and there's no way that it can't be treated as money because we can't deny that it can be use for shopping online, for purchasing whatever we want to online.
jr. member
Activity: 42
Merit: 10
April 18, 2017, 05:46:29 AM
There is no certainty that Bitcoin will overcome all the drama and succeed in the long run, but if there is one thing I can say for sure, it is that Bitcoin is more money than any other form of money I have ever seen.
Jump to: