Topic: Landmark Event For Bitcoin: First Full & Independent Wallet (Read 10054 times)

You know that's not true. libbitcoin was a full implementation since 2011. You were also claiming in another topic that I'm not a Bitcoin developer.

This thread has lots of information about full node implementations. I recently asked about the status of such software at http://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/q/12821 with no answers so far.

I intend to maintain my question and keep the status of each implementation updated based on answers I get.

Just a minor correction - bitcoinj has had a fully verifying mode for many months now. It was written by Matt Corallo. MultiBit doesn't use it out of the box because like all fully verifying implementations it's very slow, but you could make a MultiBit with bitcoind level verification just by tweaking one or two lines of code.

So whilst it's great to see libbitcoin develop like this, what Amir is saying is not correct about it being the first or only such reimplementation. Indeed, the block tester that Gregory mentions was written by Matt in order to verify the bitcoinj full mode worked properly.

This looks good, though I can't wait for picocoin

Ah, so it's a reimplementation with different separation of the network uses to how the Bitcoin Foundation backed team are doing it. Very much the sort of protocol complete software that should be produced.

I will at some stage try to get this working with my p2pool setup, has that been tested yet? Presumably p2pool needs to receive broadcasted information about the current block (to the specified port...) and the rest takes care of itself? I am hesitant to try it, as there is no small chance I may find a block (particularly as I've been unlucky with regards to block finding up till now, it'd be sensible to expect at least one before we move up another magnitude of difficulty). Don't want to go down in history as the blockchain forking devil miner  

This is a wallet. libbitcoin is the client and can do any Bitcoin thing you want really because it has a powerful API: http://libbitcoin.dyne.org

Amir,

Well done! The more implementations we get the better able we are to see bugs (like the 0.8 issue).


We need a robust plan for analyzing this; was one of the Bitcoin Foundation grants given to address this?

It's always appreciated to see an alternative and independent implementation. Thanks for your continuing efforts. I appreciate and sympathize with your values.

much needed

libbitcoin is the first full reimplementation of the Bitcoin standard. It was started May 2011 by me and Patrick Strateman.

BitsOfProof and btcd are new entries into the space in the last few months, but there was nothing before.

This wallet is the first wallet (software you can use to do Bitcoin stuff, manages your keys in a wallet, creates transactions and has an interface) based off a full reimplementation. Other wallets either depended on bitcoind or were partial nodes.

meanig gives a good explanation. The situation is deep, and the land is ours. It's been stolen by rulers and corruption. And then people work for a corrupt system that abuses, controls and limits them paying rent every month for a small box. But OK, if they want us to play this stupid economic game, we will just build our own markets, out-compete them and buy back the planet.

Empty property is everywhere in London. We occupied empty houses of the queen in January, and the police response was massive but we did a 9 hour resistance on the roof. The police would never react that way if your private property is occupied. The big response is for her majesty.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2257490/Riot-police-evict-squatters-exclusive-central-London-house-hold-rooftop-protest.html

In the G8, they sent 1000 police to arrest everybody protesting. I find it ironic that the G8 magazine had an article called "Protecting Digital Economies" talking about Bitcoin with such golden quotes like:

"alternative payment mechanisms, such
as Bitcoin and a host of others, can enable
criminal and terrorist groups to launder
money and fund their operations."

"Governments of the world have the ability
right now to ban these payment mechanisms."

"If treasuries and financial institutions
around the world were to block those
transactions and permit only legitimate
currencies to be used on the internet through
regulated payment service providers and
cards (such as Visa, MasterCard and American
Express), then the flow of many billions of
dollars to criminal groups would be stemmed."

"bring about a more safe and secure
internet environment for all citizens.
If the leaders of the European Union and
United States could be convinced to take a
lead on these initiatives, that would be a huge
contribution to making the internet a safe
place for financial transactions. At the same
time, it would also strike a blow against those
who would try to destroy the fabric of our the
world’s well-being."

I love the last sentence. Quick, the sleepwalking zombies are waking up!

Please stop this nonsense. I have given my heart and soul to Bitcoin for 3 years, opensource for 10+ years and profited nothing. I have 4 BTC and no other money. I have received no money from any of these rich & popular Bitcoin people. I am supported by good people who have not much themselves and don't really understand Bitcoin, but believe in me and what I value.

But I love Bitcoin, and am here forever. I promised myself this in summer 2010, and nothing has changed.

In the UK a squatter is a person who legally gains access to an abandoned building and starts living there. If the owner doesn't come forward to ask them to leave within a certain number of years the building eventually becomes the squatters property.

Up until last year it was a long and expensive process to evict a squatter in London but new rules have made it easier for a landlord to evict squatters from a residential home. It's still difficult to evict squatters from commercial buildings. In the case of commercial buildings police tactics are to raid the building because they believe there is a wanted person inside, then when they have everyone outside the landlord changes the locks.

London has an acute housing shortage. Planning regulations are extremely strict and the process of apply for permission to build a house can costs thousands of pounds. If you buy a field in the middle of nowhere and try to build a house it's very unlikely that the local council will allow you. There is no shortage of empty land around London. The regulations are in place solely to keep property prices high.

Successive governments have been stuffed full of property millionaires who only care about increasing the size of their portfolios. Banks have also played their part by allowing mortgage lending on large income multiples.

Building new homes and making accommodation cheaper is the antithesis of the landlord class politicians and the greedy baby boomers who vote for them. Anyone under the age of 35 who doesn't have rich parents is being screwed. Squatting is a perfectly reasonable way to say FUCK OFF to the politicians and banks. 

Just to show how fucking crazy London property is look at this shed for sale in north London. The asking price is £250,000!!!!



http://www.rightmove.co.uk/commercial-property-for-sale/property-36976334.html

Now look at the people who object to building homes. The green belt is the mythical area around cities which consists of empty fields. According to baby boomers saving these fields is more important than giving young people the chance to own a cheap home and start a family. These baby boomers are pure evil 

I bet they all have defined benefit pensions too 

That's great news!  Regarding other implementations:  I think there's btcd in Go, is this what you guys mean?  I'm not sure about its status, but believe it is also going to be finished some time soon according to the initial comments.  I'm definitely looking forward to having multiple compatible but otherwise independent implementations!

Yez! Thats written from the ground up I believe, no?

It's just a personal preference; requires some training though

Bits of proof?

Isn't there actually an Enterprise level bitcoin implementation independently written as well? I forget the name, but it's written by a hungarian guy.

Cool stuff.  If fewer people, businesses, and systems rely on the same systems, bitcoin becomes stronger.

^ this. While I appreciate the work Amir is doing for the community, he left a lot of Bitcoiners hanging with Bitcoinica. Don't turn your back on us Amir.