https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.62651709
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.62652614
@pakhitheboss and @Sakanwa, can you both please post the transaction ID of depositing in mixin safe and withdrawal ID too.
PS: If you don't want the information in public then feel free to PM me.
Sorry for any inconvenience. I need some proof that you tested the system not just wrote a review.
Cheers,
Topic: Mixin Safe (Decentralized Multisig+MPC+Timelock solution) review preperation (Read 1118 times)
August 07, 2023, 08:46:40 PM
August 05, 2023, 05:45:01 AM
You should definitely state on the website that version 25.0+ is required for creating the Safe (ideally in the combo-box where you can select the type of Safe you want to create). It was the only way I was able to sign the PSBT.
note: this allows you to sign PSBTs from Safe wallets created in older versions of Core
Yes we still need to improve the flow a lot, that's why we are testing and doing reviews. Thank you so much
August 04, 2023, 07:19:40 AM
I have enough people to talk to now, thanks
Members in Batch#4:
Your deadline to submit the reviews before 10/08/2023 @23:59 UTC. Please do not miss the deadline.
Code:
Mr.right85 Hero Member
_act_ Hero Member
GxSTxV Sr. Member
Sim_card Full Member
LoyceV Legendary
OmegaStarScream Legendary/ Staff
Z-tight Hero Member
coupable Hero Member
BitcoinTurk Hero Member
MAAManda Hero Member
Chilwell Full Member
Little Mouse Legendary
Synchronice Sr. Member
UmerIdrees Hero Member
virasog Legendary
nelson4lov Hero Member
bitmover Legendary
Iroh Sr. Member
Onyeeze Full Member
Beparanf Hero Member
August 03, 2023, 05:19:53 AM
@ETFBitcoin:
Try creating another script wallet using Bitcoin 25.0 rpcs, make sure it's the only descriptor inside the wallet, and then copy the PSBT from the website and try to sign it again - first with the script wallet so it makes the required fields in the PSBT, then paste the output and sign it to the private key wallet.
Try creating another script wallet using Bitcoin 25.0 rpcs, make sure it's the only descriptor inside the wallet, and then copy the PSBT from the website and try to sign it again - first with the script wallet so it makes the required fields in the PSBT, then paste the output and sign it to the private key wallet.
Thanks for the suggestion. Although when i login to Mixin Safe today, i discovered i can make recovery attempt again (the status no longer locked) so i decide to use recovery instead. Currently i'm waiting for "Waiting for Safe Network to approve this recovery..." which i've no idea how long it'll take (edit: it took less than 5 minutes).
August 03, 2023, 02:35:50 AM
@Royse777 I was about to finish to review, but unable to complete last process (sign PBST transaction with Bitcoin Core) use Bitcoin Core and i got locked from recovery process. The details of the problem can be seen on my review post[1]. Anyway, is it acceptable if my review is about "attempt to make transaction and use recovery instead" rather than "make transaction" ?
[1] https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/cfnp-mixin-safe-decentralized-bitcoin-custody-solutions-review-campaign-5460259
I sent a PM to cedricfung to write you a response. Hopefully you will hear soon from him.[1] https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/cfnp-mixin-safe-decentralized-bitcoin-custody-solutions-review-campaign-5460259
Quote
Anyway, is it acceptable if my review is about "attempt to make transaction and use recovery instead" rather than "make transaction" ?
The real experience will be appreciated whether it is a recovery attempt or transaction.For the Bitcoin Core signature issue, I thought maybe the Bitcoin Core is not version 25.0+?
You should definitely state on the website that version 25.0+ is required for creating the Safe (ideally in the combo-box where you can select the type of Safe you want to create). It was the only way I was able to sign the PSBT.
note: this allows you to sign PSBTs from Safe wallets created in older versions of Core
@ETFBitcoin:
Try creating another script wallet using Bitcoin 25.0 rpcs, make sure it's the only descriptor inside the wallet, and then copy the PSBT from the website and try to sign it again - first with the script wallet so it makes the required fields in the PSBT, then paste the output and sign it to the private key wallet.
August 02, 2023, 05:35:17 AM
Quote
Anyway, is it acceptable if my review is about "attempt to make transaction and use recovery instead" rather than "make transaction" ?
The real experience will be appreciated whether it is a recovery attempt or transaction.Thank you for the clarification.
@Royse777 I was about to finish to review, but unable to complete last process (sign PBST transaction with Bitcoin Core) use Bitcoin Core and i got locked from recovery process. The details of the problem can be seen on my review post[1]. Anyway, is it acceptable if my review is about "attempt to make transaction and use recovery instead" rather than "make transaction" ?
[1] https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/cfnp-mixin-safe-decentralized-bitcoin-custody-solutions-review-campaign-5460259
I sent a PM to cedricfung to write you a response. Hopefully you will hear soon from him.[1] https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/cfnp-mixin-safe-decentralized-bitcoin-custody-solutions-review-campaign-5460259
I definitely use Bitcoin Core 25.0 for purpose of testing Mixin Safe. In addition, i don't have other version of Bitcoin Core installed on my device.
August 01, 2023, 10:24:21 PM
@Royse777 I was about to finish to review, but unable to complete last process (sign PBST transaction with Bitcoin Core) use Bitcoin Core and i got locked from recovery process. The details of the problem can be seen on my review post[1]. Anyway, is it acceptable if my review is about "attempt to make transaction and use recovery instead" rather than "make transaction" ?
[1] https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/cfnp-mixin-safe-decentralized-bitcoin-custody-solutions-review-campaign-5460259
I sent a PM to cedricfung to write you a response. Hopefully you will hear soon from him.[1] https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/cfnp-mixin-safe-decentralized-bitcoin-custody-solutions-review-campaign-5460259
Quote
Anyway, is it acceptable if my review is about "attempt to make transaction and use recovery instead" rather than "make transaction" ?
The real experience will be appreciated whether it is a recovery attempt or transaction.For the Bitcoin Core signature issue, I thought maybe the Bitcoin Core is not version 25.0+?
August 01, 2023, 07:11:47 PM
i thought this is a mixer. i just installed it on my computer. I got a lot of issues due to the system requirements its giving me headaches. i end up using that flathub version for linux.
Yeah, the name can be quite confusing. It actually confused a number of members.If you have a smartphone, just use it instead to install the mixin messenger and mornin key and then use the computer, to visit the mixin safe website for set up and easier QR code scanning using the mobile phone.
I don't think the desktop version of mixin messenger has more futures like the mobile version
August 01, 2023, 01:52:33 PM
@Royse777 will be posting my review soon. by Aug 3.
i thought this is a mixer. i just installed it on my computer. I got a lot of issues due to the system requirements its giving me headaches. i end up using that flathub version for linux.
August 01, 2023, 01:07:59 PM
Coins in Mixin Safe will be secure, no worry if you keep at least one private key. Mixin Messenger or Bitcoin Core.
Now it looks like some instructions issues, the team is trying to make it more clear to use.
Now it looks like some instructions issues, the team is trying to make it more clear to use.
August 01, 2023, 11:45:03 AM
@Royse777 I was about to finish to review, but unable to complete last process (sign PBST transaction with Bitcoin Core) use Bitcoin Core and i got locked from recovery process. The details of the problem can be seen on my review post[1]. Anyway, is it acceptable if my review is about "attempt to make transaction and use recovery instead" rather than "make transaction" ?
[1] https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/cfnp-mixin-safe-decentralized-bitcoin-custody-solutions-review-campaign-5460259
I sent a PM to cedricfung to write you a response. Hopefully you will hear soon from him.[1] https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/cfnp-mixin-safe-decentralized-bitcoin-custody-solutions-review-campaign-5460259
Quote
Anyway, is it acceptable if my review is about "attempt to make transaction and use recovery instead" rather than "make transaction" ?
The real experience will be appreciated whether it is a recovery attempt or transaction. August 01, 2023, 05:20:18 AM
--snip--
Oh damn... you got locked too? 
Hopefully it was only a small amount. The Bitcoin Core approval instructions clearly seem to be incorrect.
Yeah. I didn't read other user review before testing Mixin Safe. Anyway, i'm still waiting for response from Mixin Safe customer service so there's nothing i could do for now.
August 01, 2023, 04:00:09 AM
@Royse777 I was about to finish to review, but unable to complete last process (sign PBST transaction with Bitcoin Core) use Bitcoin Core and i got locked from recovery process. The details of the problem can be seen on my review post[1]. Anyway, is it acceptable if my review is about "attempt to make transaction and use recovery instead" rather than "make transaction" ?
[1] https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/cfnp-mixin-safe-decentralized-bitcoin-custody-solutions-review-campaign-5460259
[1] https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/cfnp-mixin-safe-decentralized-bitcoin-custody-solutions-review-campaign-5460259
Oh damn... you got locked too?
Hopefully it was only a small amount. The Bitcoin Core approval instructions clearly seem to be incorrect.
July 31, 2023, 06:47:13 AM
@Royse777 I was about to finish to review, but unable to complete last process (sign PBST transaction with Bitcoin Core) use Bitcoin Core and i got locked from recovery process. The details of the problem can be seen on my review post[1]. Anyway, is it acceptable if my review is about "attempt to make transaction and use recovery instead" rather than "make transaction" ?
[1] https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/cfnp-mixin-safe-decentralized-bitcoin-custody-solutions-review-campaign-5460259
[1] https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/cfnp-mixin-safe-decentralized-bitcoin-custody-solutions-review-campaign-5460259
July 26, 2023, 06:03:04 PM
Remainder to remaining 4 members from Batch#1.
It looks like @Rockstarguy made a review but probably forgot to submit it through the report form. Maybe he missed out that bit of the instructions.Code:
Rockstarguy
Please submit your review before 23:59 UTC today.With the deadline coming in fast, try sending him a PM about this if he is not paying attention to the mention bot notifications.
July 26, 2023, 05:16:23 PM
Remainder to remaining 4 members from Batch#1.
It looks like @Rockstarguy made a review but probably forgot to submit it through the report form. Maybe he missed out that bit of the instructions.Code:
Rockstarguy
Please submit your review before 23:59 UTC today.With the deadline coming in fast, try sending him a PM about this if he is not paying attention to the mention bot notifications.
July 26, 2023, 08:36:05 AM
Remainder to remaining 4 members from Batch#1.
Code:
Rockstarguy
examplens
Potato Chips
logfiles
Please submit your review before 23:59 UTC today.examplens
Potato Chips
logfiles
I am in the process of writing. Here we had strong storms that caused serious damage to the internet and electrical network infrastructure, so I have been in very difficult conditions for the last few days. If there are additional outages today, I will post this so far written, around 70%.
I definitely wanted to ask, is adding screenshots mandatory or necessary? repeating the screenshot from the application probably only serves as proof that we really went through the process.
tx
Screenshot is not mandatory but use it when it is necessary. Your contents will reflect if a user indeed used the service. You can save screenshot in your device just in case you need to defend yourself if anyone ask question.
July 26, 2023, 08:25:46 AM
Remainder to remaining 4 members from Batch#1.
Code:
Rockstarguy
examplens
Potato Chips
logfiles
Please submit your review before 23:59 UTC today.examplens
Potato Chips
logfiles
I am in the process of writing. Here we had strong storms that caused serious damage to the internet and electrical network infrastructure, so I have been in very difficult conditions for the last few days. If there are additional outages today, I will post this so far written, around 70%.
I definitely wanted to ask, is adding screenshots mandatory or necessary? repeating the screenshot from the application probably only serves as proof that we really went through the process.
tx
July 26, 2023, 08:14:26 AM
Remainder to remaining 4 members from Batch#1.
Code:
Rockstarguy
examplens
Potato Chips
logfiles
Please submit your review before 23:59 UTC today. examplens
Potato Chips
logfiles
July 25, 2023, 09:51:32 AM
Here is a screnshot of me approving the tx with the almost-lost second signer, in a Windows 7 computer that I found in my hotel. 
@TryNinja
Maybe it is better if Mixin Safe had a UI (within both the desktop/web and the mobile apps) for you to revoke unsafe computers? It's very easy for a public computer (particularly Windows) to get loaded with malware that steals auth tokens and approves an unauthorized transfer.
@cedricfung what do you think? It would be a welcome addition to already asking the other devices for authorization of another device that's about to log in.
Agree, for now you can revoke all authorizations from Mixin Messenger -> Settings -> Account -> Security -> Authorizations.
And whenever you sign in to Mixin Safe from a different browser, the old one will also be logged out.
Now adding the feature to logout of the service when inactive for some time.
Jump to: