Author

Topic: [OFFICIAL]Bitfinex.com first Bitcoin P2P lending platform for leverage trading - page 269. (Read 723903 times)

full member
Activity: 141
Merit: 101
[...] Real traders who want to sell will set their price below the wall. [...]
No, they don't.

Not all traders, no. But even if it's just some bots that want to make a quick sell, it does happen and it does drive the price down.

Let me try to understand your point of view better. Please answer this simple question:

A 100 BTC ask in the orderbook is:

[ ] Scary and you should put asks below it or sell at market immediately
[ ] A chance to do a big buy and take a big position without moving the market


[X] I'm absolutely not worried for myself as i'm only providing swaps, not trading.

Does every argument someone makes in a post have to come from worry about personal gain? I simply see something that doesn't make sense.
newbie
Activity: 12
Merit: 0
i am completely fine with how it is, because that way you can mix long term orders with short term orders, lets say:

-i go short at 800 and put a stop buy at 805 and a limit buy at 750 and my margin is exhausted.
-i still can have a decent buy limit order @ 300 to catch a bottom.



I agree, but it should ideally be capped to x5 or x10 your balance. The trick with Exchange to put 10000 btc orders should really be fixed. I was the one who placed those 40k and 60k walls btw, apologies if it caused any panic Smiley
sr. member
Activity: 288
Merit: 250
ManualMiner
i am completely fine with how it is, because that way you can mix long term orders with short term orders, lets say:

-i go short at 800 and put a stop buy at 805 and a limit buy at 750 and my margin is exhausted.
-i still can have a decent buy limit order @ 300 to catch a bottom.

full member
Activity: 141
Merit: 101
[...] Real traders who want to sell will set their price below the wall. [...]
No, they don't.

Not all traders, no. But even if it's just some bots that want to make a quick sell, it does happen and it does drive the price down.
member
Activity: 104
Merit: 10
Pecunia non olet
[...] Real traders who want to sell will set their price below the wall. [...]
No, they don't.
full member
Activity: 141
Merit: 101
Of course you can manipulate the market. You put up a huge fake wall just above the lowest ask. Real traders who want to sell will set their price below the wall. You move the wall down a little, the sellers match that movement and adjust their prices down a little to stay under the wall, rinse and repeat. The result is that you manipulate the price downward. Then when you've moved the price a decent amount, you buy cheap, remove the wall, watch the price go up again and sell your bitcoins at a profit. How can you say this is totally fine?

..but then again, I place my orders according where it looks like I should place them on the chart and mostly ignore the orderbook. As I said: There is such a thing as hidden orders on Bitfinex and the minimum size for placing them is only 100 BTC.

From their FAQ:

Quote
What is a "Hidden order"?

A hidden order is an order which does not appear in the orderbook, and thus doesn't influence other market participants. See the fees page for minimum size and fee applicable.

Right there they're saying that large orders can influence the market. Intentionally influencing the market (as in the case of fake walls) is manipulating it. And why would they have an orderbook at all if it's not reliable? I still say that being able to put up orders on the exchange for funds you don't have is faulty design.
hero member
Activity: 504
Merit: 500
Moderator
Of course, it´s fine  Cheesy Cheesy This has nothing to do with possible market manipulation....






Edit:
All buy walls on all exchanges are mostly fake. BTC isn´t worth more than 200 bucks.
full member
Activity: 141
Merit: 101
What? That seems like a serious design flaw to me. So you can basically bluff and manipulate the market that way? To be honest I can't believe they allow this.

Yes, you really can bluff and rustle n00bs jimmies.

But "manipulate" the market? Not too sure about that one.. Just now someone here apparently read my post and put buy orders at $0.01 and put up 40k BTC asks. Were my jimmes rustled by that? No, of course they weren't.

I hate to sound rude but if that's all it takes to rustle your jimmes then you really shouldn't be trading at all.

Of course you can manipulate the market. You put up a huge fake wall just above the lowest ask. Real traders who want to sell will set their price below the wall. You move the wall down a little, the sellers match that movement and adjust their prices down a little to stay under the wall, rinse and repeat. The result is that you manipulate the price downward. Then when you've moved the price a decent amount, you buy cheap, remove the wall, watch the price go up again and sell your bitcoins at a profit. How can you say this is totally fine?
full member
Activity: 141
Merit: 101
if one places more than one order, where each order is @ max margin, is it possible that more than order gets filled?

If you have like $100 in your exchange wallet then you can put a bids for 100 BTC at $1. Now the system assumes that these may get hit at some point and that you should therefore be able to place sell orders for them in advanced, so now you can place a 100 BTC ask at say $720 and rustle people's jimmies. Now, if this ask is hit then it will just cancel since you don't have 100 BTC - but you can place the order.

What? That seems like a serious design flaw to me. So you can basically bluff and manipulate the market that way? To be honest I can't believe they allow this.
sr. member
Activity: 288
Merit: 250
ManualMiner
I found an exploit on bitfinex where I'm able to place an ulimited amount of orders on margin trading without having the liquidity to do so and I can manipulate the order book. I'm not attempting to manipulate the market right now - I just wanted to demonstrate this exploit. Please fix it.

Yep, we can all do this. And we can also all easily see when someone who just figured this out is playing around: You can put up 100 x 10 BTC bids or asks but you can't put up 1 x 1000 BTC - thus everybody can easily see that someone just figured this out. A bid order of 100s of small orders is quite easy to see.

It's no big deal, someone buys or asks from your "wall" and the orders cancel after stretching your margin to the limit.

You should be careful placing toy walls close to the spread if the book is thin overall because at some point I'll just FOK your order until you're at your limit and move the market with real actual funds backed by my exchange wallet (or trading wallet if you put a bid up) and then you're toast. And we can do the math, if you put up an ask of 1000 BTC with 100 orders when it's easy to see that you're only able to short 10 BTC - period. Thus I'll just put a real 100 BTC bid there and move it up until you get a margin call or your jimmies get sufficiently rustled. And I'm no big fish at BFX just because I can put real 100 BTC bids and asks up, there are quite a few 1000+ BTC position players in our sandbox.

It has been possible to add 100s of orders of your maximum order size for a very long time and it's never been a problem except for those who do it for fun.

if one places more than one order, where each order is @ max margin, is it possible that more than order gets filled?
sr. member
Activity: 288
Merit: 250
ManualMiner
sr. member
Activity: 446
Merit: 250
CAT.EX Exchange
i still dont get what that "liquidation price" on margin trade positions mean..
is it the price @ which the margin call is imminent?

The liquidation price is the price at which your position will be closed in order to guarantee the liquidity provider not to incur in any losses

I hope this helps

Giancarlo
Bitfinex Team
full member
Activity: 170
Merit: 104
i still dont get what that "liquidation price" on margin trade positions mean..
is it the price @ which the margin call is imminent?

Yeah, that is correct. You may notice it shows zero when you have a long position at less than 1:1 leverage, this means you won't get liquidated no matter what price does. If you've got more size on or if short then it shows the price you wiil get liquidated at.
sr. member
Activity: 288
Merit: 250
ManualMiner
i still dont get what that "liquidation price" on margin trade positions mean..
is it the price @ which the margin call is imminent?
full member
Activity: 170
Merit: 104
Does Bitfinex have a streaming API for market data?

I often notice bots placing orders next to mine pretty much immediately after i place mine, do they poll at a multihertz rate or is there some streaming api we don't know about?

Thanks for a great service!
legendary
Activity: 1022
Merit: 1000
I found an exploit on bitfinex where ...

Better email or PM them, there are bunch of exploiters here.
newbie
Activity: 7
Merit: 0
In 2 days this will be buried and people don't even know about the other, already closed thread in project development. If you want to learn about screwups, prepare for a nice read.

Trusting this forum (that regularly 502s) to deliver PMs and thinking they are an official way to reach Bitfinex is... not a smart idea. Send E-Mails and/or contact them on their own support forum if you reallly need to reach someone.
You clearly underestimate - at least my - capability for annoying the hell out of someone that did me wrong.

You can be certain that if they don't give me back my money, in a year from now, I'll still be pinging this thread regularly and talking about their screw up and the unprofessional way they are handling the matter.

hey, we dont give a shit


Hey, acutally I do.   
sr. member
Activity: 288
Merit: 250
ManualMiner
In 2 days this will be buried and people don't even know about the other, already closed thread in project development. If you want to learn about screwups, prepare for a nice read.

Trusting this forum (that regularly 502s) to deliver PMs and thinking they are an official way to reach Bitfinex is... not a smart idea. Send E-Mails and/or contact them on their own support forum if you reallly need to reach someone.
You clearly underestimate - at least my - capability for annoying the hell out of someone that did me wrong.

You can be certain that if they don't give me back my money, in a year from now, I'll still be pinging this thread regularly and talking about their screw up and the unprofessional way they are handling the matter.

hey, we dont give a shit
legendary
Activity: 2618
Merit: 1007
In 2 days this will be buried and people don't even know about the other, already closed thread in project development. If you want to learn about screwups, prepare for a nice read.

Trusting this forum (that regularly 502s) to deliver PMs and thinking they are an official way to reach Bitfinex is... not a smart idea. Send E-Mails and/or contact them on their own support forum if you reallly need to reach someone.
legendary
Activity: 2618
Merit: 1007
WTF, can you people stop spamming this thread with notifications about notifications that you sent a message somehow somewhere?! Angry
Jump to: