So what do you guys think about the way exchanges are handling the possible fork. Bitfinex is stating the even BTC in lending will be dealt with as if it was in the wallet. Do you feel safe enough?
There's not enough safety whenever you deal with a third party
Especially if that party already took (or lost, if you disagree) your funds for their own (someone else's) use. Apart from that, could you expand more on what is meant by Bitfinex stating that even bitcoins loaned out will be dealt with? That does it actually mean, that we will not see anything? Could you post a link to their official statement on this issue? I want to see that statement with my own eyes
https://www.bitfinex.com/posts/197this is the official announcement regarding forks and margin trading. It states a more reassuring approach than other exchanges. That´s why i asked if people fill safe "enough" with this reassuring
Okay, thank you for the link
I tried to get as much as I could out of that, and the most important part of their letter seems to be the following:
After much analysis, we have chosen to handle the accounting of margin trading and funding based on the model of how stock spinoffs, dividends, and distributions are handled in equity markets. Specifically, in the case of a hardfork event, lenders will receive both BTC and BTU. Anyone that is short BTC/USD or long any BTC trading pair (ETH/BTC, LTC/BTC, etc.) will owe BTU to the lender, effectively making the user short BTU. An exception is in the case that BTC is borrowed but not in use as margin collateral, in which case BTU accrues to the lender. Users that are margin long BTC/USD or short any BTC trading pair will receive BTU
As I got it, all BTC lenders will receive the corresponding amount of BTU tokens which should match the amount of bitcoins that they lent out. So far so good. But it is no clear (and I'm afraid that this is intentionally left unexplained and unspecified) what will happen to ordinary traders, not involved in margin trading. What interests me most here is whether they will receive the BTU tokens in the amount that matches their current BTC balances (i.e. at the moment of the split)? A simple question which should be given a definitive and comprehensive answer