We have no option here but to consider the base price. Kion k aik NFT ki price who hay jis p app nay buy kia. Now you want to sell at higher price, but jab tak sell ni hota tu hum buying price hi calculate kr saktay hein. On the other hand, bitcoin ki tu selling price hy exchanges p, so we can't consider buying price every time for crypto currencies.
wohi tu Umer bhai why not calculate actual price on NFT also? why base price in this case?... chalin aik aur misaal deta hon maine ghar kharedaa 10 lac ka... mere ghar k pass motorway ban jae aur ab if I sale this house it will be worth 100lac, but i'm not planning to sale, aur zakat zahir hai muje deni hia, kion k ghar maine investment k tor pe khareda tha like NFT. Ab kia main 10 lac pe zakat don ga ya 100lac k hisab which is the actual worth of my house now.
Pakistan main sab properties ki current value pe zakat dete hian na... same goes to NFT agar main NFT $10,000 kharedi thi but today after one year it worth $20,0000... then why base price?
kehne maksad sirf ye hia jo ap ne definition di hia wo ap k hisab se thaik hia likan agar koi different opinion rakhta hia on bitcion or NFT you can't say he's wrong. Kion k iss pe koi fatwa nahi hai... aur jab ijmah-umah ya fatwa nah hon ye tu apki apni swabdeed aur aqal k mutabiq faisla hoga.
If you offer 1 Eth and she refused tu ais ka mutlab yeh ni hua k aus NFT ki price 1 Eth ni hogi. She will not give zakat on her own build NFT aur jab NFT sale hogi 2 ETH p tu aus p zakat hogi bus.
Apki apni NFT is like apka apna ghar...now you want to sell your home for 1 crore rs, agar koi 80 Lakh ki qimat laga day, tu app p zakat ni hoti, jab tak k app sell na kero.
Umer bhai again you didn't get my point or may be I was unable to explain. Apki apni NFT is like apna ghar how? hahaha agar main apnay 10 ghar bana lon aur kahon ye mere personal hian and rent pe p ebhi nahi tu kia un pe zakat nahi hogi? zahir hai main 10 main aikhate tu nahi reh raha aik main reh raha hon tu kia baqi 9 pe zakat nahi banay gi?
You accepted NFT is an asset and gold is also an asset but for NFT your point of view is calculate zakat on base price but for Gold and Bitcoin based on current market price.
Just now i saw this on twitter
nahi nahi ye fatwa nahi just another point of view of someone
Is par to m b iktfa karun gi...
Ab market m Ik jese NFT's mojud hen... Agar to ap k pas esa koi NFT mojud h jiss ki price already mojud h market m to yaqeenan uss k mutabit hi Zakat nikly gi... Bss wo nisab m ati ho...
And second agar uss ki koi price mojud nai or sell b nai hui to buying price hi consider ki jaye gi... Q? K we have no other option.
Since NFT is an asset (wo nahi jo apne khud banai, but the one which you own or buy) so why not calculate current price? Yes it's unique and you own it for quite some time and if you sale now its 100x then why not calculate based on current market value?