Topic: [SDC] ShadowCash Uncensored: Zeuner, Zero Knowledge, Zero Trust. What Happened? - page 2. (Read 23489 times)

I'll buy a copy if Shen signs it.

I wasn't even invited to write the foreword!
Without it this history will only last about 10 pages - what on earth is this guy gonna write about? How there was no peer review, android wallet or market? That SDC was deanon'd? That Tecnovert left and Ryno is a recluse? I dunno. Everything the author needs is in this thread.

hey smooth, you want me to buy you a copy?
(seriously though, he's gonna sell maybe 2 copies)

These are 100% legitimate concerns and questions.

Why can't we get some real answers from (whatever is left of) Team SDC, instead of deflection in the form of attacking the messenger?



IKR?  You should see what's happening in the NXT Civil War.  JL777 had a Hearnia and pulled a whiny rage quit.  Which just happens to be the perfect excuse to abandon his dozens of incomplete projects.

Then there's the bawling at /r/btc over the fact that Honey Badger is not a punching bag and will fight back when attacked.

Popcorn supplies are running dangerously low.   At this level of drama, nobody will notice when Game of Thrones comes back!   

The question the community should be asking is what changes have been made to the process to address the underlying causes for not only the original bug, but also for: a) it not being found over a year in the wild, and b) the flaw being incorrectly dismissed by the core team once reported.

I would say the underlying causes are:

1. Poor/nonexistent core competency in cryptography and math.
2. No peer review.
3. Leadership failure in not recognizing the need for #1 and #2

Just fixing the bug is treating the symptom, not the cause.

Like how u got de-anon'd? Bazinga.

BTW You guys might wanna get that shadowchat/bitmessage clone vetted and reviewed (since it's the basis of your market) sometime before you put people's balls on the line. Just a thought.

I got this PM from wheatclove and I think it's the best post he ever wrote.
Having spoken of humility I elected to post his PM here.

I dont agree with a lot of it and dont see how SDC can recover, but Im not about to criticize.


So on that note,

I posted this a year ago , maybe more, in the official thread back when I supported SDC. It has long since been deleted and actually I may have deleted it myself after a run in with a user called cryptophile.

Anyway I re-post it here today just to show… I dunno what - maybe just for nostalgia. Some Shadow memorabilia.

The Rambo meme (with ryno as rambo) was struck up between ryno and myself over IRC when he was on his jungle expedition early last year after the release of shadowsendv2.

At the time that I made it I was looking forward to the Zeuner review, as was he.

"They drew first blood, not me"
(joke)  


https://i.imgur.com/WD7eFYY.png

^still makes me chuckle. If you liked Cryptonote you'll love this.
At that time it was said ssv2 was not CN.

From SDC ANN
Feel free to re-post here

What I care about is no longer relevant.  The conversation has expanded.

Besides, you ate wrong. There was a time I cared for learning more about shadowsend and promoting it. I defended the Team at the time who insisted it was not a crytonote copy, when now it obviously is a (broken) copy.

We can safely assume that ShadowChat (the bitmessage copy) is similarly flawed since nobody has looked closely at it. Yet it is the core of your hastily planned market.

You tried to walk before you could run.

Of the past you say Zeuner was lazy, of the present you say Thanks Shen and to the future you say nevermind the present, we'll copy zcash next. The SDC Team lack accountability, professionalism and honesty


Technically no but Im not impressed by the SDC approach.



What stuff is it you people trying to do? Create half-baked tools that'll land folks in jail?

My victory is almost pyrrhic given fatigue and zero remuneration. Still… I was right.

This is all you've ever cared about.

You don't understand software development.
You don't understand open source development.

You're just a guy. Sitting out on the sidelines. Yelling "you suck" to the people trying to do stuff.

I'd agree that Shen most likely did save men from prison time.
I still support the project, but my confidence has been shaken for sure.

No, it was about doing the right thing. You guys started with that review.



Shadow has lost all credibility and demonstrated ineptitude and irresponsibilty. I contend it is unlikely anybody will use a market made by this group.



Your idiot policy of marching ahead without review should have resulted in arrest for market users, yes, Thanks to Shen



That's why I created this thread. I find your policies abhorrent

So again ignoring the rest of the points I made?
Do you see why's everybody upset with you when you don't listen?

----

The blogger might have his mind, but not the correct/current info. Or do you not agree? See the comments, someone summed up pretty nicely.

Just to be sure, I'm not here to restore credibility of Shadow in your eyes. I stopped caring for you some time ago as you persuaded me with your actions. I just don't feel it's OK to spam this thread with your delusions.. I'm here to defend SDC with what I KNOW, so that newbies won't fall for your hateful words. As you said, it's not about you, it's about Shadow.

No tecnovert, no. He did his job and isn't longer needed. We can argue about the quality, but again – bug are, were and definitely will be. Programming is hard, I know none of us two know the exact merit needed, so let's not discuss this.
The anon basis is built, fixed as we speak and the rest of Shadow Project just sits on top of this base.

And let me answer your Zeuner question with another question: Do you know how many times have we already answered you that? Do you know the definition of insanity? (when you like the links so much, hehe)
Same goes with "taking back donations". Millions of answers you got in the past and somehow this time you think this answer will be different?
If you don't remember, do the research and scroll down the history.

----

I'm done with you. It's like talking to a wall.

Everyone who want to learn the truth about Shadow, come and join our Slack channel, get to know the community and you'll see for yourselves. Don't take anyone's word for it.

Cheers.

I went to a great deal of trouble to put all the links in the OP and research all my points as best I could.

THIS IS ALL ABOUT SHADOW, and nothing to do with me.

The Team was, and continues to be, totally irresponsible when handling these serious matters or taking responsibility for their actions. Rolling out a market without peer reviewed anon? You deserve all the shit you get for this.

Do you think the blogger working for deepdotcom has no mind of his/her own?
Do you think Im the only guy who feels this way?

No Zeuner Review,.
Now no Tecnovert.
A broken anon.

A free forum for discussion means exactly that and I am no more a troll than you are able to help restore any credibilty whatsoever as long as you continue this vendetta route of insult.

How about we discuss refunds for the Zeuner donations?
Or why Tecnovert left?
Or what idiot member of the SDC team wrote the blogpost: Shadowcash deanonymized? Nope., abotu 12 hours before it was proven otherwise??

NB: I greatly resent your attempts to discredit me. I have done, and will continue to do, more free-thinking in this space than you have ever demonsrtated.

Exactly. This never was about Shadow, it was about you, right? You didn't like something, made 180° turn and went on a crusade to crush SDC.

"Poison-tounge"? What offended you this time?



OK, what's so delusional about this exatly? I, in contrast to you, take active part in our community and therefore have some overview of what's happening, who's coming in etc.
Where do you get your info?



Seriously? This could be a nice example of your imaginative made up arguments..
Honestly: I and/or anybody else have no idea. Or will you prove me wrong? How can you even argue with something like this?

Of course that the flaw wasn't welcome, of course it would be better without it.
But it's still software as any other and there are bugs (remember Heartbleed and others?) – did you stop using OpenSSL and bash the shit out of it? No. It got fixed, it got the attention and funding it needed.

Btw Shadow and other crypto coins are about privacy, not exatly about "doing illegal stuff without facing the consequences". If you do bad stuff, expect it coming around.

So again – how many men did Shen exactly save prison time, Child_harold? I take it you wouldn't argue with made up stuff.. after all, how could we take anything you say seriously then?



Allow me to group these. Yes, our thread is modded and you alone know why. You were told MANY times, but fine, there goes again: Shadow's BTCT thread is an announcement thread. It's for annoucement. Updates from devs and community. Not for chatter and endless GIFs or youtube links to your favourite music. It's irrelevant. There's Slack/IRC for that.

Have a look at bitcointalk – does it look like a nice community? Far from it. Why would we want to spend time in this, when everyone's just attacking others? Not me.

Don't know where you did get that we promote "free speech" but sure. Shadow promotes privacy.



As mentioned before, at least now everybody knows this is just about you. Shadow is just your target, which you try to bully.

On the other hand, I call upon members to make up their own mind. You might not like Shadow, but at least you see what C_H is made of.

Cheers.

And yet even now @systh you come at me with your poison-tongue like some droided banshee trying to disabuse me of my victory?

Allow me to disabuse YOU of something; that the following statement should convince anybody that you guys are at best liars and at worst delusional:


In fact, our team is growing stronger and larger in time, new faces are enthusiastic to help out. Every this glitch just brings us closer togerther with higher motivation. So thanks actually.
But this is far from Shadow's end, I assure you




Let me ask you 3 questions:

1. Did Shen save men prison-time?
2. Is your thread still heavily modded with a deleteBot?
3. How do you reconcile SDC's censorship with their claimed "free speech" values?


I call upon members of this bitcointalk community to speak up about what's happening here.
If you support me then stand up and be counted.

For what trouble? If you start a fight, ofc you'll get into trouble. Or do you just want to bash other's work and expect it not to have any consequences?

And as usual. Yelling about others not answering your questions and then still just cherry-picking weakest or "insulting" parts of other's responses.. Don't you have anything to say about the rest?

(I'm still not over Shadow as many others. Which by definition means it's not dead, so bad luck; try it next time.)

These are the kinds of insults I've been getting for my trouble  

Shadow is Dead, Get Over It.