As I posted in the other KNC thread, to me it seems the key point is that people who bought miners directly 'make income' from the machines vs crafters or hobbyists using a machine or tool to make something and then keep it or give away at no cost to friends,family, etc. In other words, there is no direct financial gain by crafters/hobbyists using the machine
Making money be it either by selling your products made from using a machine or tool or in this case, a machine directly generating income makes the buyers a business vs a consumer. The fact that a miner generally runs 24x7x365 doing what it does (generating income) clinches it.
Now if the suit(s) had been based on simple failure to fulfill the terms of a sales contract or other breach of Contract I think the Courts wold have looked at it differently.
But I mean really.....in Sweden (or hell maybe everywhere) you can promote your miners and state in interviews (that I remember seeing) saying you will sell your 'miners' to ANYONE and they can be run at home etc etc....BUT as soon as you buy it from KNC your are a BUSINESS because KNC says you are a BUSINESS ...thus under Swedish law they can automatically make you not protected under consumer protection laws.
Man that is a 'neat trick' whatever you sell you say the person buying is a 'business' and you never have any constraints on anything you sell 'no matter how lame' because you as the Seller have deemed them a 'Business'
Talk about a 'Catch 22' ..IF I want the product and I am not a business....and state I am not a business and purchase the item..I then am 'magically' a business and have no consumer protection......all to the companies benifit and no protection to the consumer...with KNC ALWAYS no matter what the circumstances ...automatically 'upgrading your purchase' to a business....pretty slick
sheesh....
With all I'm learning about 'consumer protection' in Sweden and the USA (In the USA for example General motors hit ignition problems on vehicles for 10 years plus that caused over 100 deaths...they paid a 1 Billion dollar fine I think it was and no one was held accountable..no jail for anything for anyone) ...anyway if this is what 'consumer protection' has come to on me buying anything from a toaster to a car..I am afraid to even LOOK AT what the Insurance I have really covers for loss and/or Medical Insurance for the same...now we are talking real money...hell it is probably much worse ...with that kinda real money ..it could keep me up for weeks ....likely just as bad.
I swear stuff likes this makes me want to take a vow and dump modern society and technology and 'Just Go Amish" ....except for that whole work from dusk till dawn thing behind a mule...I'd do so
*hmmm........hot Amish girls....er no must resist......1 hr with girl 12 hours with plow.....Ack!*