Topic: The Coming Fork(s) Safety For BItcoins - page 2. (Read 2791 times)

What do you think?

I have come across a blog regarding how to protect our btc for the coming forks. You might wanna check this https://its[Suspicious link removed]/how-to-get-prepared-for-segwit2x-and-bip148-secure-your-bitcoins/ based on the given steps, i guess the paper wallet is the most secure way. You can choose which one would best suit you.

NOT true at all. When the conditions at my post above will be met, in order to claim your BTG yo'll have to do something like this
https://electrum.org/bcc2.txt

As far as B2X is concerned you didn't read my post where I documented that Jaxx is part of the NYA
http://segwit.party/nya/
Move them ASAP to i.e. Electrum to avoid troubles as B2X has no Replay Protection at all.

Thanks guys,

The main concern I see is the replay protection for both B2X and BTG.

So, simply having BTC in Jaxx where I have my private keys should not be a problem.

But, what if Jaxx decided after the fork(s) to follow the new blockchains and not the BTC blockchain? This means that my BTC will be automatically converted to the new chain! Then if B2X is 0.5 BTC then my “money” will be valued at half, 500 usd instead of 1000 usd.

It is so critical. What is the best way not to lose BTC or lose value (in usd)?

You cannot claim BTG until a wallet for it will be released and tested for safety by the community.
FYI the BTG fork has to be mined yet and its mainnet is not yet up and running with Replay-protection tested and running.

There is still no Bitcoin Gold network. It's really weird that exchanges like Bitfinex are treating it as if BTG is a real coin as opposed to a coin split contract or futures contract. The code is broken, there is no replay protection, and there is no network. BTG literally doesn't exist. So, wallet software will not allow you to claim any...this is correct.


Regarding the fork, there is no reason to move BTC from Jaxx to a paper wallet. You control your private keys on Jaxx, so you should have access to both your BTC and B2X after the fork. Claiming the B2X is a bit tricky because there is no replay protection. I would wait until some good tutorials emerge on how to separate the BTC from B2X. If you're not careful, you might lose BTC in the process.

Now,  I have my BTC in a paper wallet before BTG Fork, plus some in Jaxx after the BTG fork.

Still couldn’t find a way to claim my BTG... anybody knows howto?

For the next fork B2X, should I move my latest BTC from Jaxx to paper wallet before the B2X fork?

How to claim the B2X?

Nope,, even my bitcoin wallet is an exchange and not supporting the bitcoin Gold fork.. They give us assurance as they’re client that they will release the bitcoin gold equivalent but for us to provide bitcoin gold address that will receive it.. They do it with bitcoin Cash and I’m still sure they will even on Segwit2x.. That’s why I do trust them for they’re always be the best in my eyes..

I said SEGWIT2X NOT BTG.
BTG fork has already happened, though not witnessed by any mining.

Are you sure? I've read that it was to be at 491407.  
Currently it's 491681, so we are getting closer. I was almost certain that it will happen today, on Wednesday.

If that's the case we have an interesting situation where Yobit allowed me to sell my BTG and withdraw BTC before the fork. My BTC got sent to another exchange that is supposed to give users BTG after the fork, which means that I might get my BTG twice   I'm really confused unless you were wrong with the block number.

The main problem here are the malicious miners, which at the same time happen to be insanely influential in what they do. It has nothing to do with the protocol anymore, but more with the fact that a fork is the road to millions of dollars in instant profits, especially for the large holders behind the scenes. In case of the BG fork, it's obvious that there is only one motive that pops up, and that's their blatant greed. 200K in premine is beyond insane, and they believe to get away with it like it's just a normal thing. I have noticed that throughout the internet, there has been somewhat of a fork Gold fever, where people actually look forward to forks, while they previously were afraid that it could even damage Bitcoin. Again, greed.

BTG
1) there is a high chance that there will be an ICO sell of pre-mined BTG
2)BTG futures are consequently experiencing a dump
3)When BTG wallet will be ready its source code will have to be examined under security aspects and ICO sell maybe will have happened.
4)DON'T leave your BTC on exchanges

EDIT:
Remember that SEGWIT2X fork will happen at block 494,784

This is the thing that makes me trouble, I do not like fork events for making confused, I hope there is no fork or segwit anymore, because it will hinder the bitcoin price increase.

This depends where you are keeping your coins, if you are having on some exchanges that are not supporters of bitcoin gold then i presume that you/he/me wont receive bitcoin gold at all. Off course this dont need to be the case, maybe they will latter adopt this but necessary at all. Some choose this other dont.

Good for me,, as I have received an update not officially but from one of they’re support team that we can claim bitcoin gold equivalent to our bitcoin holdings but to transfer to an bitcoin wallet address because they don’t support this fork.. But maybe I need more clarification on the Segwit2x or they don’t include as they might be discussing it for now..

I'd like to share some more info with you:

Bittrex stance regarding BTG:
https://support.bittrex.com/hc/en-us/articles/115002320451-Statement-on-Bitcoin-Gold-BTG-

BitPanda's one, including SegWit2X:
http://mailchi.mp/coinimal/bitpandas-fork-policy?e=4d6a54d0c9

Coinbase:
https://blog.coinbase.com/timeline-and-support-bitcoin-segwit2x-and-bitcoin-gold-eda72525efd
Inside this post pay due attention to this part: "Approximately 24–48 hours post fork. Once we have ensured that the blockchains are stable, Coinbase will re-enable Bitcoin and Bitcoin2x sends and receives. Please be careful when sending funds as certain wallets and bitcoin services may refer to the two blockchains differently.".
I'll confess I couldn't help thinking to the words "ludicrous and sneaky". As I said before Coinbase is part of NYA. Segwit2X won't have BY DESIGN Replay Protection.
Logical consequence: double spending. They say "certain wallets...may refer....". It is a masterpiece of twisting the truth, which is that SEGWIT2X has NOT done anything to avoid that. It is NOT wallets' fault. Oh, if at fork's date you'll have let's say 20BTC Coinbase will take care of adding 20B2X to your deposits. Fantastic, but what about BTC withdrawal after 24-48hrs? They are NOT saying that these they'll be sent to an address belonging to BTC blockchain, and be ready to learn that this will be a fault of these shitty wallets. Go figure!

You’re welcome 😉

EDIT: almost certainly will happen within 02:00 GMT

12 words you have stored is not a private key. Private key is related to the to the address and not to the wallet: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Private_key 12 words is the recovery phrase for the wallet.

Its happening in 8.5h from now on http://prntscr.com/h12q3l

Thanks to your post i've managed to take my BTC from Nicehash! If i didn't see it i would miss the window totally!!
Thank you again!

With my utmost respect this is misleading to say the least.

BCC was a friendly fork with strong replay protection.

BTG could be a friendly fork IF strong replay protection will be implemented, which IT IS NOT YET the case less than one day from fork !!!

SEGWIT2X is a hostile fork, with no replay protection by design (so by design it will allow for double spending, nice eh   ); SEGWIT2X is meant to increase miners incomes and will have all the right things in place to allow for turning BTC into a private game for restricted numbers.
33 of the original 56 signatories of NYA, around 59%, are portfolio companies in the Digital Currency Group (DCG), an investment company run by the principal instigator of the NYA. Even nicer  

Let's mention them all,  that is to say the ones still within NYA:

Abra (United States)
supports    

ANX (Hong Kong)
supports    

Bitangel.com / Chandler Guo (China)
supports    

Bitex (Argentina)
supports    

bitFlyer (Japan)
supports    

Bitfury (United States)
supports    

BitPay (United States)
supports    

BitPesa (Kenya)
supports    

Bitso (Mexico)
supports     

Bixin.com (China)
supports    

Blockchain (UK)
supports    

Bloq (United States)
supports    

BTCC (China)
supports    

BTER.com (China)
supports    

Circle (United States)
supports    

Civic (United States)
supports    

Coinbase (United States)
supports    

Coins.ph (Phillipines)
supports    

Decentral (Canada)
supports    

Digital Currency Group (United States)
supports    

Filament (United States)
supports    

Gavin Andresen (United States)
supports    

Genesis Global Trading (United States)
supports    

Genesis Mining (Hong Kong)
supports    

GoCoin (Isle of Man)
supports    

Grayscale Investments (United States)
supports    

Guy Corem (Israel)
supports     

Jaxx (Canada)
supports     

Korbit (South Korea)
supports    

Luno (Singapore)
supports     

MONI (Finland)
supports    

Netki (United States)
supports     

OB1 (United States)
supports     

Purse (United States)
supports    

Ripio (Argentina)
supports    

Safello (Sweden)
supports     

SFOX (United States)
supports    

ShapeShift (Switzerland)
supports    

Unocoin (India)
supports    

Veem (United States)
supports    

Xapo (United States)
supports


Bottom line:

The ones who left NYA (and will stay with BTC):

Bitwala (Germany)
withdrawn       

F2Pool (China)
withdrawn       

Vaultoro (Germany)
withdrawn      

Wayniloans (Argentina)
withdrawn       

BitOasis (United Arab Emirates)
withdrawn      

CryptoFacilities (UK)
withdrawn      

surBTC (Chile)
withdrawn  


The ones who left for BCC:

1Hash (China)
moved on to Bitcoin Cash    

BitClub Network (Hong Kong)
moved on to Bitcoin Cash    

Bitcoin.com (St. Kitts & Nevis)
moved on to Bitcoin Cash    

Bitmain (China)
moved on to Bitcoin Cash    

btc.com (China)
moved on to Bitcoin Cash    

BTC.TOP (China)
moved on to Bitcoin Cash    

ViaBTC (China)
moved on to Bitcoin Cash    

Yours (United States)
moved on to Bitcoin Cash

You can easily guess the reasoning behind that moving to BCC