[TOP-200] The most trusted members (DT1, DT2, DT3) - page 3.

Coin-1

legendary

Activity: 2576

Merit: 2272

Weekly update.

The Marketplace Trust Network still grows, and now there are 60 users in the full list of DT1 members. 5 of these users are excluded by other DT1 members.

All DT1 members currently trust 314 DT2 members.

Quote from: tmfp on October 27, 2018, 04:52:33 PM

Heh heh, looks like DT3's a cool place to be, look at the company I'm keeping.... Shocked

Congratulations on joining the DT1 group! In my opinion, you deserve to be a DT1 member, not a DT3 member.

Coin-1

legendary

Activity: 2576

Merit: 2272

The tables on the first page have been updated again.

Currently there are 50 users in the full list of DT1 members, but 3 of them are excluded by other DT1 members.

All DT1 members trust 244 DT2 members, all DT2 members trust 446 users.

Quote from: S_Therapist on January 13, 2019, 11:59:38 PM

Where have you gotten the info? OgNasty is not in DT1 and Lauda is. Or am I missing something here?

Edit- got it.

Quote

These three posts were relevant for January 4, 2019.

I just edited the post you quoted. I moved the text from my previous post into it:

Quote from: Coin-1 on January 13, 2019, 08:47:07 PM

For historical purposes, I will now publish the lists of DT1, DT2, DT3 members that were on January 4, 2019, before the Marketplace Trust system has been changed.

S_Therapist

sr. member

Activity: 308

Merit: 280

Coin-1

legendary

Activity: 2576

Merit: 2272

The list of DT3 members

	User name	Current rank ^[1]	Trust from DT2 members
1)	PsychoticBoy	Legendary	4 scores
2)	alexrossi	Legendary	4 scores
3)	marnem	Hero Member	4 scores
4)	palatine	Member	4 scores
5)	Akka	Legendary	3 scores
6)	fluffypony	Legendary	3 scores
7)	SFR10	Legendary	3 scores
8)	satoshi	Legendary	2 scores
9)	evoorhees	Legendary	2 scores
10)	Ente	Legendary	2 scores
11)	zefir	Legendary	2 scores
12)	eliale	Hero Member	2 scores
13)	Pistachio	Legendary	2 scores
14)	bitcoinplaza	Sr. Member	2 scores
15)	b!z	Legendary	2 scores
16)	Mikej0h	Full Member	2 scores
17)	notaek	Legendary	2 scores
18)	demonmaestro	Hero Member	2 scores
19)	androz	Hero Member	2 scores
20)	jesse11	Sr. Member	2 scores
21)	jimmothy	Hero Member	2 scores
22)	twbt	Legendary	2 scores
23)	TheNewAnon135246	Legendary	2 scores
24)	Lesbian Cow	Legendary	2 scores
25)	wheelz1200	Legendary	2 scores
26)	whywefight	Legendary	2 scores
27)	tmfp	Legendary	2 scores
28)	BtcCrazy1	Hero Member	2 scores
29)	Eodguy149	Hero Member	2 scores
30)	DannyM	Sr. Member	1 score
31)	lightbox	Full Member	1 score
32)	Keefe	Hero Member	1 score
33)	midnightmagic	Member	1 score
34)	Pieter Wuille	Legendary	1 score
35)	dacoinminster	Legendary	1 score
36)	Vladimir	Legendary	1 score
37)	Matt Corallo	Hero Member	1 score
38)	JWU42	Legendary	1 score
39)	Meni Rosenfeld	Legendary	1 score
40)	forrestv	Hero Member	1 score
41)	edd	Legendary	1 score
42)	SgtSpike	Legendary	1 score
43)	wariner	Legendary	1 score
44)	CydeWeys	Full Member	1 score
45)	Tachikoma	Legendary	1 score
46)	smooth	Legendary	1 score
47)	warrensgun	Full Member	1 score
48)	padrino	Legendary	1 score
49)	SolarSilver	Legendary	1 score
50)	stellan0r	Hero Member	1 score
51)	apetersson	Hero Member	1 score
52)	MRBONG411	Hero Member	1 score
53)	sang	Sr. Member	1 score
54)	Otoh	Legendary	1 score
55)	Dropkickdragout	Member	1 score
56)	Garr255	Legendary	1 score
57)	JoelKatz	Legendary	1 score
58)	BitcoinPappi	Legendary	1 score
59)	lightlord	Legendary	1 score
60)	gabbynot	Sr. Member	1 score
61)	FredericBastiat	Sr. Member	1 score
62)	iron77	Member	1 score
63)	abracadabra	Legendary	1 score
64)	fronti	Legendary	1 score
65)	yochdog	Legendary	1 score
66)	kano	Legendary	1 score
67)	rdponticelli	Sr. Member	1 score
68)	ngzhang	Hero Member	1 score
69)	phantitox	Sr. Member	1 score
70)	legolouman	Hero Member	1 score
71)	bbxx	Hero Member	1 score
72)	kneim	Legendary	1 score
73)	mrkent	Sr. Member	1 score
74)	HorseRider	Legendary	1 score
75)	ninjarobot	Hero Member	1 score
76)	xiangfu	Full Member	1 score
77)	Qoheleth	Legendary	1 score
78)	red123	Sr. Member	1 score
79)	frank600	Member	1 score
80)	BadBitcoin (James Sutton)	Sr. Member	1 score
81)	Voogru	Member	1 score
82)	J.Socal	Hero Member	1 score
83)	TangibleCryptography	Sr. Member	1 score
84)	Entropy-uc	Hero Member	1 score
85)	el_rlee	Legendary	1 score
86)	Newar	Legendary	1 score
87)	AmDD	Legendary	1 score
88)	serp	Sr. Member	1 score
89)	cedivad	Legendary	1 score
90)	ninjaboon	Legendary	1 score
91)	esadee	Member	1 score
92)	sLide.	Full Member	1 score
93)	dozerz	Legendary	1 score
94)	moni3z	Legendary	1 score
95)	darkip	Full Member	1 score
96)	ZuonKing	Sr. Member	1 score
97)	buysellbitcoin	Legendary	1 score
98)	sangaman	Sr. Member	1 score
99)	thanke	Member	1 score
100)	manav1112	Sr. Member	1 score
101)	Sonica	Member	1 score
102)	BG4	Legendary	1 score
103)	iluvpcs	Sr. Member	1 score
104)	yolo2222	Full Member	1 score
105)	Chefin	Legendary	1 score
106)	ruggedman_dan	Legendary	1 (+2 / -1) score
107)	cooldgamer	Legendary	1 score
108)	Rawted	Hero Member	1 score
109)	Wolf0	Legendary	1 score
110)	bernard75	Legendary	1 score
111)	QuiveringGibbage	Hero Member	1 score
112)	shawshankinmate37927	Legendary	1 score
113)	bitspill	Legendary	1 score
114)	temor	Full Member	1 score
115)	rage1337	Hero Member	1 score
116)	FullLife	Hero Member	1 score
117)	shibaji	Full Member	1 score
118)	mrbrt	Hero Member	1 score
119)	nottm28	Hero Member	1 score
120)	finlof	Hero Member	1 score
121)	Mogumodz	Sr. Member	1 score
122)	aspeer	Member	1 score
123)	razorfishsl	Sr. Member	1 score
124)	elchorizo	Full Member	1 score
125)	lbr	Sr. Member	1 score
126)	Foofighter	Hero Member	1 score
127)	sickhouse	Hero Member	1 score
128)	Nightowlace	Legendary	1 score
129)	Sophokles	Hero Member	1 score
130)	dhenson	Legendary	1 score
131)	gubi66	Sr. Member	1 score
132)	sahkan	Full Member	1 score
133)	ElJay	Full Member	1 score
134)	mavrick951	Member	1 score
135)	Kartaiv	Member	1 score
136)	trepex	Sr. Member	1 score
137)	Hiroaki	Sr. Member	1 score
138)	chanberg	Hero Member	1 score
139)	tyrion70	Legendary	1 score
140)	yoshiyoshi	Member	1 score
141)	Kushedout	Legendary	1 score
142)	kimosan	Hero Member	1 score
143)	gudmunsn	Sr. Member	1 score
144)	mrkubanftw	Sr. Member	1 score
145)	pmorici	Sr. Member	1 score
146)	Micky25	Legendary	1 score
147)	mars78	Hero Member	1 score
148)	jc328	Member	1 score
149)	BitJohn	Legendary	1 score
150)	americandesi	Hero Member	1 score
151)	ilpirata79	Sr. Member	1 score
152)	TheOrri	Member	1 score
153)	Deathwing	Legendary	1 score
154)	daddyfatsax	Legendary	1 score
155)	Financisto	Hero Member	1 score
156)	OnkelPaul	Legendary	1 score
157)	vanycon	Sr. Member	1 score
158)	superresistant	Legendary	1 score
159)	GBattaglia	Hero Member	1 score
160)	arbitrage001	Legendary	1 score
161)	Bakal	Sr. Member	1 score
162)	xhomerx10	Legendary	1 score
163)	vizique	Legendary	1 score
164)	abdullahadam	Sr. Member	1 score
165)	Damnsammit	Sr. Member	1 score
166)	frankenmint	Legendary	1 score
167)	sidehack	Legendary	1 score
168)	djjacket	Hero Member	1 score
169)	kopipe	Full Member	1 score
170)	last2stand	Full Member	1 score
171)	yakuza699	Legendary	1 score
172)	nahtnam	Legendary	1 score
173)	alh	Legendary	1 score
174)	alp	Full Member	1 score
175)	DyslexicZombei	Sr. Member	1 score
176)	gbianchi	Legendary	1 score
177)	drewph	Member	1 score
178)	armedmilitia	Hero Member	1 score
179)	bittawm	Legendary	1 score
180)	FlensGold	Legendary	1 score
181)	ndnh	Legendary	1 (+2 / -1) score
182)	lightfoot	Legendary	1 score
183)	xzone	Hero Member	1 score
184)	tagbond	Hero Member	1 score
185)	geoffreyqp	Hero Member	1 score
186)	gingpark	Member	1 score
187)	dbshck	Legendary	1 score
188)	Nitroshock	Member	1 score
189)	BitcoinBrains	Full Member	1 score
190)	7queue	Full Member	1 score
191)	blockage	Member	1 score
192)	mentalpanda	Legendary	1 score
193)	start the art	Sr. Member	1 score
194)	srknbyr	Hero Member	1 score
195)	Crestington	Legendary	1 score
196)	iglasses	Legendary	1 score
197)	DarKSm0ke	Full Member	1 score
198)	chek2fire	Legendary	1 score
199)	dance191	Sr. Member	1 score
200)	nicolasgramlich	Full Member	1 score

Total DT3 members: 356

These three posts were relevant for January 4, 2019.

Coin-1

legendary

Activity: 2576

Merit: 2272

The list of DT2 members

	User name	Current rank ^[1]	Trust from DT1 members	Trust from DT2 members
1)	John (John K.)	Legendary	5 scores	18 scores
2)	BadBear	Legendary	5 scores	15 scores
3)	-ck	Legendary	5 scores	3 scores
4)	casascius	Legendary	4 scores	7 scores
5)	grue	Legendary	4 scores	2 scores
6)	Vod	Legendary	3 scores	9 (+10 / -1) scores
7)	Gavin Andresen	Legendary	3 scores	6 (+7 / -1) scores
8)	gmaxwell	Legendary	3 (+4 / -1) scores	6 scores
9)	tysat	Legendary	3 scores	5 scores
10)	sirius	Sr. Member	3 scores	4 scores
11)	shorena	Legendary	3 scores	4 (+5 / -1) scores
12)	Stunna	Legendary	3 scores	3 (+4 / -1) scores
13)	Kluge	Legendary	3 scores	2 scores
14)	Blazr	Legendary	3 scores	2 scores
15)	SebastianJu	Legendary	2 scores	7 scores
16)	DannyHamilton	Legendary	2 scores	5 (+6 / -1) scores
17)	KWH	Legendary	2 scores	3 scores
18)	Michail1	Legendary	2 scores	2 scores
19)	dree12	Legendary	2 scores	2 scores
20)	BCB	Legendary	2 scores	2 (+3 / -1) scores
21)	markj113	Legendary	2 scores	2 scores
22)	Raize	Legendary	2 scores	1 score
23)	mprep	Legendary	2 scores	1 (+2 / -1) score
24)	mitzie	Legendary	2 scores	1 score
25)	generalt	Legendary	2 scores	1 score
26)	MCHouston	Hero Member	2 scores	1 score
27)	Carnth	Hero Member	2 scores	No score
28)	smoothie	Legendary	2 scores	No score
29)	DeaDTerra	Legendary	2 scores	0 (+2 / -2) score
30)	LoweryCBS	Sr. Member	2 scores	No score
31)	buysolar	Member	2 scores	No score
32)	guitarplinker	Legendary	2 scores	No score
33)	HagssFIN	Legendary	2 scores	No score
34)	Mitchell	Legendary	1 score	11 scores
35)	qwk	Legendary	1 score	7 scores
36)	bertani	Legendary	1 score	6 scores
37)	monbux	Legendary	1 score	6 scores
38)	DiamondCardz	Legendary	1 score	5 (+6 / -1) scores
39)	nanotube	Hero Member	1 score	4 scores
40)	paci	Hero Member	1 score	4 scores
41)	malevolent	Legendary	1 score	4 scores
42)	ibminer	Legendary	1 score	4 (+5 / -1) scores
43)	suchmoon	Legendary	1 (+2 / -1) score	4 scores
44)	rb1205	Legendary	1 score	3 scores
45)	phantastisch	Legendary	1 score	3 scores
46)	Stemby	Legendary	1 score	3 scores
47)	yxt	Legendary	1 score	3 scores
48)	ziomik	Legendary	1 score	3 scores
49)	maxmint	Hero Member	1 score	3 scores
50)	Cripto	Sr. Member	1 score	3 scores
51)	BigBitz	Hero Member	1 score	3 scores
52)	TookDk	Legendary	1 score	3 scores
53)	marlboroza	Legendary	1 score	3 scores
54)	Light	Hero Member	1 score	2 scores
55)	EPiSKiNG	Legendary	1 score	2 scores
56)	Mousepotato	Legendary	1 score	2 scores
57)	ercolinux	Legendary	1 score	2 scores
58)	diego1000	Hero Member	1 score	2 scores
59)	monkeynuts	Legendary	1 score	2 scores
60)	Welsh	Legendary	1 score	2 scores
61)	Wardrick	Legendary	1 score	2 (+3 / -1) scores
62)	byt411	Legendary	1 score	2 scores
63)	xetsr	Legendary	1 score	2 scores
64)	NLNico	Legendary	1 score	2 scores
65)	gdassori	Legendary	1 score	2 scores
66)	ghibly79	Legendary	1 score	2 scores
67)	devthedev	Legendary	1 score	2 (+3 / -1) scores
68)	ManeBjorn	Legendary	1 score	2 scores
69)	bithalo	Legendary	1 score	2 scores
70)	mexxer-2	Legendary	1 score	2 (+3 / -1) scores
71)	minerjones	Legendary	1 score	2 scores
72)	Finksy	Legendary	1 score	2 scores
73)	mikegogulski	Sr. Member	1 score	1 score
74)	molecular	Legendary	1 score	1 score
75)	piotr_n	Legendary	1 score	1 score
76)	MiningBuddy	Legendary	1 score	1 score
77)	BurtW	Legendary	1 score	1 score
78)	haploid23	Legendary	1 score	1 (+2 / -1) score
79)	zvs	Legendary	1 score	1 score
80)	the joint	Legendary	1 score	1 score
81)	sveetsnelda	Hero Member	1 score	1 score
82)	Korbman	Legendary	1 score	1 score
83)	DeathAndTaxes	Legendary	1 score	1 (+2 / -1) score
84)	Cablez	Legendary	1 score	1 score
85)	burnside	Legendary	1 score	1 score
86)	bigtimespaghetti	Legendary	1 score	1 score
87)	kelpy	Hero Member	1 score	1 score
88)	ThickAsThieves	Hero Member	1 score	1 score
89)	Xialla	Legendary	1 score	1 score
90)	idee2013	Sr. Member	1 score	1 score
91)	sayulita	Hero Member	1 score	1 score
92)	wttbs	Legendary	1 score	1 score
93)	LazerViking	Full Member	1 score	1 score
94)	hedgy73	Legendary	1 score	1 (+2 / -1) score
95)	Anon39	Legendary	1 score	1 score
96)	MadZ	Hero Member	1 score	1 score
97)	davvo	Hero Member	1 score	1 score
98)	yahoo62278	Legendary	1 score	1 (+2 / -1) score
99)	kilo17	Legendary	1 score	1 score
100)	hilariousetc	Legendary	1 score	1 (+2 / -1) score
101)	LoyceV	Legendary	1 score	1 score
102)	allinvain	Legendary	1 score	No score
103)	teukon	Legendary	1 score	No score
104)	majamalu	Legendary	1 score	No score
105)	jwzguy	Legendary	1 score	No score
106)	Caesium	Hero Member	1 score	No score
107)	piuk	Legendary	1 score	No score
108)	jackjack	Legendary	1 score	No score
109)	aigeezer	Legendary	1 score	No score
110)	CrazyGuy	Legendary	1 score	No score
111)	naypalm	Legendary	1 score	No score
112)	paraipan	Legendary	1 score	No score
113)	danieldaniel	Legendary	1 score	No score
114)	Mushroomized	Legendary	1 score	No score
115)	wallet.dat	Sr. Member	1 score	No score
116)	ineededausername	Legendary	1 score	No score
117)	Shawshank	Legendary	1 score	No score
118)	Bees Brothers	Sr. Member	1 score	No score
119)	xkrikl	Full Member	1 score	No score
120)	vgo	Legendary	1 score	No score
121)	Dabs	Legendary	1 score	No score
122)	btharper	Sr. Member	1 score	No score
123)	davecoin	Legendary	1 score	No score
124)	stenkross	Sr. Member	1 score	No score
125)	Benson Samuel	Legendary	1 score	No score
126)	LuisCar	Legendary	1 score	No score
127)	fernarios	Hero Member	1 score	No score
128)	shiftybugger	Newbie	1 score	No score
129)	fluidjax	Hero Member	1 score	No score
130)	ioxoi	Hero Member	1 score	No score
131)	dogie	Legendary	1 score	0 (+3 / -3) score
132)	binaryFate	Legendary	1 score	No score
133)	dwdoc	Legendary	1 score	No score
134)	Tywill	Newbie	1 score	No score
135)	Taras	Legendary	1 score	No score
136)	MarkAz	Hero Member	1 score	No score
137)	FiniteByDesign	Legendary	1 score	No score
138)	brutale2	Legendary	1 score	No score
139)	gentlemand	Legendary	1 score	No score
140)	Powell	Sr. Member	1 score	No score
141)	mindtrip	Legendary	1 score	No score
142)	alch1mista	Sr. Member	1 score	No score
143)	Rmcdermott927	Legendary	1 score	No score
144)	ThePhwner	Hero Member	1 score	No score
145)	argovian	Member	1 score	No score
146)	xandry	Legendary	1 score	No score
147)	DarkStar_	Legendary	1 score	0 (+2 / -2) score
148)	Tomatocage1	Newbie	1 score	No score
149)	loshia1974	Member	1 score	No score
150)	mdude77	Legendary	1 score	-1 score
151)	GIANNAT	Legendary	1 score	-1 score
152)	EFS	Legendary	1 score	-1 score
153)	iluvbitcoins	Legendary	1 score	-1 (+1 / -2) score
154)	sapta	Legendary	1 score	-1 score
155)	favdesu	Legendary	1 score	-2 (+1 / -3) scores
156)	Lutpin	Legendary	0 (+1 / -1) score	4 (+5 / -1) scores
157)	EcuaMobi	Legendary	0 (+1 / -1) score	3 scores
158)	The Pharmacist	Legendary	0 (+2 / -2) score	1 (+3 / -2) score
159)	cryptodevil	Legendary	0 (+1 / -1) score	0 (+2 / -2) score
160)	Gleb Gamow	Legendary	0 (+1 / -1) score	No score
161)	RHavar	Legendary	0 (+1 / -1) score	0 (+1 / -1) score
162)	Hhampuz	Hero Member	0 (+1 / -1) score	-1 score
163)	actmyname	Legendary	0 (+1 / -1) score	-2 (+1 / -3) scores
164)	BayAreaCoins	Legendary	0 (+1 / -1) score	-4 scores

Total DT2 members: 164

Look at my next post below.

Coin-1

legendary

Activity: 2576

Merit: 2272

For historical purposes, I will now publish the lists of DT1, DT2, DT3 members that were on January 4, 2019, before the Marketplace Trust system has been changed.

The list of DT1 members

	User name	Current rank ^[1]	Trust from DT1 members	Trust from DT2 members
1)	theymos	Legendary	6 scores	28 scores
2)	dooglus	Legendary	5 scores	14 scores
3)	Tomatocage	Legendary	3 scores	11 (+12 / -1) scores
4)	Maged	Legendary	3 scores	9 scores
5)	OgNasty	Legendary	3 scores	7 (+12 / -5) scores
6)	Cyrus	Legendary	3 scores	6 scores
7)	Blazed	Legendary	2 scores	14 (+15 / -1) scores
8)	SaltySpitoon	Legendary	2 scores	11 scores
9)	philipma1957	Legendary	2 scores	5 (+6 / -1) scores
10)	HostFat	Legendary	2 scores	4 (+7 / -3) scores
11)	hilariousandco	Legendary	1 score	5 (+6 / -1) scores
12)	dserrano5	Legendary	1 score	-1 score
13)	OldScammerTag	Newbie	No score	No score

^[1] - the rank that is based on the amount of merits regardless of the current activity

Look at my next post below.

Coin-1

legendary

Activity: 2576

Merit: 2272

My three posts on the first page have been updated.

On January 9, 2019, the DefaultTrust list has been changed in accordance with certain rules, therefore many new users have appeared and disappeared in this TOP-200.

This post was edited on January 28, 2019.

Coin-1

legendary

Activity: 2576

Merit: 2272

Weekly update.

iluvbitcoins is a new DT2 member. Congratulations! Cool

Also LoyceV has gained +1 score from another DT2 member and rose from 146th to 101st place.

Currently DT1 members trust 164 users.

Quote from: bill gator on October 27, 2018, 04:00:04 PM

Okay, then I understand where your numbers are coming from; my argument would be that your wording is a bit confusing or misleading. Calling them "scores" puts my head somewhere else, maybe it would be better to just refer to them as "inclusions" and "exclusions". I think more people would immediately know what you are talking about if you were to tweak your wording a bit.

I appreciate the clarification, but maybe instead of saying you're basing these ratings on "Marketplace Trust System" you could say something like "Trust lists", or "Trust Hierarchy".

I think that "score" is a good term for calling the overall trust from many individuals. Perhaps the mentioned file is a dump of the Marketplace trust network.

Quote from: bill gator on October 27, 2018, 04:00:04 PM

I'm pretty interested in hearing the reasoning behind dogie excluding philipma1957, but that's discussion for another thread.

I'm interested too. I guess that philipma1957 doesn't know about it.

Quote from: tmfp on October 27, 2018, 04:52:33 PM

Heh heh, looks like DT3's a cool place to be, look at the company I'm keeping.... Shocked

Yes, satoshi is a DT3 member. Cool

tmfp

legendary

Activity: 1932

Merit: 1737

"Common rogue from Russia with a bare ass."

Heh heh, looks like DT3's a cool place to be, look at the company I'm keeping.... Shocked

and I don't get outraged scammers inboxing me with abuse for Red Tagging them (not very often anyway, unless they've checked their "junk" untrusted feedback) Grin

And just to confirm what I think is so: If you go to

Trust summary>Trust settings>Trust depth (max 4)

and change the default from 2 to 3, then all the feedback that DT3 members have left will appear (for you only) as red/green numbers under the appropriate profiles and in their "trusted feedback", just as Levels 1 and 2 do by default setting?

Quote from: bill gator on October 27, 2018, 04:00:04 PM

maybe instead of saying you're basing these ratings on "Marketplace Trust System" you could say something like "Trust lists", or "Trust Hierarchy". That's just my two cents, but if all of this information is available for everybody within a couple of clicks, how is it helpful to post it in thread format?

As far as I can see, it's just an easy to read summary of the hierarchical version of the trust network which as you say, is available within a couple of clicks, but also rather opaque (to me anyway).
I don't think OP's trying to set up a "Trust Fork" or reinvent the wheel, from what I can make out.

tmfp

legendary

Activity: 1932

Merit: 1737

"Common rogue from Russia with a bare ass."

Heh heh, looks like DT3's a cool place to be, look at the company I'm keeping.... Shocked

and I don't get outraged scammers inboxing me with abuse for Red Tagging them (not very often anyway, unless they've checked their "junk" untrusted feedback) Grin

And just to confirm what I think is so: If you go to

Trust summary>Trust settings>Trust depth (max 4)

and change the default from 2 to 3, then all the DT3 members left feedback will appear (for you only) as red numbers under the appropriate profiles, just as Levels 1 and 2 do by default?

bill gator

legendary

Activity: 1372

Merit: 1123

Okay, then I understand where your numbers are coming from; my argument would be that your wording is a bit confusing or misleading. Calling them "scores" puts my head somewhere else, maybe it would be better to just refer to them as "inclusions" and "exclusions". I think more people would immediately know what you are talking about if you were to tweak your wording a bit.

I appreciate the clarification, but maybe instead of saying you're basing these ratings on "Marketplace Trust System" you could say something like "Trust lists", or "Trust Hierarchy". That's just my two cents, but if all of this information is available for everybody within a couple of clicks, how is it helpful to post it in thread format? Hope you don't mind me asking.

I'm pretty interested in hearing the reasoning behind dogie excluding philipma1957, but that's discussion for another thread.

Coin-1

legendary

Activity: 2576

Merit: 2272

Quote from: bill gator on October 27, 2018, 02:32:17 PM

Still though, I am left confused by the following line, which is just one example as there are many.

Quote

9) philipma1957 Legendary 2 scores 5 (+6 / -1) scores

It claims that a DT2 member has given a negative rating to philipma1957, unless I am misunderstanding the table and accompanying key. Can you help me understand what the -1 score represents in this particular example?

As I can see in the dump of the Marketplace trust system, 2 DT1 members trust philipma1957:

Code:

OgNasty->philipma1957
Tomatocage->philipma1957

6 DT2 members trust philipma1957:

Code:

MarkAz->philipma1957
hedgy73->philipma1957
EcuaMobi->philipma1957
suchmoon->philipma1957
HagssFIN->philipma1957
TookDk->philipma1957

1 DT2 member does not trust philipma1957:

Code:

dogie-/>philipma1957

bill gator

legendary

Activity: 1372

Merit: 1123

Quote from: Coin-1 on October 27, 2018, 02:26:45 PM

Ranks are fixed just now.

That's a step in the right direction, I suppose, for at least the sake of functionality and accuracy.

Still though, I am left confused by the following line, which is just one example as there are many.

Quote

9) philipma1957 Legendary 2 scores 5 (+6 / -1) scores

It claims that a DT2 member has given a negative rating to philipma1957, unless I am misunderstanding the table and accompanying key. Can you help me understand what the -1 score represents in this particular example?

Coin-1

legendary

Activity: 2576

Merit: 2272

Quote from: bill gator on October 27, 2018, 02:17:12 PM

In your OP it has philipma1957 listed as a Full Member, with the trust of 5 (+6 / -1) scores, help me understand.

Ranks are fixed just now.

bill gator

legendary

Activity: 1372

Merit: 1123

Quote from: Coin-1 on October 27, 2018, 02:14:07 PM

Please note that my lists are based on the Marketplace trust system, not on feedbacks.

Consider me doubly confused then, because I've been under the impression for a long time that Trust-Feedback and Marketplace Trust are one in the same. I'm going to need this explained to me, because either I am misunderstanding what you are saying, I don't understand the trust system or you are talking sideways. How are you considering the Marketplace Trust without the Feedbacks left through that system?

In your OP it has philipma1957 listed as a Full Member, with the trust of 5 (+6 / -1) scores, help me understand.

Coin-1

legendary

Activity: 2576

Merit: 2272

Quote from: bill gator on October 27, 2018, 01:52:25 PM

https://bpip.org/report.aspx?r=mosttrusted This is Vod's rendition of the most trusted users around the forum. I do not mean to sound discouraging, but what exactly are you bringing to the table/conversation that is not already available or has not already been said? I appreciate the effort, and find these kind of things interesting, but you're sort of recreating the wheel if you ask me.

I know about the useful resource made by Vod. Please note that my lists are based on the Marketplace trust system, not on feedbacks.

Let me explain how I create this TOP-200.

Every week theymos publishes the dump of the Marketplace trust system here:
https://bitcointalk.org/trust.txt.xz

This file does not contain feedbacks. The "->" substring indicates a positive trust, the "-/>" substring indicates a negative trust. My analysis can read this dump and create TOP-200.

Best wishes.

bill gator

legendary

Activity: 1372

Merit: 1123

It would seem more coherent to make an articulated list of changes that you believe should be made to the Trust system, rather than creating a "fork" of the trust system within a thread without much explanation as to why you are doing so. I don't believe our trust system is perfect, but if you're going to create a thread about "The most trusted" it would require that you explain your criteria, especially since you're not just compiling the highest trust score, but using other criteria.

Do you believe that your thread here does a better job at representing the marketplace history or accrued trust feedback than our current system?

A bit bizarre, I agree.

OgNasty

donator

Activity: 4760

Merit: 4323

Leading Crypto Sports Betting & Casino Platform

Quote from: bill gator on October 27, 2018, 01:52:25 PM

I would argue that this thread is unnecessary, because there is already multiple compiled lists that do exactly what you are seeking to accomplish here.

https://bpip.org/report.aspx?r=mosttrusted This is Vod's rendition of the most trusted users around the forum. I do not mean to sound discouraging, but what exactly are you bringing to the table/conversation that is not already available or has not already been said? I appreciate the effort, and find these kind of things interesting, but you're sort of recreating the wheel if you ask me.

A bit bizarre that this user is trying to create their own “most trusted” list that doesn’t use the current trust system scoring method. If taking the time to do this, it could at least reflect the reality of the system or be called something else like Vod did.

bill gator

legendary

Activity: 1372

Merit: 1123

I would argue that this thread is unnecessary, because there is already multiple compiled lists that do exactly what you are seeking to accomplish here.

https://bpip.org/report.aspx?r=mosttrusted This is Vod's rendition of the most trusted users around the forum. I do not mean to sound discouraging, but what exactly are you bringing to the table/conversation that is not already available or has not already been said? I appreciate the effort, and find these kind of things interesting, but you're sort of recreating the wheel if you ask me.

The Sceptical Chymist

legendary

Activity: 3458

Merit: 6948

Top Crypto Casino

Quote from: LFC_Bitcoin on October 14, 2018, 05:30:26 AM

Why am I not in DT3?
I have one + trust from hilarious&co.

I didn't understand that distinction between getting a positive trust and being included in a DT member's trust list until about a year ago, and for a while I'd assumed I was in DT3 since Vod had left me a positive trust. Lutpin set me straight on that one, IIRC.

Quote from: LFC_Bitcoin on October 14, 2018, 06:11:52 AM

What an idiot (me)

That's exactly how I felt at the time as well. lol

Whew. I didn't realize (or had forgotten) that there are that many members in DT1/DT2. I don't see many of them active anymore, unless they hang around sections I tend to avoid, like mining and securities.

Topic: [TOP-200] The most trusted members (DT1, DT2, DT3) - page 3. (Read 3227 times)