US Tariff Ruling N297495 = 2.6% mandatory tariff on bitcoin mining hardware - page 6.

Gabrics

full member

Activity: 193

Merit: 124

Just digging around

Indeed. The problem is that you can't prove as there is no official firmware for other purposes. If I remember correctly the main point was the single purpose of the device. It can't be reprogrammed (they also said something about according to the manufacturer...).

It would be this simple in my opinion: Sell the unit configured (and marketed) as a webserver (etc.) and ship it with a firmware with some web hosting features. Than offer an ALTERNATE firmware which can mine Bitcoin on the side and/or dedicated.

I think after this it would be justifiable as a general purpose computer. But most of this up to the manufacturer and Bitmain is doing KYC for a while (just as an example what can be expected from the manufacturer).

Quote from: ccgllc on November 16, 2018, 05:57:48 PM

The equipment was duty free at the time, although they charged me fees for dealing with customs.

Has anybody won the argument with Fed-Ex that since they were responsible for dealing with customs, and errors in paperwork are on them?

Unfortunately CBP claims that it was not categorized correctly. So it never was 0%, but YOU did not report it correctly (or the shipping company acting on your behalf). Hence it is your error and there is practcally no limit how long they can go back (according to our customs agent).

It is questionable as their "ruling" came out later, so how should we know?

We should (according to them) be happy that they "only" charge the actual percentage and not a fine (yet).

minefarmbuy

full member

Activity: 1022

Merit: 221

We are not retail.

Just drive sales more under ground allowing these devices to be more prone to "tampering" with.

gmaxwell

staff

Activity: 4284

Merit: 8808

Virtually every mining device is a general purpose computer running linux plus a fixed function accelerator. Is this so different than, say, an android phone which has several fixed function accelerators (like the speech detection 'hello google' hardware, wifi modem, etc.)?

SCheek

copper member

Activity: 70

Merit: 2

Suprised it took this long to be honest. With all the various ways the US is trying to hurt China, miners seems an obvious choice.

minefarmbuy

full member

Activity: 1022

Merit: 221

We are not retail.

Interpretations? So you've proposed a new ruling?

Essentially we decided to not pursue mining hardware but went after the materials we source, even those outside of this area as those won't change so frequently. With hardware updating every three months you would have to know what is going to be released for a product exemption of the added tariffs. Just since late august there have been maybe 8-10 new releases? Coupled with de minimus threshold, market valuation, just seemed like patience is all that is needed when looking at product side.

What we really need to look at is supporting our good actors in domestic manufacturing like Gekko Science.

I'll be excited to see your submits on regulations.gov once available. Exemptions excepted or not I still think congratulations are in order!

Blokforge

member

Activity: 97

Merit: 35

So just to update, our attorneys in washington have not found any other exclusion requests at this time, if ours are the only ones that go in we will put up link for positive comments and support. We have multiple being submitted to cover multiple applications of the technology and interpretations. This is an expensive process and hopefully benefits the industry as it needs some help right now with current prices. We will accept high fives in return at the next consensus if it works out.

minefarmbuy

full member

Activity: 1022

Merit: 221

We are not retail.

I would always project 27.6% at this point.

sarcheer

copper member

Activity: 330

Merit: 103

Quote from: SCheek on December 10, 2018, 07:32:53 AM

My opinion is that there will be further tariffs given that Trump knows the US can't compete with China on electrical costs so will want to cut down the trade he would view as a low level employer and inefficient relatively.

Are speaking about competitiveness in terms of bitcoin mining or industry in general? If the former, it sounds like you are implying Trump is aware of the bitcoin mining industry or even taking it into account when he applied broad taxes to most Chinese goods. If the latter, I seriously doubt that electric costs relative to China are a serious problem for much of US industry given they enjoy much lower rates than average consumers. I have no doubt industry (like the rest of us) would love lower energy prices, but, given the copious tax incentives available to factories/manufacturers, electricity is rarely THE determining factor in profitability or competitiveness. Well, with the exception of bitcoin mining haha.

Exoskeleton

sr. member

Activity: 338

Merit: 251

Quote from: minefarmbuy on December 11, 2018, 08:04:49 PM

I imagine we'll have a burst of celebration posts to inform everyone.

A shipping company has given us a "free ride" on some orders to a certain dollar amount. We're looking at verifying, but there are some stipulations we have to follow for them to soak the duties for us. We'll see how that goes, let me know if you want to be guinea pig.

Not when it comes to this stuff. Tongue

Im fine making a few hundred dollars a month small time mining with second hand gear. But I don't need to be ordering gear not knowing what my eventual customs fees will be.

SCheek

copper member

Activity: 70

Merit: 2

My opinion is that there will be further tariffs given that Trump knows the US can't compete with China on electrical costs so will want to cut down the trade he would view as a low level employer and inefficient relatively.

minefarmbuy

full member

Activity: 1022

Merit: 221

We are not retail.

I imagine we'll have a burst of celebration posts to inform everyone.

A shipping company has given us a "free ride" on some orders to a certain dollar amount. We're looking at verifying, but there are some stipulations we have to follow for them to soak the duties for us. We'll see how that goes, let me know if you want to be guinea pig.

Exoskeleton

sr. member

Activity: 338

Merit: 251

It does look like they are making progress on easing other tariffs so I have hope this will either go to 10% or less, or be eliminated altogether.

Anyone with anymore info on the possibility please share what you know. Keep us up to date if you can.

studio_mining

jr. member

Activity: 33

Merit: 10

Quote from: Biffa on December 03, 2018, 05:57:14 AM

So the 25% duty has a 90 day reprieve?

No. Duty remains for ASICs...any new duties on other goods (many are currently at 10% and were scheduled to escalate to 25% after Jan 1)

Current duties are still 25% + 2.6%

Biffa

legendary

Activity: 3234

Merit: 1221

So the 25% duty has a 90 day reprieve?

Searing

copper member

Activity: 2898

Merit: 1465

Clueless!

Quote from: philipma1957 on November 23, 2018, 09:02:20 PM

I think i will end up paying about 800 to fed ex. maybe less.

I just grabbed a good black friday deal a 2 tb ssd for 286 - 57 coupon = 229 - 4% rebate = 219.84 for this 2 tb ssd.

all in all last year was a good year this year not too good.

2 quotes .. high price 1) be careful what you wish for

2nd quote .. you don't always get what you want, but sometimes you get what you need

just has to hang together to act as a bridge will 2021 (or at least 2020) when I tap into my full retirement....i like not working hopefully having to work for idiots again in the next 1.5 - 2.5 years....

by the by

again, anyone getting any of these notices from UPS? maybe UPS was more on the ball back in the day? I seem to remember at the time paying fees on UPS stuff

and not so much on fed ex (I am probably delusional)

brad

philipma1957

legendary

Activity: 4326

Merit: 8950

'The right to privacy matters'

Quote from: Searing on November 23, 2018, 04:41:53 PM

ah...back in the day I did pay fees on miners coming in....so perhaps it will not be much of an issue in my case ....(fingers cross)

currently selling at the Black Friday low ...its how I roll....got to stay retired next year...what are the rest of you doing?

the needs must when the devil drives....don't ya know

Anyway. I just think we are gonna see quite a big weekend dump....

brad

I think i will end up paying about 800 to fed ex. maybe less.

I just grabbed a good black friday deal a 2 tb ssd for 286 - 57 coupon = 229 - 4% rebate = 219.84 for this 2 tb ssd.

all in all last year was a good year this year not too good.

Searing

copper member

Activity: 2898

Merit: 1465

Clueless!

Quote from: minefarmbuy on November 23, 2018, 03:28:17 PM

UPS collects duties, their more proactive to charge prior to delivery like DHL.

ah...back in the day I did pay fees on miners coming in....so perhaps it will not be much of an issue in my case ....(fingers cross)

currently selling at the Black Friday low ...its how I roll....got to stay retired next year...what are the rest of you doing?

the needs must when the devil drives....don't ya know

Anyway. I just think we are gonna see quite a big weekend dump....

brad

minefarmbuy

full member

Activity: 1022

Merit: 221

We are not retail.

UPS collects duties, their more proactive to charge prior to delivery like DHL.

Searing

copper member

Activity: 2898

Merit: 1465

Clueless!

Quote from: ccgllc on November 23, 2018, 03:19:19 PM

Received Fed-Ex notifications for my (2) orders above $2500 - now several months after my original notification for a $100K+ order. Clearly they are working their way down.

Have NOT received an invoice for anything yet, although they recently tried to bill my credit card for that $100K+ order.

I see a lot on here about fed ex sending this stuff out and not much on UPS..or am I delusional?

brad

ccgllc

copper member

Activity: 658

Merit: 101

Math doesn't care what you believe.

Received Fed-Ex notifications for my (2) orders above $2500 - now several months after my original notification for a $100K+ order. Clearly they are working their way down.

Have NOT received an invoice for anything yet, although they recently tried to bill my credit card for that $100K+ order.

Topic: US Tariff Ruling N297495 = 2.6% mandatory tariff on bitcoin mining hardware - page 6. (Read 26790 times)