Author

Topic: [∞ YH] solo.ckpool.org 2% fee solo mining 256 blocks solved! - page 205. (Read 102489 times)

newbie
Activity: 25
Merit: 2
Hello everyone! I was able to connect to the pool and start mining. Although my hash rate is tiny I would like to know what exactly happens when I get a message like
`Accepted CPU 1 Diff 17k/10k`
Do I somehow need to adjust the difficulty that is set by default (10k) to be closer to the pool difficulty which is currently 21.7 T?
Any reference articles on that where I can read the explanation myself? Tried looking it up in few places already but to no avail.
Thank for your help!
Forget mining with CPU or GPU. It does not make any sense even as lottery.

Not seeing stats for such slow rates is normal on this pool. Actually it makes no sense at all to try with this. Please consider NEWPAC usb miner if you want to have some fun with bitcoin mining (at least to see your stats Smiley))). Not for earnings. You will earn nothing. It's also very doubtful as a lottery. Use solochance.com to estimate your chances of finding a block.

newbie
Activity: 6
Merit: 0
Hello everyone! I was able to connect to the pool and start mining. Although my hash rate is tiny I would like to know what exactly happens when I get a message like
`Accepted CPU 1 Diff 17k/10k`
Do I somehow need to adjust the difficulty that is set by default (10k) to be closer to the pool difficulty which is currently 21.7 T?
Any reference articles on that where I can read the explanation myself? Tried looking it up in few places already but to no avail.
Thank for your help!
full member
Activity: 637
Merit: 131

LOL, not even sure if this a serious "accusation" or just a "joke" I surely don't have the greatest sense of humor.Roll Eyes, however, if you carefully read my post and the one which I replied to, you will see that I dropped a bomb of possitvity and optimism and explained "in some detail" how solo mining chances are not all that bad compared to the lotto as opposed to what has been mentioned in the post I quoted.

With that being said, I am sure you are not a newbie just as sure as I am of that fact that I am nowhere near experienced, we all are here to learn (maybe except for the other person you compared me to Grin).


it was a drunk accusation mikey  Tongue  but i will give you this, you take criticism well.   you didnt get all keyboard warrior like i did  Sad
and yes the other person i compared you to, does know it all  Grin

member
Activity: 150
Merit: 10
Stale shares are normal your miner may have been working on some work and a new block was found before it could submit hence stale work. getwork fail not sure about.

Thanks.   Just wasn't sure if it was normal or not.  I found the info below - but i think maybe it was my miner's network connection.


ST: STaged work items (ready to use).

SS: Stale Shares discarded (detected and not submitted so don't count as rejects)

NB: New Blocks detected on the network

LW: Locally generated Work items

GF: Getwork Fail Occasions (Pool server slow to provide work)

RF: Remote Fail occasions (Pool server slow to accept work)

hero member
Activity: 1220
Merit: 612
OGRaccoon
Stale shares are normal your miner may have been working on some work and a new block was found before it could submit hence stale work. getwork fail not sure about.
member
Activity: 150
Merit: 10
Is something up with the pool?  Been mining a few weeks now, never a stale share or a GF - but  yesterday i had 17 stale shares and GF: 2

ST: 1  SS: 17  NB: 3600  LW: 1623749423  GF: 2  RF: 0

Does that occasionally happen?  I'm a newbie with btc mining.

legendary
Activity: 2394
Merit: 6581
be constructive or S.T.F.U

LOL, not even sure if this a serious "accusation" or just a "joke" I surely don't have the greatest sense of humor.Roll Eyes, however, if you carefully read my post and the one which I replied to, you will see that I dropped a bomb of possitvity and optimism and explained "in some detail" how solo mining chances are not all that bad compared to the lotto as opposed to what has been mentioned in the post I quoted.

With that being said, I am sure you are not a newbie just as sure as I am of that fact that I am nowhere near experienced, we all are here to learn (maybe except for the other person you compared me to Grin).
full member
Activity: 637
Merit: 131
The most known lottery in Poland: you cross 6 out of 49 numbers. 6 are drawn from pool.
The chance for hitting all 6 is 1:13 983 816
You can win 2,5mln EUR

Bitcoin, chance of hitting a block a day with 70 Gigahash (I mine for fun with) is 1:14 993 148
You can win about 180k EUR

Actually buying a lottery ticket every day to win 2,5mln EUR is wiser.

A great analysis but I have reasons to believe that it's a bit far from accurate, the 1 in 13m chance you have with the lotto is once every week, while the odds for hitting a block which you mentioned is based on a shot every day, so for this to be a bit more accurate you need to multiply the lotto ticket cost by 7, and then if we were to assume that the average lifespan for the miner is 2 years, then you will need to multiply that by 730, so if the ticket price is 2$, you will pay $1,460 to match the number of trials that a miner can have.

I am aware that there are other prize catogires of 3,4,5 matches but I think the prize is too small ot be considered, you also need to keep in mind that when you hit a bitcoin block you keep all the rewards and nobody can share them with you, where in the lotto, you are subject to share the prize with x amunt of people, on the othre hand, playing the lotto means you won't have to pay the power bill, no matiance, no cleaning no dead PSUs or a firmware glitch.

There are many more factors invovled to determine which would be econcmically better, I don't have the time, skills nor the desire to do that in-depth analysis (pehabs someone who does play the lotto and solo mine at the same time can do it) but I do tend to agree that perbaps and most likely playing the lotto is cheaper than solo mining.

With that being said, Solo mining is way more fun!! Grin



hey mikey,

i dunno what crawled up your ego and died to make you such a technical negative "karen",  but youve been a big ass debbie downer on simple solo mining questions asked here. you're starting to sound like another previous member who started their own mining site and only comes here to criticize the "not so experienced coder" members.   please take your negative criticism to more advanced areas of this forum.   we want simple stats, that say my puny 450Th will give me a
Chance per block: 1 in 376,480
Chance per day: 1 in 2,614
Time estimate: 7 years

 thats enough info for us noobies.
thank you kind sir
please take it down a notch on your expertise
 Wink
newbie
Activity: 2
Merit: 0
I did some rough calculations. it's a gambling, yes. taking into account risks and rewards, it is roughly 23 Powerball tickets a day per 1 TH/s.
Great  Smiley! Powerball Tickets (PBTs) - one of the best comparisons I saw so far Smiley. So today roughly at 120 TH would make 120TH * 23 PBTs * 365days ~ 1Mio PBTs / year  Grin

There are solid gears and some low-quality gears, you want to get the ones that can survive, not S9k, S9se, avoid the 17 series of bitmain altogether, just search the forum you'll find a lot of topics that discuss mining gears quality and robustness.
Thank you for that hint!
legendary
Activity: 2394
Merit: 6581
be constructive or S.T.F.U
I don't need to argue these facts with you

Well, you just did, I explained to you, the other members explained the matter in a different way but you still think that you are correct, it's sad that someone who registered here back in 2014 lacks a basic understanding of mining actually works, but if you feel good about yourself - it all that matters, numbers and law of physics are irrelevant.

Assuming I join solo.ckpool.org for solo mining, what risks are still present *except*

- the money I spend in hardware (including breakage)
- the money I spend in power

Other than the obvious like your miner catching fire and all the stuff that you probably already know, there only risk is the power bill and the cost of the mining gear.

Quote
Any tips are greatly appreciated. Thank you Smiley

There are solid gears and some low-quality gears, you want to get the ones that can survive, not S9k, S9se, avoid the 17 series of bitmain altogether, just search the forum you'll find a lot of topics that discuss mining gears quality and robustness.
legendary
Activity: 2702
Merit: 1030
Yes I am a pirate, 300 years too late!
I did my own claculation for mining here:
It is hopeless with my amount of hashrate, lets try it anyway, because: who did not try, will never win.  Cheesy

Even a blind squirrel finds a nut now and then!!
legendary
Activity: 2483
Merit: 1482
-> morgen, ist heute, schon gestern <-
I did my own claculation for mining here:
It is hopeless with my amount of hashrate, lets try it anyway, because: who did not try, will never win.  Cheesy
newbie
Activity: 1
Merit: 0
First of all, thank you for the valuable information in that thread and of course, thank you for keeping the pool running Smiley!

I am new to crypto currencies and read into the topic for a couple weeks now. For some reasons, I decided to join the game, buy some mining hardware and gamble solo for a block. And yes, I clearly understand this as gambling.

However, it seems hard to find actual (recent) information on solo mining, particularly risks involved.

So my question is:

Assuming I join solo.ckpool.org for solo mining, what risks are still present *except*

- the money I spend in hardware (including breakage)
- the money I spend in power

?

Are there any?

Any tips are greatly appreciated. Thank you Smiley

I did some rough calculations. it's a gambling, yes. taking into account risks and rewards, it is roughly 23 Powerball tickets a day per 1 TH/s.
legendary
Activity: 4256
Merit: 8551
'The right to privacy matters'
First of all, thank you for the valuable information in that thread and of course, thank you for keeping the pool running Smiley!

I am new to crypto currencies and read into the topic for a couple weeks now. For some reasons, I decided to join the game, buy some mining hardware and gamble solo for a block. And yes, I clearly understand this as gambling.

However, it seems hard to find actual (recent) information on solo mining, particularly risks involved.

So my question is:

Assuming I join solo.ckpool.org for solo mining, what risks are still present *except*

- the money I spend in hardware (including breakage)
- the money I spend in power

?

Are there any?

Any tips are greatly appreciated. Thank you Smiley

You could win a block causing tax problems or people wanting money from you.

I toss some gear here just because I can. https://solo.ckpool.org/users/146UJM5kgzLVUV23CXCf33KQKHckoX1gx3

every once in a while I rent some hash but it is really hard to hit a block now due to high cost of coin.

Ie if you rent at a good fair price 1 coin would give you about a 1 in 6.25 chance

Asking to spend 35,000 USD for a 1 in 6 chance is hard.
newbie
Activity: 2
Merit: 0
First of all, thank you for the valuable information in that thread and of course, thank you for keeping the pool running Smiley!

I am new to crypto currencies and read into the topic for a couple weeks now. For some reasons, I decided to join the game, buy some mining hardware and gamble solo for a block. And yes, I clearly understand this as gambling.

However, it seems hard to find actual (recent) information on solo mining, particularly risks involved.

So my question is:

Assuming I join solo.ckpool.org for solo mining, what risks are still present *except*

- the money I spend in hardware (including breakage)
- the money I spend in power

?

Are there any?

Any tips are greatly appreciated. Thank you Smiley
legendary
Activity: 2912
Merit: 1091
--- ChainWorks Industries ---
hey, don't argue here that much in this nice thread Smiley. it was only to explain to newbies that counting on hitting a block makes no sense nowadays Wink


True ...

Whatever the thoughts that come across, there is no sense in squabbling. I KNOW what works for me with the understanding I have, and so does everyone else.

To each their own and hopefully we can all pull through this together (hence the reason for a Pool in the first place). The system is based on what we can do to help one another, and I have had more than my share of help from everyone here, including some schooling Wink

So for that I am thankful, and whether I explain myself clearly or not, it is not about squabbling, more that it is about sharing mindsets, trains of thought and hard evidence of what works for you - no matter what 'your setup' may be.

Now to get that damn theSolarFarm running in the next 12 months, and start slamming the hell out of the hashrate Wink

#crysx
newbie
Activity: 25
Merit: 2
hey, don't argue here that much in this nice thread Smiley. it was only to explain to newbies that counting on hitting a block makes no sense nowadays Wink
newbie
Activity: 10
Merit: 3


And this is why ...

This is why the system is misunderstood - because you think I am wrong on statistical probabilities that are fact, as well as ratios and mathematical facts that you think are incorrect.

All good though, the more you believe you are right, the more those like me seem to be benefittting from the manipulation of these statistical facts. Probability has feeling, so what you believe or feel is right or wrong is irrelevant. It's maths. The probability is based on EVERY block, on EVERY game, on EVERY hash. Whether we like it or not.

It makes no difference anyway guys, as the probabilities are not what we are all dealing with here. A block WILL be hit when the hashrate is there, that is coded into the system, whether 10minutes or so is also (almost) irrelevant, it WILL be hit - it actually HAS to be unless the chain is stopped with no hash driving it.

I don't need to argue these facts with you, look at the probabilities of Lotto for every games played, and the same goes for every block,

All good though. The misconception there is in the world, the better for those that can deal with the way it works.

#crysx
[/quote]



This will be my last post on that topic, because I already believe argueing is kind of senseless here. I didnt put any feeling or emotional expression into my reply. Please provide me the lines of code where the Certainty of solving a block is implemented (and I dont mean the Diff Adjustment based on the average blocktime).
Maybe the following analogy might help:
The probability for a standard dice to roll a 1 is 1/6. But that doesnt mean, that you get a 1 every 6 rolls. It is highly improbable but possible, that you roll a 1 six times in a row but the same is to say for not a single 1 in 30 tries.
Even if you roll 100 or 1000 times you're not guarenteed to get a 1 but the chances for that are ridiculously small, but it is still NOT CERTAIN!
The same goes for BTC Mining and the underlying SHA256 hashing. Although the "dice" here has 2 to the power of 256 sides which is for human beings an incredible huge solution space. Because it is that large there is no specific hash value demanded but every value that fulfills the defined criteria. Sticking to BTC being below a certain threshold that is adjusted every 2016 blocks and corresponds to enough leading zeros in the hashvalue of a solution.
But the principal stays the same, there's no guarentee of finding such solution in a finite timespan.
legendary
Activity: 2912
Merit: 1091
--- ChainWorks Industries ---
1 in xxx chance for lotto is EVERY GAME played, not every week.

1 in xxx chance for BTC is EVERY BLOCK mined, not every day.

Nothing of what I said contradicts this, you are just using a different form of representation of probabltity, 1 in x chance every block is equal to 1/144 chance a day.

Quote
Mathematically, the probability is the same no matter which way you approach it.

No, it's not the same, this can't be further from the truth.


Quote
So a Lotto win is NEVER guaranteed regardless of it's probability, whereas a block to be hit is an ABSOLUTE CERTAINTY every 10minutes or thereabouts. It is just a matter of whether YOU hit the block. Lotto has no inbuilt certainty - EVER.

This is also wrong, first of all, it's not guaranteed that a block is to be found every 10 mins it could take days, it can even take years, there is no law in the universe that forces a bitcoin block to be found in x amount of time, but then even if we were to agree to the 10 mins theory, it really doesn't matter, just because a block is guaranteed to be found it does not make your chances any better, also just because there is a possibility that nobody wins the lotto it doesn't make your chances any worse, the probability of any other event happening aside from you being lucky enough has absolutely ZERO impact on your own luck.

Think about it this way, imagine that nobody else but you is trying to solve the next Bitcoin block, does that increase/decrease your chances? the simple answer is 'No', and the same thing goes for the lotto, whether you are playing it alone or with a trillion other people/tickets your chances are ALWAYS the same.

It's a general misconception that many people think they are competing against other miners or other lotto players, no you are not, you are competing against your own luck and that's all about it, the lotto has an exception of the reward being divided between possible potential winners and that's a whole different scope.



And this is why ...

This is why the system is misunderstood - because you think I am wrong on statistical probabilities that are fact, as well as ratios and mathematical facts that you think are incorrect.

All good though, the more you believe you are right, the more those like me seem to be benefittting from the manipulation of these statistical facts. Probability has feeling, so what you believe or feel is right or wrong is irrelevant. It's maths. The probability is based on EVERY block, on EVERY game, on EVERY hash. Whether we like it or not.

It makes no difference anyway guys, as the probabilities are not what we are all dealing with here. A block WILL be hit when the hashrate is there, that is coded into the system, whether 10minutes or so is also (almost) irrelevant, it WILL be hit - it actually HAS to be unless the chain is stopped with no hash driving it.

I don't need to argue these facts with you, look at the probabilities of Lotto for every games played, and the same goes for every block,

All good though. The misconception there is in the world, the better for those that can deal with the way it works.

#crysx
newbie
Activity: 10
Merit: 3
The most known lottery in Poland: you cross 6 out of 49 numbers. 6 are drawn from pool.
The chance for hitting all 6 is 1:13 983 816
You can win 2,5mln EUR

Bitcoin, chance of hitting a block a day with 70 Gigahash (I mine for fun with) is 1:14 993 148
You can win about 180k EUR

Actually buying a lottery ticket every day to win 2,5mln EUR is wiser.

A great analysis but I have reasons to believe that it's a bit far from accurate, the 1 in 13m chance you have with the lotto is once every week, while the odds for hitting a block which you mentioned is based on a shot every day, so for this to be a bit more accurate you need to multiply the lotto ticket cost by 7, and then if we were to assume that the average lifespan for the miner is 2 years, then you will need to multiply that by 730, so if the ticket price is 2$, you will pay $1,460 to match the number of trials that a miner can have.

I am aware that there are other prize catogires of 3,4,5 matches but I think the prize is too small ot be considered, you also need to keep in mind that when you hit a bitcoin block you keep all the rewards and nobody can share them with you, where in the lotto, you are subject to share the prize with x amunt of people, on the othre hand, playing the lotto means you won't have to pay the power bill, no matiance, no cleaning no dead PSUs or a firmware glitch.

There are many more factors invovled to determine which would be econcmically better, I don't have the time, skills nor the desire to do that in-depth analysis (pehabs someone who does play the lotto and solo mine at the same time can do it) but I do tend to agree that perbaps and most likely playing the lotto is cheaper than solo mining.

With that being said, Solo mining is way more fun!! Grin



Probability ...

1 in xxx chance for lotto is EVERY GAME played, not every week.

1 in xxx chance for BTC is EVERY BLOCK mined, not every day.

Mathematically, the probability is the same no matter which way you approach it. However, with BTC, the chances are (like Lotto) that the more hashrate you have (the more Games in Lotto), the larger the chance of winning simply due to the amount of different plays. It is still the same probability with each hash/games played, but the chances (ie - risk of loss) are different.

This is why any form of gambling (especially trading - which is a complex form of gambling) have their risk. The difference is, that with Lotto, a games may NOT win, whereas with BTC (or almost any other Crypto) a block WILL be hit at certain interval.

So a Lotto win is NEVER guaranteed regardless of it's probability, whereas a block to be hit is an ABSOLUTE CERTAINTY every 10minutes or thereabouts. It is just a matter of whether YOU hit the block. Lotto has no inbuilt certainty - EVER.

#crysx

I do not agree on the "Absolute Certainty" Part. It is just an on-average-solution-timespan derived from the Poisson Distribution Probability. There were periods when the time between two blocks found were 3 hours for example.
If you want to calculate the true probability you need to consider every hash value and its chance of beeing below the current difficulty level. Lets go for the 70GH/s. Say the current Diff is 20T and for BTC the Diff Value when 1 corresponds to 8 leading hex numbers which means 2 to the power of 32 in binary. So roughly 4,3 billion hashs in decimal system necessary to find such a value on average. Multiplay this with 20.000 billion (20T) and you get the chance for each single hash calculated of beeing below that threshold. For such small possibilities you can simply sum them up, the deviation is negletable. But please consider this isnt possible anymore for "probable" events. If you would control the complete BTC Hashrate your Chance of finding a Block in 10 mins is around 63% and not 100% when you sum all hashs up (your machines would have calculated the above mentioned amount of hashs in that time) but as stated at the beginning the probabilty is a distribution. To achieve 100% your integral would need to be 1 and that means to integrate to infinity. Which is hard to achieve if we believe our state of the art science that the universe is finite in regard of its lifespan  Undecided 
Jump to: